Bad news for Kentucky sheriff who shot judge friend dead in his chambers
Former prosecutors claim the Kentucky sheriff who shot a local judge dead in his chambers last year faces an uphill battle with his insanity defense.
Letcher County Sheriff Shawn 'Mickey' Stines gunned down Judge Kevin Mullins inside the county courthouse on September 19.
Exactly why Stines killed his close friend soon after they had lunch together remains a mystery, with only vague explanations from his lawyers so far.
The shooting and the moments leading up to it were caught on film.
Stines' lawyers plan to present an insanity defense if the case goes to trial, claiming two weeks of intense stress drove him to murder.
Defense attorney Jeremy Bartley claimed Stines irrationally feared for the lives of his family after being questioned at a deposition for a sexual assault lawsuit.
The sheriff told officers seconds after the shooting, 'They're trying to kidnap my wife and kid,' and expressed fear he would be murdered on the way to jail.
But two former prosecutors believe a jury is unlikely to believe he was insane as he appeared to know right from wrong when he pulled the trigger.
Georgia legal expert Phil Holloway pointed to Kentucky State Police bodycam footage of Stines being arrested minutes after the shooting.
Stines was terrified of being transported to the Leslie County Jail, an hour's drive away, and begged to be locked up in the one next door instead.
'I leave this building, I won't draw another breath,' he told them while handcuffed, his leg nervously shaking.
Stines said he was worried the transport would stop along the way, and someone else would get in the car and kill him.
Holloway said Stines' fear that he would be killed, however paranoid or delusional, showed he knew that murder was wrong.
'If they know right from wrong, they can still be convicted even if they have a mental health issue,' he told Fox News.
'He knows that killing is wrong because he's asking the police to not kill him.'
Michael Wynne, a former prosecutor in Houston, said the CCTV footage of the moments leading up to the shooting was even more damning.
'The video shows he knows what he's doing is wrong. If you don't know what you're doing is wrong, you don't usher everybody else out of the room, and you don't go ahead and make sure the door is closed,' he said.
'Those are all things that show that he has an ability to make cognizant decisions.'
Wynne said Stines risked a harsher sentence by trying an insanity defense, as the judge and jury could 'punish' him for pursuing it.
Bartley issued a legal filing saying his client's state of mind at the time of the shooting would be key to his upcoming trial.
He said the case would hinge on testimony that Stines gave at a deposition for a lawsuit by Sabrina Adkins days before the September 2024 shooting.
Stines in that interview answered questions about one of his deputies allegedly sexually assaulting jail inmates.
An accuser in that case claimed that she was forced by a deputy sheriff to have sex in Mullins' chambers for six months in exchange for staying out of jail.
Bartley claimed Stines was concerned about backlash from his deposition testimony, which caused him to fear that his or his family's lives were in danger.
Stines had been a close friend to Mullins for around 30 years and the pair had been seen dining together at a local restaurant for lunch just hours before the shooting
The attorney claimed Stines' 'mental health' was affected by the perceived threat.
'Ultimately, he was in fear for the safety of his wife and his daughter, and I think what you see there is the result of that,' he wrote.
Footage from just before the shooting showed Stines express concern about his family, and call his daughter from the judge's phone.
Adkins accused Judge Mullins of inappropriate behavior, claiming she had witnessed him engaging in sexual acts with women in exchange for special treatment.
This lawsuit, filed in January 2022, claimed Mullins was involved in a sex-for-favors scheme within his chambers.
Adkins also alleged former deputy Ben Fields was involved and filmed illicit encounters, some of which reportedly involved Mullins.
Stines, a close friend of Mullins for about 30 years, was mentioned in the legal proceedings just three days before the shooting.
