Fire on historic ship The Tui most likely caused by electrical fault
Photo:
RNZ / Peter De Graaf
The fire that
destroyed a historic ship in the Bay of Islands
was most likely caused by an electrical fault, not by arson, a fire investigator says.
The Tui, a century-old sugar barge converted into a replica sailing ship by the late underwater explorer Kelly Tarlton, was severely damaged by fire early on Wednesday morning.
Police initially treated the blaze as suspicious and, given how little remained, Northland fire investigator Craig Bain was not hopeful of being able to establish the cause. Luck was, however, on his side.
"As the digger was bringing bits and pieces out, we were looking for the likes of switchboards and hard drives for the security system, and anything that might show an origin point," Bain said.
"Just by pure luck, once everything had been removed, I went into what was left and looked over the side - and lying in the sand were the burnt-out remnants of the mains switchboard. Digging through that a bit further I found what was left of the mains cable that feeds the switchboard, and that had significant arcing and a fair bit of melting on it as well, indicating significant heat."
That led the investigation team to conclude an electrical fault was the most likely cause of the fire.
The find was even more unexpected given how quickly they had to work to beat the incoming tide.
Bain said the switchboard was still warm to the touch when found, and appeared to have fallen out of the boat early in the fire. Power was live to the switchboard due to the vessel's pending restoration, and it was possible moisture had entered it during the wild weather lashing the Bay of Islands that night.
Bain said the finding that the fire was most likely electrical rather than suspicious could provide some comfort to the owners, as well as to the Tarlton family.
"I think it's quite a benefit to the folks starting out on this project to restore the boat that there doesn't appear to be anything malicious about the fire, that we know of."
Kelly Tarlton created the Tui in the 1970s to display his collection of treasures salvaged from shipwrecks around New Zealand. Later it housed a series of restaurants and cafes but for the past decade it had been empty and increasingly derelict.
It was bought last year by researchers Cat Peters and Thibaud Guerin, who planned to turn it into a centre for free community marine education.
In April this year their TriOceans Education Trust received a grant from Foundation North to restore the ship. Work had just started when the fire broke out.
Parts of the ship not destroyed by the blaze had to be demolished that morning, both to allow firefighters to fully extinguish the flames between its two hulls and to ensure debris did not enter the Bay of Islands on the high tide at 2.30pm.
The site was blessed before dawn on Saturday in a moving ceremony led by the chairman of neighbouring Te Tii Marae, Ngāti Kawa Taituha.
Fiona Tarlton took part, representing the family, and said she planned to gift the marae a framed photo of the Tui and her late father.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Wilding pine problem at ‘tipping point' in Southland
Wilding pines pictured at Mid Dome, Northern Southland. The trees are causing major issues in the region. Photo: Environment Southland / Supplied Wild conifer trees are running rife in Southland with fears some areas could be overtaken in the next 30 years. The region is now at a "tipping point" as trees spread aggressively through high country, farmland and conservation areas, councillors have been warned. These grizzly details were captured in an Environment Southland report presented to council on Wednesday, which one elected member described as "sobering". Photo: A species of concern was the Douglas fir which was reeking havoc for a number of reasons including the distance its seed could travel, a tolerance to the climate, and commercial popularity. Its spread was accelerating at a rate which current investment and control could not keep up with, the report said. "Without further intervention, vast areas of Northern Southland could be overtaken within 30 years, resulting in irreversible environmental and economic loss." Productive land, native ecosystems and landscapes were all at risk because of rapidly spreading conifers - especially Douglas fir, the report said. It noted that Southland risked passing a "point of no return" under its current response. Meanwhile, costs rose by 30 percent every year removal was delayed, and the $24.6 million spent on the problem since 2016 could end up going to waste without follow-up work. Councillor Eric Roy said the battle was being lost, and called for immediate action such as limiting where trees could be planted. "This is one of the most sobering reports I've read in some time," he said. Council chair Nicol Horrell said there had been conversations with Government ministers who were aware of the problem. The Government had committed "quite a bit" of money as part if its shovel ready projects, but it would all be wasted if control work couldn't keep up, he said. Mid Dome Wilding Trees Charitable Trust covers an area of more than 68,000 hectares in Northern Southland, and was one such example of a group struggling under reduced budgets. The Trust aims to control wilding pines from the Mid Dome area before handing over the control of any wilding re-growth to landowners. Last year, it expressed concern all of its work was at risk and called on the council to increase its funding after 18 years of stagnancy. A series of recommended steps were included in the council report such as clarifying roles and responsibilities, securing long-term funding, and supporting landowners and community action. Wilding conifers are invasive weeds that threaten to permanently alter New Zealand's landscapes, the DOC website states. When conifer cones mature, they open to release masses of wind-blown seeds which can travel kilometres, according to DOC. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Council plans to block road access to Cape Palliser due to vandlism
