'No one should be handled like dad was' - family of nursing home patient
In a new episode broadcast on television last night, the family accused those responsible of failing 'people who are in dire need of attention'.
Several accusations were made, including claims that a man was left alone in a corridor to tear pieces of paper, left cold with only a blanket, and that urine was 'all over the floor'.
The programme was aired last week to allege multiple accusations of care failings for vulnerable residents at two nursing homes.
These were identified in the broadcast as Residence in Portlaoise, Co Laois, and Beneavin Manor in Glasnevin, Co Dublin.
HIQA confirmed that it would carry out a review of both nursing homes that are operated by the Emeis Ireland group, which is the country's largest provider of private nursing homes.
The company has since issued apologies to residents and their families and vowed an in-depth review to immediately address the issues.
Yesterday, family members of elderly man Audeon Guy, 80, spoke out about his care at Beneavin Manor.
Mr Guy was identified as one of the vulnerable residents who appeared in the undercover documentary.
His family has called for accountability and expressed their shock and distress at witnessing the footage of their father.
Audeon's son Paul said: 'No one should have to go through what we've seen.
'No one should be handled like our father was. These are human people – people who lost their dignity and no one should have to go through that.
Audeon's daughter Sarah said: 'Our dad is the loveliest man. The nicest friend, neighbour, and best dad in the whole world.'
Paul and Sarah's father ended up in Beneavin Manor in January past after being diagnosed with Lewy body dementia, which causes severe confusion and hallucinations, following a bad fall last year.
A HIQA inspection of the nursing home last November reported that residents were happy and that the centre was well managed.
But the Guy family developed several concerns about the facility in recent months and made complaints.
The family is now searching for new care for him and has urged the Government to enact a new law - the Adult Safeguarding Bill - to protect vulnerable individuals.
Paul said: '[Father] was actually left alone many times. I have examples of him sitting on his own in the corridor ripping up pieces of paper which was meant to be some form of activity.
'It happened to all the other people in the footage as well. That's the bigger issue: there's no accountability for this.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
6 hours ago
- Sunday World
Child at risk of sexual abuse was on social services waiting list for 14 months
Hiqa has highlighted serious child protection and welfare service concerns about the service operated by Tusla in the Dublin south central area A child who was reported as being at risk of sexual abuse was on a waiting list for 14 months, a new inspection report has revealed. The child was among a number of children at the centre of allegations of being sexually or physically abused who waited months for proper protection. The Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) highlighted serious child protection and welfare service concerns about the service operated by the Child and Family Agency (Tusla) in the Dublin south central area. The child was on a 'medium prioritisation list' and did not get therapeutic support, although a second concern was made a month after the first. Hiqa carried out a monitoring inspection between last April 8 and 11 to assess the progress the service had made to address non-compliances since the previous inspection in February last year. Inspectors escalated 13 cases. Hiqa said one child had been the subject of three referrals, two of which were for physical abuse. One of these dated back to 26 months before the inspection. The third came in as a child welfare referral and was received two months before the inspection. This had not been screened to establish the risk of harm to the child and ensure that it was correctly categorised. One child was referred and known to the service for 12 months due to concerns over domestic violence and emotional abuse. A preliminary enquiry was completed, and the child was prioritised and was unallocated. The child's safety was potentially at significant risk There was no safety plan in place and despite a manager's review of the referral a year later, indicating a need for a safety plan, this had not happened at the time of inspection. This meant the child's safety was potentially at significant risk due to the lack of a required safety plan and the long period that the safety plan had not been in place. In another case, gardaí referred a child who was contacted by a person of concern. The child was placed on a list for 12 months. Hiqa said the percentage of unallocated cases has been reduced from 54pc in February last year, to 41pc at the time of the inspection, and is currently at 34pc as a result of focused efforts in the area. Inspectors found that when children were allocated, the quality of services provided was good, and that the welfare of children was central to decisions made. It is important to note that where a child or young person is awaiting allocation, their case is regularly reviewed and if anything changes that necessitates an urgent response, an urgent response is provided. Other positive aspects of the service included the appointment of domestic violence support liaison officers to support referrals where domestic violence and abuse was a presenting concern or issue. Tusla is the Child and Family Agency. Photo: Stock image Today's News in 90 Seconds - August 19th The area received 7,781 child protection and welfare referrals in the 12 months before the inspection. Speaking about the report, Gerry Hone, interim director of services and integration at Tusla, said: 'Oversight by Hiqa assists us in striving for the best possible standards across our services. However, on this occasion, due in part to challenges relating to rising demand and the capacity of the service to meet this demand, we have not reached those expected standards. 'While there are many examples of good practice in the report, the Dublin South Central area has been challenged to provide a timely service to all children and families. There has been a considerable effort undertaken in the area in the recruitment and retention of staff, and we are beginning to see the dividends of this across the service. This is reflected in the further seven percent decrease in the number of children awaiting allocation today, since the inspection in April. 'New staff in any role will often need time to gain experience, and management and staff in the area are working diligently to train and support new staff to gain the skills and experience they need.'
