Twelve Hong Kong activists appeal convictions in landmark ‘47 democrats' case
HONG KONG--Twelve Hong Kong pro-democracy activists appealed their subversion convictions and jail terms on Monday in a national security case that has spotlighted Beijing's ongoing crackdown on dissent and drawn international criticism.
The appeal stems from the '47 democrats' case, named for the number of activists who were arrested and charged with 'conspiracy to commit subversion' in early 2021.
The court eventually found 45 of the defendants guilty of organising and holding an unofficial primary election in July 2020 after massive pro-democracy protests brought the city to a standstill. Prosecutors considered the action to be a 'plot' to undermine the Hong Kong government.
Security was tight around the West Kowloon law courts building as scores of police officers, some with police dogs, patrolled the area and occasionally searched passers-by.
'I want to see all of them,' said an elderly man surnamed Wong who was among around 100 people queuing to get a public ticket for the hearing. 'They're not criminals.'
Foreign diplomats from over half a dozen countries were in attendance for this latest stage of the legal saga that began with dawn police raids on the homes of high-profile democrats in early 2021.
Some countries such as the United States have condemned the case as 'politically motivated' and are calling for the immediate release of the democrats who were sentenced last November to prison terms of up to ten years.
Hong Kong and Chinese authorities, however, have defended the independence of the judiciary and say no one is above the law and the democrats have received a fair trial.
Of the 16 democrats who pleaded not guilty during the trial, 11 have decided to appeal, including Gordon Ng, Gwyneth Ho and Owen Chow, who were all jailed for over seven years. Another democrat, Prince Wong, who pleaded guilty, is appealing her sentence.
One defendant, Michael Pang, decided to withdraw his application on Monday.
The appeals are expected to take around 10 days and will also include a government appeal against the acquittal of one of the democrats, barrister Lawrence Lau.
A years-long crackdown under a China-imposed national security law has resulted in arrests, the closures of liberal media outlets and civil society groups. The last two remaining pro-democracy parties, the Democratic Party and the League of Social Democrats, disbanded this year citing growing pressures.
The case is one of the most prominent so far under a 2020 national security law that was imposed by China in response to mass pro-democracy protests in 2019.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Diplomat
32 minutes ago
- The Diplomat
Recall Campaigns Reach Fever Pitch in Taiwan
With less than two weeks until voting, both the KMT and DPP are ramping up outreach to their supporters. With just under two weeks before the recall votes scheduled to take place on July 26, the political atmosphere in Taiwan is tense. The recalls largely target politicians of the Kuomintang (KMT), with over 30 recalls set to take place in the near future – the vast majority of them (24 recall votes) on July 26. Hsinchu Mayor Ann Kao of the Taiwan People's Party (TPP), who was suspended from office on corruption charges and sentenced to seven years and four months in jail, is also among the 24 politicians to face a recall vote on the 26th. Pro-recall and anti-recall rallies are taking place across Taiwan. Anti-recall rallies are primarily organized by the KMT, while pro-recall rallies are organized by both the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) and pro-recall civic groups, such as the Economic Democracy Union or the various local groups that have emerged to campaign for recalls in constituencies across Taiwan. As would occur in an election year, the KMT is relying on a campaign strategy that deploys heavyweight politicians – termed 'hens' (母雞) in Taiwanese political parlance – to campaign for lesser-known politicians, referred to as 'chicks' (小雞). Examples include Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an campaigning for KMT city councilors in Taipei, as well as Taichung Mayor Lu Shiow-yen campaigning for KMT city councilors in Taichung. Campaigning has taken on international dimensions. In the recall signature collection process, international campaigns were organized among overseas Taiwanese in the United States and Europe to submit signatures for recalls. In addition, pro-recall voters have been called on to fly home to vote amid reports that China has also taken measures to make it easier for KMT supporters who are based in China to also return. The KMT has failed to collect enough signatures to force a recall vote for any DPP legislators. However, there was one recall vote against DPP county councilor Chen Yu-ling. The recall was unsuccessful for the KMT, as number of voters did not reach the necessary threshold to be binding. Chen surviving her recall vote has been interpreted by the DPP as a favorable sign. While recalls were mostly organized by civic groups, the DPP has become more of a visible presence in the late stages of the recall campaign, carrying out its own efforts to boost turnout in the voting. Driving up turnout among DPP voters is likely the goal behind a series of ten nationwide speeches by President Lai Ching-te. Assessments of Lai's speeches, which have often focused on reiterating Taiwan's sovereignty and providing a historical narrative that emphasizes Taiwan's sovereignty, have been mixed. Across the Taiwan Strait, the Chinese government has framed them as another pro-independence provocation. The KMT has done similarly, suggesting that Lai is more focused on pushing for Taiwanese independence rather than addressing domestic issues in Taiwan. Still, Lai's speeches are primarily an attempt to influence the recalls, and they have been understood as such domestically. If Lai had in fact made a sudden move to shift the cross-strait status quo, this would have led to stronger domestic reactions. Lai dominated