'Salty' high earner's complaint over missing out on BTO ‘lottery money' draws criticism from fellow HENRYs
Posting on r/SgHENRY, he asked if other high earners like him also felt upset about missing out on what he described as 'state-sponsored moneybags of a couple hundred grand.'
'Yes, on one hand, we will benefit over the long run because of our higher earning capacity, but I still feel frustrated that the government didn't hand me a couple of hundred thousand dollars, too. I worked hard for years to get to where I am today, while others receive a few hundred thousand for free. If I had taken it easy instead, I might be worth as much now as if I had just gotten a BTO,' he said.
He further lamented having to pay much higher income tax compared to those who can get a BTO, take on higher housing debt, and serve as 'exit liquidity' to these BTO owners. 'Am I crazy or entitled to feel this way?' he asked.
While the responses came quickly, many did not share his view.
One commenter wrote, 'This is like me driving a Porsche, and I complain that petrol prices are super expensive, not subsidised by the government. How come the people getting public transport can get subsidised fees? If only I am poorer and don't buy a car, then I can enjoy the subsidy!!'
Another commenter admitted feeling 'salty sometimes' but called it a matter of entitlement. 'It is a privilege to be earning higher income. I don't know about you, but if you are above the income ceiling, you probably don't have to look at the price tag at most places you eat. This is something that I greatly appreciate. The extra disposable income for you to invest and save is exponentially higher than others, too; what you save in a year may take someone up to 10 years to save.'
Meanwhile, another remarked that just like how luck played a role for BTO flippers, luck played a role in his situation, too. 'You're salty because you feel your high earnings were a product of your hard work, while the BTO flippers just got lucky. You need to realise how much luck was involved as well for you to be a high earner — from the family you were born to to the environment or opportunities you had.'
He added that way more people work as hard but have never earned as much. 'Once you stop thinking your earnings are all your hard work, then it's just a different lottery that you won, so why again are you salty about others winning when you won as well (and arguably it's way better to be a high earner than a one-time BTO profit),' he added.
He also pointed out that not all BTO flippers make hundreds of thousands flipping, adding that the majority do not make such an amount, and this is after years of holding their flats.
Last year, the Housing and Development Board (HDB) announced that from October 2024, new BTO projects launched would be classified as Standard, Plus, or Prime flats, based on their location and features.
While Singaporean technopreneur and 1M65 movement founder Loo Cheng Chuan said Standard flats generally bring higher profits, he noted that returns still depend on location, with some expensive flats reselling at high prices but making lower profits of under S$100,000.
Last month, under the current BTO income ceiling, another Reddit user asked if anyone had ever quit their job just to qualify for housing, though most responses advised against it. /TISG
Read also: 'We're fast becoming like Hong Kong now': Wing Tai Holdings' 88% sold River Green condo draws flak over 'very small' 980 sq ft four-bedders
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
39 minutes ago
- CNA
Singapore leaders congratulate Indonesia on its 80th Independence Day
SINGAPORE: Singapore's President Tharman Shanmugaratnam, Prime Minister Lawrence Wong, and Minister for Foreign Affairs Vivian Balakrishnan have written to their Indonesian counterparts to convey their congratulations as the country marks its 80th Independence Day on Sunday (Aug 17). In letters to Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto and Indonesian Minister of Foreign Affairs Sugiono, provided to the media by Singapore's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, they recognised the country's progress since its independence in 1945 and expressed hopes for continued cooperation between the two neighbours. They also thanked their Indonesian counterparts for attending Singapore's 60th National Day Parade (NDP) on Aug 9, noting that both countries are commemorating milestone anniversaries this year. President Tharman, writing to Mr Prabowo, said that Indonesia's 'transformation, progress and spirit of togetherness since independence in 1945 has been an inspiring story'. 'It has continued to achieve robust economic growth, uplifted its people, and is recognised as a respected voice in the global community,' Mr Tharman said. 