Abolish SNP's free university tuition for students who can afford it, say half of Scots
Half of Scots support reintroducing tuition fees for students whose families can afford to pay, new research has revealed.
The report, published by the Carnegie Trust for the Universities of Scotland, found 48 per cent of Scottish adults would back the idea of charging fees 'based on the ability to pay'.
Fewer than a third of respondents (29 per cent) said they would not back such a move, according to polling conducted by Ipsos Mori.
Although there was widespread support for the taxpayer providing 'some form of help' with the cost of fees, Scots were divided over the 'extent and scope' of the assistance that should be provided.
While 44 per cent said the Scottish Government should support all first-time undergraduates, 43 per cent said students' families should pay at least some of their fees if they can afford to do so.
SNP ministers responded to the findings by vowing to stick with their flagship free-tuition policy, which means that even the wealthiest students pay nothing.
But the Carnegie Trust for the Universities of Scotland, which was founded using funds from industrialist Andrew Carnegie in 1901, said the research showed 'there is room for a more nuanced and open discussion on priorities for funding'.
The report was published after Scottish universities warned last week that they were 'dangerously reliant' on income from foreign students to survive under the SNP's current funding model.
The SNP Government pays universities £1,820 for each Scottish student to cover the 'free' tuition each year but institutions have warned this does not nearly cover the cost of providing courses.
Scotland's universities have been keen to recruit international students to help plug the financial black hole, as they charge them up to £40,000 per year in tuition fees.
But official figures last week disclosed overseas student numbers dropped by more than 10,000 last year, with industry body Universities Scotland warning this had left the sector 'in a hugely exposed position'.
A series of Scotland's most eminent universities warned of cuts, with Edinburgh stating it needs to make urgent savings to plug a £140 million budget gap.
Hannah Garrow, Carnegie Trust for the Universities of Scotland chief executive, said: 'We know how complex the higher education funding system is and how much rides on it.
'However, recent discussions on how to finance higher education feel like they are stuck on repeat, while for many people funding continues to be seen as a barrier to access.'
Ms Garrow argued the research showed that 'the public can inject some democratic innovation into the debate' if politicians were 'struggling'.
Asked where the Scottish Government should prioritise its funding for post-school education, 61 per cent backed apprenticeship places allowing young people to 'earn why they learn'.
Half said grants or bursaries for low-income students to help cover the cost of living, while only a quarter (26 per cent) said funding all first-time undergraduate tuition fees.
'Commitment to free tuition will not change'
A Universities Scotland spokesman said: 'For far too long Scotland's conversation about university funding has been in a binary loop of free versus fees. It's time to move beyond that and get into a different kind of conversation.
'This survey suggests that conversation is already happening amongst the public. It is a conversation that needs to start in a meaningful way amongst our political leaders too.'
Miles Briggs, the Scottish Tory shadow education secretary, said: 'We will continue to engage with Universities Scotland to develop policies for the benefit of young people across Scotland. The SNP must do the same and consider options to fix the financial crisis across the university sector.'
But a Scottish government spokesman said: 'The Scottish Government's commitment to free tuition will not change. Access to higher education should be based on the ability to learn – not the ability to pay.
'The commitment also ensures that Scottish students do not accrue additional tuition fee loan debt incurred by their peers in the rest of the UK.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
2 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Spending review must scrap benefit cap or face unbearable poverty
The Chancellor has pledged to invest in 'Britain's renewal' ahead of the spending review, which will be unveiled after Prime Minister's Questions on Wednesday. Ms Reeves is expected to announce significant increases in spending on the NHS, defence and schools, with £113 billion of investment expected thanks to looser borrowing rules. That will mean more money for the Scottish Government, with the Barnett Formula designed to allocate funding to devolved administrations when spending declarations are made on issues like health, justice and education. Ms Reeves already announced a significant U-turn on winter fuel payment cuts, leading to hopes the UK Government could abolish the two-child limit, at a cost of around £3 billion. The policy restricts means-tested benefits, including Universal Credit, to the first two children in a household. Experts have said scrapping it would be the most beneficial way to lift thousands of children immediately out of poverty across the UK. Read more: Scottish ministers have announced they will mitigate the policy from April 2026 – but scrapping it frees up millions of pounds. Speaking to The Herald, Ms Kelly said: 'While we remain hopeful of what might emerge from the spending review, social security and welfare alone won't lift families out of poverty long term. 'We hope to see an end to the two-child limit but this must be combined with action on housing, employment, childcare, and addressing the public debt crisis. 'Immediate support is needed for those in greatest need, alongside long-term strategies to rebuild communities and create sustainable routes out of poverty.' The charity boss added: 'We have seen the same research as ministers and know it would be the most effective lever. It is beyond time to pull it. 'Taking this single measure has the potential to transform the lives of thousands of children in Scotland and hundreds of thousands across Britain. 