India and Pakistan's Kashmir fallout hits economy too

CNA

26-04-2025

MUMBAI: Rapidly deteriorating relations between India and Pakistan over a deadly shooting in Kashmir are starting to have small but prickly economic consequences for both nations.
The killing of 26 men on Tuesday (Apr 22) in Indian-administered Kashmir, the deadliest attack on civilians in the Himalayan region in a quarter of a century, triggered public outrage across the world's most populous country.
India has unveiled a series of mostly symbolic diplomatic measures against Pakistan, after accusing its regional rival of supporting "cross-border terrorism".
Islamabad, which rejected the allegations, responded on Thursday with similar tit-for-tat measures - but upped the ante by halting trade with New Delhi and closing its airspace to Indian airlines.
Experts say that while the retaliatory moves will not have an immediate or far-reaching impact, they will likely result in longer and more expensive flights for Indians, while forcing Pakistan to increase pharmaceutical imports from other countries.
Pakistan's decision to close its airspace to carriers from its neighbour will see journeys from India to Central Asia, Europe and North America take up to two hours longer.
"We are currently looking at, on average, an extra 60 minutes to 120 minutes for flights depending on where they go," Sanjay Lazar, aviation expert and CEO of Avialaz Consultants, told AFP.
'SABRE RATTLE'
Pakistan's move is expected to hurt Air India, owned by Indian conglomerate Tata Group, the most.
Air India said that some flights to North America, Europe and the Middle East will have to take an "alternative extended route".
And the extra flying time may eventually make flights more expensive.
"There is extra fuel burn, because you're taking a more circuitous route," Lazar said.
"And if you add an extra stop on the route, then you incur additional crew and landing costs too."
Airfares could rise if restrictions continue beyond six months, though airlines are unlikely to hike up fares immediately to avoid the risk of "not appearing patriotic enough", he added.
Mark D Martin, of Martin Consulting, said ticket prices could rise by more than 35 per cent to Middle East destinations and by over 45 per cent to Europe.
"It's always the airline business that gets impacted when India and Pakistan spar and sabre rattle," Martin said.
"Let's hope better sense prevails, and this situation deescalates, as this will have an earning impact on airline financials."
Indian government data shows that when Islamabad closed its airspace in 2019 -- after New Delhi hit it with airstrikes in response to an attack in Kashmir -- domestic airlines saw a financial cost of nearly 5.5 billion rupees (US$64.3 million) during the nearly five-month-long shutdown.
THIRD COUNTRY TRADE
But analysts say Pakistan's decision to halt trade is unlikely to have a major impact, as regular diplomatic flare-ups between the two nations over decades have prevented close economic ties.
India exported less than US$450 million in goods to Pakistan between April 2024 and January 2025, a tiny fraction of its overall shipments.
Key items included pharmaceutical products worth over US$110 million, and sugar worth over US$85 million.
"Imports from Pakistan were negligible -- just US$0.42 million, limited to niche items like figs, basil and rosemary herbs," Ajay Srivastava of Global Trade Research Initiative, a New Delhi-based think tank, said in a briefing note.
But Islamabad also said Thursday it had suspended "all trade with India" including "to and from any third country through Pakistan".
It is not immediately clear how this would impact indirect trade through countries such as the United Arab Emirates or Singapore.
Indirect trade is far higher, totalling around US$10 billion, according to Srivastava.
"Informal sources say that Pakistan imports several Indian products this way, including chemicals, pharmaceuticals, cotton and yarn," he said.