Mission before money: how Europe's defence startups are luring AI talent
STOCKHOLM/PRAGUE/PARIS :Some European tech workers who might once have headed to the United States are looking at defence startups closer to home. Others are rushing back to Europe from jobs abroad.
A sense of patriotism stirred by the war in Ukraine and U.S. President Donald Trump's upending of security alliances is a motivation for many, as well as the opportunity to make money as European governments boost military spending.
For others, it's the appeal of working on cutting-edge battlefield applications that use artificial intelligence.
Reuters spoke to two dozen AI engineers, venture capital firms, government officials and defence companies in Europe who said the influx of tech talent reflected a changed political landscape as the United States retreats from its post-World War Two role as guarantor of Europe's defences.
"There are people that are really mission-focused, and what they want to do in their life is to have an impact and not only earn a big salary," said Loïc Mougeolle, CEO of Paris-based battlefield AI provider Comand AI.
"They're really motivated to have an impact rebuilding Europe and change the course of history for Europe."
There are longstanding ethical concerns about the use of AI in battlefield contexts. But the technology appeals to investors: Comand AI raised $10 million in a December funding round, while Germany's Alpine Eagle, which focuses on technology to counter autonomous drones, raised 10 million euros ($11.4 million) in March.
Amid intense competition for AI talent, Mougeolle said Comand AI has recruited engineers and product managers from U.S.-based ChatGPT maker OpenAI and data analytics provider Palantir Technologies.
Alpine Eagle plans to hire across product, engineering, business development and sales as it looks to expand outside Germany. "Europe, in terms of defence and also public security, is a huge market," CEO Jan-Hendrik Boelens told Reuters.
Salaries in Europe can be significantly lower than in the United States: Glassdoor data shows Helsing - Europe's only defence "unicorn", valued at over $1 billion - pays up to $150,000 per year for an AI engineer, compared with $270,000 at Palantir or $380,000 at Google.
Helsing declined to comment for this story.
As well as poaching experienced talent, companies like Comand AI, Helsing and Alpine Eagle are recruiting new graduates.
Stelios Koroneos, founder of variene.ai, a Greek defence tech startup, said the war in Ukraine had reduced the stigma around working in defence for many young engineers.
"Young people started realizing freedom does not come for free," Koroneos said. "You need to be able to defend yourselves. Some do it with guns and others do it with the knowledge they have and the things they build."
Julian Dierkes, a 27-year old doctoral student at Germany's RWTH Aachen University, researches reinforcement learning, which trains software to make autonomous decisions to achieve optimal results and has broad applications for defence.
"For me it is important if I do research in defence that I am protecting European democracies," he told Reuters.
STARTUPS SURGE
Defence startups have surged since Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022, and technology - particularly drones - has helped keep Kyiv in the fight. PitchBook data shows venture capital investment in European defence companies reached $626 million in 2024, up from $254 million in 2023 and $62 million in 2022.
And Europe's rearmament plans promise more: the European Union aims to mobilise 800 billion euros ($911 billion) for defence while countries like Germany have pledged massive increases in their defence budgets.
According to the Zeki State of AI Talent Report, European defence companies are targeting top engineers as even established firms shift focus from hardware to software for everything from drones to troop-tracking technology.
Its analysis, based on a dataset of 800,000 people, found the number of top AI engineers in Europe's defence sector based on published research soared to 1,700 in 2024 from 144 in 2014. Comparable U.S. roles grew to 6,927 from 487 over the same period, according to Zeki data.
Zeki defined top talent as engineers with a proven track record of breaking new ground in AI discovery such as published research.
"We believe this represents significant and sustained growth in the sector," Zeki's chief executive Tom Hurd told Reuters.
Investors, tech workers and recruiters said unease with the current U.S. political environment was prompting some Europeans to seek opportunities at home. Deep cuts to funding for universities and research bodies by Trump's administration have prompted scientists in other disciplines to consider moving to Europe.
"Many of the world's top AI researchers come from Europe. Some went to the U.S., but many are returning to work on European sovereignty, resilience, and long-term value creation," said Jeannette zu Fürstenberg, managing director at U.S. venture capital firm General Catalyst in Berlin.
"I think that's a powerful signal."
MORE THAN MONEY
Benjamin Wolba last year co-founded the European Defense Tech Hub, which aims to connect tech founders, investors and policymakers and whose events have received sponsorship from Helsing and General Catalyst.
He said more than 12 defence tech startups had emerged from hackathons it organised in Munich, Copenhagen and Paris in 2024 that were attended by around 440 people. The privately-owned network hosted a similar event in Amsterdam last month.
"We're seeing growing anecdotal evidence that AI graduates are increasingly open to working in defence, especially over the past 12 months," Wolba said.
