Govt panel to examine reliance of students on coaching, fairness of entrance exams
The Ministry of Education has set up a nine-member panel to examine issues relating to coaching, emergence of 'dummy schools' as well as the effectiveness and fairness of entrance examinations, according to officials.
The panel headed by Higher Education Secretary Vineet Joshi will suggest measures to reduce the dependency of students on coaching centres for transition to higher education.
'The committee will examine the gaps in the current schooling system that contribute to students' reliance on coaching centres, particularly the limited focus on critical thinking, logical reasoning, analytical skills and innovation and the prevalence of rote learning practices,' a senior Ministry of Education official told PTI.
Scores of students preparing for engineering, including JEE Main and JEE Advanced and medical entrance exams, including NEET UG prefer to take admission in dummy schools so that they can focus solely on their preparations for competitive exams. They do not attend classes and straightaway appear in the board exams.
Aspirants also choose dummy schools to take advantage of state-specific quotas for admissions to medical and engineering colleges. For example, candidates who complete their senior secondary education in Delhi become eligible for the Delhi state quota in medical colleges, giving them an additional incentive to enrol in dummy schools in the capital.
'The reasons behind the emergence of 'dummy schools' will be examined and the panel will study their role in encouraging full-time coaching at the cost of formal schooling and suggest ways to mitigate them,' the official added.
The panel will study the effectiveness and fairness of competitive entrance examinations in the context of the school education system and their influence on the growth of the coaching industry.
'The role and impact of formative assessments at school and higher education levels will be assessed and how their absence affects students' conceptual understanding and preparedness for competitive examinations. The panel will also analyse the rising demand for quality higher education, limited availability of seats in premier institutions and how the imbalance drives students towards coaching institutes,' he said.
Evaluating the awareness levels among students and parents regarding multiple career pathways and the impact of this lack of awareness on the over-dependence on a few elite institutions; assessing the availability and effectiveness of career counselling services in schools and colleges and suggesting measures for strengthening career guidance frameworks, are among other terms of reference of the committee.
Other members of the panel include the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) chairman; joint secretaries from school education and higher education departments; representatives of Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Madras, National Institute of Technology (NIT) Trichy, IIT Kanpur and National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT); and principals of schools (one each from Kendriya Vidyalaya, Navodaya Vidyalaya and a private school).
The coaching centres in the country have been at the centre of several controversies and the move comes following complaints received by the government about rising cases of student suicides, fire incidents, lack of facilities in coaching institutes as well as methodologies of teaching adopted by them.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
17 minutes ago
- NDTV
"Our Lips Were Sealed But...": Ex Tihar Official Recalls 1975 Emergency Days
New Delhi: "Our lips were sealed but our conscience wasn't," said a retired Tihar Jail official, claiming that during the 1975 Emergency, probe agencies covertly deployed officers inside the prison to monitor staff and political detainees. While discipline was maintained, many jail staff were deeply troubled by the detention of familiar faces, including teachers and leaders, HC Verma, who was posted in Tihar Jail in 1975 as an Assistant Superintendent and was 26 years old, recalled that the staff was initially told to expect a group of 'extremist' prisoners. He emphasized that while the jail staff maintained official discipline, many were deeply disturbed by the detention of people they knew personally. Sharing an emotional encounter with his former school teacher Master Somraj, who was among the detainees, Verma, who went on to become the Superintendent of Prisons, recalled, "I instinctively touched his feet when I saw him. He stopped me and warned, 'don't do this in jail -- it could go against you'." Verma said that in the initial days of the Emergency, jail officials were kept in the dark about the identity and numbers of incoming detainees. "We were told that dangerous extremists were being brought in. Only later did we realize that they were prominent national leaders," HC Verma said in an interview with PTI. He said that amid the sudden influx of political detainees, including leaders like Raj Narain, George Fernandes and Maharani Gayatri Devi, the intelligence apparatus moved quickly. "We later got to know that under-cover officers from various probe agencies were deployed inside the prison under various pretexts like PWD workers, electricians and many other different works. Their job was not just to keep tabs on the inmates but also to monitor the conduct of the jail staff," he said. He recalled that even a minor breach of confidentiality was met with swift punishment. "In one such case, a woman warden was immediately suspended and detained for allegedly passing a