NZ's failing heart care 'on the verge of collapse'
Half of all heart attack patients are not being treated within accepted timeframes in New Zealand, which has just a third of the cardiologists it needs, according to a new University of Otago report commissioned by cardiac advocacy charity Kia Manawanui Trust.
For the first time, the total cost of heart disease to the New Zealand economy has been calculated at an estimated $13.8 billion a year.
Trust chief executive Letitia Harding said the findings exposed a system that was failing at every level.
"Heart care in New Zealand isn't just stretched - it's on the verge of collapse," she said. "We are failing in all aspects and it's costing New Zealanders their lives."
Key findings from the Heart disease in Aotearoa: morbidity, mortality and service delivery report include:
Life-threatening delays: Half of all heart-attack patients are not seen within internationally accepted timeframes
Workforce shortage: New Zealand has only a third of the cardiologists it should have
Māori and Pacific people hospitalised or die from heart disease more than a decade earlier, on average, than other New Zealanders
Heart disease costs the country's health system and economy $13.8 billion per year
Postcode lottery for care: Regions with the highest death rates - Tairāwhitii, Lakes, Whanganui, and Taranaki - have the fewest cardiac specialists
Lucy Telfar-Barnard. Photo: University of Otago
Wellington-based cardiologist and trust medical director Dr Sarah Fairley said the findings by Otago researcher Dr Lucy Telfar-Barnard matched the experience of front-line clinicians.
"From inside the system, I can tell you that this report reflects what we see every day - a workforce stretched beyond safe limits, patients slipping through the cracks and no end in sight."
Harding said the report should be "a wake-up call for the government".
The trust is calling for immediate investment in public hospital cardiac care infrastructure - beds and equipment - and a national strategy to recruit and retain cardiology staff.
The total cost of heart disease deaths in 2020 was $13.09b, from 74,708 life years lost.
In 2024, New Zealand had 173.2 full-time cardiologists or 32.8 FTE per million people. That is three times lower than the average (95 specialists per million) of all countries measured by the European Society of Cardiology.
Ministry data showed no cardiac staff at all in Wairarapa or Whanganui, no cardiologists or sonographers/cardiac physiologists in Lakes, West Coast or Souther Canterbury, and no cardiologists in Tairāwhiti.
With 96.3 full-time cardiologists per million, Auckland was the only city with comparable number of specialists to European countries. Waikato (47.5 FTE per million) was half the European average, while others were much less, ranging from 21.4 to 27.
The number of cardiology sonographers had dropped from 70.4 in 2013 to just 43.5 in 2024, despite the 17% population increase. The ratio of sonographers had nearly halved from 16 per million to 8.2.
Heart disease was responsible for one in five deaths and five percent of hospital admissions.
The cost of heart disease:
Hospitalisations cost an estimated $538,790,541 a year
Work days lost $17,996,766
GP visits $65,166,640
Prescriptions $61,906,660
Mortality $13,094,819,487
Total: $13,778,680,094
These were minimum costs, as they did not include the cost of emergency department visits, nor indirect costs of workdays lost to emergency department and outpatient visits, nor years lost to disability.
In a statement, Health Minister Simeon Brown said the government expected Health New Zealand to have a continued focus on strengthening cardiac services nationwide.
He said the report highlighted several key areas Health New Zealand must act on, including addressing regional variations in service quality and patient outcomes.
"I have been advised that Health New Zealand has established a National Clinical Cardiac Network which is developing national standards and models of care, while also establishing dedicated work streams to ensure consistent, quality care.