British university student Michael Rowley, 20, said he had recently rejected offers of accounting and more traditional AI jobs to work for a company developing technology that allows sensors to better track troop movements.
"When I decided to go into defence I had quite a few options, and for me it was the opportunity to do meaningful work," said Rowley, whose Tiresias startup won a tech event in Munich in February. "If I want to work for most tech companies I might write code for advertising, but to be able to contribute to the front lines and help protect democracy is an opportunity not many people get."
Marie Inuzuka worked at OpenAI and Palantir before joining Comand AI as a product manager in December last year, attracted by the opportunity to do "more mission-driven, impactful work".
The 34-year-old is a descendant of survivors of the 1945 U.S. bombing of Nagasaki.
"My grandparents lived through the atomic bomb, so defence has always been very close to my heart," she told Reuters.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
US investors, Asia's ultra-rich drive growth in Asia-Pacific private credit
[SINGAPORE] A slight uptick in private-credit fundraising in Asia-Pacific (Apac) last year has given market players optimism for a positive 2025, even as investors continue to avoid China. They said deals in India and Australia can fill the gap, while more investors within and outside Apac are allocating capital to private credit in the region. And the key sectors they are looking to lend to are infrastructure such as data centres, and renewable energy. Last year, Apac-focused private credit fundraising hit almost US$5.9 billion across 33 funds, 7.5 per cent higher than the $5.5 billion raised from 32 funds in 2023, according to Preqin Pro data. 'Given the success of private credit strategies in the US and Europe generally, many of the funds from these markets view Asia as the next frontier, both from a capital deployment perspective and a market diversification perspective,' Shaun Langhorne, partner at law firm Clifford Chance, told The Business Times. State Street is seeing more US credit managers looking to diversify into Apac. West Coast-based managers are looking for new growth ideas, according to Eric Chng, senior managing director for global alternatives at State Street. 'They have come to a point where they can only grow US for so much, they're looking for new ideas for growth. Recently, I had two conversations with two managers, each managing more than US$100 billion in private credit. They are asking me, how do I deploy to Asia?' BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up The US remains the biggest market for private credit, which market players estimate is around US$1.7 trillion in global assets under management (AUM) currently. Apac, which Preqin said accounts for 5 per cent of the global market, could grow at an annualised rate of 8 per cent until 2029 to US$160 billion. In a State Street survey of 450 institutional investors over the world – 120 of them from Asia – 31 per cent said they would deploy more capital this year to developed Apac, a subset spanning Singapore, Australia, Japan, Hong Kong and New Zealand. That's up from 29 per cent in 2024. American investors in Apac deals A look at some of the biggest private credit deals in the Asia-Pacific shows the deep involvement of American investors. These include India's biggest deal on record: a US$3.4 billion refinancing for conglomerate Shapoorji Pallonji Group. Investors include American managers such as Ares Management, Cerberus Capital Management, Davidson Kempner Capital Management and Farallon Capital Management. Goldman Sachs Asset Management's hybrid fund – part of its private credit strategy – has also reportedly provided US$600 million to partially finance conglomerate Jubilant Bhartia Group's purchase of a 40 per cent stake in Coca-Cola's Indian bottling unit. Another reason investors are showing more interest in Apac is the higher spreads they can get here, compared to the competitive and mature markets in the West, said Chng. 'Because it's so ultra competitive, the spreads are lower than what you get in Asia, and the outperformance of Asian credit is at the top of mind of a lot of Western fund managers … as a fund manager, if you know that you can get 200 basis-point extra spread on the same structure in Asia, you will find a way to get there.' Spread measures the additional yield that investors demand for holding debt with a higher perceived credit risk than a safer bond, such as a government bond or an investment-grade corporate bond Investor interest globally has been rising in private credit, the financing provided by non-bank lenders to companies. That's as returns have beaten those from private equity (PE) in the past three years, and where PE investors are facing challenges in exiting their current investments due to the volatile deal climate. An Apr 29 report by index provider MSCI shows that private credit funds generated 6.9 per cent last year, exceeding the PE funds' return of 5.6 per cent. 2024 marked the third straight year of outperformance. For Apac, the returns could be in the range of mid-to-high-teens per cent, said Chng. More family offices getting invested Within Asia itself, more family offices are allocating funds to private credit, as their liquidity needs and investment horizon are aligning closer to those of institutional investors. 