
Category confusion mirrors shifting definition of ‘TV'
There was the usual scattering of snubs (justice for Diego Luna!) and surprises (so good to see the 77-year-old Kathy Bates getting attention for Matlock — and for network TV!).
And as always with the Emmys, there was a certain amount of category confusion. The contentious debate over what qualifies as comedy and what qualifies as drama continues this year. But there are other questions raised by our increasingly complex, overwhelming and overlapping viewing universe. What exactly is a 'television movie' these days? What does 'limited series' even mean anymore?
The Emmys started way back in 1949, when nominees included titles like What's the Name of that Song? The Television Academy's awards continued through decades when folks watched three TV channels on a box in their living room.
Now we have entertainment being delivered by multi-platforming, vertically integrated global conglomerates, with options spread across broadcast TV, cable TV and proliferating streaming services. Then there's the simultaneous-release model, in which movies debut on big screens and small screens at the same time.
The Emmys are ostensibly a way to award excellence in television, but they have also become a way to track the seismic shifts in what we watch, how we watch, and even why we watch.
Emmy categories have always modified as viewing patterns have changed. In the early 1950s, for instance, the drama side was divided into 'Best Dramatic Series,' 'Best Mystery or Intrigue Series' and 'Best Western or Adventure Series.'
Overall, though, the lines between comedy and drama have remained clear-cut.
From the '60s onwards, comedies were generally 30 minutes long, while dramas expanded magisterially to an hour. Comedies often involved catchy theme songs, laugh tracks, running jokes and wacky neighbours. Dramas often meant hospitals, courtrooms, police precincts, serious talk and big issues.
Lately, those lines have blurred to the point the straight-up binary of drama and comedy doesn't really work anymore. Partly, it feels as if we're living in a tragicomic era, an 'if you don't laugh, you'll cry' world, and our pop culture reflects that. But TV writing has also evolved, becoming more hybridized, more in-between.
There are now feel-bad comedies, cringe comedies and trauma-coms that can be as difficult and draining to watch as Chernobyl. Think Fleabag, a hilarious story about grief.
Then there are dramedies where gruelling emotions and big ideas get peppered with jokes. Think Succession, a drama about family dysfunction and late-capitalist crisis that sometimes plays like a foulmouthed sitcom.
In this year's Drama noms, The Pitt feels the most like an old-school Emmy drama, covering life-and-death stakes in an underfunded, overcrowded Pittsburgh ER.
But The White Lotus? With its uniformly ghastly characters, it probably works better as sharp, nasty eat-the-rich satire. Certainly, its most memorable beats were comic in this latest season. ('Piper, nooooooo!') Or Severance? While the show's continuing examination of the impossibility of work-life balance reached astonishing moments of poignance, the story still retains its core of super-stylized, deadpan absurdist humour. Can a series that features Burt G.'s head carved from watermelon ever really class as drama?
Then there's Slow Horses. Because it's a spy series and a lot of people die (like, a lot), it's viewed as a drama. But its titular screw-up spies spend more time wrangling with their crosstown colleagues than they do on proper espionage. And honestly, Gary Oldman as their shambolic but shrewd leader has never been funnier. I laughed more at Slow Horses than I ever did at Season 3 of The Bear.
And that brings us to issues in the Comedy category. The Bear was already facing backlash for submitting in the comedy category before its mopey third season.
Meanwhile, other shows are testing the limits of comedy, often in intriguing ways.
This season of Nathan Fielder's wildly uncomfortable docu-comedy The Rehearsal, which was nominated for comedy writing and directing, was funny — provided you didn't have any plane travel booked. But as Fielder's experimental and deliberately awkward comic approach took on real-life issues in air safety, it was also terrifying.
Partly what determines Emmy categories is not subject matter or even tone but strategy on the part of the production studios. This year, there were 126 submissions in the drama category, making for the most crowded and competitive classification, 69 in the comedy and 33 in the limited series category.
The limited series category is for shows with a predetermined number of episodes that tell a complete, non-recurring narrative. It's exemplified this year by the British series Adolescence, which felt brilliant, dark and absolutely unrepeatable.
But sometimes the studio approach is to make a supposedly limited series and then see what happens. If nobody tunes in, well, it was definitely limited. If the show is a hit, though, then perhaps that self-contained story can be stretched out a little. Downton Abbey started as a limited series — which the Emmys were calling a miniseries at the time — and then just kept going. (And going and going.)
This year The Penguin, starring Colin Farrell (and his prosthetics) and Cristin Milioti, makes for an interesting case. It leads the Limited Series pack, but its 24 nominations have created such a buzz, there are already rumours about a possible Season 2.
There's a lot going on, then, with this year's Emmy nominations, and in September we'll see how this all plays out. In the meantime, nominees might want to take some advice from those nervous characters in The Studio, who can tell you that awards shows don't matter at all. (Except they do.)
alison.gillmor@freepress.mb.ca
Alison GillmorWriter
Studying at the University of Winnipeg and later Toronto's York University, Alison Gillmor planned to become an art historian. She ended up catching the journalism bug when she started as visual arts reviewer at the Winnipeg Free Press in 1992.
