Never mind the spin - Ireland isn't close to ‘breakeven' on the €21 billion AIB bailout
Paul O'Donoghue
GOOD NEWS – WE'RE up on our big investment!
'What investment?' you cry.
Why, the Great Bank Bailout investment, of course!
You see, during the week the state sold its final shareholding in AIB.
It was once assumed that a lot of the cash poured into the lender was a sunk cost.
It turns out, that isn't the case. The government said during the week that, once everything is factored in, AIB will come extremely close to repaying its bailout.
Some €20.8 billion was put into the lender during the financial crisis. The government so far has gotten back €19.8 billion. Eventually, the total recovered amount will likely rise to just over €20 billion.
Multiple media outlets reported during the week that AIB will end up about '€700 million shy' of repaying the state. Essentially, coming very close to breakeven.
This is based on calculations provided by
the Department of Finance.
The department said when you look at the bailout money collectively put into AIB, Bank of Ireland (BOI) and PTSB, 'the state is €0.6 billion above break-even on its €29.4 billion investment'.
All of that sounds great.
But it doesn't give the full picture.
Here's why.
A LUAS tram passes in front of AIB headquarters.
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
The debt
To cut a long story short – the government's figures don't take debt servicing costs into account.
When the Irish state poured €29.4 billion into those AIB/BOI/PTSB during the financial crisis, it borrowed money to do so.
This debt costs money to service – quite a bit. Let's start with AIB.
As stated, the AIB bailout cost was €20.8 billion.
The Comptroller and Auditor General (basically the state spending watchdog) previously estimated that, as of the end of 2021,
debt servicing costs on the AIB bailout amounted to €7.1 billion.
That amount is on top of the €20.8 billion – so straight away, the actual AIB bailout cost goes to €27.9 billion.
And interest is still being paid on that money. In a statement to
The Journal
, the organisation said the report, published in 2022, 'is the most recent report the C&AG has published on this issue'.
But as some interest would still have racked up between 2022 and now, it's likely the final AIB bailout cost, when debt servicing is included, is well above €28 billion.
With this in mind, we asked the Department of Finance how taxpayers are €0.6 billion 'up' on the AIB/BOI/PTSB bailouts.
A spokesman said: 'The figures are based on a simple cash in, cash out basis. We have never included debt servicing costs over the last 10 years of tracking these figures.'
Advertisement
Asked why debt servicing costs are not included, the spokesperson said: 'It [the Department] doesn't include debt servicing costs, which are under the remit of the NTMA'.
The NTMA (National Treasury Management Agency) is the Irish agency which manages the state's assets.
Let's think about that for a minute. The Department of Finance doesn't include the billions in debt servicing costs – which are real costs – because counting this is handled by a different state agency.
Does that sound like a good reason to ignore billions in taxpayer funds spent?
It would be one thing if profit and loss wasn't mentioned at all. But by saying taxpayers are actually in profit on the AIB/BOI/PTSB bailout, the Department's claims paint a misleading picture.
Let's take a quick look at debt servicing costs for the three main banks. As of end 2021, the most recent figures available:
AIB: €7.1 billion
BOI: €0.7 billion
PTSB: €0.7 billion
That's an additional €8.5 billion. So rather than taxpayers being '€0.6 billion above break-even', we'd actually be about €8 billion down. Not even counting the additional debt costs paid since the end of 2021.
It's also telling how the Department chose to highlight the 'investment' into AIB, Bank of Ireland and PTSB.
It didn't mention the other two lenders we bailed out 'invested' in at the same time. This pair, of course, was Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide (INBS). Between them, they received bailout funds of €34.5 billion.
The state has recovered about €1.1 billion of that amount. The remaining €33.4 billion
is officially deemed an 'unrecoverable sunk cost'.
Anglo and INBS were merged into a new state-owned entity called the Irish Bank Resolution Corporation (IBRC), which is trying to get anything it can back for taxpayers.
So it's perhaps understandable why the Department would prefer to forget about these two when talking about how well we are doing on our banking 'investment'.
Let's do a quick rundown of where things actually stand when looking at the Irish state's banking 'investments' – when including debt servicing costs.
AIB – loss for the state. Likely in the region of €8 billion
BOI – profit. Approximately €1.4 billion
PTSB – state still holds 57% stake, currently valued at €600 million. State will likely finish at a loss of about €1 billion. Possibly less, depending on how much it ultimately sells the shares for.
