Cross-examination of state witness in eight accused murder trial continues
Zenzele Mzikayise Yende (48), Werner Potgieter (48), Moses Dlamini (59), Masodeni Elliot Msongelwa Dlamini (61), Cornelius Lourens Greyling (26), Sikhumbuzo Zikalala Nhlabathi (25), Mzwakhe Dlamini (48), and Nkosinathi Msibi (26) are accused of the alleged murder of Sifiso Thwala and Musa Nene, and the alleged attempted murder of Sthembiso Thwala on August 9, 2020. They are also facing kidnapping charges.
Vilakazi was being questioned by opposing counsel on his statement he made to Warrant Officer Nhlapo and his evidence in court.
Counsel said his statement and his evidence in court were contradictory because in his statement, he did not mention who took out one of the victims from the Toyota Corolla to be assaulted, but mentioned in court that it was Nkosinathi. Vilakazi responded by saying the only error he made was forgetting to mention that aspect, but that it was indeed Nkosinathi who took out one of the victims from the car.
He further added that at the time he made the statement, he could not recall certain aspects of the incident, but he now had a clearer memory of what transpired that day.
According to opposing counsel, Vilakazi's evidence in court contradicted his statement to Nhlapo on various aspects. Vilakazi replied that on the day he made the statement, Nhlapo told him he may forget some of the things that happened that day, but advised him that should he remember anything, he must mention it in court, but be careful not to mention things that never happened.
Vilakazi had testified in court previously that on the night of the incident, Msongelwa instructed him and Nkosinathi to fetch rocks for him, which they did. Msongelwa then allegedly took one of the rocks, placed it on the ground, took Thwala's foot, and placed it on the rock. He then allegedly proceeded to take another rock and hit Thwala on the foot, multiple times, until he bled.
It was Msongelwa who allegedly used pliers on Thwala to further assault him.
Counsel then asked Vilakazi why he didn't say in his statement that it was he and Nkosinathi who fetched the rocks and took off Thwala's shoes. Instead, Vilakazi told Nhlapo that it was Msongelwa who did that.
Vilakazi responded that the officer must have recorded it wrong, because he told Nhlapo that he and Nkosinathi were the ones who fetched the rocks and took off Thwala's shoes, on Msongelwa's instruction.
Counsel then told him that the contradictions in his evidence in court and his statement were lies. Vilakazi replied by insisting that he had never told lies, although some confusion might be there between the two statements.
More witnesses are expected to testify next week, as the trial is ongoing.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
6 hours ago
- IOL News
Police minister Mchunu announces closure of inquests into Gavin Watson and Marcus Jooste's deaths
An inquest into the death of late former Bosasa boss Gavin Watson was held at the Kempton Park Magistrate's Court on May 30 resulting in the closure of the culpable homicide case. Image: FILE Police minister Senzo Mchunu has announced the closing of the culpable homicide case concerning the late former boss of Bosasa, Gavin Watson, following an inquest by the Kempton Park Magistrate's Court three months ago. Mchunu made the announcement in a response to parliamentary questions from DA MP Glynnis Breytenbach regarding the release of autopsy reports for both Watson and the late former CEO of Steinhoff International. Watson died when the car he was driving, a company Toyota Corolla, hit a bridge pillar near the OR Tambo International Airport on August 26, 2019, near the OR Tambo International Airport while Jooste committed suicide last year in Hermanus on March 21. Mchunu said the investigation into Watson's culpable homicide case was completed after autopsy and toxicology reports were received, following a significant delay by the Department of Health. 'The finalised case docket was forwarded to the office of the Senior Public Prosecutor on 2024/09/24, for a decision regarding prosecution,' he said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading Mchunu also said an inquest was held earlier this year at the Kempton Park Magistrate's Court on May 30, resulting in the closure of the case. 'The findings of the Inquest Court, in terms of Section 16 of the Inquest Act, 1959 (Act No. 58 of 1959), resulted in the closing of the case of culpable homicide that had been registered,' he said. An inquest was conducted in the Hermanus Magistrate's Court after the death of the former CEO of Steinhoff International Marcus Jooste after his apparent suicide on March 21, 2024. Image: FILE Turning to Jooste's case, Mchunu said an inquest was conducted in the Hermanus Magistrate's Court after the death of Jooste, due to his apparent suicide on March 21, 2024. 'The post-mortem report was received on 25 April 2024. The blood/alcohol report was received on 2024/08/08 and the ballistic report was received on 16 October.' In March, Mchunu indicated in a parliamentary reply to Breytenbach that Jooste's ballistic and blood alcohol reports were still outstanding. At the time of his death, Jooste had been under investigation for his actions linked to the collapse of Steinhoff International, where he faced charges of fraud and racketeering. Jooste and former Steinhoff company secretary and head of legal, Stephanus Grobler, were told through their legal representatives on March 20, 2024, to hand themselves over to the Hawks two days later. Mchunu said at the time Jooste and his legal representatives were aware of the investigation since its inception in 2018 and that there was no evidence that he intended to flee from South Africa. When the Randburg Magistrate's Court last year issued the warrant of his arrest on March 20, the investigators had circulated the warrant of arrest on the electronic system of the Department of Home Affairs to alert all ports of entry and exit of the existence of the arrest warrant. 'This step was taken to prevent Jooste from leaving the Republic of South Africa,' Mchunu said. He also said the investigators had then informed Jooste's legal representatives that he should report to the Pretoria Central police station on March 22, 2024. 'The SAPS investigators circulated the arrest warrant timeously to prevent Jooste from leaving the Republic of South Africa.' He also said his legal representatives were advised because of their previous commitment that he would hand himself over. 'Neither the prosecutors and or the SAPS investigators could not have contemplated that Jooste would commit suicide,' he said. 'The SAPS had taken necessary measures to ensure he does not evade arrest by skipping the country. Therefore, the outcome remains unfortunate and there is no further consequence management considered to be necessary in this matter.'
