Thugs who burned down tanning salon as families slept upstairs get extra jail time
Keith McCormack Smith, Jason Ryle and PJ Lyons had their sentences increased
The destroyed salon and fire-damaged apartments on Tullow Street
At the Court of Appeal, Keith McCormack Smith (24) had his four-year sentence increased to seven years; Jason Ryle (26) had his three-and-a-half-year sentence increased to six years; and PJ Lyons (21) had his three-and-a-half-year sentence increased to four-and-a-half years.
McCormack Smith – also known as Keith McCormick and Keith McCormick-Smith – of Riverview, Church Road, Mulhuddart, Dublin 15 pleaded guilty to arson at Tip Top Tanning Studio, Tullow Street, Carlow on May 17, 2022, and arson to a Toyota car on the same date and at the same location. He also pleaded guilty to various other charges including unlawful use of a motor vehicle, unlawful carriage in a motor vehicle and theft between May 1 and May 17, 2022.
Judge Eugene O'Kelly sentenced McCormack Smith to six years with the final two years suspended at Carlow Circuit Court on July 31, 2024.
Damaged shop front and apartments on Tullow Street
Ryle, of Raithin, Mullingar, Westmeath and Lyons, of Cedarbrook Walk, Ballyfermot, Dublin 10, also pleaded guilty to arson arising out of the same incident. Ryle and Lyons further pleaded guilty to a number of other charges including unlawful use of a motor vehicle, attempted theft and theft on various dates in May 2022.
Ryle was sentenced to five and a half years' imprisonment with the final two years suspended while Lyons was also handed a sentence of five and a half years with the final two years suspended for a period of two years and three months.
Appealing the leniency of these sentences in April last, Niall Storan BL, for the DPP, said the incident in Carlow occurred shortly before 5am on May 17, 2022 when a stolen Toyota Avensis was rammed into a building on Tullow Street in Carlow and set alight causing the building to catch fire.
Mr Storan said the ground floor of the building operated as a tanning salon during the day and the upper levels were residential apartments. He said McCormack Smith was driving the Toyota car while PJ Lyons recorded what was happening on his phone and Ryle was also present.
Ryle had a bottle containing accelerant in his hand which he then poured onto the car while McCormack Smith got out and the three fled the scene.
A garda investigation revealed that multiple vehicles had been stolen in different locations and were involved in the commission of various offences which ultimately led to the arson at the tanning salon.
The offenders were ultimately identified through social media content from a TikTok account.
The destroyed salon and fire-damaged apartments on Tullow Street
Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 20th
Mr Storan told the Court of Appeal in April that it was 'difficult to conceive of a more serious arson offence' than this one which was both 'targeted' and 'pre-meditated' to cause 'an enormous fire'.
He argued the headline sentence of eight years was too low and the sentences imposed did not adequately reflect the gravity of the offence. The lawyer suggested the judge had misplaced the offending at the mid-range on the scale of gravity.
Mr Storan also said insufficient weight was given to the many aggravating factors including the fact that the apartments over the premises were occupied by families who were sleeping at the time, the pre-meditation involved, the use of an accelerant and the fact that the respondents were on bail.
In delivering judgement, Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy said that the arson was a very serious offence, with obvious aggravating factors including the planning involved, the use of a getaway vehicle, the attack on a business premises, the fact that residential apartments needed to be evacuated, and the fact that each man had previous convictions and was on bail at the time.
She said that the court agreed with the DPP that the sentencing judge reduced the sentences by too much, with the sentences ultimately imposed not meeting the gravity of the offending.
Ruling that the sentences were unduly lenient, Ms Justice Kennedy said that the court would quash the sentences and move on to resentencing the three men.
She said that the appropriate headline sentence for McCormack Smith was ten years for the arson offence, which was reduced to eight years with the final year suspended.
In the case of Ryle, the headline sentence set was nine and a half years, reduced to seven years with the final year suspended.