The Journal
21 hours ago
- The Journal
Child at risk of sexual abuse left on social services waiting list for over 14 months
A CHILD IN Dublin was placed on a wait list for over 14 months after a referral of sexual abuse was made to Tusla, even though a second concern was raised a month after the first referral. It is one of several cases highlighted in an inspection report by the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA), exposing numerous service delays in the Dublin South Central area. The inspection examined progress on case allocation, waitlists, safety planning, and oversight of child protection cases. In the 12 months prior to the inspection, the area received 7,781 child protection and welfare referrals. In the case of the child at risk of sexual abuse, they were placed on a waitlist and classified as 'medium' priority, the HIQA report found, with no adjustment made after the second referral. The report also noted that the child had not been met by child welfare officers, despite internal audits recommending such contact. At the time of the inspection, the child had still not received any therapeutic support. In a separate case flagged by HIQA, a referral alleging physical abuse of a child with complex needs was incorrectly classified as a child welfare concern and prioritised as medium, with gardaí initially not notified. Advertisement In another case involving a one-year-old, clarifying information needed to assess risk had not been sought six months later, leaving the child's wellbeing unestablished. Overall, HIQA found that social services staff in the Dublin South Central area were lacking, as the scale of demand continued to challenge the service. However, HIQA also highlighted that the percentage of unallocated cases had fallen from 54% in February 2024 to 41% at the time of the inspection, and is currently at 34%, which the report described as reflecting 'focused efforts' in the area. Tusla said that cases awaiting allocation are regularly reviewed, with urgent responses provided when necessary. Alamy Alamy In a statement on the inspection, the agency highlighted ongoing reforms, including the Local Integrated Service Delivery Model, designed to improve access to services and support staff. Gerry Hone, Interim Director of Services and Integration at Tusla, said HIQA oversight 'assists us in striving for the best possible standards across our services.' In relation to the child at risk of sexual abuse, he added: 'On this occasion, due in part to challenges relating to rising demand and the capacity of the service to meet this demand, we have not reached those expected standards.' Tusla said that improvements agreed with HIQA following the inspection include better oversight and progression of unallocated cases, allocating additional resources, and implementing a compliance plan for child protection and welfare referrals for children in care. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Children at risk of physical or sexual abuse experienced ‘significant' delays before Tusla intervention, report finds
Children in Dublin who were at risk of physical or sexual abuse experienced 'significant' delays in receiving a child protection and welfare service, according to the health watchdog. The Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) on Monday published an inspection report on protection and welfare services operated by Tusla, the child and family agency , in the Dublin South Central area. One child was on a waiting list for assistance for more than two years, Hiqa said. In a number of cases, the authority found gardaí should have been informed of certain allegations but were not. The inspection was carried out from April 8th to 11th, 2025. It found that 'in most cases' at-risk children experienced long delays before intervention. READ MORE 'This was as a result of children not being allocated in a timely manner and being placed on a waiting list after they had been deemed to meet the criteria for a service,' the report noted. 'It was clear that the welfare and protection needs of some of the children referred to the Dublin South Central service area were not always met in a timely and effective manner.' One child who had been the subject of three referrals, two of which were for physical abuse, was placed on a waiting list. One of these referrals dated back 26 months before the inspection. 'The third came in as a child welfare referral and was received two months before the inspection. This had not been screened to establish the risk of harm to the child and ensure that it was correctly categorised,' the report said. In relation to another child, a sexual abuse referral was received 14 months before the inspection, with another concern referred one month later. 'The child was placed on a wait-list and prioritised as medium, with no consideration given to revising the priority following the receipt of the second referral,' the report stated. 'The child had not been met with despite audits carried out by a manager that indicated that this should be done. The child had still not received any therapeutic support at the time of the inspection.' In a separate case, Tusla received an allegation of physical abuse in respect of a child with complex needs which 'was inappropriately categorised as a child welfare concern, and prioritised as medium'. 'Gardaí were not notified of this allegation of abuse. This was brought to the attention of the area manager and response provided showed that gardaí had been notified after the inspection,' the report stated. Hiqa said these cases 'illustrated gaps in the service capacity to carry out assessments of children's welfare and protection needs in a timely manner'. 'This had resulted in children waiting for significantly long periods in many cases for the required support and interventions,' it said. 'Inspectors escalated 13 cases and the response provided indicated that all cases had actions completed to ensure children's safety and that risks identified were being effectively managed.' Responding to the report, Tusla said the Dublin South Central area received 7,781 child protection and welfare referrals in the 12 months before the inspection. Despite improvements in recruitment and retention of staff since the previous inspection in February 2024, the service 'remained challenged by the scale of demand, and its current capacity', a statement noted. 'The area has developed an action plan to bring it into compliance, which has been accepted by Hiqa.' Gerry Hone, interim director of services and integration at Tusla, said the Dublin South Central area has been 'challenged to provide a timely service to all children and families'. 'There has been a considerable effort undertaken in the area in the recruitment and retention of staff, and we are beginning to see the dividends of this across the service.' There has been a 7 per cent decrease in the number of children awaiting allocation since the inspection in April, Mr Hone added.