casual remark about the well-being of a prominent leader to an outsider. What we got to know that she only said that the leader is fine. But within hours, she was suspended and locked in the same ward where earlier she was monitoring the detainees," Verma said. He said that surveillance of multiple probe agencies extended to routine delivery and food checks, ensuring nothing was passed without scrutiny. "Even when a relative brought homemade food for a prisoner on his birthday, it was refused. A junior staffer who tried to help deliver, he was also placed under suspension," he added. On June 25, 1975, Indira Gandhi announced the imposition of the Emergency in a broadcast on All India Radio, shortly after the Supreme Court granted a conditional stay to an Allahabad High Court verdict declaring her election to the Lok Sabha as null and void. It was lifted on March 21, 1977. At the peak, Tihar housed around 1,900 detainees, including 350-400 political prisoners under MISA and others under the Defence of India Rules (DIR). "Managing such a mix of hardened criminals and high-profile political detainees was a massive responsibility I was given," Verma said. He further said that during the Emergency the jail authorities categorised political detainees under different prisoner classes to manage the influx of high-profile leaders. Verma said there used to be different categories like -- A and B. The B-class ward was well maintained and got vacated to accommodate the incoming political prisoners. Cellular wards were also cleared for leaders like Nanaji Deshmukh. Verma said efforts were made to ensure prominent detainees were kept in relatively comfortable conditions within the framework of jail rules.
Hindustan Times
26 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
'I crashed Air India plane': Chennai techie's shocking revenge plot for man who married someone else
What began as an investigation into claim of downing the Air India plane that crashed in Gujarat's Ahmedabad and bomb threats targeting the Narendra Modi Stadium in the city as well as multiple sites across 12 Indian states has ended in a bizarre twist — a tale of unreciprocated love, personal revenge, and cyber deception. Ahmedabad: A crane being used to clear the debris of the crashed Air India plane, in Ahmedabad, Saturday, June 14, 2025.(PTI) Ahmedabad Police on Monday said it arrested a woman who allegedly orchestrated a wave of terror threats in a calculated attempt to frame a man who had rejected her. The accused, Rene Joshilda, a senior consultant at a multinational company in Tamil Nadu's Chennai, was arrested after an extensive digital surveillance operation traced the source of the hoax emails, according to a PTI news agency report. Loved the man but it was one-sided She loved Divij Prabhakar and wanted to marry him but it remained one-sided, PTI quoted joint commissioner of police (crime) Sharad Singhal, explaining the motive. 'Her dreams crashed when Prabhakar married another girl in February, filling her with revulsion and revenge,' he added. According to police, Joshilda created fake email IDs — some in Prabhakar's name — and used virtual private networks (VPNs), virtual phone numbers, and even the dark web to mask her identity. Despite her sophisticated attempts to cover her digital trail, a small misstep ultimately led cyber crime officers to her doorstep in Chennai. Woman trained in robotics, employed at Deloitte Rene Joshilda, an engineer trained in robotics and employed at Deloitte since 2022, is accused of sending hoax threat emails to high-profile locations, including the Narendra Modi Stadium, BJ Medical College, and schools in Ahmedabad. She also allegedly targeted several other locations in Maharashtra, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu, Delhi, Karnataka, Kerala, Bihar, Telangana, Punjab, Madhya Pradesh, and Haryana — with emails often timed ahead of major religious events or VIP visits. One of the threatening messages read: "Bomb successfully planted in Narendra Modi Stadium. Save the stadium if you can." Claimed to down Air India plane Another ominous email to Ahmedabad's BJ Medical College, whose hostel the ill-fated Air India plane crashed into on June 12, referred to a crash of the airline's aircraft. "I think now you know power. Like we sent you mail yesterday we crashed the Air India plane with our former CM... Now you know we are not playing," the mail read, seemingly referring to the June 12 Air India plane crash. The investigation, however, stemmed from an FIR registered at Sarkhej police station in Ahmedabad after a threat mail was received by a school on June 3, 2025. The sender wrote she wanted to attract attention to a 2023 rape case in Hyderabad. "Going to blast the bomb in your school to bring police attention about the rapist who raped the girl in Lemon Tree Hotel in Hyderabad in 2023." In total, she sent: 13 threat emails to Narendra Modi Stadium 4 to Geneva Liberal School 3 to Divya Jyoti School 1 to BJ Medical College 'She allegedly sent emails to various locations in 11 other states besides Gujarat,' said Singhal, emphasizing the coordinated response from state cyber crime teams across the country. 'We were tracking her for a long time. She was very smart and didn't reveal her virtual trail, but due to a small mistake of hers, we tracked her and caught her from her house in Chennai,' he added. 'We can say that we have busted a big module.' Rene Joshilda's use of her technical skills for personal vengeance, police say, created widespread panic and misled law enforcement across India — all stemming from a deeply personal vendetta and emotional heartbreak.