'If it is not taken, however, the impact is equally huge but devastating for those children will remain in poverty, their lives constrained by poverty and their life chances sabotaged by poverty.' The Chancellor's review is not considered a 'fiscal event', meaning there will not be any detailed tax or spending decisions. Read more: But she will set out her spending plans until 2029, department by department. Ms Reeves has already committed to reversing cuts to winter fuel payments, in a major U-turn from the UK Government. It means that around nine million pensioners with an income of under £35,000 a year will now receive the payment automatically – but the Scottish Government has refused to say whether it will make equivalent changes to devolved legislation. First Minister John Swinney has also urged the UK Government to take more action and spend more money to address the country's housing crisis. The Scottish Government declared a national housing emergency in May 2024, following the footsteps of 12 local authorities, including Glasgow and Edinburgh. He said the Scottish Government is already investing £768m this year in affordable housing, but called on UK ministers to do more. "We continue to call on the UK Government to provide multi-year funding for housing to give developers and third sector organisations long-term certainty,' Mr Swinney said. The Chancellor said the investment was only possible because of the 'stability' she has introduced after the October budget. She is expected to say her spending review will 'ensure that renewal is felt in people's everyday lives, their jobs, their communities'. The Chancellor will say: 'The priorities in this spending review are the priorities of working people. 'To invest in our country's security, health and economy so working people all over our country are better off.' But the spending review is expected to set out tough spending limits for departments other than health, defence and education. She will say on Wednesday: 'I have made my choices. In place of chaos, I choose stability. In place of decline, I choose investment. In place of retreat, I choose national renewal. 'These are my choices. These are this Government's choices. These are the British people's choices.'
Daily Record
3 hours ago
- Daily Record
Rangers will never suffer Crystal Palace UEFA sweat as SFA chief makes dual ownership rules clear
Mike Mulraney explains that Ibrox takeover as well as Hearta and Hibs deal meet key criteria set by Hampden beaks Mike Mulraney insists the SFA would never allow dual ownership where it could cost clubs a place in Europe. Co-Leeds United investor, the 49ers group, has just bought a minority share in Rangers, similar to Brighton owner Tony Bloom at Hearts and Bournemouth's holding company Black Knight who have put money into Hibs. SFA chiefs have given these deals the green light but only because they are minority investments in the Scottish clubs. English FA Cup winners Crystal Palace are sweating on their European inclusion for next season because they also have control of French side Lyon. Mulraney said: 'We make sure if ever there is a contention about a dual-ownership model whereby the Scottish club would be seen as subordinate, that cannot be. You can't get investment rights unless you agree the Scottish club is never subordinate. 'In the event UEFA said, 'these two clubs can't play in the same competition, we've changed the rules', nobody really thought about it. The SFA ensures that the Scottish club is never subordinate.'
Glasgow Times
3 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Care reform Bill passed unanimously at Holyrood
The Scottish Government proposed to shift accountability for providing social care to ministers and create local bodies that would be responsible for administering care. But serious opposition from political parties, local authorities and trade unions resulted in the plans being ripped out of the Bill despite around £30 million being spent on its development. The name of the Bill was eventually changed to the Care Reform (Scotland) Bill and it was passed with the support of 116 MSPs on Tuesday. Speaking about the failed proposals for the creation of a National Care Service, Scottish Tory health spokesman Dr Sandesh Gulhane said: 'Let's not pretend we've arrived at this moment by design. 'We're here because of yet another SNP policy that promised the world and delivered a fiasco. 'The now defunct National Care Service Bill was once hailed as the most significant reform to health and social care since the creation of the NHS. 'But, in reality, it was a half-baked plan dreamt up by ministers, clearly in an ivory tower that was dead in the water before the ink had dried on the first draft.' While Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said: 'The way we care for our most vulnerable is more important than party politics. 'That is why Scottish Labour committed to help the Scottish Government deliver such a service, but as I warned at the time, the devil would be in the detail.' The Scottish Government, Ms Baillie claimed, 'attempted a power grab'. 'Four years later, three first ministers later, three health secretaries later and £31 million later and what we have before us is a drastically reduced Bill with not a National Care Service in sight, and not a single extra penny of that money going directly to social care,' she added. Despite the changes, social care minister Maree Todd said the Government remained committed to the creation of a National Care Service. The remaining provisions will implement changes to the existing care system, the biggest of which has been dubbed 'Anne's Law'. The change will allow family and friends to be named as 'essential care supporters' and require care homes to facilitate visits from them in all but the most extreme circumstances. The proposals grew from a Scottish Parliament petition by Natasha Hamilton, who was unable to visit her mother Anne Duke in her care home during the pandemic, ultimately missing her death. Speaking in Holyrood on Tuesday, Ms Todd praised the work of campaigners for Anne's Law, some of whom were watching proceedings from the public gallery. 'I have been profoundly impacted by the conversations that I have had with them,' she said. 'The emotional harm and trauma that they and their loved ones and many others suffered from being unable to see one another for such long, isolating periods during the pandemic must be acknowledged to make sure that this never happens again.' As well as Anne's Law, the legislation will also give unpaid carers the right to take breaks.
