Is Gordon Brown right that Scottish child poverty 'worse every day'?
Relative child poverty rates in Scotland are not "getting worse", but have fallen from 25% in 2021 to 23% in 2024, according to the most recent statistics available.
At the same time, UK-wide child poverty rates have remained at 30%, while rates in England and Wales have risen. These figures are after housing costs, which experts say is the most reliable measure.
WHAT DID GORDON BROWN SAY?
(Image: PA) On Thursday, the Daily Record reported that Brown had warned that child poverty 'in Scotland is getting 'worse every day''.
However, the former prime minister's comments were actually more specific to his local area.
Brown represented the constituencies of Dunfermline East and then Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy at Westminster, before leaving the parliament in 2015.
He told BBC Radio 4 on Thursday: 'I live in the constituency in which I grew up. I still live here. I see every day this situation getting worse.
"I did not think I would see the kind of poverty I saw when I was growing up when we had slum housing ... this is a return to the kind of poverty of 60 years ago and I think we've got to act now."
Brown went on: "This problem is getting worse. It's going to worsen over the next few years because there's a built-in escalator in the poverty figures because of the two-child rule.'
The former Labour leader called on the current UK administration to scrap the two-child benefit cap, suggesting that tax rises aimed at slot machines and online casinos could pay for the policy.
WHAT'S THE TRUTH?
The Daily Record's headline, that child poverty in Scotland is getting worse, is not supported by official government figures.
As mentioned above, relative child poverty rates in Scotland have fallen from 25% in 2021 to 23% in 2024, according to the most recent statistics available.
At the same time, UK-wide child poverty rates have remained at 30%. However, rates in England and Wales have climbed in recent years, with both at 31% in the latest figures.
Brown, however, spoke specifically about his local area in Fife.
Data from the Department of Work and Pensions shows the number of children in low income families in the region has been decreasing in recent years.
According to the official figures, Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy had 3851 children living in families living with relative low income before housing costs in 2023/24. This is down from 4032 the previous year, and 4609 in 2019/20.
In Glenrothes and Mid Fife, the DWP data shows that 4680 children were in families in relative low income before housing costs in 2023/24. This was down from 5075 the previous year, and 5623 in 2019/20.
So, across the constituencies which Brown used to represent, the number of children living in low income households appears to be declining.
More and more children and living in low-income families in Rachel Reeves's constituency, according to official figuresHowever, the former prime minister was calling for the UK Government to act – specifically for Chancellor Rachel Reeves to scrap the two-child benefit cap (which the SNP have committed to doing in Scotland from 2026).
The DWP figures show that, in Reeves's Leeds West and Pudsey constituency, the situation has been getting worse.
In 2023/4, there were 6934 children in families with relative low income. This was up from 6519 the year before, and 6324 in 2019/2020.
In Prime Minister Keir Starmer's constituency of Holborn and St Pancras, DWP figures show there were 5357 children in families with relative low income in 2023/24. This was a drop on the previous year's 5569, but above 2019/20's figure of 5239.
FACT-CHECK RATING
False. Child poverty rates in Scotland are not getting 'worse every day'. In fact, the trend is downwards. Experts say this is due to interventions such as the Scottish Child Payment, as well as lower housing costs north of the Border.
However, in England and Wales, child poverty rates are indeed worsening. Brown is right to say that scrapping the two-child benefit cap would likely help reverse this trend.