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Zohran Mamdani: Can an Indian-American socialist be the future of the Democratic Party?
(L-R) Zohran Kwame Mamdani with his parents Director Mira Nair, and Mahmood Mamdani (PTI Photo) Indian-American democratic socialist Zohran Mamdani, 33, stunned the political world by leading New York City's Democratic mayoral primary, prompting Andrew Cuomo-ex-governor and scandal-scarred heavyweight-to concede. If Mamdani wins the general election this November, he would become the city's first Muslim and Indian-American mayor - and at 33, its youngest in more than a century. Why it matters This was more than a mayoral primary. It was a referendum on where Democrats go after President Donald Trump's second-term victory. In pitting a fresh-faced socialist against a scandal-scarred party heavyweight, the race spotlighted the deep fissures within the Democratic coalition - between youth and establishment, idealism and pragmatism, grassroots and big money. Mamdani's possible win signals that the Democratic Party's progressive wing isn't just surviving - it's thriving, especially in major urban centers. And yet, the very elements that electrify his base could prove radioactive in a general election. The big picture Zohran Mamdani's ascent wasn't supposed to happen. When Cuomo entered the race - four years after resigning as governor amid sexual harassment allegations - he was the clear favorite. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Never turn off your computer again, if you own a mouse Panzer Rush Play Now Undo He had name recognition, $25 million in super PAC backing, and deep ties to the city's political machinery. But Mamdani, a Ugandan-born Indian-American, upended the race with a savvy campaign that focused on affordability - New York's defining issue. His platform : Mamdani pledged to freeze rents on over a million regulated apartments, offer free public buses, build city-owned grocery stores, and fund universal childcare. These proposals would be bankrolled by $10 billion in new taxes on the rich and corporations. His style: Leaning into TikTok and Instagram, Mamdani reached voters where they live - on their phones. His viral videos paired sharp critiques of economic inequality with hopeful messaging. Young voters, especially in gentrifying neighborhoods, turned out in force. His support: Rep Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Senator Bernie Sanders didn't just endorse Mamdani; they helped power his volunteer army of 50,000 - a scale rarely seen even in national races. It worked. Mamdani received nearly 44% of first-choice votes to Cuomo's 36.3%, according to the New York City Board of Elections. With ranked-choice tabulation still ongoing, his lead is expected to widen thanks to a cross-endorsement strategy with third-place finisher Brad Lander. What they are saying Cuomo, conceding Tuesday night, acknowledged defeat: 'Tonight is his night. He deserved it. He won.' As The New York Times reported, New York attorney general Letitia James compared the energy surrounding Zohran Mamdani's campaign to a political moment not seen in over a decade. 'It really represents the excitement that I saw on the streets all throughout the City of New York,' James said. 'I haven't seen this since Barack Obama ran for president of these United States.' Ocasio-Cortez celebrated the win: 'Billionaires and lobbyists poured millions against you… and you won,' she posted on X. But not everyone is cheering. 'This is a capitalist city that has a historic relationship with Israel,' said Kathy Wylde of the Partnership for New York City. 'Should he win the primary, he's going to have to deal with that. Or there will be a serious surge to try and prevent him from becoming mayor.' Some Democrats view Mamdani as unqualified. Cuomo, in one debate, scoffed at his opponent's short résumé: 'He's never dealt with Congress. Never negotiated with unions. He's never even managed an infrastructure project.' Mamdani's retort? 