What this attack submarine sidelined for a decade says about the US Navy's maintenance failures
The Los Angeles-class sub came up during the confirmation hearing of Adm. Daryl Caudle, President Donald Trump's pick for top admiral. The Senate recently confirmed him as the new chief of naval operations.
Last month, Caudle responded to fresh concerns about the Boise and questions of whether it might be time to scrap the boat. He told the US Senate Armed Services Committee that if he were confirmed, he'd look hard at the Boise's situation.
"The decision whether or not to actually walk away from Boise is a big one, and I want to make sure I clearly understand the trajectory and trends," Caudle said, responding to a question from Sen. Mike Rounds, a South Dakota Republican who had asked him if it was time to "just simply pull the plug on that one."
"I hear you loud and clear, senator, on how unacceptable it is, how long she's been in the yards," the admiral said.
He added that the Boise's delays were "a dagger in my heart as a submarine officer." Caudle previously served as commander on three nuclear-powered submarines and was the commander of Submarine Forces Atlantic and Submarine Forces, US Pacific Fleet.
The Boise and the larger US Navy shipbuilding and maintenance issues were major topics of conversation in Caudle's hearing. The Boise was originally launched in 1991 and conducted operations until early 2015, when it wrapped up its last patrol and docked at Naval Station Norfolk for scheduled repairs.
Limited dry dock availability and workforce capacity left the Boise and its crew waiting. In 2016, the vessel lost its ability to perform unrestricted operations, and then it lost its dive certification in the following year. Those developments were then followed by more waiting, leaving the valuable combat asset out of action.
In 2019, then- US Secretary of Defense Mark Esper visited the Boise and praised the crew for maintaining "readiness and lethality" as the vessel was still standing by for repairs.
In February 2024, the Navy awarded prominent shipbuilder Huntington Ingalls Industries (HII) a $1.2 billion contract to begin an engineering overhaul on the Boise. The work is expected to be completed by 2029, meaning the ship will not have set sail on a patrol for roughly 15 years by the time it's finished. That's a staggering waste of an expensive, front-line asset. Even when the work is done, the ship will be nearing the end of its service life.
The Boise has thus emerged as an example of overstretched and under-resourced shipyards, insufficient planning, and the challenges of budget instabilities that affect Navy readiness. The sea service did not immediately respond to request for comment from Business Insider.
Work on US nuclear-powered submarines is typically handled by one of the Navy's four public shipyards, which have seen dramatic demands in recent decades due to a lack of investment in maintenance from the Navy and the increased complexity of the subs and nuclear-powered aircraft carriers, Bryan Clark, a retired Navy submarine officer and defense expert at the Hudson Institute, told Business Insider.
A "combination of factors created a huge backlog at the shipyards," Clark said.
The long tail of COVID-19 disruptions, particularly for supply chains and labor pools, added strain to Navy shipyards in the early 2020s. In more recent years, experts have pointed to persistent workforce shortages, uneven investment, and inconsistent Navy planning as critical causes of ongoing delays in major shipbuilding programs and maintenance backlogs.
The Navy's long-standing struggles with routine maintenance stretch back decades, with challenges including persistent shipyard bottlenecks, limited dry dock availability, troubling scheduling missteps, workforce shortages, unreliable or inconsistent maintenance data, and unforeseen issues that tend to emerge during repairs and cause significant delays.
Supply chain problems and shortages of spare parts and critical materials have also added to the strain.