In Scotland, the SNP have already committed to doing so, meaning the gap in child poverty rates on either side of the border is likely to widen – unless the UK Government takes similar action.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
16 minutes ago
- The Independent
Labour accepted £40k donations from criminal it kicked out of party
Labour has said it is returning more than £40,000 donated by a convicted criminal who the party had already expelled as a member. The donations came from businessman Abdul Sattar Shere-Mohammod, 55, known as Shere Sattar, who was convicted of actual bodily harm in 2022, and thrown out of Labour later that year. The money includes £10,300 given to the central party last June, a figure that is just below the threshold to be disclosed to the elections watchdog, the Electoral Commission, the Sunday Times reported. The revelations raise questions about Labour's procedures for accepting political donations, a hot topic in the wake of reports earlier this year that Elon Musk planned to give Nigel Farage's Reform UK party $100m. In its manifesto at the last election, Sir Keir Starmer 's party pledged to 'protect democracy by strengthening the rules around donations to political parties'. As well as the money given to the party, £15,000 was donated by Mr Mohammod to, in part, support the re-election of Portsmouth MP Stephen Morgan, the early education minister. The party said Mr Morgan was not aware of his conviction. His local party should have declared these, but blamed an 'administrative error' that it said was being 'rectified'. Mr Mohammod also gave £10,000 to the local party of Southampton MP Satvir Kaur and £5,000 to Amanda Martin, another Portsmouth MP. Both declared the money in their parliamentary register of interests. The paper said the donations to Mr Morgan and his local party only emerged when a reporter contacted Mr Mohammod. Asked about his conviction this week, Mr Mohammod said he had been present during a violent confrontation after his son's bike had been stolen. He said he had tried to prevent a 'bad situation' but that his sons had gotten into a fight. He denied personally assaulting the victim. Labour told the paper the £10,300 donation to the party was below the £11,180 limit set by the Electoral Commission, meaning it didn't need to be declared. In a statement, the commission said: 'Donations that have been reported late by parties and accounting units are considered in line with our enforcement policy. We can confirm we are currently considering this matter.' Labour said that because Morgan's crowdfunding page said that donations would also support other campaigns in Portsmouth, it could not be considered a direct donation to him and did not need to be declared in his register of interests. It added that the donations would be submitted to the Electoral Commission in the party's next quarterly return. A spokesman said: 'These donations were made to Portsmouth Labour Party. Action has since been taken to return them.' They also said that Ms Kaur returned her donation last year, Martin was in the process of doing so, while the national party did so on Thursday after being contacted by the paper.
The Guardian
17 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Revealed: oligarchs spied on UK lawyers who ran Serious Fraud Office cases
Oligarchs whose business empire was under investigation by the Serious Fraud Office spied on lawyers who ran some of the UK's most sensitive criminal cases. The Guardian has obtained surveillance images of former SFO prosecutors taken by hired spies. Their goal is said to have been gathering information on the agency's activities, identifying its sources and gaining 'leverage'. Backed with billions from Vladimir Putin's regime, the oligarchs were at the time waging an aggressive counterattack against an SFO investigation into suspected corruption and fraud, a major case the agency ultimately dropped. Andy Slaughter, a Labour MP who chairs parliament's justice committee, said: 'It is deeply troubling that individuals with knowledge of serious fraud inquiries should be surveilled by the very organisations they have been investigating.' He added: 'The hunter has become the hunted.' The surveillance began in 2019. It is unclear when, or if, it finished. As the law enforcement agency that takes on the toughest white-collar crime cases against multinational corporations and billionaires, the SFO often faces fightbacks by well-funded law firms and even cyber-attacks. But this is believed to be the first time surveillance of former SFO prosecutors has been revealed. Lawyers for the oligarchs' mining company did not dispute that the surveillance took place. But they said any 'investigations' into the targets were lawful, undertaken in preparation for lawsuits it brought against the SFO. On Saturday 7 March 2020, the spies pulled up in a car outside the home of former senior SFO prosecutor Tom Martin. At 10.39am, the target emerged from his front