Dodgers star Shohei Ohtani and agent accused of sabotaging $240M Hawaii real estate project
A Hawaii real estate investor and broker are suing Shohei Ohtani, claiming the Los Angeles Dodgers star and his agent got them fired from a $240 million luxury housing development on the Big Island's coveted Hapuna Coast that they brought him in to endorse.
According to the lawsuit filed in Hawaii Circuit Court on Friday, Ohtani's agent, Nez Balelo, increasingly demanded concessions from developer Kevin J. Hayes Sr. and real estate broker Tomoko Matsumoto before demanding that their business partner, Kingsbarn Realty Capital, drop them from the deal.
'Balelo and Otani, who were brought into the venture solely for Otani's promotional and branding value, exploited their celebrity leverage to destabilize and ultimately dismantle Plaintiffs' role in the project — for no reason other than their own financial self-interest,' the lawsuit claims.
The suit accuses Ohtani and Balelo of tortious interference and unjust enrichment. Hayes, a developer with 40 years of experience, and Matsumoto, who was to be the listing agent for the houses averaging $17.3 million each, say that Ohtani and Balelo also tried to undermine their interests in a second, neighboring venture.
A spokesman for Balelo's agency, CAA Baseball, declined comment. Attempts to reach Kingsbarn officials for comment were not immediately successful.
'This case is about abuse of power,' the lawsuit says. 'Defendants used threats and baseless legal claims to force a business partner to betray its contractual obligations and strip Plaintiffs of the very project they conceived and built.
'Defendants must be held accountable for their actions, not shielded by fame or behind-the-scenes agents acting with impunity. Plaintiffs bring this suit to expose Defendants' misconduct and to ensure that the rules of contract, fair dealing, and accountability apply equally to all — celebrity or not.'
Ohtani, 31, arrived from Japan in 2018 as perhaps the most heralded international star in baseball history, with an ability to both pitch and hit that made him doubly valuable to his team. A five-time All-Star and three-time Most Valuable Player, he signed a record 10-year, $700-million contract with the Dodgers before last season and helped the team win the 2024 World Series.
Investment materials for The Vista at Mauna Kea Resort, which remained online on Monday night, listed Hayes and Matsumoto as part of the management team, along with Kingsbarn. It called Ohtani 'Japan's Babe Ruth' and the '1st Resident,' giving him top billing ahead of the iconic Mauna Kea Resort, 'one of the most celebrated hotels in Hawaii,' Hapuna Beach, 'rated the #1 beach in America by Conde Nast Traveler' and two golf courses – one designed by Arnold Palmer, the other by Robert Trent Jones Sr.
'Ohtani will act as the celebrity spokesperson for the project and has committed to purchasing one of the 14 residences within the project,' the brochure says. 'He also intends to spend significant time at The Vista in the off-season and will construct a small hitting and pitching facility for preseason training."
The suit says the developers spent 11 years working on the deal and 'as part of a bold marketing strategy' signed an endorsement deal in 2023 with Ohtani, 'one of the most high-profile endorsements imaginable."
'This partnership with Ohtani will elevate the demand and create buzz within the Japanese luxury vacation home market, which is a primary target audience for the project," the investment brochure said. 'We see Shohei Ohtani's homeownership as having a significant impact on the global exposure of the project and expect to accelerate the pace of sales, thereby helping us achieve our pricing objectives.'
The suit said Balelo 'quickly became a disruptive force,' threatening to pull Ohtani from the deal if concessions weren't made.
'Kingsbarn began capitulating to Balelo's every whim,' the suit said. 'Over time, it became increasingly obvious that Kingsbarn was more concerned about preserving its relationship with Otani than honoring its obligations to its business partners.'
Last month, in what the suit called 'a coordinated ambush,' Kingsbarn fired Hayes and Matsumoto.
'Kingsbarn openly admitted during the call that Balelo had demanded the terminations and that they were being done solely to placate him,' the suit said. 'Plaintiffs stand to lose millions of dollars in compensation tied to projected homebuilding profit, construction management fees, and broker commissions.'
