
How smartphones turned Western society into a ‘failed state'
It seems to me, and might seem to you, as though headlines have always ticked across the bottom of our TV screens during news broadcasts. Strange, how quickly technological innovations lose their novelty. This one is only 23-and-a-half years old: the 'ticker' was reserved for sports scores until the day in 2001 when two hijacked passenger jets were flown into New York's World Trade Center. Fox News gave its ticker over to the news service that day; MSNBC and CNN quickly followed. Cable channels, you might say, quickly and seamlessly went from addressing their viewers' anxieties to stoking them.
That's Chris Hayes's view, and he should know: the political commentator and TV news anchor hosts a weekday current affairs show on MSNBC. The Sirens' Call, his new book, is first of all an insider's take on the persuasion game. Hayes is a hard worker, and a bit of a showman. When he started, he imagined his regular TV appearances would bring him some acclaim. 'And so,' he writes, 'the Star seeks recognition and gets, instead, attention.' This experience is now common. Thanks to the black mirrors in our pockets, we're now all stars of our own reality TV show.
To explain how he and the rest of smartphone-wielding humanity ended up in this peculiar pickle – 'akin to life in a failed state, a society that had some governing regime that has disintegrated and fallen into a kind of attentional warlordism' – Hayes sketches out three kinds of attention. There's the conscious attention we bring to something: to a book, say, or a film, or a painting. Then there's the involuntary attention we pay to environmental novelties (a passing wasp, a sudden breeze, an unexpected puddle). The more vigilant we are, the more easily even minor stimuli can snare our attention.
This second kind is the governing principle of advertising, an industry that over the last two decades has metastasised into something vast and insidious: call it 'the attention economy'. Everything is an advertisement now, especially the news. The ticker and its evolved cousins, the infinitely-scrolling feed (think X) and the autoplaying video-stream (think TikTok) exist to maintain our hypervigilance. You can, like Hayes, write a book so engaging that it earns the user's conscious focus over several hours. If you want to make money, though – with due respect to Scribe's sales department – you're better off snaring the user's involuntary attention over and over again with a procession of conspiracy theories and cat videos.
The third form of attention in Hayes's typology is social attention: that capacity for involuntary attention that we reserve for events relating specifically to ourselves. Psychologists dub this the 'cocktail-party effect', after our unerring ability to catch the sound of our own name across a crowded and noisy room. Social attention is extraordinarily pregnant with meaning, and without a steady diet of it, we suffer. Why do we post anything on social media? Because we want others to see us.
'But,' says Hayes, 'there's a catch... we want to be recognised as human by another human, as a subject by another subject, in order for it to truly be recognition. But We Who Post can never quite achieve that.' In feeding ourselves with the social attention of strangers, we have been creating synthetic versions of our most fundamental desire. 'This is the story of Donald Trump's life,' Hayes explains, by way of example: 'wanting recognition, instead getting attention, and then becoming addicted to attention itself, because he can't quite understand the difference, even though deep in his psyche there's a howling vortex that fame can never fill.'
Elon Musk gets even harsher treatment. 'What does the world's richest man want that he cannot have?' Hayes wonders. 'What will he pay the biggest premium for? He can buy whatever he desires. There is no luxury past his grasp.' The answer, as Musk's financially disastrous purchase of Twitter demonstrates 'to a pathological degree, with an unsteady obsessiveness that's thrown his fortune into question, is recognition. He wants to be recognised, to be seen in a deep and human sense. Musk spent $44 billion to buy himself what poor pathetic Willy Loman [in Arthur Miller's play Death of a Salesman] couldn't have. Yet it can't be purchased at any sum.'
We're not short of books about how our digital helpmates are ushering in the End of Days. German psychologist Gerd Gigerenzer's How to Stay Smart in a Smart World (2022) gets under the hood of systems that ape human wisdom just well enough to disarm us, but not nearly well enough to deliver happiness or social justice. The US social psychologist Jonathan Haidt took some flak for over-egging his arguments in The Anxious Generation (2024), but the studies he cites are solid enough and their statistics amount to a litany of depression, self-harm and suicide among young (and predominantly female) users of social media. In Unwired (2023), Gaia Bernstein, a law professor at Seton Hall University in New Jersey, explains how we might sue GAMA (Google, Amazon, Meta, Apple) for our children's lost childhood.
Among a crowded field, Hayes singles out Johann Hari's 2022 book Stolen Focus for praise, though this doesn't reflect well on Hayes himself, whose solutions to our digital predicament are weak beer compared to Hari's. Hari, like Gigerenzer and Bernstein, had bold ideas about civil resistance: he used his final pages to construct a bare-bones social protest movement. Hayes, by contrast, believes that the markets will somehow self-correct: 'I think (and fervently hope) we will see increasing growth in businesses, technologies, and models of consumption that seek to evade or upend the punishing and exhausting reality of the endless attention commodification we're living through,' Hayes says.