headlines at the start of his series of speeches, which may have been his goal. At times, Lai seemed to set traps for the KMT with his comments, such as when Taichung Mayor Lu Shiow-yen unwisely retorted to a statement by Lai that the People's Republic of China had never controlled Taiwan that this was merely Lai's 'personal view of history.' It is indeed the case that the PRC – which was founded in 1949, four years after the KMT took control of Taiwan – has never controlled Taiwan. Meanwhile, former president Ma Ying-jeou traveled to China for the 17th annual Straits Forum in June, meeting with the Chinese Communist Party's chief ideologist Wang Huning, who is a member of the Politburo Standing Committee. In comments in Xiamen, where the Straits Forum was held, Ma stated, 'No political force can suppress or prevent sincere exchanges between people on both sides of the Strait, let alone block the natural feelings of the Chinese people on both sides of the Strait who share the same roots and origins.' Ma's trip was probably also aimed at influencing the recalls, as a means to reinforce the KMT's traditional claim to be the only political party in Taiwan able to communicate with the CCP and, in this way, to maintain cross-strait peace. After Ma's trip, current KMT party officials such as vice chair Andrew Hsia reiterated that the KMT remains committed to a 'One China' stance. Nevertheless, Ma's comments emphasizing Taiwan as 'Chinese' could potentially backfire, just as the former president had inadvertently stoked public outrage against the KMT shortly before the 2024 elections. In an interview with Deutsche Welle at the time, Ma claimed that Chinese President Xi Jinping could be 'trusted' and argued Taiwan 'can never win' if it came to a war with China. The DPP has put a great deal of effort into recalling KMT legislative caucus leader Fu Kun-chi in his home constituency of Hualien, sending 20 percent of central party staff to Hualien to assist with the effort. Fu is often seen as the architect of the KMT actions in the past two years that provoked the recalls: the largest set of government budget cuts in Taiwanese history, expanding legislative powers to allow for new powers of investigation, and freezing the Constitutional Court. Although current Vice President Hsiao Bikhim previously held the seat currently occupied by Fu from 2012 to 2020, Hualien generally votes pan-Blue, raising questions about whether the recall will be successful. Complicating the DPP's efforts is the uncertainty regarding tariffs imposed by the United States. In recent days, the news cycle in Taiwan has been dominated by coverage of the tariffs that U.S. President Donald Trump imposed on other Asia-Pacific countries, such as Japan and South Korea. The DPP is likely to see public backlash if Taiwan is unable to negotiate a similar or lower percentage. By contrast, if Taiwan is able to secure a favorable tariff rate, this will be a political accomplishment that the DPP can tout ahead of the recalls. In the meantime, the KMT has also carried out a series of actions in the legislature intended to impact the recall. Most controversial has been forcing through measures that would distribute 10,000 Taiwanese dollars (US$340) to every member of the public. Cash hand-outs have traditionally been effective before elections in convincing members of the public to vote for a political party, but it is also possible that voters will see the move as an attempt to buy votes, historically an issue that has long plagued Taiwanese politics, or to bribe the public. The cash hand-outs also run counter to the KMT's claims that the budget cuts earlier this year were necessary for fiscal balance. Another contentious issue has been the impact on Taiwan from Typhoon Danas earlier this month, which led to over 900,000 homes losing power and caused NT$1.6 billion in agricultural losses. The DPP has alleged that the KMT cut funds that would have otherwise been available for disaster relief. By contrast, the KMT called on the DPP to put disaster relief ahead of the recall vote, with Lu Shiow-yen calling on Lai to suspend the recall vote in order to focus on disaster relief – something that Lai likely would not have the power to do without overstepping his bounds as president. Some splits in the KMT appear to be visible ahead of the recalls. KMT chair Eric Chu called on both sides to take a step back, and stating that the KMT would relent on the issue of subsidies for Taiwan's state-run power utility, Taipower, as a means of compromise. Such subsidies are used to keep electricity prices in Taiwan artificially low. The KMT had claimed that the subsidies were unnecessary, while the DPP accused the KMT of seeking to raise electricity prices in the hopes that the public would blame the DPP. Although the KMT did eventually allow some subsidies to pass, there was initially resistance from the KMT legislative caucus to Chu's comments. KMT legislators, including Fu, complained that Chu did not consult with them on the change in plan ahead of time. This is not the only time in recent memory that Chu, historically a moderate, has clashed with the KMT legislative caucus. Comments by Chu have been interpreted as publicly calling on KMT legislators who are relatively open about their views that Taiwan is part of China to keep a low profile to avoid angering the public ahead of the recall. But Chu's position is likely to be increasingly contested ahead of a KMT central chair election to take place this fall, with Chu expected to be challenged by not only Lu Shiow-yen but Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an. For now, all of Taiwan is awaiting the results of the recalls. To change the balance of power in the legislature, the DPP will need to not only successfully recall KMT legislators, but also win at least six legislative seats in the resulting by-elections. Though recalled legislators are not allowed to run again, it is not impossible that, even in the event of a successful recall, a different KMT legislator would win in the by-election.
