Fighters at unsanctioned events could expose themselves to criminal charges, says lawyer
Photo:
PHOTOSPORT
A sports lawyer says participants in an underground street fighting competition could be exposing themselves to criminal charges.
The King of the Streets event - which has received the backing of New Zealand UFC fighter Dan "Hangman" Hooker - was held over the weekend in a suburban backyard of an Auckland property, with 32 combatants and no weight limits.
Fighters competed for a prize of $50,000 with Hooker later confirming all participants would receive $1000 through TheDoctor, an online streaming, gambling and give-away website linked to the event.
Last week, police said they were
assessing the event
against existing legislation.
Former AUT law lecturer Craig Dickson told RNZ if the event was unsanctioned, it could be "problematic" around issues of consent.
"If you're going on to the field under those rules then there is a certain level of consent given that people can assault you," he said.
"But you then get to a position where there are actions outside of those rules that you can't be seen to be consenting to. Once you get far enough outside the rules, then clearly that still qualifies as a criminal assault."
Mixed martial arts is not considered under the Boxing and Wrestling Act 1981 that stipulates both amateur and professional fights require a police permit.
"There is a level of violence and bodily injury resulting that is so severe that your consent will be ineffective because public policy would say the public wont allow assaults over a certain level," Dickson said.
He said in the scenario of a fighter being seriously injured, or killed, there were legal grounds for charges under the Crimes Act.
"I don't think there's any question about that. Particularly if it's an unsanctioned event and whatever that rule base is, if you're far enough outside whatever that rule base might be, then you squarely land on assault to injure territory.
"If we're talking about an unsanctioned event that doesn't fall under any of the [necessary] parameters, then it's hard to see how that's greatly different to anybody conducting a similar assault on the street on a Friday night."
The governing body for mixed martial arts is calling for the government to urgently regulate popular combat sporting codes.
President of the New Zealand Mixed Martial Arts Federation (NZMMAF) president Terry Hill told
Checkpoint
the event was not the first amateur event held on these shores.
Hill said there was no legal framework in place that administered amateur events such as the King of the Street event held at the weekend.
"The basic requirement's you need is referees, qualified judges, and medical staff. By all accounts there [were] at that event," he said.
"There was a very good referee, they did have three judges apparently, and there were medics checking the fighters afterwards."
Unlike other countries, New Zealand did not have a combat sports commission regulating amateur events, Hill said.
"The Boxing and Wrestling Act is just completely irrelevant to what you're looking at today. And there are real health and safety issues about it," he said.
Although the event was billed as an amateur event, the winner of the King of the Street tournament was a professional, Hill said.
"The regulations are very loose and hazy and they need to be tightened and it's the government that needs to enforce that, through sport, through policing etcetera. Otherwise people can just do what they want."
Despite the event being unregulated, reports from the weekend's fighting had been positive, Hill said.
"By all accounts, everyone was very well behaved and there were no problems or incidents at all.
"But it's certainly intimidating to everybody else who isn't involved in it, and that's what the promoters want. It's shock entertainment."
Hill said there were reports on social media that nine different gangs were represented at the event.
"Good on them for not losing control and getting out of hand, but the potential for it is huge."
Hill said he was making enquiries after hearing that the $50,000 prize was not awarded in cash, but rather cryptocurrency,
"Something needs to be done for combat sports in New Zealand. In 2019 you had three corporate boxers die in a 12-month period, not good enough.
"If three All Blacks had died playing rugby then there would've been a huge inquiry."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
All Blacks victorious in Argentina: what we learned
Analysis: The more things change, the more they stay the same - at least for the Pumas and their attempts to beat the All Blacks on home soil. This morning's test, won 41-24 by Scott Robertson's side, followed a now well-established script for those played between the two sides in Argentina and ticked off every box along the way. The All Blacks shot out to a big halftime lead, then fell asleep at the start of the second half, just long enough for the Pumas to get themselves back in the match. A second-half All Blacks yellow card even gave the hosts a sniff of victory, with Billy Proctor now joining the South American sin-bin inmate club started by Joe Moody and Liam Squire in 2016, then subsequently adding Matt Todd, Kieran Read and Sonny Bill Williams. Anton Lienert-Brown punched his ticket too, just for good measure, but his yellow for a head clash with moments to play was meaningless in the wash-up. Not meaningless was the importance of this result. Yes, the All Blacks established that lead, but the way they finished was more impressive, given how clinical and crowd-killing Samisoni Taukei'aho's powerful efforts were. The All Blacks seemed to flick a switch, something we'd become perhaps too accustomed to during the 2010's, and one of some pretty notable good points. . Samisoni Taukei'aho scores against the Pumas. Photo: ActionPress Halfback Cortez Ratima was under the microscope and stepped up very well, the scrum again earned plenty of key field position and Robertson's stripped back Plan B proved to be very effective. The All Blacks leaned on their forward dominance and Beauden Barrett's boot when they needed to, and it worked, with Ardie Savea's decision-making at the end empowered to go for tries, rather than shots at goal. Importantly, this time last year, the All Blacks' biggest issue was their inability to score at the backend of games, something now in the rearview mirror through this season's first four tests. Not that they probably knew it at the time, but it also sent a serious and ironic message out in regard to what had transpired a few hours earlier in Johannesburg. South Africa had racked up a 22-0 lead after only 20 minutes against a sorry-looking Wallabies side, who somehow got hold of Asterix's magic potion and piled on 38 