logo
Facebook enables gender discrimination in job  ads, European human rights body rules

Facebook enables gender discrimination in job ads, European human rights body rules

CNN28-02-2025

A European human rights body has ruled that Facebook's algorithm shows gender bias when promoting job advertisements, marking what activists say is a crucial step in holding big tech companies accountable for the design of their platforms.
The Netherlands Institute for Human Rights said in a February 18 decision that Facebook's algorithm reinforced gender stereotypes by mainly showing 'typically female professions' to female Facebook users in the Netherlands and that Meta (META), the social platform's owner, should have monitored and adjusted its algorithm to prevent that.
The Institute's decision follows CNN As Equals reporting revealing that Facebook users in Europe were missing out on job opportunities due to gender bias.
The 2023 article was based on findings shared with CNN by international non-profit Global Witness, which investigated Facebook's job ads and found that ads in the Netherlands and five other countries often targeted users based on historical gender stereotypes.
For example, ads for mechanic positions were predominantly shown to men, while those for preschool teacher roles were primarily directed to women. Global Witness said its experiments in the Netherlands, France, India, Ireland, the United Kingdom and South Africa demonstrated that the algorithm perpetuated similar biases around the world. The non-profit's investigation led to four complaints from the Dutch human rights group Bureau Clara Wichmann and the French organization Fondation des Femmes.
The Netherlands Institute for Human Rights said in its February ruling that Meta Platforms Ireland Ltd., which manages Facebook ads in Europe, failed to demonstrate that its advertising algorithm does not engage in prohibited gender discrimination. The Dutch body said Facebook must revise its advertising algorithm to prevent further discrimination.
The European Union has several directives that prohibit discrimination based on gender, including in online advertising.
The Institute's ruling added that 'Meta Ireland has acknowledged that the gender data point can be part of the algorithm. Meta Ireland has not refuted that this data point can promote stereotyping via the algorithm.'
A Meta spokesperson told CNN that it would not be commenting on the matter.
Meta spokesperson Ashley Settle previously told CNN that the company applies 'targeting restrictions to advertisers when setting up campaigns for employment, as well as housing and credit ads.' Those audience targeting restrictions are in place in the United States, Canada and more than 40 European countries and territories, including France and the Netherlands, according to Meta.
'We do not allow advertisers to target these ads based on gender,' Settle said in a 2023 statement. 'We continue to work with stakeholders and experts across academia, human rights groups and other disciplines on the best ways to study and address algorithmic fairness.' Meta did not respond to questions from CNN at the time about how the algorithm that runs its ad system is trained. In a 2020 blog post about its ad delivery system, Facebook said ads are shown to users based on a variety of factors, including 'behavior on and off' the platform.
Berty Bannor of Bureau Clara Wichmann celebrated the Dutch institute's decision, telling CNN that the ruling was significant.
'Today is a great day for Dutch Facebook users, who have an accessible mechanism to hold multinational tech companies such as Meta accountable and ensure the rights they enjoy offline are upheld in the digital space,' Bannor said.
'I see this as a first step in showing that anti-discrimination laws apply just as much to big tech companies as they do to the offline world,' she added.
Rosie Sharpe, Senior Campaigner on Digital Threats at Global Witness, said the ruling 'marks an important step towards holding Big Tech accountable for how they design their services and the discriminatory impact their algorithms can have on people.'
'We hope this ruling can be used as a springboard for further action, in Europe and beyond,' she added.
While the decision by the Netherlands Institute for Human Rights is not legally binding, experts say that, if the case is further escalated, a court will be required to consider the Institute's findings.
Dutch lawyer Anton Ekker, who specializes in artificial intelligence and digital rights, told CNN that the Institute's ruling could lead to fines by the Dutch data protection regulator or orders to modify specific algorithms, specifically those that reinforce inequalities and disproportionately harm marginalized groups based on gender, race, ethnicity or religion.
If Meta does not take action on the job ads algorithm, NGOs might choose to pursue further legal action to stop the discriminatory use of its algorithms, he said.
The Dutch ruling comes as protection of digital rights has been severely undermined, particularly for women and marginalized groups, Bannor said.
Last month, Meta said it would end its diversity, equity and inclusion programs, change its policies on hateful conduct on its platforms and drop its third-party fact-checking programs in the US.
Users are now allowed to, for example, refer to 'women as household objects or property' or 'transgender or non-binary people as 'it,'' according to a section of the policy prohibiting such speech that was removed. A new section of the policy notes Meta will allow 'allegations of mental illness or abnormality when based on gender or sexual orientation, given political and religious discourse about transgenderism and homosexuality.'
Previously, such comments would have been subject to removal by Meta's moderators.
Meta has faced various allegations of discrimination over the past decade, including lawsuits in the US regarding housing, employment and credit ads. As a result, the company has modified its algorithm for these ads in the US.
Sharpe at Global Witness told CNN that it's 'outrageous' the same changes were not applied globally, arguing that algorithms and AI are increasingly impacting everyday life and posing significant risks to social justice.
CNN's Kara Fox contributed reporting.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Meta is looking to build an AI lab to develop ‘superintelligence' - a computer brain that works better than a human
Meta is looking to build an AI lab to develop ‘superintelligence' - a computer brain that works better than a human

