Pantomime villains: Why the Lions aren't everyone's cup of tea
Last Thursday in Adelaide, after the team announcement to face the Australia and New Zealand XV at the elite St Peter's College, a schoolboy tried to ask a question before being shut down by the Lions' management. Perhaps they were concerned he was going to draw attention to frequent offsides or the issues at the breakdown.
The battler
It is almost impossible to consider booing an Australian, never mind one as likeable off the field as Melbourne-raised Scotland centre Sione Tuipulotu.
Tuipulotu's brilliance for Scotland and the Lions comes after he failed to cement his place in Australian rugby.
If there is a slight point of contention, it was the Scottish centre's row with Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii on a chilly day last November in Edinburgh.
Suaalii tried to dominate Tuipulotu at the point of contact, but managed to injure himself making a big tackle. There was sledging between the two in a subsequent scuffle, with Suaalii telling his compatriot he would 'see you next time'. That next time comes on Saturday night.
The bruiser
Lions loosehead prop Ellis Genge will have happy memories of the last time he visited Suncorp Stadium. Playing for England, he helped defeat the Wallabies in the second Test in a standout performance that helped his country level the series, before going on to win it overall in Sydney.
Genge had been stung by Taniela Tupou saying that he looked forward to smashing him, and instead meted out the punishment to the Wallabies, running over Michael Hooper after just 30 seconds. The prop also shoved the Wallabies' captain in the chest after a try was scored by Billy Vunipola.
Genge escaped sanction after tackling halfback Nic White and using his elbow to keep the Wallabies player pinned to the ground.
'Leaning on me with an elbow is a nice way to put it. Ellis has that in his game,' White said after the game in Brisbane.
Wallabies fans will have an opportunity to see the new, matured Genge, who is letting his actions speak far louder than his words this time in Brisbane.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
18 minutes ago
- 7NEWS
Melbourne appeal AFL tribunal's three-match ban of veteran defender Steven May
Melbourne are exercising their right to appeal the Steven May guilty verdict, which saw the star defender suspended for three games on Wednesday night by the AFL tribunal. May was found guilty of rough conduct for a collision that concussed Francis Evans and left the Carlton forward with a broken nose and a chipped tooth. The tribunal ultimately found that May did not fulfill effectively his duty of care to the extent that 'a reasonable player' would under specific circumstances. But the decision has divided the AFL world, and former greats and expert Channel 7 commentators Nick Riewoldt and Matthew Richardson expressed their disbelief in the verdict on Thursday morning. Riewoldt, in particular was shocked the use of the words 'reasonable player'. 'I want to meet this reasonable player,' Riewoldt said on Triple M. 'I can't wait to meet him. Who is he? Who is this reasonable player? Superman, part Superman, part Flash, can bend time, can do all of these things. 'Unbelievable decision from the AFL tribunal last night to suspend Steven. May. 'I really thought that common sense was going to prevail.' Riewoldt said he thought the case would be similar to that of Fremantle captain Alex Pearce, whose three-match ban for concussing Port Adelaide's Darcy Byrne-Jones in May was overturned at the tribunal. Pearce was cleared after Fremantle successfully argued that he was contesting the ball. Pearce also declared at the time 'it would not sit well with me if I pulled out of that contest'. 'We had one earlier in the year with Alex Pearce, where I thought 'good', they're not trying to jam every incident into their own framework, into their own narrative, that every head knock and subsequent concussion is a breach of duty of care,' Riewoldt said. 'There are going to be accidents. It's a contact sport, and I thought this one would fit that mould perfectly, and yet, here we are, Steven May being suspended for three weeks. 'There has to be an appeal.' Richmond legend Matthew Richardson agreed. 'I didn't like it,' Richardson said on Channel 7's Sunrise. 'I thought, right from the start Steven May was contesting the ball. They arrive pretty much at the same time. I mean, there's a 10th of a second in it. 'I think Steven May tried to win the footy. It was an accidental collision. And it's a big ruling for the AFL and the game, in my belief. 'I mean, basically it looks like to me that if you concuss someone, no matter how accidental it is, you're going to get rubbed out. 'I think they just need to be transparent, the AFL, and come out and say that. 'I think Melbourne and Steven May, they've got to appeal this, because all the people I speak to, past players, no one has agreed with that decision so far.' Melbourne revealed they were appealing the decision on Thursday afternoon.