'I think the deposition has several important roles in this case... it's going to be a large portion of the story we tell,' Bartley said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
29 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Terrifying moment 7-foot alligator twirls into 'death spiral' as Florida cops try to wrestle it from backyard pool
A 7-foot alligator launched into a violent 'death spiral' as deputies and a professional trapper struggled to drag it from the bottom of a family's backyard swimming pool. In astonishing footage released by the Martin County Sheriff's Office the reptilian intruder and be seen thrashing and spinning around with brutal force in a deadly maneuver usually reserved for killing prey. This time, the gator was fighting against being captures at a home in the quiet Pinecrest Lakes community. Deputies Dawn Ferris and Sergeant Crystal Nash were the first on scene after startled residents dialed 911, reporting the unwelcome and very large guest soaking up the sun in their fenced pool. The alligator, lounging in the water as if it owned the place, seemed utterly unfazed by its growing audience. But when professional trapper Matt Hines arrived to remove the stubborn reptile, the calm suddenly turned into chaos. Video shows Hines securing the beast with a snare pole, cautiously maneuvering to guide the gator toward the shallow end. Sensing the loss of control, the alligator unleashed a vicious death roll, twisting its muscular body with terrifying speed, thrashing its powerful tail and churning the water making waves across the pool. The gator spun clockwise, then reversed, twirling back the other way in a frenzied display of raw power. The pole strained under the force of the reptile's spiraling assault as Hines dug in his heels, battling to maintain his grip. At one point, the gator was nearly dragged to the pool's edge, but refused to surrender. Instead of climbing the steps as Hines coaxed it, the gator pivoted violently and spun again in a chilling reminder of why these creatures have ruled swamps and rivers for millennia. 'This was no easy task,' the Martin County Sheriff's Office noted dryly on social media. 'As unbelievable as it looks, this is the second time today that a gator has been found soaking up the sun in a residential pool in our area.' It took all of Hines's experience and sheer determination to finally subdue the beast. Inch by agonizing inch, he dragged the reptile up onto the pool deck as the creature writhed in defiance. From there, the slow, tense trek to the waiting transport vehicle began. Fortunately, no one was injured, and the gator was safely removed from the property, but the encounter left no doubt about the dangers lurking even in suburban backyards. Officials were quick to remind the public that the standoff wasn't just a freak occurrence. It is mating season for alligators in Florida, a period when the typically reclusive reptiles become more aggressive and mobile, sometimes turning up in unexpected and unwanted places. The pole strained under the force of the reptile's spiraling assault as Hines dug in his heels, battling to maintain his grip with the gator pulling in the other direction 'Residents and pet owners, please stay alert,' the sheriff's office warned. 'Alligators are wild animals and can be extremely dangerous if provoked. As you can see by the powerful 'death spiral,' it is not safe to attempt to remove a gator unless you are a trained professional.' Incredibly, authorities believe the gator managed to get into the pool by either climbing over the fence or finding its way under it - a sobering thought for anyone who assumes a backyard barrier is enough to keep wildlife out.
Daily Mail
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The Orkney Assassin unmasked: How schoolboy, 15, escaped justice for 14 years for racist point blank execution of Indian waiter - and whose parents STILL believe 'real' killer is out there
New details have been revealed about a schoolboy who swerved justice for 14 years after his racist murder of an restaurant waiter. Michael Ross went on to be hailed for heroics in the first Gulf War as he served as a Black Watch sergeant. He joined the famous Scottish regiment at the age of 17 and progressed through the ranks, eventually becoming the sergeant of a sniper platoon - and his service included a tour of duty in Iraq in which comrades were killed. But he remained free for years before being jailed for the shooting to death at point blank range of Shamsuddin Mahmood at an Orkney Islands restaurant in Scotland. Ross was finally brought to justice when jailed for life, aged 29, in June 2008 - found guilty of carrying out the killing as a 15-year-old teenager. Now a new investigation has shed new light on Ross, as he and his family continue to say he was wrongly convicted. He was ultimately found guilty of what was described as a 'savage, merciless and pointless' murder of Mr Mahmood. Yet his parents are continuing to insist he is innocent and the 'real' killer remains on the loose, as suggested in a new Amazon Prime Video documentary about the case. Ross is seen here as a 29-year-old defendant outside Glasgow High Court in June 2008 The killing of 26-year-old Mr Mahmood came on June 2 1994 when a masked man walked into the Orkney Islands' only Indian restaurant and 'executed' his victim before calmly walking away. Ross's trial in 2008 heard that, as a youth, he harboured extreme racist views that drove him to hunt down and murder one of the island's few Asian residents. he became the main suspect just months after the murder, but police did not have enough evidence to charge him. The breakthrough came when a new witness walked into Kirkwall police station in 2006 with a note saying he had seen the killer in