door wearing jeans and a Wolverhampton Wanderers hoodie. It was a momentous day: Martin was taking his young son to the football for the first time. Martin had run complex, transnational bribery investigations at the SFO. Although he never worked on the oligarchs' case, he felt he would have been an attractive target for anyone seeking intelligence on the agency. Known to his colleagues as a charismatic leader, Martin had brought an employment tribunal claim over his 2018 dismissal during a power struggle with American prosecutors – a claim he would win. It was apparent from press coverage that he knew the SFO's inner workings and had fallen out badly with its management. Over years of pursuing powerful suspects, Martin had sometimes thought he was being watched. But none of his fears were confirmed. He said he was 'absolutely appalled' when the Guardian showed him surveillance images of his home taken by oligarchs' spies. 'I'm there with my lad,' he said. 'We're not fair game.' Martin said that if operatives were seeking 'kompromat', the Russian term for compromising material that can be used to apply pressure, there was nothing to find, except perhaps his passion for model trains. 'It's an attack on the rule of law,' he said. 'You're not trying to defend yourself in a court, you're trying to shift the odds in your favour.' The surveillance stretched across the country. In a rural village, the oligarchs' operatives spied on Mike Walsh, a former Metropolitan police officer. After leaving the force in the late 1990s, Walsh switched to the private intelligence industry. One client had been in a fight with the oligarchs' corporation over some African mines. In May 2019, the spies traced Walsh, who was by then retired, to his home and photographed him as he put the bins out. Other targets had held senior positions in UK law enforcement much more recently, as members of the very SFO team investigating the oligarchs' affairs. James Coussey was awarded an OBE in 2010 after decades trying to convict the perpetrators of financial crimes. Three years later, he was recruited to the SFO for one last assignment: investigating suspected fraud and bribery at a mining company that had been among the most valuable listed on the London Stock Exchange. Three oligarchs, known as the Trio, were the founders and largest shareholders of the Eurasian Natural Resources Corporation (ENRC). It owned mines from Kazakhstan to Congo extracting coal, chrome and cobalt. Every few days it made revenues bigger than the SFO's annual budget. The team Coussey joined followed money trails between Swiss banks, African kleptocracies, ex-Soviet dictatorships and the Mayfair property market. In 2018, after five years on the case, Coussey called an end to his career. 'I don't think he really wanted to retire,' said Martin, his SFO colleague and fellow surveillance target. 'He loved his job and he did it in a really calm and classy way.' By then, the ENRC case had become one of the highest-stakes investigations in the SFO's history. It seemed that criminal charges were close. The SFO's prosecutors had interviewed one of the oligarchs, plus the son-in-law of another. The oligarchs and their company denied wrongdoing. ENRC's lawyers were on the counterattack. As part of a high court claim against the SFO, they alleged that Coussey had negligently mishandled evidence. A judge would find no 'knowing or reckless breach of duty'. But the legal action had revealed Coussey's identity as a member of the investigation team and put him on the oligarchs' radar. In retirement, Coussey fell into ill-health. The spies' surveillance images of him are time-stamped: a Monday morning in February 2020. They show an elderly man outside his home, bald and bespectacled in a jersey and bodywarmer, pottering between the garage and a blue hatchback. Coussey has since died. Martin called him one of the prosecutors of his generation. He was 'the most upright lawyer you could ever meet', albeit with a fondness for rude jokes. 'He's given his country immense service.' Entrusted with powers to seize evidence, SFO prosecutors undergo security vetting. During his years at the agency, Martin was aware of 'near constant' cyber-attacks. So sensitive was the oligarchs' case that Coussey and the rest of the investigating team worked from a restricted area of the SFO's headquarters off Trafalgar Square. Sons of the Soviet Union's central Asian provinces, the Trio's path to riches began when two of them worked at a KGB business venture in Moscow during the fall of communism. They have used an assortment of private intelligence companies since arriving in London in the mid-2000s. There were the former agents of Mossad and other Israeli intelligence and military services who set up Black Cube and Diligence, run by alumni of MI5 and UK special forces. These operatives targeted Neil Gerrard, a former ENRC lawyer who, a judge would later find, leaked to the SFO as he milked the oligarchs for fees. Both firms