Cape Palliser Lighthouse. Photo: 123RF Plans to block road access to a remote stretch of the South Wairarapa coastline will deny surfers access to one country's most pristine surf breaks. South Wairarapa District Council wants to close access to a paper or unfinished road that leads to the Cape Palliser coast line due to continued vandalism and destruction. The road passes through private and Crown land before ending at the rugged beach. The council said native flora and fauna in the area has been damaged by four wheel drives, quad bikes and campers, who are also a fire risk. The area includes Wāhi Tapu sites, ancestral burial grounds and historic pā sites. "Council has engaged with local hapū, Ngāti Hinewaka and have agreed the continued vandalism, disrespect to the land and its owners and the poor social behaviours displayed are not acceptable," South Wairarapa District Council said. If the proposal to block road access goes ahead, there will be no overland route to reach that part of the beach. Michael Gunson first surfed White Rock along that part of the coast in 1976. Gunson told Checkpoint it was a popular surf spot but really hard to get to, even with the paper road open. He said if the road is shut, there would be no access for the general public. "It's a gem, it really is a gem. It's on par with Castle Point, as far as I'm concerned, as far as dramatic landscapes go," he said. While Gunson understands where the council and landowners are coming from, he wants to work to find a solution. "I am not going to defend clowns in any way, shape or form. What I think that needs to be done is some good consultation, some good kaupapa shared with the landowners, DoC and the council, and we need to work this out," Gunson said. He said they need to find out how to maintain public access in a way that minimises any damage to the coastline. Gunson said said there could be signage and education around how to respect the landscape, and encourage others to report bad behaviour when they see it. He said there has been a lot of opposition to the council's proposal as it has sparked a lot of attention among surfers online. "Not everybody that goes there is a vandal. They go there out of deep respect for the beautiful, wonderful coastline," he said. The South Wairarapa District Council in a statement to Checkpoint said there has been 2139 online submissions on the proposal so far. The council said the proposed bylaw is being developed using powers under the Local Government and Land Transport Acts but acknowledges that restricting walking access to the paper road would not be legally enforceable. However, that right of access doesn't extend to the adjoining private land, and council is responding to issues raised by the hapu around ongoing damage to land bordering the paper road. It said the consultation is providing an understanding of what level of access the community feels is appropriate - balancing the need for safe public access with respect for adjoining landowners. South Wairarapa District Council is accepting feedback on the proposal until 19 August . It said all feedback will be reviewed before a final decision is made. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Papanui High School brings back uniforms for seniors after decades without
School uniforms at Papanui High School will be compulsory for year 13s in 2026. (File photo) Photo: Left Hand Rotation/Flickr A Christchurch college is bringing back uniforms for senior students after decades of them wearing their own clothes, despite strong opposition from its community and students. At the moment, year 13 students at Papanui High School get to wear their own clothes in their final year. The school surveyed more than 800 students, teachers and community members about a uniform refresh. Overwhelmingly, students and the community did not want uniforms made compulsory for year 13. Some of the teenagers said wearing their own clothes in their final year helped prepare them for the workplace and was a reward for staying in school. A petition's been launched to try and halt the change. But for now, the uniform will be compulsory for year 13 from next year. Papanui High School Principal Robert Gilbert told Checkpoint the main reason the school decided to re-introduce uniform was down to "safety concerns". "We're a very large school, now 1600 students... the school is so large that it's not possible to keep our student community safe because we don't know who the people are on site when they're not wearing a uniform." Gilbert said it had become nearly impossible to differentiate year 13 students from other groups of people on site. "We can't differentiate between say a year 13 student, maybe a trainee teacher, maybe a year 12 student out of uniform, a visitor, or some thug down the road coming in to sell drugs." While Gilbert could not confirm if there had been drug dealers on the school site, there had been issues with non-students entering the grounds. "We wouldn't know because we can't tell which are our students and which aren't. That's probably the point. "We have certainly had unwanted people on site, usually from other schools not in uniform and causing havoc in our school, and it has become a health and safety issue." He said there had also been issues when it came to students off school grounds, particularly at the shopping mall next door. "We want to be able to know where our students are... so if our year 13's go to the shopping mall, that they're identified as representatives and role models from our school, and not just any other random teenager who's wandering through the mall." He said it wasn't uncommon that their students had been accused of behaviour they weren't responsible for, due to their lack of uniform. "What happens if you've got other youths in the mall who are causing trouble? We automatically get blamed because we're the school right next door, whereas if they're in uniform, they're easily identifiable." Gilbert said while the school had considered other options to identify students, such as an ID card, lanyard, or badge, health and safety was not the only factor in reinstating the uniform. "That is a big reason, but that's not the sole reason. "For a lot of students, having a wardrobe, a selection of clothing, the right labels, clean clothes, it is not a problem for them, but for some families that's an issue." He also had concerns about causing divides between the students. "What we actually end up doing by saying you can wear whatever you like... is we start creating an us and them situation with our students." As a solution to this issue, year 13 students can currently opt into wearing a uniform if they would like to. However, Gilbert said this option was no longer viable due to the added health and safety concerns. He also cited a sense of belonging and pride for the students who had managed to reach year 13. However, in a survey sent out to students, staff and community about the proposed changes, only 24 percent of year 13 students supported a compulsory uniform. Parents said they were only made aware of the change through a school newsletter, which outlined progress on the development of a refreshed uniform. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