IBRC – loss. Likely in the region of €35 – €40 billion once all costs are included.
Briefly returning to AIB. Seeing as the Department of Finance consistently refers to the bank bailouts as 'investments', it's worth briefly considering them as such.
If someone invests €20.8 billion in 2010, and receives a payout of say €20.8 billion in 2025, how did they fare? Well, you *could* say they broke even, on a 'cash in, cash out' basis.
But in reality, they lost money due to inflation. €20.8 billion in 2010 is worth the same as about €27 billion in today's money.
And that's on top of… something… oh yeah, billions in debt servicing costs! How do we keep forgetting those pesky charges?
When the government continuously forgets them as well, it can be hard to remember!
We're down billions
None of this is necessarily to say that bailing out the banks was the wrong move. The Irish state got something valuable for the AIB bailout. It ensured one of the country's main lenders didn't collapse.
It also got a decent amount of the bailout money back in the end. At least, from AIB, PTSB and BOI. Likely a good bit more than was expected during the crash.
That's all fine. So why can't the government be happy with that, rather than trying to spin that we are around 'breakeven' on our AIB 'investment'?
To its credit,
AIB's statement on its return to private ownership
didn't make any mention of the state's 'return on investment'.
So if AIB hasn't tried to claim this, why has the government?
Put simply – the government is trying to spin that taxpayers got a return on the bank bailouts. Three of them, at least.
But we didn't. Even on those selectively-chosen three bailouts, we're down billions and billions of euro.
When the government is trying to rewrite history, it should be called out for it.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
I left frantic UK life to buy 85p home in sunny paradise – now I'm building property empire for cost of two pints
AFTER years of enduring the rat race as a jewellery dealer in the UK, George Laing took a gamble on a new life in Europe - with just 85p. With gruelling hard work and patience, the Brit is slowly transforming a derelict three-story building into his dream home - and he has another plan up his sleeve. Advertisement 15 George Laing, 32, bought his dream home for cheap as part of the €1 Houses project Credit: Instagram/george_laing_ 15 The property George bought for 85p Credit: SWNS 15 He snapped up the home in Mussomeli, Sicily - a sun-soaked region popular with those wanting the laid back European lifestyle Credit: Alamy 15 The Brit reveals his long and pricey renovation process - but insists it has been worth it Credit: Supplied 15 George has done all the renovation work himself Credit: Instagram/george_laing_ Advertisement He has just finalised the deal on a SECOND 85p house - and intends to purchase up to 15 more over the next three years. When The property was in desperate need of an overhaul, with a hole in the roof and no running water or electricity. Several wooden beams were rotting from both ends and worrying cracks lined almost every wall in each room. What started as a crumbling €1 house has now started to turn into a beautiful, liveable home George Laing The bathroom was a tiny box and the kitchen was simply a metal stove connected to a propane tank. Advertisement But beyond the gloomy exterior and lackluster interior, And even with no prior background in revamping anything close to a three-floored home, George was determined to get stuck in. He now spends two weeks a month at home in the UK and the rest in beautiful Sicily, working tirelessly to complete his George even plans to open up an antiques shop in Mussomeli at the end of the year so he can continue his jewellery business in Italy. Speaking to The Sun, the young homeowner has revealed just how far he has come in the past 12 months. Advertisement I left UK to buy 85p home - I get perfect weather, cheap booze & better neighbours He said: 'It's surreal to see the first house coming together - we've got water, electricity, and now we're onto the exciting part: fitting out the kitchen and bathrooms with marble from a local quarry. 'I want the finish to be as beautiful as the bones of the building. 'Once the first house is finished, we're throwing a huge celebration — the mayor's coming, the neighbours are invited. "It's not just a personal milestone, it's a community one. "What started as a crumbling €1 house has now started to turn into a beautiful, liveable home." Advertisement Just 10,000 residents live in George's new hometown of Mussomeli. The sun-soaked region of Sicily has long been known as a glorious haven for those wanting the laid back European lifestyle. George, who lives in Eastbourne and used to work to London, says the drastic change in vibes is one of the key factors behind why he purchased the home. He explained: "In Sicily, life is just a bit slower. "You've got a different quality of life, and obviously the weather is 25-30 degrees everyday. And it's a beautiful place." Advertisement 15 The first three-storey home