'Your ideals of harmony and mutual respect are, indeed values shared by the people of Singapore.' Mr Tharman also highlighted the longstanding ties between Singapore and Indonesia, adding that Mr Prabowo's presence at Singapore's NDP 'reflects the close friendship and common heritage of our two nations'. Mr Wong, in his letter to Mr Prabowo, said Indonesia has established itself as a 'respected, trusted, and constructive player in ASEAN and on the international stage'. He added that under Mr Prabowo's leadership, Indonesia has 'made bold moves to uplift the lives of its people by strengthening food and energy security, developing human capital, and safeguarding the nation's economic interests'. Mr Wong, who is also Singapore's Finance Minister, also thanked Mr Prabowo for attending Singapore's NDP shortly after the latter's state visit and the Singapore-Indonesia Leaders' Retreat in June. 'These were valuable occasions to reaffirm our shared strategic vision for the bilateral relationship and to chart the way forward for further collaboration in areas like trade and investment, defence, energy and food security,' Mr Wong said. Dr Balakrishnan, who conveyed Singapore's congratulations to Indonesia's Foreign Minister Sugiono, described the country as a 'beacon of progress on the global stage'. He also said that 'good progress' was being made on bilateral initiatives discussed between Mr Prabowo and Mr Wong at the Leaders' Retreat. Dr Balakrishnan also expressed his appreciation for the strong cooperation with Mr Sugiono at ASEAN and other international forums, and extended an invitation to his counterpart to make an official visit to Singapore.
Independent Singapore
2 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
‘Is this a red flag?' — Man shocked after learning company he applied to expects employees to be ‘on standby even when on leave'
SINGAPORE: A man was stumped when he learned that one of the companies he applied to expects all their employees to 'be on standby even when on leave.' He shared his disbelief in a Reddit post on Friday (Aug 15), explaining that when the HR representative called to discuss the 'container operations role' he had applied for, he was told the role would require him to be on standby '24/7, 365 days a year, even while on medical, annual, or childcare leave.' The man said that after hearing about the unusual policy, he asked the HR representative, 'What is the point of being on leave if you are still expected to work when needed?' to which the HR reportedly responded, 'It's expected by the company, and that is how it is.' He then contrasted this with his current job at a small-to-medium enterprise (SME). 'I am currently in a similar position in an SME, which respects my leave, and my colleague will cover for me when I am on leave — which I then cover for him when he goes on leave,' he wrote. 'Yet this MNC, with thousands of employees globally, can't or does not wish to do so. It just leaves a bad taste in my mouth that they think it is OK. It's just a basic expectation to have a work-free period during leave.' Though the man didn't mention the name of the company, he hinted that this is 'one of the largest shipping companies in the world.' Seeking advice from other forum members, he asked if this policy was indeed a 'red flag.' 'Shipping industry is like that.' Convinced he would have a rough time at the company, some users urged the man to reject the role. One said, 'Red flag. If they're one of the largest shipping container companies in the world, they should be able to sort it out without reaching to people on AL. They have thousands of employees, and the success of the business doesn't rest on one person.' Another added, 'Epic red flag, just reject.' Others, however, told the man that many companies in the shipping industry operate this way. One user shared, 'Shipping industry is like that. I don't do containers, but my shipping ops is also expected to take calls 24/7 unless they are big enough to have cover from another overseas office. Most of the time, no one will call you unless there is a major issue la. I take calls on leave all the time, even when I am travelling overseas.' Another commented, 'I heard shipping industry is like this, expected to be on standby 24hrs. But in return, they are paid very well. I have heard of 1-year bonuses. So if you're gonna take up such a job, make sure you are handsomely rewarded.' A few users also advised the man to 'gather more details about the role' before deciding to reject it. One wrote, 'You should ask more questions regarding it pertaining to your role, like what kind of standby are we talking about (need to answer call/ or need to be physically present). In the past few years, how often has it been necessary for someone in your same role. Ask for real-life examples of such cases, etc.' In other news, a 28-year-old local has confessed on social media that he is on the verge of giving up on his career in UI/UX design after more than a year of job hunting. Posting on Reddit's singaporefi forum on Wednesday (Aug 13), he explained that, aside from the fact that the industry feels 'completely saturated,' most companies seem to be hiring only for senior roles that demand years of experience—positions that, in his view, 'no one can realistically fulfil.' Read more: 'I'm exhausted': Local UI/UX designer on the brink of giving up after a year-long job hunt
