Responsibility To Protect: An Unfulfilled Promise, A Ray Of Hope
Addressing the General Assembly, António Guterres said that the world is witnessing more armed conflicts than at any time since the end of the Second World War.
' Too often, early warnings go unheeded, and alleged evidence of crimes committed by States and non-State actors are met with denial, indifference, or repression, ' he told Member States on Wednesday.
'Responses are often too little, too late, inconsistent, or undermined by double standards. Civilians are paying the highest price.'
The pledge
The Secretary-General's address marked two decades since the 2005 World Summit, where global leaders made an unprecedented commitment to protect populations from the atrocity crimes of genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and crimes against humanity.
Known as the Responsibility to Protect, or R2P, the pledge affirmed that sovereignty carries not just rights, but responsibilities – foremost among them, the duty of every State to safeguard its own people.
When national authorities manifestly fail to do so, the international community has a duty to act – collectively, timely and decisively – in accordance with the UN Charter.
An unfulfilled promise
'Two decades on, the Responsibility to Protect remains both an urgent necessity, a moral imperative and an unfulfilled promise, ' he said.
He cited worsening identity-based violence, deepening impunity, and the weaponization of new technologies as compounding threats to populations around the world.
'No society is immune from the risk of atrocity crimes,' Mr. Guterres continued.
A ray of hope
The Secretary-General also presented his latest report on the Responsibility to Protect, reflecting on two decades of progress and persistent challenges. It draws on a global survey showing that the principle still enjoys broad support – not only among Member States, but also among communities affected by violence.
' Communities see it [R2P] as a ray of hope, ' he said, ' but they also call for effective implementation at all levels. '
Mr. Guterres emphasised that prevention must begin at home: with inclusive leadership, the protection of human rights and the rule of law. And it must be supported worldwide through multilateral cooperation and principled diplomacy.
' No society is immune from the risk of atrocity crimes, ' he said.
'[Prevention] must be supported globally – through multilateral cooperation, principled diplomacy, and early and decisive action to effectively protect populations.'
Flashback: 2005 World Summit and the birth of R2P
The Responsibility to Protect was adopted by consensus at the 2005 World Summit – at the time, the largest-ever gathering of heads of state and government. The Summit also established the Peacebuilding Commission to support post-conflict recovery and the Human Rights Council to uphold human rights.
The R2P principle is built on three pillars: the State's responsibility to protect its population; the international community's role in assisting States in this effort; and the duty to take collective action when States manifestly fail to protect their people.
Since its adoption, R2P has helped shape international responses to atrocity crimes, guided UN operations, and informed preventive efforts through national, regional, and multilateral mechanisms.
Keep the promise
Yet the gap between principle and practice remains a central concern – one the Secretary-General is urging the international community to close.
' Let us keep the promise, ' Mr. Guterres said. ' Let us move forward with resolve, unity, and the courage to act. '
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
11-08-2025
- Otago Daily Times
NZ mulls recognition of Palestinian state
By Russell Palmer of RNZ New Zealand will make a decision on whether to recognise Palestine as a state over the next month, Foreign Minister Winston Peters has confirmed. In a statement this afternoon, Peters confirmed he spoken about the matter at Cabinet today, and the government would formally consider the move - coming to a decision in September. He will travel to the UN Leaders Meeting in at the General Assembly in New York in late September, and will present the government's approach to the UN at that time. While the announcement does not change New Zealand's position on Gaza or Palestinian statehood, the deadline of next month suggests New Zealand may join other Western partners in moving forward with recognition. Shortly after the statement, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese confirmed Australia would move ahead with recognising Palestinian statehood. This would be done at the UN General Assembly in September. He said the decision had been reached after conversations with a range of other world leaders, including New Zealand's Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, whom he met over the weekend. It follows multiple other Western countries signalling they intended to recognise Palestinian statehood, including France, the United Kingdom, and Canada. Peters' statement said the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza was rightly at the forefront of the global agenda, and New Zealand "has been giving this issue careful, methodical and deliberate attention". "New Zealand has long asked whether the pre-requisites for a viable and legitimate Palestinian state - in security, political, diplomatic and economic terms - exist. Fundamentally, we will need to weigh up whether sufficient progress is being made against these benchmarks in order to warrant New Zealand recognising a Palestinian state at this juncture," he said. "We will be taking heed of the facts on the ground deteriorating rapidly, our close partners being divided on the issue of recognition, and a range of Arab states making clear Hamas must disarm and must have no future role in Palestinian governance. "This is not a straightforward, clear-cut issue," Peters said. "There are a broad range of strongly held views within our government, Parliament and indeed New Zealand society over the question of recognition of a Palestinian state."