Japan Today
42 minutes ago
- Japan Today
China exports beat forecasts in June after U.S. tariff truce
China and the United States de-escalated their bruising trade war in talks last month By Mary Yang and Matthew Walsh China's exports rose more than expected in June, official data showed Monday, after Washington and Beijing agreed a tentative deal to lower swinging tariffs on each other. Data from the General Administration of Customs said exports climbed 5.8 percent year-on-year, topping the five percent forecast in a Bloomberg survey of economists. Imports rose 1.1 percent, topping the 0.3 percent gain predicted and marking the first growth this year. China's exports reached record highs in 2024 -- a lifeline to its slowing economy as pressures elsewhere mounted. Beijing's efforts to sustain growth have been hit by a bruising trade war with the United States, driven by President Donald Trump's sweeping tariffs, though the two de-escalated their spat with a framework for a deal at talks in London last month. Monday's customs figures showed Chinese exports to the United States surged 32.4 percent in June, having fallen the month before, according to an AFP calculation based on official data. "Growth in export values rebounded somewhat last month, helped by the U.S.-China trade truce," Zichuan Huang, China economist at Capital Economics, said. "But tariffs are likely to remain high and Chinese manufacturers face growing constraints on their ability to rapidly expand global market share by slashing prices. "We therefore expect export growth to slow over the coming quarters, weighing on economic growth," she added. Customs official Wang Lingjun told a news conference on Monday that Beijing hoped "the U.S. will continue to work together with China towards the same direction", state broadcaster CCTV reported. The tariff truce was "hard won", Wang said. "There is no way out through blackmail and coercion. Dialogue and cooperation are the right path." Analysts say China's economy is expected to have expanded more than five percent in the second quarter thanks to its strong exports. Official figures are due to be released on Tuesday. But they also warn Trump's trade war could cause a sharp slowdown in the final six months of the year. Beijing is targeting an overall expansion of around five percent this year -- the same as last year but a figure considered ambitious by many experts. First-quarter growth came in at 5.4 percent, beating forecasts and putting the economy on a positive trajectory. Beijing has struggled to sustain growth since the pandemic as it battles a prolonged debt crisis in the property sector, chronically low consumption and high youth unemployment. Data released last week showed that consumer prices edged up in June, barely snapping a four-month deflationary dip, but factory gate prices dropped at their fastest clip in nearly two years. Many economists argue that China needs to shift towards a growth model propelled more by domestic consumption than the traditional key drivers of infrastructure investment, manufacturing and exports. Beijing has introduced a slew of measures since last year in a bid to boost spending, including a consumer goods trade-in subsidy scheme that briefly lifted retail activity. © 2025 AFP
Japan Today
an hour ago
- Japan Today
China steps in as U.S. pulls back from diplomacy, report says
The U.S. and Chinese flags are seen on the day of a bilateral meeting between the U.S. and China, in Geneva, Switzerland, May 11, 2025. KEYSTONE/EDA/Martial Trezzini/Handout via REUTERS THIS IMAGE HAS BEEN SUPPLIED BY A THIRD PARTY By Patricia Zengerle China is increasing its diplomatic reach as President Donald Trump's administration pares back America's international presence, Democrats from the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee said in a report released on Monday. The report, the result of months of staff travel and research, was released as the Trump administration makes deep cuts to the State Department, including beginning on Friday to fire more than 1,350 U.S.-based employees, part of a total reduction of nearly 3,000 people for the U.S.-based workforce. The administration has also cut billions of dollars in foreign aid, effectively shutting down the U.S. Agency for International Development, leading to the firing of thousands of its employees and contractors. Critics said the cuts would undermine Washington's ability to defend and promote U.S. interests abroad. Research published in The Lancet medical journal said the cuts to USAID and its dismantling could result in more than 14 million additional deaths by 2030. The Trump administration says its changes help align foreign policy with Trump's "America First" agenda, and are part of a push to shrink the federal bureaucracy and cut what Trump officials say has been wasteful spending. The Democrats' 91-page report listed ways, from broadcasting to health programs and development efforts, that committee researchers said China is expanding its influence. "China is pursuing a clear vision for the international order while the Trump Administration seeks to diminish America's engagement globally," the report said. It lists dozens of cases in which the committee researchers found that China had stepped in as the U.S. eliminated or cut back international programs, from funding vaccines and providing food to infrastructure development. For example, in Africa, as the U.S. terminated food assistance programs, China in March donated $2 million in rice to Uganda. In May, after the U.S. terminated a $37 million HIV/AIDS grant in Zambia, China said it would help the African nation fight HIV/AIDS, including by donating 500,000 rapid HIV testing kits and planning more meetings to discuss its continued partnership on the issue. In Southeast Asia, Chinese President Xi Jinping embarked on a tour to meet with leaders in Vietnam, Cambodia and Malaysia, the report said. The trip yielded an agreement in Vietnam for railroad connections, 37 cooperation agreements in Cambodia in sectors including energy, education and infrastructure and technical and manufacturing exchanges in Malaysia. And in Latin America, China in May hosted the "China-Latin American and the Caribbean Forum" and announced it would provide a $9 billion credit line and additional infrastructure investments for the region. © Thomson Reuters 2025.