public toilets on the night of the murder brandishing a gun and identified him as Michael Ross. Ross's lawyer Donald Findlay, defending, insisted it was unthinkable for a 15-year-old to have committed such a crime, suggesting the killing bore all the hallmarks of a 'professional hit'. But at the end of a six-week trial, jurors took just four hours to find Ross guilty of murder by a majority verdict. Ross was subsequently sentenced to life behind bars with a minimum of 25 years. He insists he is innocent of the killing - and last month told the Orcadian newspaper that he was 'doing a 25-year life sentence for something I didn't do'. His parents have also rallied to his defence in the new documentary called The Orkney Assassin that will be made available on Amazon Prime Video this Sunday. Promotional material ahead of the broadcast suggests there is still 'a shadow of doubt still lingering and dividing opinion in the Orkney Islands to this day'. Speaking to the programme-makers, Ross's mother Moira Ross recalls the moment she asked the then-teenager whether he was a killer after his initial arrest. She says: 'I remember him coming home with the detective and he went up to his room and sat there, and I did go up and ask him. 'I said, "Did you shoot that man?" - and he said, "No". I just can't get over the look on his face when I asked him that.' Mr Mahmood had been living on the Orkney Islands for just six weeks before his death and was planning to return home to Bangladesh to wed his fiancée. His brother, barrister Abul Shafiuddin, paid tribute at Ross's 2007 trial, saying of Mr Mahmood: 'He was our baby brother and at least we know the person who killed him will be punished.' Ross was also found guilty by majority of attempting to defeat the ends of justice by disposing of the murder weapon and changing his clothing. During the trial, it emerged that his policeman father Edmund Ross had been jailed for hampering the investigation by withholding crucial evidence. Advocate depute Brian McConnachie QC, told the court the prosecution's case against Ross was based on 'compelling, unanswerable' circumstantial evidence. When the guilty verdict was announced, Ross leapt from the dock and tried to escape before being led to the cells - having been wrestled to the ground by a court official. He had been one of 12 soldiers decorated for outstanding service in Iraq in 2005 and was even mentioned in dispatches for showing bravery following two improvised explosive attacks in north Babil. Yet his downfall eventually came when a new witness walked into Kirkwall police station in 2006 with a note saying he had seen the killer in public toilets on the night of the murder, brandishing a gun - and identified him as Michael Ross. Ross had been questioned as a 15-year-old in relation to Mr Mahmood's death, after two witnesses had suggested they saw him wearing the same balaclava and dark clothing as the murderer in woodland a fortnight earlier. But he was only charged with lying to police and interfering with a witnesses, receiving a four-year jail term in 1997. His eventual murder trial was told now the anonymous letter writer, later named as William Grant, told of seeing Ross in public toilets near the restaurant, clad in balaclava and dark clothes, on the night of Mr Mahmood's killing. Jurors also heard that Ross had told a fellow army cadet as a schoolboy that 'blacks should be shot' and had textbooks scrawled with swastikas, SS symbols and slogans suggesting 'death to the English'. His father Edmund Ross tells the new Amazon Prime Video documentary: 'I didn't believe it. 'I knew my son for all that years and he never showed any tendencies or anything like that that I would expect him to go out and shoot anyone.' The Orkney Assassin: Murder in the Isles is being made available to Amazon Prime Video viewers in the UK and Ireland on Sunday 8 June.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
New Mexico police officer dies following traffic stop shooting
A police officer from northwestern New Mexico has died, several days after being critically injured when a man opened fire during a traffic stop. Law enforcement agencies gathered Sunday to escort the body of Bloomfield Police Officer Timothy Ontiveros from an Albuquerque hospital, where he had undergone multiple surgeries over recent days, to the office of the state medical investigator. A procession back to Bloomfield will be held Tuesday. Ontiveros had pulled over a man for a traffic violation on Memorial Day. Authorities said the man refused to roll down his window or provide identification. After negotiations failed, officers opted to arrest him and broke a window to take him into custody. The man subsequently began shooting, hitting Ontiveros and narrowly missing a second officer at the scene. That officer returned fire, striking and killing the suspect. Authorities said the man had a record that included previous arrests for assault, trespassing, resisting an officer and threatening hospital staff. Ontiveros, 33, previously worked for the Farmington Police Department and was a volunteer firefighter for the neighboring community of Aztec. A GoFundMe page was set up to help his family. 'In his short time with the agency, he demonstrated kindness, professionalism, and dedication to the safety of the community he served,' Bloomfield Police Chief Phillip Francisco said Sunday in a social media post. Ontiveros had joined Bloomfield police in December. Francisco asked for the community's support as the department navigated what he called a tremendous loss. Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham also mourned the loss of the officer. 'His death is a heartbreaking reminder of the dangers our law enforcement officers face every single day,' she said in a statement Sunday.