"This includes funding for new training positions for cardiac sonographers - a key workforce needed to bring down the echocardiogram waitlist."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
16 minutes ago
- Scoop
Ngāi Tahu-Whānau Āwhina Plunket Nursing Scholarship Winners Announced
Two passionate advocates for better Māori health outcomes have been awarded Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu and Whānau Āwhina Plunket's Mere Harper and Ria Tikini Memorial Scholarship for 2025. Reia Hartgers and Chantal Vanisi each received $1500 towards their Bachelor of Nursing Degrees, supported by Ngāi Tahu and Plunket. The annual $3000 scholarship commemorates the work of Mere Harper and Ria Tikini, two highly respected Māori midwives and healers from Karitāne, who were key figures in Plunket's beginnings. It is awarded to full-time nursing students of Ngāi Tahu descent who are in their final year of study. Scholarship awardee Chantal Vanisi is completing her Bachelor of Nursing at Otago Polytechnic in Dunedin. 'This scholarship is an honour and a reminder of the legacy I carry as a Ngāi Tahu nurse, especially as I whakapapa to Karitāne where Mere Harper and Ria Tikini lived and worked,' Chantal says. 'It strengthens my commitment to delivering care that uplifts and respects our whānau. As a registered nurse, I'm dedicated to keeping Māori health at the forefront of my practice and contributing to a future where our people experience equitable and empowering healthcare.' Advertisement - scroll to continue reading Scholarship awardee Reia Hartgers is completing her Bachelor of Nursing at Ara Institute of Canterbury and her goal is to specialise in neonatal nursing incorporating Māori cultural values. 'I'm incredibly grateful to receive this scholarship,' Reia says. 'It will enable me to concentrate on my upcoming placement and my whānau without also having to work weekends. It's a privilege to be supported, honouring the legacy of Mere Harper and Ria Tikini as I work towards improving Māori health outcomes.' Whānau Āwhina Plunket Chief Executive, Fiona Kingsford says it is a pleasure to support students such as Chantal and Reia. 'This scholarship celebrates Plunket's history of strong and inspirational wāhine, while also helping support the next generation of Māori nurses to bring their valuable cultural knowledge to the profession. We look forward to seeing the positive impact both Reia and Chantal will have in their health careers.'' Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu Chief Operating Officer, Kendall Flutey, says the iwi values the opportunity to work with Whānau Āwhina Plunket through this shared initiative. 'Assisting Reia and Chantal to complete their nursing studies is a fitting way to honour the legacy of Mere Harper and Ria Tikini. This scholarship clearly aligns with our tribal whakataukī, Mō tātou, ā, mō kā uri ā muri ake nei, which speaks to the importance of looking after the wellbeing of future generations.' Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu and Whānau Āwhina Plunket's Mere Harper and Ria Tikini Memorial Scholarship was established in 2020. About Whānau Āwhina Plunket Pēpi, tamariki and whānau are at the heart of Whānau Āwhina Plunket. The charity is Aotearoa New Zealand's largest health and wellbeing support service for tamariki – seeing 290,000 under-fives in 2024. About three-quarters of newborns are enrolled with Whānau Āwhina Plunket each year. Our nurses provide clinical assessments, and along with Kaiāwhina and Community Karitāne, support whānau and families, through home and clinic visits, as well as PlunketLine 0800 933 922, a free 24/7 telephone advice service for parents. Our website is one of the country's most widely read digital child health resources, with 1.8 million visits each year. It is available data-free through the Zero Data portal at and you can choose to view it in English or te reo Māori.
Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
Orewa Local Gets #GutsyForGutCancer Running 161km In Under 24 Hours
Press Release – Gut Cancer Foundation What began as a personal challenge became a public journey. I never expected the magnitude of what unfolded, besides the first 4km I was never alone Neville says. Even at 3am he had local runners coming out to show their support and run alongside … Orewa local Neville Modlin inspired his community this past weekend running 161.8km in 23 hours and 55 minutes to pay tribute to his father who recently passed away from pancreatic cancer. In late November 2024 when Neville Modlin's father casually mentioned he was feeling 'a little under the weather' their family had no idea that his funeral would be held on New Years Eve that same year. Neville's father passed away only 6 weeks later after a short and intense journey with pancreatic cancer which is becoming one of New Zealand's deadliest cancers with 88% of Kiwis passing away within 5 years of diagnosis. Neville says 'the speed that everything progressed for my dad was totally unexpected.' Within 10 days they were planning the estate, after 15 he became an expert in cancer medication and in 30 he was organising fulltime care and planning a funeral. Not to mention supporting his mum throughout the process who was navigating losing her life partner of over 60 years. Neville channelled his grief into action, taking on his biggest personal challenge in part of The Gut Cancer Foundation's #GutsyForGutCancer raising critical funds and awareness for Kiwis battling gut cancer. 'What began as a personal challenge became a public journey. I never expected the magnitude of what unfolded, besides the first 4km I was never alone' Neville says. Even at 3am he had local runners coming out to show their support and run alongside him, some whom he had never met before. Neville and his family have been blown away by the communities support both on the day and in the fundraising campaign as they've now surpassed their initial fundraising goal by almost 6 times! Like many New Zealanders Neville didn't know much about gut cancers when his father was diagnosed, 'because he went downhill so fast there was little support – We were figuring it out one day at a time.' Liam Willis, Executive Officer of The Gut Cancer Foundation (GCF) highlights that gut cancer is the most common form of cancer in New Zealand with over 6,100 Kiwis diagnosed every year. 'They have some of the worst survival rates of any cancers;' 8 Kiwis die from gut cancer every day. The GCF funds innovative research, addresses barriers to treatment and is particularly focused on improving experiences similar to Neville's by establishing a comprehensive pipeline to support Kiwis with access to vital resources throughout the cancer journey for patients and whanau. Liam shares the GCF has created an online hub of resources that is a comprehensive source of information for anyone diagnosed with a gut cancer, adding 'our team are on hand to answer questions they or their whanau may have.' 'We are committed to developing this service to ensure we meet the need of our community and no one has to face a gut cancer diagnosis alone.' The generosity of the GCF supporters and donations help gives New Zealanders access to international clinical trials and allows the foundation to continue to be the voice for our communities. 'By raising awareness of signs, symptoms and specific risk factors we hope to see these cancers detected earlier, increasing the chances of patients surviving their diagnosis.' says Liam.