say they played no part in the surveillance of former SFO prosecutors. That surveillance began in 2019, directed by Dmitry Vozianov, a Russian consultant who handles 'special situations' for oligarchs. Vozianov fends off threats to his clients' business interests, overseeing lawyers, spies and public relations experts. Faced with an SFO investigation, the Trio hired him. For this covert surveillance operation, Vozianov deployed a decorated veteran of the parachute regiment. Damian Ozenbrook served in Afghanistan, Northern Ireland and the Balkans. After leaving the military, he set up his private intelligence company , Blue Square Global. The goals of the surveillance Vozianov assigned to Ozenbrook were 'to know what was going on in the SFO', said a source with knowledge of the operation, and to find out 'what, if any, informants the SFO were using'. The source believes it was 'all about leverage'. Vozianov did not respond to a request for comment. Lawyers for Ozenbrook's firm did not dispute that his operatives spied on former SFO prosecutors on Vozianov's instructions – though they said there had been no surveillance of serving SFO personnel. The oligarchs' operatives also watched John Gibson, a barrister who had run the SFO's ENRC investigation for four years. Gibson left the SFO for a law firm in 2018. A letter he received two years later from ENRC's lawyers at the US firm Quinn Emanuel stated that he had been seen meeting a journalist in the National Theatre's underground car park in September 2020. An SFO spokesperson said: 'We have been aware of the risk of surveillance for many years and our first priority is always the safety and wellbeing of our colleagues. We note that this report relates to surveillance of former colleagues following their departure from the SFO.' In 2023, after a high court judge found the SFO had been wrong to accept leaked material from ENRC's lawyer at the outset of its investigation, the agency dropped the case. There was, it said, 'insufficient admissible evidence' to bring charges. Two of the oligarchs have died during the long struggle with UK law enforcement, their stakes passing to their heirs. The Russian state banks that backed them are now under sanctions. Nonetheless, their corporation is due to receive millions from the public purse as damages. While surveillance by state agencies is highly regulated – the SFO would have needed a warrant to conduct an operation like the oligarchs' – surveillance by private firms is not. Slaughter, the MP, said: 'Everything about this rings alarm bells, from the Russia links to the involvement of ex-security force operatives.' He said it raised 'wider issues for the government as to how it regulates private investigators'.
The Guardian
17 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘I became obsessed': New Labour psychodrama grips TikTok teenagers
This summer, TikTok has been revisiting very public, deeply personal and sometimes toxic feuds from the 1990s. And it is not just the Gallagher brothers – another psychodrama has taken hold: the rivalry between Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. Videos dedicated to New Labour's heyday are booming on the social media platform, posted by teens who were not even born then. The most viral examples splice together archival footage and quotes about the era, set to hit soundtracks from current pop artists such as Chappell Roan – who was born a year after Labour won its 1997 landslide. Popular videos from the New Labour revival include montages detailing the rivalry between Blair and his chancellor – peppered with fiery excerpts from Andrew Rawnsley's book The End of the Party – to the backing of songs such as Charli xcx's Girl, So Confusing and Radiohead's Let Down. Fan culture in politics has become increasingly popular, as a younger generation of digital natives reach voting age. Last summer, lime-green videos of Kamala Harris with songs from Charli xcx's smash album Brat went viral on X and TikTok, leading to mainstream conversations about 'brat summer' on CNN and Fox News. For 18-year-old Ellen, who runs the account @politicsprincess, the clips – or 'edits', in social media jargon – allow her to combine her interests of trawling video archives and pop culture. One of Ellen's most popular posts, which has 130,000 views, pairs tightly edited clips from the 1997 Labour party campaign with Justin Bieber and Nicki Minaj's Beauty and the Beat. The John Prescott punch, photos of Blair gazing over at Brown and even Saddam Hussein (to the lyric 'beauty from the East') all feature in the highlights reel. This article includes content provided by TikTok. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. To view this content, click 'Allow and continue'. 'I just became completely fascinated and obsessed with these people,' says Ellen. 