Read full biography
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Montreal Gazette
3 days ago
- Montreal Gazette
Brownstein: Ted Lasso's Nick Mohammed takes a winning kick at Just for Laughs
Ted Lasso fans best not go to the Just for Laughs solo show Mr. Swallow: Show Pony expecting one of the series's stars, the Emmy-nominated Nick Mohammed, to reprise his role as rival soccer-team coach Nate. Mohammed's character on Ted Lasso is forever brooding and morose and feeling betrayed. Mohammed's work in Mr. Swallow: Show Pony is anything but. Attired in a glittering gold lamé jacket, Mohammed speaks frenetically in a high-pitched tone and displays the sort of high-end energy that sounds like way too much helium intake. Mohammed's act here is mentalism, magic, music, drama and — oh yeah — comedy with raucous crowd interaction. Simply put, the show, running until Saturday at Le Gesù, is rollickingly hysterical and about as original as anything ever assembled on a JFL stage — which is saying something in light of past fest performances from Mr. Methane and Stevie (the Regurgitator) Starr. Without giving away too much about his show, Mohammed's Mr. Swallow explains, with self-deprecating wit, how he must carry the aspirations of England's South Asian community on his shoulders — even though Mohammed is not South Asian as many presume: his mom is from Cyprus and his dad from Trinidad. He also notes, removing a shoe and sock, that he has been mysteriously endowed with a white foot to help him get his foot in the door of a lily-white cultural industry. Mohammed throws everything into his act, save for the roller skates he has been known to don and occasionally dazzle audiences with on stage. In his dressing room following his debut show Wednesday evening, Mohammed, 44, simply attired in a black T-shirt, is low-key and calm. While his stage act is well known in the U.K., he realizes crowds on this side of the pond could be taken by surprise with his Mr. Swallow antics. 'This is a character, truly based on a teacher of mine, that I've been doing since I was 15 in my school playground and professionally for the last 20 years,' he says. 'It's been with me for so, so long. 'I've always loved magic and mentalism, but that sort of crept out of my career once other comedy took over. I used to gig as a working magician, table hopping at weddings and hotels. Now I've tried to refine it a little.' Given his wide-ranging, cheerful, extroverted skills, one may wonder why he was ever cast to play such a dour, introverted character like Ted Lasso's Nate. 'The role actually got quite challenging toward the end. But I've always loved the idea of being quite malleable in terms of the way you inhabit a different character. For me, that's the real joy of being an actor — like the Ted Lasso character, whom I found so interesting on a different level,' explains Mohammed, who has appeared in films like The Martian with Matt Damon and the coming Control with James McAvoy and Julianne Moore. But Mohammed, who has been nominated twice for a supporting-actor Emmy for the Apple streaming series, says he has been gobsmacked by Ted Lasso's global popularity. 'It's weird, because for the first season we were all quite sheltered from the success of it. We weren't travelling because of COVID. But now we can't get away from it. And we're all so grateful for it.' The fourth season of Ted Lasso — winner of back-to-back Outstanding Comedy Series Emmys for its first two seasons — just started production in ... not London, as in the previous seasons, but Kansas City, the hometown of lead star Jason Sudeikis. But the plan is to return to London. In this iteration, Ted (Sudeikis) takes on a new challenge: coaching a second-division women's soccer team. Series regulars like Emmy winners Hannah Waddingham and Brett Goldstein, along with Brendan Hunt and Jeremy Swift, are all back for another kick at the ball. But Mohammed is here, so whither Nate? The glint in his eye suggests Nate may not be forsaken in Season 4. 'Well, who knows? We'll have to see,' he allows, before letting loose with a hearty laugh. 'I know they're in Kansas at the moment, so we'll just see what happens.' Pause. 'I'm being very coy.' But the coyness and wide grin show no trace of bitterness, so one could easily infer that Nate will be back on the pitch, likely in a melancholic state once again. 'These are all good theories,' he says. 'And don't forget they film these shows over a long time.' Mohammed concedes that while his dad was a huge soccer fan who took him to games, he was much more arts-oriented growing up. 'I spent a lot of time doing magic and playing music, but I also liked to do a lot of gymnastics as a kid. But since doing Ted Lasso, I'm increasingly falling in love with the sport. Jason and Brett and producer Joe Kelly, who created the show together, are such sports nuts, so you can't help but be affected by it.' This is Mohammed's first foray to Montreal and JFL, but, based on opening-night reaction, it won't be his last. 'I've always tried to do something that's a bit of an antidote to something that can get too heavy, but what's nice in this show hopefully is that there is a little bit of stuff in there about race and identity. It's like having my cake and eating it.' And certainly getting his foot in the door. AT A GLANCE


Edmonton Journal
6 days ago
- Edmonton Journal
Malcolm-Jamal Warner, who played Theo on 'Cosby Show', dies in Costa Rica drowning