is still far from finished but George is determined to see the project through Credit: Instagram/george_laing_ 15 The home was falling apart when George first bought it but he has managed to transform it into a dream home Credit: George Laing 15 The kitchen was simply a metal stove connected to a propane tank at first Credit: George Laing 15 George's rather uninviting front door when he first purchased the home Credit: George Laing Despite living in a foodie paradise, renovating the home hasn't been without its challenges. Advertisement He said: "It's been like a full-time job mixed with the most personal kind of DIY adventure. "I've overseen everything from rewiring and plumbing to sourcing materials locally and working with Italian builders who don't speak a word of English. "Navigating Italian bureaucracy without being fluent in Italian was definitely up there. "Also, understanding the true structural condition of the property - it's not always obvious what lies behind the walls until you start breaking them open. "And of course, doing all this on a tight budget meant I had to be hands-on with almost everything." Advertisement But George loves the lifestyle so much that he has just finalised the deal on a second 85p house. BIG PLANS He said: "It's a totally different challenge, and I'm already planning how to preserve what's special, while breathing new life into it. "And I'm planning to purchase another three to five in the next year, another 10-15 over the next three years. "I've learned so much and now I want to go even bigger and begin to grow my property portfolio. "There's also something incredibly addictive about rescuing these abandoned homes. Advertisement "I'm passionate about bringing life back to these forgotten places and helping others do the same." 15 The derelict home was so cheap as it was being flogged by the local authorities Credit: Instagram/george_laing_ 15 Fixing the home up has been a real challenge with piles of rubbish being left over from the previous owner Credit: Instagram/george_laing_ 15 George had the street filled with rubbish during the renovation Credit: George Laing From the first moment he arrived, George could tell he had entered into a tight-knit community. Advertisement The locals in Sicily are very different to what George is used to. He quickly became friends with his Italian neighbours - although he admits he still has to use Google Translate to chat with them. And being in his early 30s, George has been thrilled to find the price of alcohol is drastically lower in Italy. He said: "It's just nice to buy things that are a lot cheaper. "You get a beer or a cocktail in Sicily for €1.50 or a glass of wine for €2 - whereas it's £7.50 now in London for a pint. Advertisement "Even just living there day to day you spend less money, which is a nice bonus." 15 George's hilltop view from his new house Credit: Instagram/george_laing_ 15 George puts a lot of his impressive handwork down to YouTube videos Credit: George Laing Three spacious storeys of room to play with and a classic Italian balcony at the front were paired with a glorious marble staircase. George is proud of his bold choice and says despite his pals being nervy about the move he is now confident it was the right choice. Advertisement One of the main reasons he left was the struggle to find a home in and around London on the cheap. He said: "Financially getting on the property market in London or anywhere in the UK is incredibly hard. £5,000 in the UK isn't going to get you diddly squat." Another key factor is not having to pay an astronomical mortgage. Getting on the property ladder is notoriously hard in the UK due to the lack of available housing, surging house prices and rising bills. In 2023, 42,000 Brits left their lives behind and moved to a new EU nation. Advertisement For George, when he heard Italy was flogging homes for less than £1, the bold move made sense - something others are now getting on board with. He said: "Seeing something so neglected come back to life is incredibly rewarding. "Also, becoming part of the local Sicilian community sharing food, stories, and wine with neighbours has made this much more than just a renovation. "It's been a total life reset in the best way." How does the €1 house scheme work? DEPENDING on the region, a number of towns and villages across Italy have offered the cheap €1 properties to encourage people to move to the area. There are around 25 regions who are taking part, each with a number of properties. Many of the areas have a dwindling or aging population and hope to build the community again. The properties range from small houses to larger villas, but are all in a very rundown condition. The conditions for buying each property also vary, but the majority of them need large renovation works which are part of the scheme According to Maurizio Berti, who runs the website "We are talking about dilapidated or unsafe properties that need major renovations." Conditions include notary fees, paying an additional three-year buying guarantee policy of €5,000 (which is refunded when it expires) as well as starting the project within two months once permits are given. The houses are put to an auction where people can bid on them so they technically aren't all €1. While some do sell for €1, on average houses sell for around €5,000 euros, although some are up to €20,000. Some of the schemes even offer to pay you money for buying a home if you can boost the economy with a new business venture. 15 The main living space has been taken over by work tools for the past few years Credit: Instagram/george_laing_ Advertisement