NZ Herald
3 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Anti-vaccine group Voices For Freedom's book criticised for misleading Covid claims
The book features photos and descriptions of 22 supporters of the VFF movement under the Latin heading 'dramatis personae', including Nelson-based lawyer Sue Grey who was recently fined for breaching a suppression order. A marketing lecturer told the Herald the design strongly evokes the look and feel of Government documents, risks misleading readers into assuming it's endorsed by the Government, and poses reputational risk for the legitimate Royal Commission. However Deeks said the book was necessary because commissioners overseeing the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the Covid-19 response were relying on government agencies and 'favoured experts'. VFF was allowed to make submissions as part of public hearings on vaccine safety last month. 'If the public is to engage meaningfully, they need access to a clear, evidence-based counterpoint while the hearings are live, not months later,' Deeks told the Herald. Nelson-based lawyer Sue Grey is listed in the book as one of its 22 "dramatis personae" - or list of characters. Photo / NZME The book claims foreign DNA found in Pfizer and Moderna vaccine vials could cause cancer and 'genomic instability', suggests deaths increased as a result of the booster vaccine rollout, and that there's no robust scientific evidence for the widespread use of face masks. Many of the topic-based sections are written or co-authored by New South Wales lawyer Katie Ashby-Koppens. Ashby-Koppens has been helping represent the views of VFF founders Alia Bland and Deeks during hearings at the Government's Royal Commission. She has no medical qualifications. Otago University epidemiologist professor Michael Baker told the Herald he was 'mystified' as to the purpose of the book. He said the most productive channel for making valid arguments about the country's Covid-19 response was at the Government's official Royal Commission, where submitters, including members of the VFF, were asked to justify their views. University of Otago epidemiologist, Professor Michael Baker said if claims haven't gone through the scrutiny of a peer review process they "don't have much standing". Photo / Supplied Baker said there was also another way to gain scientific credibility. 'If you think the science is wrong, the most effective channel is to write something and get it published in a journal. Then it goes through a peer-review process. Unless it goes through some scrutiny, it doesn't have much standing,' he said. There was 'no evidence' to support increased mortality being linked to the use of vaccines, he said. The anti vaccine group Voices For Freedom has produced a 271-page book about New Zealand's response to the Covid-19 pandemic which a marketing expert says looks like a Government document. Photo / Michael Morrah Baker's colleague and professor of public health at Otago University Nick Wilson didn't think the publication was worth spending money on. 'From a public health perspective, if they're not using well-informed people, it [the book] has very little value. 'There has been a range of evidence on masks that show that they work.' Professor Nick Wilson said the book has little value "if they're not using well-informed people". Photo / John Gerritsen, RNZ He said New Zealand's Covid-19 response 'was not perfect' but it worked - a conclusion supported by the first phase of the Royal Commission, which finished last year. 'We have some very thorough documents from the first Covid inquiry. That is the official source of information,' he said. Commissioners in the first phase the inquiry concluded the vaccine mandates were 'reasonable' for specific professions in 2021 and said lockdowns were an effective tool for managing virus elimination. VFF's book uses the colour navy blue throughout and states on the front cover that it's a 'special report' on the New Zealand Royal Commission of Inquiry. Auckland University's Dr Herbert Sima said there is a credible likelihood the publication could be mistaken for an official government report. Auckland University senior marketing lecturer Dr Herbert Sima told the Herald the design of the book was problematic. 'There is a credible likelihood that this publication could be mistaken for an official government report,' he told the Herald. He said those unfamiliar with VFF or its contributors, or those who skim read the document without reading the fine print could be misled. 'The design employs multiple visual and textual strategies that can strongly evoke the look and feel of an official government document.' He said this included the navy blue colour palette and bold sans-serif fonts. He said that raised ethical concerns from a marketing perspective. 'It risks misleading readers into assuming government endorsement. It leverages public trust in official inquiries to amplify the advocacy group's viewpoint,' he said. He said it also posed reputational risks for the Royal Commission. Deeks said navy blue is a longstanding brand colour of VFF and the movement's logo is displayed on the book's cover. 'The Government does not have dibs on a colour palette,' she said. In response to Baker, Deeks claimed the book did contain legitimate scientific perspectives. 'It is grounded in peer-reviewed science, official data, and testimony from internationally recognised experts, many of whom advised governments before 2020,' she said. Michael Morrah is a senior investigative reporter/team leader at the Herald. He won News Journalist of the Year at the 2025 Voyager Media Awards and has twice been named reporter of the year at the NZ Television Awards. He has been a broadcast journalist for 20 years and joined the Herald's video team in July 2024.