___
AP MLB: https://apnews.com/hub/mlb
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
26 minutes ago
- Forbes
The Rise Of The Ranchette For Business And Investment
Shaun Michael Lewis is the CEO of Clearwater Properties. Investors have discovered something known to rural America for a long time: Great things are possible with small pieces of rural land. What appeared to be a real estate trend has now gained a real footing and may represent a fundamental shift in the way in which investors and entrepreneurs are approaching location, scale and opportunity. These investors are turning to 'ranchettes,' typically defined as rural properties between 5 and 40 acres in size. A trend that at one time was almost strictly the domain of retirement-age buyers seeking hobby farms has now expanded to include young professionals, serious investors and even corporations seeking portfolio diversification amid economic uncertainty and a saturation of more traditional ventures. What Is Driving This Trend? What is causing the surge in this trend? I believe there are several converging factors: During periods of inflation, hard assets tend to attract investors because they're seen as a reliable store and driver of value. Land represents a classic 'hedge,' offering both return through agribusiness use and appreciation via development potential. The pandemic fundamentally changed the perspective of many Americans as to density and open space, including investors and entrepreneurs. The psychological impact of the lockdowns seems to have enhanced the value of alternative locations that exist outside of dense urban environments. Improvements in rural connectivity, in conjunction with the emergence of tools for working or running businesses remotely, has reduced the barriers for both semi-absentee ownership and full-time remote work in rural areas. I've worked with investors who, concerned about the resilience of food systems, are increasingly interested in properties with a potential for small-scale agriculture. Even if these investors never grow anything commercially, the option to potentially do so provides value. There also exists a financial rationale for buying these properties, albeit one that varies considerably by region. In my work, I've observed some common characteristics shared by properties that experience the highest levels of appreciation: proximity to growing metropolitan areas, natural amenities such as lakes, streams or mountain views, and favorable zoning regulations. The return on a ranchette investment can come in different forms, whether from land appreciation, tax benefits arising from agricultural exemptions, potential income streams from grazing leases or specialty crops, or even conservation easements in certain regions. There exists an entrepreneurial angle, too, as the possible creative uses of these properties exist in staggering numbers. An entrepreneur might consider launching a craft brewery or winery, an organic farm or restaurant, artisan workshops, and many other ventures. The risk profile for ranchettes does differ significantly from more traditional real estate investments, especially when the former investments have established businesses that tend to maintain value during economic downturns because they generate revenue rather than relying solely upon appreciation. Who Is Buying Ranchettes? The demographic profile (including age) of investors buying small rural properties has shifted in some areas in recent years, and based on my own and other firms' experience in this domain, several distinct categories of buyers have emerged: Younger investors who have observed their peers' earned wealth evaporate during recessions or market crashes, and who are dissatisfied with traditional investment vehicles may be drawn to more tangible assets. These individuals, with legitimate skepticism about market stability, are seeking out investments that offer potential appreciation and business opportunities. Some buyers are betting purely on appreciation after watching land values in certain rural corridors rising. Such properties, including those within reasonable driving distances of growing metropolitan areas, have the potential to experience superb increases in value. Some companies are buying ranchettes for use as employee retreats or remote working hubs. Such use cases typically involve higher-end properties with existing infrastructure than can be repurposed for remote work, meetings or company retreats. High-earning professionals increasingly have the ability to work from anywhere, and I've seen some of them leveraging that geographic flexibility. Tech workers, consultants and even creative professionals have come to the realization that they need not be constrained to high-cost urban locations. They now have the freedom to take their big metro salaries to rural areas where prices for land are far more reasonable. Future Outlook I expect to see continuous growth in ranchettes as investments, particularly if professionals continue embracing freedom of location. Despite this, I've seen the most premium properties in the most desirable locations becoming increasingly scarce, which could result in higher prices and push buyers to seek out previously overlooked areas. Technology will continue to expand the possibilities, especially considering the emergence of satellite internet, improvements in off-grid solutions, and flexible work and management systems. I believe the next wave of ranchette businesses will only grow in terms of their sophistication and viability. The Reality Check Despite the appeal and benefits of ranchette investment, it is by no means a guaranteed path to success. Rural entrepreneurship employs a different skill set than that required for urban businesses. Infrastructure challenges are real, even with continuous technological improvements. Weather, seasonal and tourist fluctuations, and local operations can often complicate business operations in ways that would not affect urban entrepreneurs. The most pronounced risk may be overconfidence. Buying the property is relatively straightforward. Building a profitable business on that same property requires planning, discipline and execution much like any other venture. The rural setting, while different, doesn't eliminate fundamental business challenges. Nevertheless, for entrepreneurs seeking ventures outside of the norm, ranchettes represent an opportunity to build something truly different: an enterprise firmly rooted in community, place and authenticity. The information provided here is not investment, tax or financial advice. You should consult with a licensed professional for advice concerning your specific situation. Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