The Citizen
3 days ago
- The Citizen
Mpumalanga man appears in court on drug dealing charges
John Mathebula (37) appeared in the Nelspruit Magistrate's Court on July 28 on a charge of dealing in dagga, with an estimated street value of R1.5 million. According to the Mpumalanga police spokesperson, Lieutenant Colonel Jabu Ndubane, members of the SAPS White River K9 Unit acted on intelligence regarding a white Toyota Corolla suspected of being used to transport dagga smuggled across the border by drug mules. ALSO READ: Nelspruit magistrate postpones judgment in Johan Louwrens' culpable homicide trial 'The vehicle had been identified as part of an ongoing investigation. At about 18:40 on July 25, informants spotted the vehicle travelling from Barberton towards Mbombela. The team successfully intercepted it near Mataffin. The driver attempted to flee on foot but was swiftly apprehended,' she said. ALSO READ: Three men sentenced to life for brutal Bushbuckridge double murder Ndubane also said upon searching the vehicle, police discovered 17 bags of dagga, weighing approximately 250kg, with a street value estimated at R1.5 million. The vehicle was confiscated for further investigation. Mathebula was arrested on the scene and charged with dealing in dagga. He was granted R1 000 bail and is expected to appear in court again on September 29.
IOL News
26-07-2025
- IOL News
Legal battle erupts as Ingonyama Trust pursues former chair over millions
THE former chairperson of Ingonyama Trust Board (ITB), Judge Jerome Ngwenya, who is being accused of hoarding millions borrowed by Ingonyama Holdings from the ITB SABELO NSELE The Ingoyama Trust Board (ITB) is pointing fingers at its former chairperson, Judge Jerome Ngwenya, for hoarding R41 million of its funds. The members of the board said they're at their wits' end attempting to recoup R41 million in loans that were borrowed by its investment arm, Ingonyama Holdings, when Ngwenya was still the chairperson of the board. Ngwenya is one of the directors of Ingonyama Holdings, and the board has failed several times to remove him from this position. The interim chief executive of ITB, Siyamdumisa Vilakazi, said they have taken legal action against Ngwenya. Vilakazi said Ingonyama Holdings was registered in 2019, and in 2021 it borrowed millions of rand from ITB. Vilakazi said Ngwenya has refused to answer where this money went. "This money was paid in three caches. The first batch was R10 million in March 2021, followed by another R10 million in July and then R21 million in November. Since then, Ingonyama Holdings has never produced any financial reports of its expenditure. The Auditor-General keeps asking when this money is going to be paid back," said Vilakazi. He said they've applied twice to the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission (CIPC) to have Ngwenya removed as the director of Ingonyama Holdings. They've failed in both instances, according to Vilakazi, as Ngwenya's lawyers keep opposing the removal. "Today we are saying we are distancing ourselves from Ingonyama Holdings. We want people to know that Ingonyama Trust has been taken over by some people. That's why we have taken legal action." He said he can't explain further on their multi-pronged legal approach since there are ongoing investigations. "There are also suspicions of corruption that are being probed by the Hawks," said Vilakazi. Attempts to get Ngwenya's comment were met with anger. He asked how the board has failed to take away Ingonyama Holdings from him if the company truly belongs to the Ingonyama Trust. Ngwenya challenged this reporter to send proof of the registration of Ingonyama Holdings, attempts to remove him as the director of the company, and the details of the legal action allegedly taken against him before he could proceed with answering questions. The deputy chairperson of the Ingonyama Trust, Advocate Linda Zama, said it was a mistake to have Ngwenya as both chairperson of ITB and a director of Ingonyama Holdings simultaneously. Zama, who was a member of the ITB when Ingonyama Holdings was given R21 million in loans, said she opposed this decision; however, she was outnumbered when the board voted on the matter. The matter caused her to resign from the board.