Otago Daily Times
07-08-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Primary school teachers reject 'insulting' pay rise offer
Primary school teachers have voted the reject the 1% pay rise offer. Primary teachers have voted to reject a 1% pay rise from the Ministry of Education. The vote, which closed on Wednesday, saw primary teachers overwhelmingly say 'no' to the collective agreement offer. Teacher and NZEI Te Riu Roa primary teacher negotiation team lead Liam Rutherford said the ministry's offer was essentially asking teachers to take a pay cut. "On the heels of the government scrapping our pay equity claim, this offer was insulting, and members have overwhelmingly reflected that sentiment in the vote," he said. "As educators, we want to be valued, supported, and respected for our work. Yet this offer doesn't address our key claims or the issues that we've spoken up about." Rutherford said the current offer contains no reference to teachers' Toitū Te Tiriti claim, which would introduce an expression of the obligations and commitments of the parties to Te Tiriti in the collective agreement. He said it also does little to address other pay-related claims to recognise additional expertise or responsibilities that primary teachers may hold, he says. From August 18-29, primary teachers will head into mass paid union meetings with other education member groups, including principals, support staff and Ministry of Education learning support to decide on their next steps.
Scoop
31-07-2025
- Scoop
With Gaza Smouldering, Ministers Renew Push For Two-State Solution At UN
30 July 2025 The High-level International Conference for the Peaceful Settlement of the Question of Palestine and the Implementation of the Two-State Solution took place in New York from 28 to 30 July. The United States and Israel did not participate. France and Saudi Arabia, co-chairs of the Conference, called on all UN Member States to support a declaration urging collective action to end the war in Gaza and to achieve a just, peaceful and lasting settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The New York Declaration on the Peaceful Settlement of the Question of Palestine and the Implementation of the Two-State Solution outlines political, humanitarian, and security steps to be taken on a timebound and irreversible basis. The co-chairs urged countries to endorse the declaration by the end of the 79th session of the General Assembly, in early September, should they so wish. Act before it is too late In his stark opening remarks on Monday, Secretary-General Guterres stressed that the two-State solution is the only viable path to ending the longstanding conflict and achieving lasting peace in the region, warning that there is no alternative. 'A one-State reality where Palestinians are denied equal rights and forced to live under perpetual occupation and inequality? A one-State reality where Palestinians are expelled from their land? That is not peace. That is not justice. And that is not acceptable,' he said. He condemned both Hamas' 7 October 2023 attacks and the scale of Israel's military response, reiterating his call for an immediate and permanent ceasefire, the unconditional release of hostages, and unfettered humanitarian access. 'This conflict cannot be managed. It must be resolved,' Mr. Guterres concluded. 'We must act before it is too late.' Calls for peace Over the three days, more than 125 speakers took the floor during the general debate, including high-level representatives from across the globe and major regional and international organizations such as the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) and the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). Delegates underscored the urgency of concrete steps to realise a two-State solution, highlighting the need to empower and reform the Palestinian Authority, reconstruct Gaza and ensure accountability for violations of international law. France, which co-chaired the Conference, recalled its support for Israel as it joined the community of nations and affirmed that Palestinians deserve the same right to a homeland. 'At a time where the two-State solution is more threatened than ever, France is ready to fully recognise the State of Palestine,' said Jean-Noël Barrot, Minister for Europe and Foreign Affairs. That recognition, he added, would come in September when leaders reconvene for the General Assembly's 80th session. Co-chair Saudi Arabia's Foreign Minister, Faisal bin Farhan al Saud, emphasised the suffering of thousands of civilians in Gaza under bombardment, while Israeli settlements expand in Jerusalem and the West Bank to alter the region's demographic nature. 'Peace and security do not take place through deprivation of rights or force,' he said, underscoring the need for a genuine and irreversible peace process. The United Kingdom's Foreign Secretary, David Lammy, outlined recent UK actions – including the suspension of arms exports and sanctions on extremist settlers, and restoring of funding to the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees. 'It is with the hand of history on our shoulders that His Majesty's Government therefore intends to recognise the State of Palestine when the UN General Assembly gathers in September here in New York,' he declared. 'We will do this unless the Israeli Government acts to end the appalling situation in Gaza, ends its military campaign and commits to a long-term sustainable peace based on a two-State solution.'