A lawsuit involving Kroger and singer Jewel could shed light on why the former supermarket CEO mysteriously resigned
In March, Kroger's CEO resigned from his corner-office role after nearly five decades at the company — an abrupt exit that left questions and $11 million on the table. Now, a lawsuit involving '90s folk sensation Jewel could bring some answers. Rodney McMullen, who joined Kroger in 1978, left after an internal investigation into 'his personal conduct,' the grocer said in a statement at the time. The Cincinnati-based company had kept the details tightly under wraps. A lawsuit from 2023 might push Kroger or McMullen himself to reveal those details. In legal filings, the plaintiffs — which include a company co-owned by singer-songwriter Jewel Kilcher — accused Kroger of breach of contract over a wellness festival partnership. McMullen isn't a defendant in the lawsuit, but he was identified as a trial witness. McMullen and his lawyer refused to answer questions about his resignation during deposition this year and requested a protective order to bar questioning on the 'embarrassing' topic, as described by his lawyer in court documents. But an Ohio judge had ordered McMullen to submit a written response by August 8 about his resignation, including the names of people involved. There will be 'incredible consequences… if this ever gets out,' McMullen's lawyer, Jeffrey Hinebaugh, said in front of the judge in May. Hinebaugh added that 'having to sit there and explain to people something that's completely unrelated and personal is the embarrassment.' The plaintiffs, meanwhile, said these questions are 'routine' and could reveal the corporate culture at Kroger. 'We respect the court's thoughtful ruling, and we're pleased that the court is not giving Mr. McMullen a free pass to avoid testifying just because the former CEO's lawyer says that answering questions would be embarrassing,' Brian O'Connor, a lawyer representing the plaintiffs, said in a statement to CNN. CNN has reached out to Hinebaugh for comment. Kroger declined to comment. However, the public will not get its eyes on McMullen's written response. If the court grants the protective order, the statement will be made part of the record kept under seal – meaning it's only available under judicial eyes. And if the court denies the request, then the written disclosure won't be entered into the record at all. But if the court decides to deny the request, more information on McMullen's resignation may come out because the plaintiff's lawyers would be able to question the ex-CEO on the topic. A trial is set for May 2026. Wellness festivals not going well Jewel had come up with an idea for a wellness festival alongside Trevor Drinkwater, CEO of Inclusion Companies. Drinkwater's company already had experience creating other retail-sponsored, celebrity-backed festivals like Bentonville Film Festival. Jewel and Drinkwater then decided to partner with Kroger on the 'Wellness Your Way' festivals for five years, according to the lawsuit. There was no formal agreement, but rather an agreement over email in June 2018 since Drinkwater's company would take the financial risk, the lawsuit said. Festivals under the partnership took place from 2018 to 2021, and Jewel performed a total of 12 times and and participated in 45 panels at these events, according to a legal complaint. But after the festivals became profitable, Kroger replaced Drinkwater and Jewel's company with one run by Kroger executive Colleen Lindholz's sister, legal filings allege. The plaintiffs argue this violated Kroger's business ethics policy. '(Lindholz) also informed (Drinkwater) that the festival had become Kroger's premiere annual corporate event, the CEO Rodney McMullen wanted to make it a part of his legacy, and Kroger needed to have ownership and control of it,' the lawsuit said. Kroger and the new company, Advantage, went on to host two more festivals in 2022 and 2023. The lawsuit alleges the plaintiffs lost $2 million of their own money and profits of at least $5 million. McMullen told Jewel over email, 'I'm not involved in planning of the Festival this year. That's Colleen's responsibility. Please communicate with her on this,' according to the lawsuit. McMullen's mysterious departure McMullen resigned in March after a company investigation found his personal conduct was 'inconsistent' with Kroger's ethics policies. The company said it did not involve Kroger's finances and no associates were involved. His resignation came a few months after Kroger rival Albertsons called off its $25 million merger with Kroger amid regulatory pressure. Albertsons subsequently sued Kroger for breach of contract agreement. Albertsons' lawyers, too, are curious about the circumstances leading to McMullen's departure. The company wants to compel Kroger to disclose McMullen's actions because it could have distracted him 'or conflicted with his obligations to Kroger' during the doomed merger process. 'McMullen's conduct and business ethics are central to this litigation,' Albertsons said in a motion filed late July. 'Yet Kroger refuses to produce any documents regarding significant lapses of 'business ethics' so serious they cost McMullen his job weeks after the Merger was blocked.' McMullen earned roughly $15.7 million in 2023, according to an SEC file. With his resignation, he forfeited more than $11 million in unvested stock and options, and any bonuses. CNN's Jordan Valinsky contributed to this report.