Yahoo

time29 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Meta is looking to build an AI lab to develop ‘superintelligence' - a computer brain that works better than a human

Mark Zuckerberg is hiring a team of top AI researchers to develop a Meta 'superintelligence' research lab with machines capable of outperforming the human brain, according to reports. Meta is spending billions on AI projects in 2025, with 'superintelligence' considered a step up from what AI is currently capable of, experts told The New York Times. Meta recently hired Alexandr Wang, 28, the founder and chief executive of Scale AI, to join the lab, the newspaper reported on Tuesday. The company is also planning to hire other Scale AI employees as part of a deal that would see Meta invest billions into Scale AI. Some researchers from top AI companies have already agreed to join Meta after being offered seven to nine-figure compensation packages. The company is reportedly planning to unveil the lab soon, according to the outlet. Zuckerberg has personally met with experts in the field at his homes in Lake Tahoe and Palo Alto, California, reported Bloomberg. Meta has already announced plans to invest around $60bn to $65bn in AI infrastructure and related projects in 2025. Mark Zuckerberg, Meta's CEO, has said he wants to make the company an AI powerhouse and has expanded the technology across social media platforms. The company recently released a Meta AI app and Ray-Ban AI sunglasses that retail for $230. About one billion people use Meta AI every month. Zuckerberg, 41, called AI 'potentially one of the most important innovations in history' in February. 'This year is going to set the course for the future.' Zuckerberg created Meta's first AI lab in 2013. Yann LeCun, the company's chief AI scientist, has been overseeing Meta's AI innovation since then. There are few details about how Meta's superintelligence would operate. Other tech giants are similarly working to come out on top with AI infrastructure. Amazon and Microsoft are also racing to develop their AI infrastructure. On Monday, Amazon announced it would be investing $20bn in Pennsylvania to expand cloud computing infrastructure and advance AI innovation. Meanwhile, Microsoft will invest $80bn in AI infrastructure during its 2025 fiscal year. Similarly, Google is working to hire employees from AI start-ups and license their technology. The company last year agreed to pay $3bn to hire technologists and license technology from Character AI, a start-up that builds chatbots for personal conversations, the newspaper reported. Error while retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data

Boss of London ad champion quits after losing crown to French rival
Boss of London ad champion quits after losing crown to French rival

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Boss of London ad champion quits after losing crown to French rival

The boss of WPP is to step down months after the British advertising behemoth lost its crown to a French rival. Mark Read will leave after more than three decades at WPP, including seven years as chief executive. He will continue in the role until the end of the year while the board searches for his successor. Mr Read's departure, though long-expected in the industry, comes at a turbulent time for WPP. The London-based group, which employs around 110,000 people worldwide, last year lost its title as the world's largest ad company by revenues to French rival Publicis. Meanwhile, its two other largest rivals – Omnicom and Interpublic – have agreed to merge in a $30bn (£22bn) deal that will further erode WPP's dominance. The British company is also grappling with industry-wide turmoil sparked by the rise of artificial intelligence (AI), which threatens to upend the work of ad agencies. This has compounded the challenge posed by tech giant such as Google and Meta, which have grown their share of the advertising market in a direct threat to traditional holding groups. Mr Read's tenure has been dominated by efforts to simplify WPP, which had ballooned into a sprawling network of companies under his predecessor Sir Martin Sorrell, who left the company he founded following allegations of misconduct, which he has always denied. As chief executive, Mr Read oversaw the merging of a number of agencies while selling off some non-core businesses, including the £2.5bn sale of a 60pc stake in market research group Kantar. More recently, the ad boss has also vowed to invest heavily in AI, pumping £300m into the technology this year and investing in generative AI startup Stability AI. However, WPP's growth has ground to a halt in recent years and the company's share price has more than halved during Mr Read's tenure, pushing its market value below £6bn. Shares fell a further 2pc after his departure was announced. Alex DeGroote, a media analyst, said: 'The company is much simpler today than it was when he came on board as chief executive.' But he added: 'There's just a feeling of the company having lost a lot of ground to the likes of Publicis, so I can't honestly say that he will be remembered as having delivered immense shareholder value.' Mr Read's future has been in doubt since Philip Jansen, the former BT boss, was appointed as WPP chairman at the beginning of the year. Mr Jansen said Mr Read had 'played a central role in transforming the company into a world leader in modern marketing services'. Mr Read said: 'After seven years in the role, and with the foundations in place for WPP's continued success, I feel it is the right time to hand over the leadership of this amazing company. 'I am excited to explore the next chapter in my life and can only thank all the brilliant people I have been lucky enough to work with over the last 30 years, and who have made possible the enormous progress we have achieved together.' Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