And in the case of Lyons, Ms Justice Kennedy fixed the headline sentence at nine years, reduced to six and a half years with the final two years suspended.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
3 days ago
- Extra.ie
Woman who brought child to Ireland told to return her to home country
A woman who brought her daughter to Ireland, claiming she feared for their welfare due to her partner's excessive drinking and threatening behaviour, has been ordered by the Court of Appeal to return her child. Judge Donald Binchy noted that the woman had obtained a barring order against her partner in the European country where they lived, as well as 24-hour police protection, prior to her moving to Ireland in 2023. She told the court: 'I was hoping I would be able to continue to live in [our home country] and to facilitate [the father's] contact; however, given his behaviour, I could not do so.' She said she decided to leave on October 8, 2023 after getting a threatening video from the father. A woman who brought her daughter to Ireland, claiming she feared for their welfare due to her partner's excessive drinking and threatening behaviour, has been ordered by the Court of Appeal to return her child. Pic: Shutterstock She continued: 'It was the persistent actions of [the father] at this time that forced me to leave with the child as I was fearful for her welfare and my own. I was in constant fear of [the father] turning up unexpectedly, drunk and aggressive. ' Judge Binchy said the mother's claim of her eight-year-old child being at grave risk was key to the case. The judge added that the woman, who cannot be identified, accepted that her former partner had custody rights to the child in their former country, and that there were ongoing custody proceedings when she decided to move. However, the judge said that the partner was barred from contacting the mother, after an incident in their home country in February 2023 when the father and an accomplice allegedly assaulted the woman and threatened to kill her. In February 2023, the father and an accomplice allegedly assaulted the woman and threatened to kill her. Pic: Getty The woman was afforded 24-hour police protection until her departure to Ireland in October 2023. The man appealed the barring order, and it was amended to allow him to have contact with his daughter, the judge noted. He was also given a conviction and a ten-month community service sentence for the February 2023 incident, which is under appeal. Judge Binchy said the High Court found clear evidence of 'threatening, intimidatory and aggressive comments and communications' from the father to the mother. However, he said the High Court had ordered the return of the child, based on the protective measures in place in their home country, both through the courts and the police. Judge Binchy dismissed the woman's appeal against the order that the child must be returned to her home country.
Sunday World
4 days ago
- Sunday World
‘I don't want you to be consumed by guilt' – Dad of crash victim (8) comforts lorry driver
Ms Moore (46) and Abbigael (8) of Cois Coille, Kilkelly Road, Swinford, Co Mayo, died instantly when their car collided with an oncoming lorry Saturday 6th of July Swinford Co Mayo The funeral cortege of Aisling Moore and her daughter Abbigael Tournié Moore are carried through Swinford after the funeral mass which took place at at Our Lady Help of Christians , Swinford. The Mother and Daughter were tragically killed on the N26 road close to Swinford on Tuesday 2nd July. Photo Conor McKeown The father of a little girl who died alongside her mother in a collision between their car and a lorry, wrote a letter offering his 'heartfelt support' to the lorry driver. There were emotional scenes at the inquest of Aisling Moore and her daughter Abbigael Tournie Moore, who lost their lives in the accident on the N26 in Mayo on July 2 last year. Ms Moore (46) and Abbigael (8) of Cois Coille, Kilkelly Road, Swinford, Co Mayo, died instantly when their car collided with an oncoming lorry despite efforts by both drivers to avoid impact, the inquest heard. Coroner for Mayo, Dr Eleanor Fitzgerald, returned a verdict of accidental death for both Ms Moore and Abbigael who died after Ms Moore accidentally crossed into the path of the lorry at Callow, on the N26 between Foxford and Swinford. The inquest heard evidence from a witness who was travelling behind Ms Moore, who saw her car miss a left-hand bend and veer into the path of the lorry on the opposite side. Martin Crean, a HGV driver with West Coast Express in Enniscrone, Co Sligo, struggled to contain his composure throughout the inquest and as he described the moments before the collision. The court heard Mr Crean's Scania articulated lorry and Ms Moore's Toyota Avensis car were both in perfect working order before the collision. The inquest heard that as Mr Crean neared the bend, Ms Moore crossed in front of him and hit a grass verge and she manoeuvred back across the road. At the same time, Mr Crean braked hard, but as he was pulling a 45-foot trailer it caused the lorry to jackknife out of control. Both Ms Moore and her daughter, who were the only occupants of the car, suffered extensive injuries and were pronounced dead at the scene. Saturday 6th of July Swinford Co Mayo The funeral cortege of Aisling Moore and her daughter Abbigael Tournié Moore are carried through Swinford after the funeral mass which took place at at Our Lady Help of Christians , Swinford. The Mother and Daughter were tragically killed on the N26 road close to Swinford on Tuesday 2nd July. Photo Conor McKeown Mr Crean wept and was comforted by his wife as Dr Fitzgerald read a letter written by Abbigael's father, Arnaud Tournie, to the inquest at Ballina courthouse, at his request. Mr Tournie wrote the letter 'with the full weight of a father's sorrow', but also 'with a sincere desire' to offer Mr Crean 'some comfort'. 