These issues, combined with broader weaknesses in the Navy's shipbuilding enterprise, have raised concerns within the service and on Capitol Hill about the fleet's size and overall readiness, particularly as the US emphasizes the need to deter or, if necessary, fight a potential conflict with a major power like China, which has far greater shipbuilding and repair capacity.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
12 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Thousands Of People Are Thinking The Same Thing After The Trump Administration Said That Teenagers Are Now Eligible To Be ICE Agents
I assume we're all just a little too familiar with Kristi Noem by this point. She's the US Homeland Security Secretary under President Donald Trump, and has been committed to helping him carry out his mass deportation goals during his second term. Noem has celebrated the openings of new immigration detention facilities like "Alligator Alcatraz" and the "Speedway Slammer" and shown up to cosplay as an ICE agent conducting raids in Los Angeles. Noem recently hopped on Fox News to promote recruitment for ICE, and at the end, she shared that the age requirements to become an agent were changing. "We've removed any of the age barriers. We no longer have a cap on how old you can be, or you can continue at age 18," she told Lawrence B. Jones on a segment of Fox & Friends. "Sign up for ICE and join us and be a part of it. We'll get you trained and ready to be equipped to go out on the streets and help protect families. Related: Newsweek wrote an article about Noem's announcement, also reporting that "To lure candidates, ICE is offering incentives including signing bonuses of up to $50,000, student loan forgiveness, enhanced retirement benefits and extensive overtime opportunities." The outlet later posted the story to the r/politics subreddit, where thousands of people reacted and commented. People had some choice words, including dozens of comparisons to the youth wing of the Nazi party, which sought to indoctrinate young Germans. Here's what some commenters had to say: 1."Ahh the restart of Hitler Youth." —Maddogskip 2."Yeah, give an 18-year-old a gun and a badge. Nothing will possibly go wrong. These baby agents are going to end up shooting themselves or other officers in a panic." —thedoppio 3."Already here. ICE is his SS." —Ozymanadidas 4."Wow, $50,000 signing bonus for hired thugs, but $0 for teachers and first responders. Priorities." —RealPersonResponds Related: 5."Does it come with knives, scout uniforms with lederhosen, and a bright red armband?" —Blochamolesauce 6."Straight from Gestapo to Trumpler Youth. Textbook stuff." —floyd_underpants 7."Trump's version of Hitler's Youth and Brownshirts. 'Trump's Youth' has a terrible ring to it. Also, a teen should not be given that type of power. Allow them to walk around holding loaded rifles and allow them to kidnap people based on skin color? FFS, Trump, no one should be allowed to do that." —iiitme 8."I mean, most of the existing agents behave like teenagers, so this makes sense." —DistractedPhoenix Related: 9."Some kid is going to get shot or seriously hurt from this." —NimDing218 10."Oh, so student loan forgiveness is OK as long as you're a Nazi. Got it." —horseradish_is_gross 11."Dictators love kids. Witness when Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge would take skilled workers, have them train a kid to do the job, then execute the worker. Children are much more malleable." —outinthecountry66 12."Thanks, protest voters and MAGA. Great job causing this." —Fakeskinsuit 13."Sign up to be a huge POS! Fuck that." —Moist-muff 14."He's practically begging people to join. Huge signing bonus. Student loan forgiveness. Now, child labor is needed because so many people don't want to participate in his Nazi bullshit. He saw the Gen Z white voting demographic and lowered the age." —jaron_b 15."Brainwash the 18-year-old youth. Old military trick." —morbob Related: 16."Nazi youth coming your way." —fairoaks2 17."Every day, another dumbass thing. If you don't trust teens to drink, should you trust them to be making armed arrests?" —BigRonDongson 18."Incel Collection Establishment." —Edelgeuse 19."Oh, this shouldn't cause any problems whatsoever. Kyle Rittenhouses running around everywhere. Yup. Teenage boys most certainly have the mental acumen for it. I hate this timeline…" —Don-Von-Shitzenpants finally, "Ah, yes. The reintroduction of the Hitler Youth. It was only a matter of time." —MuchDevelopment7084 What do you think? Let us know in the comments. Note: Submissions have been edited for length and/or clarity. Also in In the News: Also in In the News: Also in In the News:
New York Post
13 minutes ago
- New York Post
James Carville urges Dems to ‘unilaterally' pack Supreme Court, make Puerto Rico, DC new blue states ‘to save democracy'