The Prompt: Meta Eyes Scale AI
The Prompt: Meta Eyes Scale AI

Forbes

timean hour ago

  • Forbes

The Prompt: Meta Eyes Scale AI

Welcome back to The Prompt. Meta is reportedly planning to acquire a 49% stake in data labelling behemoth Scale AI for $14.8 billion, according to The Information. The deal is slated to place Scale AI's young billionaire CEO Alexandr Wang at a top position inside Meta along with a number of Scale AI employees, who will work in a new AI lab dedicated to developing 'superintelligence'— an AI system that outperforms human capabilities. CEO Mark Zuckerberg is reportedly closely involved in assembling the team of AI researchers and has gone to great lengths like setting up a WhatsApp group called 'Recruiting Party,' personally reaching out to potential recruits and rearranging desks for researchers to sit near him, Bloomberg reported. The new lab is part of Meta's efforts to keep up in the cutthroat AI race while wrangling a string of internal issues including employee churn, management problems and delayed or disappointing product releases. Now let's get into the headlines. DATA DILEMMAS Social media network Reddit sued Anthropic for allegedly training its AI models on personal user data without permission, and continuing to do so despite telling Reddit it had stopped, Forbes reported. Reddit was an early mover in capitalizing on its rich reserve of organic human data catalogued in its discussion forums, striking licensing deals with OpenAI and Google. In a lawsuit filed last week, Reddit claimed Anthropic's bot accessed its servers 100,000 times. BIG PLAYS ChatGPT will now be able to connect to a crop of external applications such as Google Drive, DropBox and Sharepoint, allowing enterprise users to glean insights from internal documents through the chatbot. It will also be able to access meeting recordings and transcriptions. The announcement was the latest in a series of feature releases intended to increase ChatGPT's functionality and keep people engaged. OpenAI has also reached $10 billion in annualized revenue through sales of its consumer products, CNBC reported. AI DEAL OF THE WEEK Young AI coding startup Anysphere has become the face of 'vibe coding' — a phrase coined by OpenAI cofounder Andrej Karpthy describing the use of large language models to create applications when the user doesn't necessarily need to know how to program. The nascent startup has raised $900 million at a $9.9 billion valuation and claims to have about $500 million in annualized revenue. The startup is betting that AI is going to dramatically transform software engineering in the next decade, making it magnitudes easier to program applications while eliminating cumbersome aspects of the process like correcting syntax or or debugging code. All a person has to do is press tab and AI completes the line of code for you and jumps to the next spot. Also of note: Enterprise AI startup Glean raised $150 million in Series F funding at a $7.2 billion valuation. Employees use the company's AI tools to search for internal information and build AI agents (software that can carry out specific tasks end-to-end) that can resolve IT tickets, write performance reviews and help prepare for meetings. Glean claimed to have passed $100 million in annualized revenue in February. (Read our 2023 profile of the company here.) DEEP DIVE Runway AI Throngs of excited moviegoers piled into Alice Tully Hall at Lincoln Center on Thursday night to be a part of Runway's third annual AI film festival. Cristobal Valenzuela, CEO of the $3.3 billion video and photo generation AI startup, spoke to a crowd of hundreds, asking them to think less about the digital tools and AI software used to make the short films they were about to watch, and instead focus on their human elements. The winning film, Total Pixel Space by Jacob Adler, is a jumble of both realistic and impossible vivid landscapes like a flying pig, people floating in a city or inside a pool, a bloom of jellyfish and a meerkat donning a bright yellow turtleneck. The 9 minute 28 second film raises the question of how many images could possibly exist in the world. The answer: Every image is composed of thousands of pixels— coordinates of positions and colors, a coalition of numbers. The film was selected from 6000 submissions, up from 300 a year ago, as interest in experimenting with AI models has exploded over the years. For all the creative benefits of video generation AI software, TV networks and filmmakers are adopting the technology for a more pragmatic reason: to produce and edit both television shows and movies quickly and more cheaply. AMC Network, which has produced popular shows like Breaking Bad and The Walking Dead, recently announced its plans to use Runway's AI models to create marketing and TV content. Lionsgate, the studio behind blockbuster hits like The Hunger Games and The Twilight Saga, has a partnership with Runway to use its models with a goal of making films on a fraction of the budget. But several studios don't want to openly admit they're using AI due to fears of backlash from creatives, who have voiced their concerns that these AI models are trained on copyrighted data scraped from the internet without consent and compensation. Runway is also currently facing litigation from a group of artists who claim their data was illicitly used to train its AI models. WEEKLY DEMO The Department of Government Efficiency developed a faulty AI tool to review thousands of contracts at the Department of Veteran Affairs that could be cut, labelling them as 'munchable,' Propublica reported. The software, developed by a programmer who has no formal experience in AI, was prone to making errors such as hallucinating the size of contracts, misreading them and inflating their value. MODEL BEHAVIOR Autonomous vehicles became easy targets during protests against Immigration and Customs Enforcement arrests in Los Angeles over the weekend. At least five Waymo driverless vehicles that were in the area were vandalized and set ablaze amid the protests. After the incident, Waymo halted its service in parts of downtown LA.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store