'My daughter and her mother, Abbigael and Aisling, lost their lives in the tragic accident, and since then my life – and our lives – have been turned upside down,' Mr Tournie wrote. 'No words can express the depth of my grief. Yet, despite this immense pain, I want you to know that I do not hold you responsible for this tragedy. 'I understand how deeply such an event can mark the life of someone who, through no fault of their own, becomes part of it. That is why I want to extend my heartfelt support to you. I know you must carry this image with you every day, and that it cannot be easy – for you or your loved ones. 'I do not want you to be consumed by guilt, because this accident was neither the result of negligence nor of any wrongdoing on your part. 'You did what you could, and no one is ever truly prepared for such a moment. It is a tragedy – unfathomable and unfair – for all of us. 'Please receive these words as a gesture of compassion, of humanity, and, I hope, a small measure of solace. I wish you, with time, the inner peace needed to move forward and to honour, in your own way, the memory of these two beautiful souls taken too soon.' The inquest heard the mother and daughter had spent a few days at the Ocean Sands Hotel in Enniscrone and were returning home to Swinford to prepare for Abbigael to spend time with her father in France. The accommodation manager at the hotel, Johnny Burke, recalled saying goodbye as they left the hotel that day. Mr Burke said he later heard a woman and child had been killed close to Swinford and got a bad feeling. He said he rang Swinford garda station, but they would not confirm their identities, 'but I knew', he said. 'I didn't sleep a wink that night,' he added. Garda John Naughton, who examined the scene, explained that conditions were dry at the time and speed was not a factor. He said an examination of Mr Crean's tachograph found no breaches. It also showed that in the seconds up to and including impact, he had slowed from 80km to 43km per hour. Gda Naughton said braking hard caused the lorry to jackknife and there was no way Mr Crean could recover control. Sergeant John Melia, who led the investigation, said Mr Crean was tested for alcohol and drugs following the accident and found to be negative for both. Dr Tamas Nemeth, pathologist in Mayo University Hospital, said both deaths were due to injuries sustained during the accident. Sympathising with the family, Dr Fitzgerald recorded verdicts of accidental death. She also expressed sympathy with Mr Crean and hoped he takes comfort in Mr Tournie's letter. Dr Fitzgerald also commended the vast work done by gardaí and led by Sgt Melia. Court presenter Sergeant Seán McHale also expressed sympathy to Mr Tournie and the Moore family along with Mr Crean and all the witnesses who gave evidence. He said it was evident the tragedy had been traumatic for everybody. He also commended his colleagues in the gardaí and the emergency services.
Sunday World
6 days ago
- Sunday World
Hit-and-run driver who mowed down pregnant student and killed her baby boy is jailed
The pregnant woman was hit and 'thrown into the air for quite some distance' before she tumbled and rolled into his car, said the witness A driver who mowed down a five-months-pregnant student and killed her baby boy has been locked up for 13 years. Renju Joseph, 31, was struck by a car driven at high speed by Ashir Shahid, 20, as she walked on a zebra crossing in the village of Bamber Bridge, near Preston, Lancashire. The Toyota Prius was estimated to be travelling at between 58mph and 71mph at the time, in dark, wet conditions, in a 30mph zone, Preston Crown Court heard. Mrs Joseph was taken to hospital from the scene in Station Road in the early evening of September 29, and an emergency C-section was carried out in an attempt to save the life of her son, Olive. She was walking slightly behind two female colleagues on the crossing at about 7.50pm as they headed to work a night shift at a local care home. A motorist travelling in the opposite direction said the Prius driver seemed to increase speed about 15 metres away from the crossing and then swerved from the two pedestrians in front. The pregnant woman was hit and 'thrown into the air for quite some distance' before she tumbled and rolled into his car, said the witness. Prosecutors said the driving of Shahid before the collision also 'left a lot to be desired'. Video clips recovered from his mobile phone and that of his front seat passenger, younger brother Sam Shahid, 17, showed them laughing and singing to music as the car is driven erratically and at speed. Ashir Shahid mowed down a pregnant woman and killed her baby (Lancashire Constabulary/PA) News in 90 Seconds - August 15th Sam Shahid was also seen to put his feet and upper body out of the window while the driver removes both hands from the wheel at times and makes gun gestures. Minutes after the collision the Toyota was abandoned in a side street and covered with a sheet by the defendants, before others moved the vehicle on to the back of flatbed truck and dumped it in Farnworth, Greater Manchester. Ashir Shahid was arrested days later and made no comment when interviewed, but