'What attracts me to it … these complex human relationships.' However, she adds: 'Most people understand that editing doesn't equal endorsement.' Charlie, who runs another New Labour-centric account, says she was engrossed by the 'Blair-Brown-Mandelson-Campbell psychodrama', referencing the arch-Labour strategists Peter Mandelson and Alastair Campbell – who have also become part of third way folklore. Ellen and Charlie asked for their surnames to be withheld. Edits, or fanvids, are short, modified videos that remix existing clips which are then overlaid with music, often to show appreciation for – or to satirise – a person or artwork. Dr Lucy Bennett, a media lecturer at Cardiff University, said the edits also show how 'political messaging is being increasingly processed through fan remix culture'. Many of the New Labour edit creators are aged between 17 and 21, and did not directly experience the New Labour era. Often A-level politics students, their introduction to that period of government comes from documentaries or archived footage shown in classrooms. 'Lolitics', the term for internet political fandoms, exists predominantly on Tumblr, X and TikTok. Users in the community create memes, videos and images about political figures and events, applying the language and practices of fan culture to politics with tongue-in-cheek whimsy. Past examples of this content include the 'Milifandom' of the early 2010s, a celebration of the then Labour party leader Ed Miliband. Users created endearments such as 'Milibae' and Photoshopped images of Miliband in flower crowns. This article includes content provided by TikTok. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. To view this content, click 'Allow and continue'. Political figures born in analogue times are taking note. During their live shows, The Rest Is Politics podcast hosts Alastair Campbell and Rory Stewart played TikTok posts made about them to the audience – including a montage of them with Casual by Chappell Roan playing in the background. 'Most of the TikTok spoofs that The Rest Is Politics seems to have spawned are broadly affectionate in nature,' Campbell said. 'So, whilst often satirical, they in many ways help to ventilate support for the 'disagree agreeably' approach we are trying to take.' Stewart and Campbell watching the edit was 'pure insanity' for its creator, Charlie, whose posts have garnered more than 1m likes. The podcast was Charlie's gateway into studying New Labour history. 'I then read the Alastair Campbell diaries – all eight volumes, by the way – and my jaw was on the floor.' She adds that a 'slight nostalgia' for New Labour is common in the community. 'The contrast of what came before and after makes it seem like one of our better periods of government in recent history.' For young people reaching voting age, their only exposure to politics has been the 'disconcerting unpredictability' of the 2010s, says Stephen Coleman, professor of political communication at the University of Leeds. 'What I think they are doing is recovering a historical image of a different kind of politics. You did have improvements in the NHS, introduction of devolution, peace in Northern Ireland – big structural things.' He adds: 'I think the problem Keir Starmer is facing is people have lost touch with what it means to do normal politics.' The Gallagher brothers Biggest hit Wonderwall tops the Oasis charts on Spotify with 2.4bn streams and was one of the standout tracks on the band's second album – (What's the story) Morning Glory? – which has sold more than 22m copies worldwide. Most famous row A backstage fight between Liam and Noel shortly before going on stage at the Rock en Seine festival in Paris in 2009 led to the band breaking up for nearly 16 years. Legacy Oasis are widely considered the kings of Britpop. Their musical legacy runs through many bands such as Fontaines DC, Kasabian and Arctic Monkeys. Bandmates Alongside the Gallagher brothers, the original Oasis lineup comprised Paul 'Bonehead' Arthurs on guitar, Paul 'Guigsy' McGuigan on bass guitar and Tony McCarroll on drums. Famous fans Lewis Capaldi, Tom Cruise and Dua Lipa – to name but a few. And the entire Manchester City squad. Tony Blair and Gordon Brown Biggest hit Labour winning a 179-seat majority at the 1997 general election after 18 years of Conservative rule. Most famous row Brown saying to Blair: 'There is nothing that you could say to me now that I could ever believe,' according to Robert Peston's biography of the chancellor. Legacy Securing a peace deal in Northern Ireland with the Good Friday agreement, devolution in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland and the Sure Start childcare scheme. Bandmates Back-up vocalist Ed Miliband (went solo after a few years) and unifier Harriet Harman who served in both cabinets. They were followed by a rhythm section of Alastair Campbell and Brown adviser Ed Balls. All overseen by band manager Peter Mandelson – who is enjoying a comeback over in the US. Famous fans Fellow third way-er and former US president Bill Clinton, Tory successor David Cameron and the UK prime minister, Keir Starmer.