Forbes
an hour ago
- Forbes
Passports & Properties: How Travel Inspires Service
Family-led real estate businesses are a common means of developing multi-generational wealth. The long-term vision also benefits communities by promoting sustainable growth instead of quick profits and uncertain consequences. Several recurring traits help family-run real estate firms thrive, even in an industry prevalent with corporate contenders. Multi-Generational Leadership Imparting knowledge and connections from one generation to the next is essential to providing continuity within the company and community. Children and grandchildren can build upon the ethics and values their founding ancestors established. Amr Zaki Developments is a prime example, demonstrating three generations of legacy-focused stewardship that has incrementally begun operating in prominent real estate markets worldwide. Yassin Youssef, Director of Operations, emphasizes how generational leadership is a cornerstone of Amr Zaki Developments' philosophy of legacy, long-term vision, and meaningful community impact. 'Success isn't about shortcuts. It's about vision, belief in yourself, and relentless persistence. Be original in a world full of copies.' Remaining a family-led firm allows the company to cultivate a sustainable legacy to reflect its values, foster trust, and create lasting value for future generations. The firm's roots date back to 1963 when it became one of Egypt's prominent real estate developers by rebuilding war-torn villages and assisting with the national recovery. Specifically, in 1977, founder Mohamed Zaki's first significant project was constructing nine condominium buildings after acquiring French Consulate land in Alexandria. This project yielded a $26 million net profit and solidified Amr Zaki Developments' reputation. In 2003, Amr Zaki, Mohamed's son and the second generation of leadership, expanded the company into North America by establishing a presence in Toronto, Canada. His core tenets were a commitment to excellence, discipline, and community development. Today, the third generation is now at the helm and has branched into the Cayman Islands and the United States. Residential, commercial, and healthcare properties adhere to the same degree of dedication to sustainable growth and community enrichment as previous generations. Notable examples include receiving awards from the President of Egypt for preserving and restoring historic buildings, becoming one of Egypt's leading developers, and recognition within local real estate circles and business networks in the countries in which it operates. Strategic Expansion Instead of focusing on immediate income and increasing shareholder value, family businesses have more liberty in building enduring assets across multiple markets that serve communities and uphold ethical standards. These businesses must still be able to navigate challenges and take calculated risks to secure a long-term legacy and financial sustainability. As many entrepreneurs can attest, success often emerges from failure. For instance, Amr Zaki Developments had to adapt to a completely different business environment and start from scratch with forging strategic partnerships when entering the Canadian market in the early 2000s. The company has faced numerous setbacks and started over. Moreover, the sudden passing of Amr Zaki in 2022 presented personal and professional challenges for the company's new generation of leadership to preserve his legacy while continuing to move forward. Through these challenges, the real estate developer is gaining expertise to build a diverse portfolio that was infeasible as a startup. Specifically, the Canadian portfolio includes: Current leadership is also leveraging its expertise and longstanding values to collaborate on large-scale residential and commercial private equity initiatives from its offices in the Cayman Islands and Palm Beach, Florida. Firms continue innovating as business practices and community needs progress. Community Involvement Instead of completing a real estate project and pursuing the next opportunity, remaining in communities and providing long-term philanthropy is pivotal. Social responsibility allows companies to give back to residents, protect the environment, and increase living standards for years to come. Founded in 1996, the Amr Zaki Foundation provides clean drinking water and essential infrastructure to rural Egyptian communities. This ongoing commitment fosters long-term sustainability for underserved populations to thrive and reflect the family's vision of helping as many as possible realize their financial and personal dreams. Other family-run firms also provide vitality to the communities they serve. One in particular is Houston-based Hines. It strives to build people-centric environments that foster economic resilience, community health, and productivity by assessing local needs. Each employee also receives one paid day off per year to volunteer at a charitable organization of their choice. Many developers are increasingly incorporating eco-friendly practices that leave places better for future residents than when construction begins on the parcel. Sustainable building goes hand in hand with multi-generational leadership. Exceptional Service Family succession in senior leadership, community interaction, and developing a sound strategic plan solidify a firm foundation. Quality service and exceeding customer expectations are vital to winning back repeat customers and withstanding the test of time in a competitive market. Many positive reviews are an excellent starting point, but industry recognition also gains clout. Depending on the business, it can be better to remain local and specialize in a particular niche or cater to a specific community to establish trust and build loyalty with high-quality service. The Otis Warren Group specializes in local residential and commercial real estate. This third-generation firm looks beyond 'bricks and mortar' to earn a profit by offering development, property management, and real estate brokerage for student housing, residential, and commercial properties within the greater Baltimore area. Emphasizing accountability, truth, and best practices are reasons why the firm has won the Maryland Multi-Housing Association Inc. Silver Star Award multiple times. Final Thoughts Running a family-focused real estate business can be highly rewarding. While the market conditions continuously differ and evolve, residential and commercial clients seek stability and want to support firms that invest in the economic and social well-being of the community. Each generation inherits its unique challenges and must continue to innovate and adapt to shifting consumer needs. These variables offer opportunities to strengthen trust with existing families and network with up-and-coming generations, ultimately achieving results that corporations, primarily focused on quarterly profits, often ignore or struggle to satisfy adequately.