Courier-Mail
19 minutes ago
- Courier-Mail
NRL news, updates: Kevin Walters' Kangaroos appointment torn to shreds as contract detail says it all, Cameron Smith, Wayne Bennett, Brad Fittler
Don't miss out on the headlines from NRL. Followed categories will be added to My News. After being unveiled as the new Kangaroos coach, Kevin Walters has a big task ahead of him; first to convince a trio of stars to stay loyal and then potentially an even tougher battle in keeping his job. Earlier this week, Walters was appointed by the Australian Rugby League Commission (ARLC) to replace Mal Meninga as Australia's next coach on a short term deal. The three-game contract that covers the upcoming Ashes series against England at the end of this year suggests even the ARLC aren't confident he is the right man for the job. FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. But first cab off the rank is to try and hold onto several Aussie stars. On Wednesday, six-time Kangaroo representative Greg Alexander raised genuine concerns over whether Walters is the man to convince the likes of Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow, Payne Haas and Tino Fa'asuamaleaui to stay loyal to the green and gold instead of switching to Toa Samoa for the Pacific Championships. 'What if he can't get them on the plane?' Alexander asked Corey Parker on SEN. 'Just think about how many (Australian) players didn't play in the Pacific Championships last year, how many went 'I need a little bit of surgery' instead? 'The squad might be scattered with some of the best players, but Kev might be taking two or three down the list to fill other spots.' Kevin Walters has been named the next coach of the Kangaroos but faces a tough task ahead of him. Image: Getty Parker agreed. 'I know there are more than capable props, but if you pull Payne Haas and big Tino out of the front row, they're two of the leading props in the entire game,' Parker said. 'We also know Mitch Barnett is gone for the rest of the season with an ACL, Val Holmes is gone, and Latrell Mitchell is leaning against it (selection) given his injury situation. 'There's going to be a lot of players unavailable, which makes the task even more challenging for Kevvie.' Walters is understood not to have been the first choice for the Australian job either, with Brad Fittler turning the role down. He also wasn't the second choice with Wayne Bennett reportedly preferred to Walters, but the current coaching rules didn't allow it. Brad Fittler turned down the chance to become Kangaroos coach. (Photo by) Because Wayne Bennett is an active NRL coach he was ineligible to lead the Kangaroos. (Photo by) And veteran journalist Andrew Webster suggested on the Off The Record Podcast that the appointment of Walters on a three-game deal again adds to the notion that the Australian team is no longer the superpower they once were, and therefore it is no surprise that several stars are considering defecting. 'Kevin Walters is basically the last man standing. The fact they have only given him three games shows their lack of faith,' Webster said. 'It could be a very tough tour (with stars such as Hammer, Payne and Tino potentially not there). That's why I wish they made a better decision with the coach.' 'Hammer, Payne and Tino. … The Kangaroos used to be like the Harlem Globetrotters. But it's a different time now, and they are no longer the superpower that they were, and that's something Kevvie will have to deal with.' The ARLC handed Walters only a three-game deal, which will just cover the upcoming UK Tour. But the short-term deal suggests not even they are confident the Queenslander is the right man for the job. Cameron Smith is reportedly seen as the long-term Kangaroos coach. Picture: Jonathan Ng And Nine journalist Michael Chammas revealed talks with Melbourne Storm legend Cameron Smith about a possible transition into the Kangaroos head coach role are already underway. Smith's link to the Kangaroos' top job would further explain Walters' short term appointment. 'My understanding is Peter V'landys spoke to Cameron Smith a few days ago and told him we're going to go with Kevvie,' Chammas said on The Journos podcast. 'When Peter V'landys spoke to Cameron Smith, he brought up the assistant coach's role and said he would like to transition him into the head coach down the track as early as the 2027 World Cup. 'The three-match contract tells me that they're not completely sold that Kevvie is the right man, and in the end, there weren't many people that fit his criteria.' The Kangaroos are scheduled to leave for the UK just two weeks after the NRL grand final on October 5. Originally published as Kevin Walters' Kangaroos appointment torn to shreds as contract detail says it all
ABC News
28 minutes ago
- ABC News
Demons to appeal Steven May's three-match AFL suspension
Melbourne will appeal the AFL tribunal's decision to suspend Steven May for three matches. The Demons will present their case to the AFL appeals board next week. "We felt we presented a really strong case, and Steven's sole intention was to win the ball, and we believe he provided a contest in a reasonable way given the circumstances," Demons general manager of football Alan Richardson said. "After reviewing the outcome and seeking further expert legal advice this morning, we have decided to appeal the tribunal's decision." May was suspended on Wednesday night for the controversial collision that concussed Francis Evans and left the Carlton forward with a broken nose and a chipped tooth. His case was sent directly to the tribunal, with the rough conduct charge graded as careless, severe impact and high contact. AFL tribunal counsel Andrew Woods pushed for a three-match ban to be imposed, declaring May should have slowed down or changed direction to either avoid or lessen the collision. It was a position with which the three-person tribunal ultimately agreed, delivering a guilty verdict after deliberating for more than 90 minutes. May had pleaded not guilty, with his lawyer Adrian Anderson arguing his client's actions were not unreasonable. The premiership defender clashed with Evans at speed while attacking a loose ball in the Blues' eight-point win at the MCG on Saturday night. Given the rolling ball popped up during its final bounce, Evans arrived a fraction of a second earlier than his opponent, with a charging May making contact after continuing his trajectory. May was also concussed in the same match, and he thanked the AFL tribunal for pushing the hearing out to Wednesday instead of the usual Tuesday slot. During his evidence, he reiterated the fact he thought he would arrive at the bouncing ball first. "I definitely thought it was my ball given how the previous bounces reacted," May said. "Then it took an unusual bounce given the conditions. It actually bounced up and towards Evans, which I didn't anticipate." May's hands were still in front of him in a collect-the-ball type pose when his shoulder made contact with Evans's head. "I thought it was going to be in my hands. I just can't believe I didn't take possession," May said. "I thought I did everything right. I was shocked." In his findings, tribunal chair Jeff Gleeson said the evidence from the biomechanics expert showed May had only 0.56 seconds from the ball's final bounce until the moment of the collision, and that he would have needed at least 0.2 to 0.25 seconds to react. "We find, however, that May could and should have reacted before the moment of the last bounce of the ball," Gleeson said. "Even if, contrary to our view, May could and should not have reacted until the final bounce of the ball, we find that he had sufficient time to position his body so that he was no longer attempting to gather the ball. "It's important to note in this regard that May had a relatively long period of time to sum up the key features of the contest. "May ran a sufficient distance and had sufficient time with an unimpeded view of what was before him to determine what he could and should do in the likely event he did not reach the ball first or at the same time." AAP