unanswered points for a famous victory . The Springboks seemed to forget who they were, trying to run it from everywhere, without setting a platform. Cortez Ratima stepped up at halfback against Argentina. Photo: ActionPress For a while there, the All Blacks seemed likely to do the same thing, especially after Tomas Albernoz stepped past some very confused defence close to the All Black line to draw the Pumas within a converted try. Where the Springboks faltered, uncharacteristically letting the occasion get to them and losing their heads, the All Blacks screwed theirs back on. All it took was one penalty, one chance in the 22 and, suddenly, Taukei'aho's first try solidly gut-punched the resurgent Pumas. His second was the left hook follow-up that knocked the hosts out, pushing the score to a far more comfortable and familiar looking one. While the cold-as-ice ending should rightfully be lauded, plenty of things remain to work on, before the sides meet again next weekend in Buenos Aires. At times, the backline looked like they'd just met each other before kickoff, heading backwards with possession and bringing back horrific memories of the turning point in last year's loss to the Pumas in Wellington. The aforementioned lack of discipline was concerning, especially since Proctor's yellow came after a frenetically unhinged period of defence, and Ratima's early subbing was a headscratcher, but the impact of Taukei'aho and especially Patrick Tuipulotu off the bench was extremely heartening. Tuipulotu's shift was about enough to gain a man-of-the-match award, with a couple of huge tackles and vital lineout intelligence at the right time. Most of all, coach Robertson will be pleased with the fact that he brought on the right amount of experience to manufacture that clinical finish. Along with the Wallabies win, the result sends the All Blacks back to the No.1 ranking in the world - for whatever that's worth. There were patches in Cordoba where they certainly played like a team befitting that title, but with plenty more to work on, if they want to hang onto it and eventually win back the Rugby Championship. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
NPC Rugby live updates: Wellington v Otago
Cam Millar. Photo: ActionPress Wellington bounced back from an opening-round defeat to beat Waikato last weekend, meanwhile Otago went down to Hawke's Bay. Kickoff is 2.05pm.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Violence and riots now common in New Zealand prisons, staff union says
Prison guards and staff now face more and more violent incidents and riots, with prisoners more concentrated, their union says a day after a riot at Waikato's Spring Hill facility. Photo: Corrections / Chai Patel Violence and riots in prisons are now increasingly common as a result of higher prison populations, a group representing Corrections staff says, a day after a fiery prison riot in Waikato. On Saturday afternoon a group of prisoners refused to leave an exercise yard at Spring Hill Corrections Facility south of Meremere, damaging property and lighting fires, resulting in the prison going into lockdown. Firefighters and ambulance crews were sent to the facility and a specialist Advanced Control and Restraint team was dispatched. President of the Corrections Association, the union for Corrections workers, Floyd du Plessis told RNZ their staff were facing more and more violent incidents, and outdated staffing levels were compounding the problem. "It's a very dangerous situation. Anytime when you've got a number of prisoners threatening harm, reports of potential weapons, it's definitely a dangerous situation for staff, and it's only through the training and fast thinking of staff that [they are] able to bring it to a close relatively quickly and safely." The events on Saturday had been isolated to the yard and contained by staff, he said: "There was no risk of it spreading further in the way that the staff managed to deal with it and bring it to a close." Riots were not uncommon in New Zealand prisons, du Plessis said, and they were increasing. "We have events like this that happen on a regular basis across the country. There's just some of them that tend to become public knowledge and shared wider. But it's actually more common than people realise. "Spring Hill itself is one of those prisons that do hold quite a number of high profile prisoners, volatile prisoners. And so you do have these incidents that do tend to come at that higher level. "The reality is these situations are getting more common, they are becoming more violent, and the reality is it's something that we do need to urgently address." The association had been campaigning for improved security measures to help shut down disorder quicker and more safely, he said. "We have been lobbying for that. We need better safety equipment. And that's something that we are going to continue to push. "The other factor is we need more staff. Our prisons are staffed based on a ratio that was developed many, many years ago ... [the] problem is prisons have become far more violent than they used to be. And so those calculations just aren't fit for purpose. "So in places like Spring Hill, for high security prisoners, you're talking about two staff managing up to 30 prisoners. That's just not safe. These are the most violent people in our country and we expect two staff to manage them without incident. That's just not realistic. "We need to re-look at it and we need more staff in the prisons and we need to give them tools to safely operate." Du Plessis said more prisoners were being packed into the same spaces, there were not enough beds to manage the situation and staffing levels were too low. "What we're doing then is we're condensing more and more of these people into tight spots. We have a serious problem with available beds. So across the country, we're jam packing everyone in as tightly as we can. "And what that means is it ... doesn't give us room to move people around or to manage the people better. And so unfortunately that does create tension, which leads to violence. We urgently need more beds across the country and staff to staff them." Staff also want access to other safety measures, du Plessis said, such as PepperBall ranged weapons which are promoted as non-lethal. "That's something that we can use at a distance that can quickly bring these things to a close. But we need the government to work with us to change legislation and put them in place." RNZ has contacted Corrections and the Minister of Corrections for comment. On Saturday, Custodial Services Commissioner Leigh Marsh praised Corrections staff who contained the Spring Hill riot without any injury to staff or prisoners. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