Article content Malcolm-Jamal Warner, who as teenage son Theo Huxtable on 'The Cosby Show' was central to a cultural phenomenon that helped define the 1980s, died at 54 in an accidental drowning in Costa Rica, authorities there said Monday. Article content Costa Rica's Judicial Investigation Department said Warner drowned Sunday afternoon on a beach on Costa Rica's Caribbean coast. He was swimming at Playa Cocles in Limon province when a current pulled him deeper into the ocean. Article content Article content 'He was rescued by people on the beach,' the department's initial report said, but first responders from Costa Rica's Red Cross found him without vital signs and he was taken to the morgue. Article content Warner created many TV moments etched in the memories of Generation X children and their parents, including a pilot-episode argument with Bill Cosby's Cliff Huxtable about money, and another episode where Theo tries to hide his ear piercing from his dad. His Theo was the only son among four daughters in the household of Cliff Huxtable and Phylicia Rashad's Clair Huxtable on the NBC sitcom, and he would be one of the prime representations of American teenage boyhood on a show that was the most popular in America for much of its run from 1984 to 1992. Article content He played the role for eight seasons, appearing in each of the show's 197 episodes and earning an Emmy nomination for supporting actor in a comedy in 1986. For many the lasting image of the character, and of Warner, is of him wearing a badly botched mock designer shirt sewed by his sister Denise, played by Lisa Bonet. The 'Gordon Gartrell' shirt later became a memeable image: Anthony Mackie wore one on 'The Tonight Show' with Jimmy Fallon and the profile picture on Warner's Instagram shows a toddler sporting one. Article content Article content NBA Hall of Famer Magic Johnson was among those giving tribute Monday. Johnson said on X that he and his wife are sad to hear of the death of their friend. Article content 'We were both super fans of the hit 'Cosby Show' and continued to follow his career on shows like 'Malcolm and Eddie' and 'The Resident,'' Johnson said. 'Every time I ran into Malcolm, we would have deep and fun conversations about basketball, life, and business. He will truly be missed.' Article content Article content Like the rest of the 'Cosby Show' cast, Warner had to contend with the sexual assault allegations against its titular star, whose conviction in a Pennsylvania court was later overturned. Article content Warner told The Associated Press in 2015 that the show's legacy was 'tarnished.' Article content 'My biggest concern is when it comes to images of people of color on television and film,' Warner said. 'We've always had 'The Cosby Show' to hold up against that. And the fact that we no longer have that, that's the thing that saddens me the most because in a few generations the Huxtables will have been just a fairy tale.'


Winnipeg Free Press
6 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Gen Xers mourn drowning death of The Cosby Show's Theo actor Malcolm-Jamal Warner
DETROIT (AP) — For Black youth and teens growing up in the mid-1980s, 'The Cosby Show' offered something rarely seen on television up until that time — a sitcom that placed characters who looked like them in a positive light. And Malcolm-Jamal Warner's 'Theo Huxtable' was the character Generation X most related to. Fans took quickly to social media on Monday as news of Warner's accidental drowning in Costa Rica spread. 'It's like losing one of us,' said Harriet Cammock, a 58-year-old Detroit author and speaker. 'This is the thing with television. When you're watching people every week on television, you think you know them and you're related to them.' Warner was swimming Sunday afternoon at Playa Cocles in Costa Rica's Limon province when a current pulled him deeper into the Caribbean, according to that country's Judicial Investigation Department. First responders found him without vital signs. 'The Cosby Show' was groundbreaking and a ratings giant, drawing in viewers across racial, cultural and economic backgrounds. The show ran for 197 episodes from 1984 to 1992. In 1986, Warner earned an Emmy nomination for supporting actor in a comedy. The show starring Bill Cosby as Cliff Huxtable and Phylicia Rashad as his wife Clair and 'made the wider society aware that there are Black people who live like white people do,' said Cammock, who is Black. 'The perception that we don't live like they do was hurtful.' Lynn Reasonover, 62, of Oak Lawn, Illinois, began receiving messages Monday afternoon about Warner's death. Her initial thoughts were 'Nope, didn't happen.' 'Then, I kept seeing the news flashes and friends started sending texts,' Reasonover said. 'So, it's sinking in. Makes you realize how much some celebrities help shape our memories. His work had such a huge impact. I'm feeling a personal loss because we grew up with him. It's like losing a part of our childhood.' Reasonover saw much of her family in the Huxtables where both parents were professionals who valued education and handled family issues with understanding and love. 'They had similar problems to what we experienced growing up,' she said. 'We could relate and that's why we laughed.' Rasheda Williams, 46, of Detroit was about the same age as Rudy, the youngest character on 'The Cosby Show' and Theo's little sister. Williams said she and others are mourning Warner's passing because of what they saw in the character he played. 'He's like the ideal cousin you wish you had,' Williams said. 'Hearing the news has really affected some of us. It was unexpected. He wasn't sick. That makes it even more tragic.' 'He wasn't just an actor,' she said. 'He was also an activist, a positive role model, not just for young Black men, but for young Black women as well.'