Independent Singapore
2 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
Experts call for Singapore–Johor cross-border taxi revamp amid e-hailing debate
MALAYSIA: Calls are growing for Malaysia and Singapore to work together to modernise the Cross-Border Taxi Scheme (CBTS), with transport consultants arguing that it no longer meets the needs of thousands of daily commuters between Johor Bahru and the island republic. According to Free Malaysia Today (FMT) , transport experts Wan Agyl Wan Hassan and Rosli Azad Khan said the current scheme — limited to 200 licensed cabs from each country operating only between Larkin Sentral and Ban San Street Terminal — is outdated and underutilised. Limited reach leaves commuters frustrated Rosli noted that the CBTS' fixed points fail to serve many passengers, particularly those living in western Johor. 'Commuters have to travel all the way to Johor Bahru to cross to Singapore (via the Causeway). No one talks about this bigger issue and problems faced by those who live on the western side of Johor Bahru,' he said, as reported by FMT . He added that there are still no taxis or buses serving the Tuas Second Link, despite it being a vital route for travel to southern and western Johor. Proposals for reform Wan Agyl, founder of transport think tank My Mobility Vision , argued that modernising the CBTS is the most practical short-term solution, FMT reported. He proposed expanding pick-up and drop-off points, integrating licensed taxis with ride-hailing apps, and piloting a controlled bilateral e-hailing programme. 'This ensures the service meets commuter needs without eroding licensed operators' livelihoods or creating (the need for) new enforcement,' Wan Agyl explained, citing models from other busy border cities such as Hong Kong–Shenzhen and San Diego–Tijuana. He also suggested safeguards like reciprocal driver licensing, cross-border insurance, digital booking verification, and geofenced pick-up zones to prevent congestion and protect existing operators. Rising urgency as congestion worsens Tebrau MP Jimmy Puah has also called for talks with Singapore to ease restrictions on cross-border e-hailing, arguing that many Johoreans prefer travelling via Changi Airport when heading overseas. However, experts emphasised that quick fixes such as limiting rides to airports or ferry terminals would not be enough to address the long-standing issues haunting the region. The urgency for reform is further highlighted by the worsening traffic at the Causeway, exacerbated by long queues and limited transport choices. Read related: 'No bus at all': Commuters endure long, miserable waits as public transport falls short Netizen frustrations Netizens are quick to express just how frustrated they are over the daily stress they have to face during their commute. Many agreed that reform should focus on making legal services more efficient rather than letting unlicensed ones fill the gap. One user wrote that authorities should 'expand the taxi services facilities and not promote 'illegal' services. If the public licensed transport services are good and relevant, then all these illegal services will not be in demand. Those who wish to drive to earn a living, then join the licensed platforms.' Others vented about the state of congestion at the Causeway and Tuas Second Link. 'The traffic is so bad,' one netizen sighed, while another remarked that during peak hours, 'we can't even get on a bus.' Sarcasm also peppered the comments. A few suggested that instead of debating e-hailing, governments should first figure out how to unclog the Causeway jams, with one saying the only real solution is to 'build three more bridges before talking about apps.' Another quipped that no amount of fancy pilot programmes will matter if travellers are still stuck for hours in a sea of brake lights Looking ahead With the Rapid Transit System (RTS) Link set to open in late 2026, experts believe reforming the CBTS and piloting regulated e-hailing services would complement rather than compete with the upcoming infrastructure. For now, however, cross-border commuters are left waiting in traffic — and waiting for policy change. Read also: 'Don't embarrass yourselves': Singapore car caught (again) pumping subsidised RON95 in Malaysia