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Ireland is 2nd dearest spot in Europe & is getting more expensive – but consumers aren't powerless to hunt for value
ANYONE who has recently stood in a supermarket queue, filled up their tank or received an energy bill will tell you that Ireland is an expensive place. And now, new data from Eurostat confirms it. 4 Ireland is the second most expensive country in the EU Credit: Getty Images - Getty 4 Ireland has the second-highest alcohol prices in the EU Credit: Getty Images - Getty 4 Daragh Cassidy insists consumers aren't powerless despite the high costs In fact, we are the second most costly country in the entire Only But while the Danes at least benefit from generous public services, good public transport and clean streets, Here, Daragh Cassidy of comparison site asks why Ireland is so expensive – and considers what can be done to bring prices down. WHAT is quite striking about Eurostat's figures is how far we seem to be drifting from the European average each year. In 2015, our prices were 28 per cent above average, but the gap seems to be widening almost every year. And we're no longer just more expensive than our Mediterranean neighbours. We've leapfrogged traditionally costly countries like Finland, Let's start with the obvious — Ireland has the second highest alcohol prices in the EU — almost 198 per cent the average. Only REASON FOR HIGH COST Much of this is due to high government taxation and the recent introduction of minimum unit pricing. The cost of food and non-alcoholic drink is also relatively high in Ireland. Our However, this is actually an improvement on recent years. In 2020, our prices were over 21 per cent above average, but that's probably not much comfort to households. Dining out and hotel stays are pricey, too, with costs nearly 30 per cent above the EU average. 'HARVEY NORMAN EFFECT' Mobile and broadband services? A jaw-dropping 40 per cent higher. There are a few positives, though! Our clothing costs are slightly below the EU average, and the 'Harvey Norman effect' keeps the cost of household appliances and furnishings somewhat in check. These small wins, though, are dwarfed by the overall trend: Ireland is an expensive place to live. But why? NO EASY ANSWER There is no single answer. And some reasons are complex and structural. But factors which contribute to our high cost of living include a lack of competition in certain sectors and high taxation on goods such as tobacco, alcohol, petrol and Low government subsidies in areas such as public transport and childcare compared to our In addition, businesses are faced with high insurance and energy costs which then get passed on to consumers. MORE IMPROVEMENTS So what can be done? Ireland is unlikely to ever be a cheap country — nor should we aim to be. High prices often go hand in hand with high living standards. It should be noted that most of the countries with the highest standards of living in the world (such as INCOME ISSUE But the problem is that Irish incomes, while high, don't quite match the salaries in these countries. We have Danish prices, but wages closer to Taxpayers in more expensive countries tend to get back more from the government in terms of better and more affordable So what now? The SHOP AROUND Regulators such as ComReg and the CRU need sharper teeth and stronger mandates to tackle anti-competitive practices. And a Minister for Consumer Affairs could help ensure consumer interests are more consistently championed at government level. But consumers aren't powerless. By shopping around and switching providers for everything from electricity and insurance to broadband, households can claw back hundreds of euro a year. Ireland may never be a bargain destination, but that doesn't mean we can't find better value. 4 Grocery prices are the third highest in the EU, at nearly 15 per cent above average Credit: Getty Images - Getty
Extra.ie
an hour ago
- Extra.ie
This is how much Ireland's Euromillions winner will earn in interest alone