Democratic strategist James Carville urged on Wednesday that Democrats open 'Pandora's Box' and execute multiple controversial power grabs to 'save democracy,' including establishing a permanent electoral majority the next time they gain power. 'The Democrats talk about democracy – the importance of democracy and preserving democracy and saving democracy,' Carville said. 'Well, the truth of the matter is, people are right when they say this democracy is really imperfect.' Carville listed several perceived imbalances in the current system, including Texas attempting to redraw its congressional districts. He argued that if Democrats can pull off a resounding victory in 2028 – winning the presidency, the Senate, and the House – they should use it to enshrine their power in unprecedented ways. 'They are just going to have to unilaterally add Puerto Rico and District of Columbia states,' Carville said. 'They're going to have to do it. They're just going to have to do it. And they may have to expand the [Supreme Court] to 13 members,' he said. While he once would have viewed such actions as politically risky, Carville argued that the Democrats have no other choice in this era of President Donald Trump. 3 Democratic strategist James Carville urged his fellow party members to pack the Supreme Court in the next general election cycle. REUTERS 3 Carville said if the Democratic Party can sweep the 2028 election, they should use it to enshrine their power in unprecedented ways. Getty Images for SCAD 3 Carville said Democrats have no choice but to take advantage of their power in the current era of President Donald Trump. Ron Sachs/CNP / 'Any of those things in isolation I would be skeptical about. I would be cautious about. I would say, 'Well, I don't know if that's the greatest idea in the world, you're opening Pandora's Box,'' he said. 'If you want to save democracy, I think you got to do all of those things because we just are moving further and further away from being anything close to democracy.' Carville said he was unsure if 'it's something that they should talk about during the campaign,' but argued it should be a day one priority once Democrats are elected.
New York Post
13 minutes ago
- New York Post
EPA terminates $7 billion Biden-era grant program, cutting solar access to thousands of US households
The Environmental Protection Agency on Thursday terminated a $7 billion grant program that was intended to help pay for residential solar projects for more than 900,000 lower-income U.S. households. It's the latest Trump administration move hindering the nation's shift to cleaner energy. The funding, part of Democratic President Joe Biden's Solar for All program, was awarded to 60 recipients including states, tribes and regions for investments such as rooftop solar and community solar gardens. Advertisement 3 The Environmental Protection Agency eliminated a $7 billion grant program from the Biden administration to help low-income homes across the U.S. have solar power. AP Solar, a renewable energy, is widely regarded as a way to introduce cleaner power onto the electrical grid and lower energy bills for American consumers. EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin said in a statement on social media that authority for the program was eliminated under the tax-and-spending bill signed last month by Republican President Donald Trump. Advertisement The law eliminated the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund that was approved under the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act. The fund set aside $20 billion in 'green bank' money for community development projects to boost renewable energy, and an additional $7 billion for the solar program. 'The bottom line is this: EPA no longer has the statutory authority to administer the program or the appropriated funds to keep this boondoggle alive,″ Zeldin said. 'Today, the Trump EPA is announcing that we are ending Solar for All for good, saving US taxpayers ANOTHER $7 BILLION!' Advertisement 3 The latest move by the Trump administration will have close to 900,000 households across the nation lose access to solar energy in their homes. AP Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt, who introduced the Solar for All program to slash electric bills for working families, called Zeldin's action illegal. 'Solar for All means lower utility bills, many thousands of good-paying jobs and real action to address the existential threat of climate change,″ Sanders said in a statement. 'At a time when working families are getting crushed by skyrocketing energy costs and the planet is literally burning, sabotaging this program isn't just wrong — it's absolutely insane. We will fight back to preserve this enormously important program.' Advertisement The Trump administration has already targeted the 'green bank' funds, first freezing the grants, then terminating the agreements altogether. 3 In a statement, EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin said, 'Today, the Trump EPA is announcing that we are ending Solar for All for good, saving US taxpayers ANOTHER $7 BILLION!' AP Zeldin called them 'a clear cut case of waste and abuse' and a 'gold bar' scheme earlier this year. The EPA has argued that the tax and policy bill law repealed the green bank and allows the agency to rescind the money it has already obligated. The recipients of that money disagree. They say the bulk of the money had already been disbursed and isn't affected by the law. Grant recipients have filed lawsuits challenging the administration's actions, and a judge ruled in April the EPA cannot freeze the contracts. Advertisement Rhode Island Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, the top Democrat on the Senate Environment Committee, called Zeldin's elimination of the solar program a betrayal 'that will further hike electricity costs and make our power grid less reliable.' 'Trump is — yet again — putting his fossil fuel megadonors first,' he added.