when his phone was examined it revealed that on the night of the collision he made an online search for 'charge for hit and run human'. A video clip on his Snapchat account also showed him singing along to the Shaggy song It Wasn't Me and laughing. Voice note recordings were also discovered of Sam Shahid rapping: 'Ran that bitch over, baby got packed. She still not woke up, she still asleep.' Ashir Shahid, of Windsor Road, Walton le Dale, Preston, pleaded guilty in June to causing death and serious injury by dangerous driving. On Friday, he was also banned from driving for 15 years and one month, and must pass an extended retest. Sam Shahid, also of Windsor Road, was detained for three years after he pleaded guilty to assisting an offender. Sentencing, Judge Ian Unsworth KC said Ashir Shahid's acceleration in the moments before the crash was 'akin to what you may see on a Formula 1 race track'. He said: 'Your driving was nothing less than appalling. You engaged in a prolonged and persistent course of dangerous driving. 'Your speed was significantly in excess of the speed limit and was highly inappropriate for the prevailing road conditions. 'Olive's life lasted five hours and 38 minutes. He did not live to see dawn. His mother never saw him alive. 'His life was snubbed out before it really began.' Sam Shahid, 17, has been detained for three years for assisting an offender (Lancashire Constabulary/PA) Mrs Joseph spent a fortnight in a coma before she learned of the death of her son, the court heard. She and her nurse husband, Nyjil Jonn, had planned a gender reveal party at a baby shower for family and friends on October 2. One of her last memories before the collision was buying a dress to wear for the occasion, she said in a victim personal statement read out to the court. Mrs Joseph said: 'Everything has been ruined by that one night and the callous and reckless actions of those two people in that car. My life will never by the same again. 'I will never get to meet my baby, be a mummy to him or watch him grow up. They have taken my first child away from me and I will never get him back.' Mr Joseph said it was 'incomprehensible' to see their son placed on the lap of his unconscious wife as she fought for her life. He said he was scared for the future of the couple, both originally from India, and the possible long-term impact on his wife. Mrs Joseph suffered life-changing injuries including a bleed to the brain, a cracked spinal cord and fractures to her pelvis, ribs and leg. She has had to learn to walk again but struggles to stand for long periods of time, the court heard. Jonathan Duffy, defending Ashir Shahid, who has no previous convictions, said: 'Of course he knew that he had struck a pedestrian but didn't know at the time how seriously injured Mrs Joseph was. 'He deeply regrets his behaviour immediately after the offence, All he can say is that he panicked and was in shock.' Shahid had expressed feelings of shame, guilt and remorse in a letter to the court, he said. Fellow defence barrister Jennifer Devans-Tamakloe, said Sam Shahid explained to her that rapping about something as serious as these events 'makes it easier for him to cope with, as odd as that sounds'. She said: 'While Sam clearly has difficulties of his own, he has ambitions. He says he wants to join the Army.' Sam Shahid had six prior convictions for 13 offences including burglary and vehicle theft, the court was told. Judge Unsworth told the defendants: 'You seemingly have no moral compass. Throughout these proceedings you have sat with your heads down as if in shame. You have no shame.' He noted how they both 'disappeared into the night like cowards' following the collision and then shortly after acted with 'breathtaking coolness' as they began a cover-up operation. He told them they had 'not shown a care in the world for anyone and anything around you' as they careered through residential streets at dangerously high speeds. Judge Unsworth said: 'Your arrogant, selfish and shameless actions put multiple people at risk including yourselves. 'Neither of you have a shred of remorse for your involvement that evening.' He told Sam Shahid: 'You sang utterly vile rap songs in which you glorified the events of that evening and speak in utterly despicable ways of Renju and her dead son Olive. It defies belief. 'You have an ingrained criminality and are someone who at the age of 17 seems to revel in and take pleasure from it.' Following sentence, the Josephs' lawyer, Cathy Leach – of JMW Solicitors, said: 'The enormity of the tragic effects of the accident and the injuries sustained, are something Renju and Nyjil will live with daily. 'Their lives will never be the same. They wish to retain their privacy but have specifically asked us, as their lawyers, to pass on their thanks be passed on to the many people who have been magnificent in their response to the tragedy. 'They specially want to mention the other road users and people who were witnesses to the terrible accident who took the trouble gave evidence to the police and the court.' Det Chief Insp Andy Fallows, of Lancashire Constabulary's major investigation team, said: 'My thoughts first and foremost today are with Renju and family. They have been through the most appalling ordeal and my heart goes out to them. 'They have shown the most incredible dignity and courage since this tragic collision and throughout these proceedings. 'In contrast Ashir Shahid and his co-defendant have shown nothing but arrogance and a lack of remorse for what they have done.'