But what evidence has he to bolster such a hope? The spread of farmers' markets in American cities and the resurgence of vinyl in record stores. Hayes is the very picture of an intelligent, engaged commentator, and I came away admiring him. But if I were an investor I would show him the door.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
Khaby Lame: World's biggest TikTok star leaves US after being detained by ICE
Khaby Lame, the world's most popular TikTok personality, has left the US after being detained by federal agents. An Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) spokesperson said the Senegalese-Italian influencer - who has 162.2m followers on TikTok - was detained on Friday at Harry Reid International Airport in Las Vegas after he "overstayed the terms of his visa". The 25-year-old had arrived in the US on 30 April, the ICE spokesperson added, and was allowed to leave the country without a deportation order by a voluntary departure. Those with a deportation order on their records can be prevented from being allowed back into the US for up to a decade. While in the US, Lame - whose legal name is Seringe Khabane Lame - attended the Met Gala and the Metropolitan Museum of Art's Costume Institute benefit gala in New York City. He became famous online during the COVID-19 pandemic, where he would react to complicated life hack videos without saying a word. With millions of followers, he signed a multi-year partnership with designer brand Hugo Boss in 2022, and was appointed as a UNICEF goodwill ambassador in January this year.


Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Coco Gauff makes complaint after winning French Open as she details trophy woe
Coco Gauff became tennis' new Queen of Clay after her victory at the French Open over the weekend, but was unable to take the Coupe Suzanne Lenglen trophy home with her If Coco Gauff was feeling elated after her sensational French Open triumph, then the night out that followed didn't quite live up to expectations. So much so that she's complained night's out after major sporting events should be made ILLEGAL! The American secured her second Grand Slam title on Saturday, staging a remarkable comeback against Aryna Sabalenka. The final was a rollercoaster, with Sabalenka initially seizing control, but Gauff rallied to dominate the second set 6-2 and clinched the match with a 6-4 win in the decider. The victory was sweet for Gauff, who fell short against Iga Swiatek in the French Open final three years ago and comes nearly two years after her maiden Major win at the 2023 US Open. In high spirits, Gauff took to TikTok to share her post-match celebrations, albeit with a tongue-in-cheek tone as she captioned her video: "Going out after winning a sporting event should be illegal." She humorously lamented the post-victory condition, saying, "You're emotional, dehydrated, starving, and then they put champagne in my hand. Of course I'm going out bad.... I had fun tho we upppppppp." Gauff journeyed back to the USA on Monday - but revealed that her endeavours in Paris weren't enough for her to take the Coupe Suzanne Lenglen trophy back home with her. The 21-year-old displayed the 'mini replica' she had been given and explained how the real one "stays with the tournament." "It's the memories that matter the most," she added. Gauff has her sights set on accumulating more Grand Slam titles following her victory. After triumphing at Roland Garros, she reflected: "I think this win was harder than the first [title] because you don't want to get satisfied with just that one." "I was going through a lot of things when I lost here three years ago. I'm just glad to be back here. I was going through a lot of dark thoughts." She also triumphed in a post-match war of words with Sabalenka, who had bitterly declared that she had been "terrible" and that Swiatek would've beaten Gauff - a sentiment the American refused to entertain and brutally shut down. "I mean, I don't agree with that," she responded when told of Sabalenka's words. "I'm here sitting here." Gauff also referenced her recent dominating win over Swiatek at the Madrid Open" "Last time I played - no shade to Iga or anything, but I played her and I won in straight sets. "Yeah, I don't think that's a fair thing to say, because anything can really happen. Yeah, honestly the way Aryna was playing the last few weeks, she was the favourite to win. So I think she was the best person that I could have played in the final. "Her being No.1 in the world was the best person to play, so I think I got the hardest matchup just if you go off stats alone."


Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Kylie Jenner's £4.40 brow gel is worth the hype but watch out for one thing
Kylie Jenner's go-to brow gel costs less than a fiver and has been a staple in my makeup routine for a while now - but there's one slight downside to the product Kylie Jenner 's TikTok account has become a treasure trove for beauty-obsessed fans looking to upgrade their makeup and skincare routines with the latest celebrity-favourite products. From promoting the latest from her own beauty brand Kylie Cosmetics, to sharing exactly how she gets her wavy hairstyle, with the help of her hairstylist, Kylie is sharing all of her beauty tips and tricks on the social media app. But I found that her latest recommendation, the got2b Glued 4 Brows & Edges 2in1 Gel, is a product that's long been a part of my makeup routine - and for good reason too. Kylie showed off her most recent makeup routine in a 'get ready with me' upload, and prepped her brows with the gel, which you can get your hands on for just over a fiver in your local supermarket and your closest Boots or Superdrug store. The gel is practically invisible, vegan friendly, free of silicones and alcohol and is dermatologically tested, so you can trust that your skin won't react badly, despite this product offering a super strong hold for your brows and edges for up to 72 hours. It's made of the same 'Glued' formula that you'll find in got2Be's iconic hairspray, which is often used to keep slick back buns frizz free and even hold wigs in place all day long. Help us improve our content by completing the survey below. We'd love to hear from you! My review of got2b Glued 4 Brows & Edges 2in1 Gel I've been using the got2b Glued 4 Brows & Edges 2in1 Gel for a long while now and I'm currently on my second purchase as it quickly became a staple in my everyday makeup routine. I usually apply the gel before my foundation and allow it to fully dry for brows that won't budge all day long. Not only does the gel last all day, but a little goes a long way, so you can be sure to have this as part of your beauty bag for a long while before you run out and have to repurchase. I haven't used the gel on my edges so I can't speak for their hold there, but for my brows, which can be quite unruly at times, this is the best product to tame and keep them neat. Pros and cons of got2b Glued 4 Brows & Edges 2in1 Gel Pros Super strong hold Quick-drying Hold lasts well over 24hrs Cons Slight flaking if there's excess product left on the skin I've found that a white residue appears if mixed with foundation or SPF Where to buy got2b Glued 4 Brows & Edges 2in1 Gel