'To Mr Cuomo, I have never had to resign in disgrace.' Between the lines Mamdani's background is a mosaic of contrasts and symbolism. Born in Uganda to Indian parents, he immigrated to New York at age 7. He became a US citizen in 2018, worked as a housing counselor, and was elected to the state Assembly in 2020. His resume may be thin, but his personal story resonates - especially in a city that thrives on reinvention and defiance. Zoom in His grassroots campaign was something new - and arguably, something the Democratic Party desperately needs. Volunteer-powered: Mamdani built a 50,000-person ground game - a rare feat in any race, let alone a city primary. Youth-centered: He dominated among voters under 50, particularly in gentrifying parts of Brooklyn and Queens. Clear contrast: Where Cuomo ran a nostalgia-heavy campaign focused on his Covid-era briefings and past infrastructure wins, Mamdani looked forward, offering transformative ideas on cost of living, transit, and equity. Even critics admit Mamdani tapped into something real. 'I like youth,' said Sheryl Stein, a voter in Manhattan. 'But him having no experience and no proven track record to run the largest city in this country… is pretty scary.' Too bold to scale? When strengths become liabilities Mamdani's appeal in New York City-his sharp leftist message, unapologetic socialist label, and vocal support for Palestinian rights-has made him a hero to progressives and younger voters. And then there's his political circle: Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. Their support helped power Mamdani to victory-but could also tether him to a wing of the party that many centrists believe cost Democrats the Senate in 2022 and the White House in 2024. No doubt, his affiliation with the Democratic socialists of America is a political asset in neighborhoods like Astoria or Brooklyn's Park Slope. But outside deep-blue enclaves, it's more polarizing than galvanizing. But these same qualities could become major vulnerabilities if he becomes the new face of the Democratic Party nationally. David Axelrod, former Obama strategist and a native New Yorker, told The Times that while those positions may create vulnerabilities, Mamdani's disciplined focus on affordability could offer a valuable roadmap. 'There is no doubt that Trump and Republicans will try and seize on him as a kind of exemplar of what the Democratic Party stands for,' Axelrod said. 'The thing is, he seems both principled and agile and deft enough to confront those sort of conventional plays.' For many Democratic strategists still haunted by the party's losses in the 2024 Trump-Harris rematch, Mamdani represents everything the GOP is eager to caricature: far-left, anti-Israel, anti-corporate, and too radical for middle America. The result leaves national Democrats with a strategic choice: embrace Mamdani as a compelling next-generation leader who communicates economic urgency in a way Kamala Harris did not-or sideline him as an ideological outlier in a centrist pivot aimed at reclaiming suburban and independent voters. Either path carries risk. And neither comes with a guarantee. Trump-aligned Republicans have already begun labeling him as a 'genocide apologist' for his criticism of Israel's conduct in Gaza-an attack line that's potent in swing districts, even if ineffective in New York City. Mamdani's decision not to denounce slogans like 'Globalize the intifada' feeds into GOP narratives about Democratic extremism and identity politics run amok. For now, Mamdani is an electrifying figure within the party. But to be a national standard-bearer, he'll need to do something most idealists struggle with: show he can build bridges across ideological lines without diluting his message. If he can't, his star may shine brightly-but briefly. What's next The November general election is shaping up to be one of the most unpredictable in city history. Adams, despite skipping the primary, remains a potent force. He's leaning into outsider status after being politically rehabilitated by the Trump Justice Department's abandonment of his case. Cuomo hasn't ruled out continuing on the independent line. If Mamdani survives this gauntlet, it will be over the objections of many of the city's unions, party leaders, editorial boards, and business interests - a clean break from Democratic norms. If he makes it to City Hall, he'll inherit a bureaucracy of 300,000 employees and a fiscal structure resistant to radical reform. His ideological purity will meet the realpolitik of budget crises, federal interference, and labor negotiations. A crash is not unthinkable. Still, even the possibility of an Indian-American socialist mayor governing the world's most influential city was unimaginable just a few years ago.