The mystery winner of Ireland's largest-ever €250m EuroMillions windfall will earn €5m a year in interest without even spending a cent of their newfound mega-fortune. Financial experts this weekend said even Ireland's notoriously stingy banks would pay 2% interest on the massive winnings. And even if they don't opt to squirrel away their fortune in a high-interest Swiss bank account, the 2% Irish rate would still earn the winner a princely €416,667 every month on €250 million, or €5,000,000 a year. In Co. Cork, Ireland, the winning €250 million EuroMillions ticket was located last week. Pic: Shutterstock At the stroke of a pen – or a computer-generated quick-pick – the newly minted lottery winner has landed almost half of U2 frontman Bono's personal fortune, or a shade less than golf Grand Slam hero Rory McIlroy's reported €280m earnings. It's likely the elated lottery winner will blow at least a portion of their megabucks windfall on a new home, a holiday or a toy. If it's the latter, a Mercedes-Benz S-Class will set them back a mere €242,655. Or if they fancy themselves more of a high-flyer, every billionaire's 'must-have' toy – a Gulfstream jet – would cost around €70m. Mercedes S-Class. Pic: Getty Images However, the winner could probably afford to splash out around €9.5 million for an 11-seater Pilatus PC-24, though it would be more sensible to hire one as needed. Chartering a Pilatus PC-24 from Dublin to the south of France would cost €10,474 – mere pocket change to the winner, whoever they are. As they mull over their life-changing windfall, the rumour mill over the identity of Ireland's biggest-ever lottery winner was in overdrive yesterday. Pilatus PC-24 Pic: NICOLAS MESSYASZ/SIPA/Shutterstock (15365121a) Anyone who walks into the Centra shop on Cork's Shandon Street, where the winning ticket was sold this week, is a likely suspect. And the manager of the city centre shop, run by three generations of the Clifford family, said Cork's finest sleuths are determined to crack the still-unsolved mystery. Simon Champ told 'It's like a small town in the middle of the city here and it would be very hard to keep it a secret long in an area like this. Simon Champ. Pic: Seán Dwyer 21/06/25 'I don't know who the winner is and we're trying to enjoy the buzz and the craic,' he said. 'So, anyone who comes in over the next few weeks with a new shirt, a new watch or a new hairstyle or haircut, we'll be looking at them and asking: 'How can you afford that?'' Mr Champ added that, for whoever has landed the windfall, 'this is a real opportunity for someone to do something for their community.' He jokingly added: 'As long as it isn't Elon Musk, we're happy.' On Thursday evening, the owners of the busy shop in the heart of Cork city were notified they had sold the winning ticket. The National Lottery. Pic: Artur Widak/NurPhoto/Shutterstock Mr Champ recalled: 'The National Lottery rang us on Thursday evening. The owner, Ted Clifford, is on holiday, so I then got a phone call. 'It was around six or half six in the evening, and I was in the car on my way home to Fermoy. 'I thought it was a wind-up. I thought it was someone scamming me. But when the person explained who they were, I had to pull in the car for a few minutes.' While the identity of the winner is not yet known, they have been in contact with the National Lottery head office in Dublin. They have 90 days to collect their quarter of a billion fortune – and until they do, the guessing game continues in the close-knit neighbourhood around Shandon Street. Esther Cotter, who works at the Homer pub just a few doors up from Clifford's shop, is a regular lottery player, but insisted she is not the €250m winner. She said: 'We haven't a notion who it is. Everyone is hoping it is someone local. You couldn't keep that quiet here.' Her pal Noelle Nagle agreed, and she's hopeful the windfall will be collected by someone whose life will change for the better. 'We hope that it's someone that needs it. It isn't us,' adding she heard the €250m winning ticket was bought for €7. Local Sinn Féin TD Thomas Gould also said it's only a matter of time before the winner's identity becomes known, if they are local. Mr Gould, whose constituency office is just across the road from Clifford's shop, told 'No one has an idea who it is. Whoever it is, I just wish them all the best. It's an enormous amount of money. 'Clifford's is a real local shop on Shandon Street, and people are delighted we have had such a big win in our local shop. It's something that would be very hard to keep a secret here because everyone knows everyone, and there are great friendships and neighbours here. 'It's probably someone local who has won,' he added. Meanwhile, one of the few people on Shandon Street yesterday who was not trying to guess the identity of the new multimillionaire was three-year-old Loug from Youghal, Co. Cork. He and his granny Mary Cooper arrived at Clifford's after hopping on the bus in their home town and wandered into the shop on Shandon Street after spotting a display of balloons erected to celebrate the €250m win. They may not be the Lotto millionaires, but little Loug still walked away a winner with a free ice cream cone given to him by shop manager Simon. Loug's granny, Mary, said: 'We head off every Saturday together to go to all these free things, and we came to the shop because Loug loves balloons. 'I think it's great. I hope it's a group of people who have won because I think they might be happier in the long run. 'We came for the Shandon Festival and the manager told us where to go and he gave Loug a free ice cream cone,' she said.