'Family offices are now coming into private credit space in a big way, because they have similar needs to the institutional investors,' said Serene Chen, Asia-Pacific head of credit, currency and emerging market sales, and head of Singapore institutional sales at JPMorgan Chase. While family offices comprise less than 10 per cent of the Asian investor base in private credit, interest is growing, Chen said. JPMorgan has also seen increased participation in private credit from Asian institutions, across local sponsors, insurance and pension funds, she added. With the increased interest, market players said private credit managers have no problems securing capital in Apac. These include Ares, which is raising another Asia special situations fund to boost its credit investments in the region. It's reportedly targeting a size no smaller than its previous fund, which hit about US$2.4 billion in 2023. On Jun 12, Chicago-headquartered investment manager Nuveen announced the second close of its Australian commercial property debt fund, raising more than A$650 million. Last month, Singapore-headquartered Granite Asia said it secured over US$250 million from anchor investors for its first private credit fund. Active fund-raising Market players noted that raising capital isn't an issue, especially as lower returns and the challenging exit environment for PE investments are leading investors to turn to private credit. Some note that, with investors still preferring to steer clear of China – traditionally the biggest private credit market in Asia – the danger is borrowers may have the upper hand. With a 'deep pool of capital chasing' limited pool of borrowers, some private credit fund managers could be tempted to impose less stringent terms to ensure deployment, said State Street's Chng. Clifford Chance's Langhorne said it's not a clear-cut case that a deep capital pool would improve the bargaining position of borrowers. Citing the Sharpooji Pallonji deal signed last month, he said: 'Demand was high and they were able to borrow a substantial amount in one transaction. However, given they are unlikely to be able to raise the same amounts of capital from traditional capital providers, the trade-off for the borrower involves meeting the returns the private credit funds seek, as well as accommodating the structure and protections required to deploy the funds.' The loan tenor for that transaction is three years, with the yield on the zero-coupon bond hitting as high as 19.75 per cent. 'There is a lot of capital available for deployment, but that does not mean that capital providers are just throwing money at the borrowers seeking capital. The investment still has to meet their expected returns and risk expectations,' said Langhorne.
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
Investors brace for oil price spike, rush to havens after US bombs Iran nuclear sites
A U.S. attack on Iranian nuclear sites could lead to a knee-jerk reaction in global markets when they reopen, sending oil prices higher and triggering a rush to safety, investors said, as they assessed how the latest escalation of tensions would ripple through the global economy. The attack, which was announced by President Donald Trump on social media site Truth Social, deepens U.S. involvement in the Middle East conflict. That was the question going into the weekend, when investors were mulling a host of different market scenarios. In the immediate aftermath of the announcement, they expected the U.S. involvement was likely to cause a selloff in equities and a possible bid for the dollar and other safe-haven assets when trading begins, but also said much uncertainty about the course of the conflict remained. Trump called the attack 'a spectacular military success' in a televised address to the nation and said Iran's 'key nuclear enrichment facilities have been completely and totally obliterated'. He said the U.S. military could go after other targets in Iran if the country did not agree to peace. 'I think the markets are going to be initially alarmed, and I think oil will open higher,' said Mark Spindel, chief investment officer at Potomac River Capital. 'We don't have any damage assessment and that will take some time. Even though he has described this as 'done', we're engaged. What comes next?' Spindel said. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up 'I think the uncertainty is going to blanket the markets, as now Americans everywhere are going to be exposed. It's going to raise uncertainty and volatility, particularly in oil,' he added. Spindel, however, said there was time to digest the news before markets open and said he was making arrangements to talk to other market participants. Oil prices, inflation A key concern for markets would center around the potential impact of the developments in the Middle East on oil prices and thus on inflation. A rise in inflation could dampen consumer confidence and lessen the chance of near-term interest rate cuts. 'This adds a complicated new layer of risk that we'll have to consider and pay attention to,' said Jack Ablin, chief investment officer of Cresset Capital. 'This is definitely going to have an impact on energy prices and potentially on inflation as well.' While global benchmark Brent crude futures have risen as much as 18% since June 10, hitting a near five-month high of $79.04 on Thursday, the S&P 500 has been little changed, following an initial drop when Israel launched its attacks on Iran on June 13. Before the U.S. attack on Saturday, analysts at Oxford Economics modeled three scenarios, including a de-escalation of the conflict, a complete shutdown in Iranian oil production and a closure of the Strait of Hormuz, 'each with increasingly large impacts on global oil prices.' In the most severe case, global oil prices jump to around $130 per barrel, driving U.S. inflation near 6% by the end of this year, Oxford said in the note. 'Although the price shock inevitably dampens consumer spending because of the hit to real incomes, the scale of the rise in inflation and concerns about the potential for second-round inflation effects likely ruin any chance of rate cuts in the U.S. this year,' Oxford said in the note, which was published before the U.S. strikes. In comments after the announcement on Saturday, Jamie Cox, managing partner at Harris Financial Group, agreed oil prices would likely spike on the initial news. But Cox said he expected prices to likely level in a few days as the attacks could lead Iran to seek a peace deal with Israel and the United States. 'With this demonstration of force and total annihilation of its nuclear capabilities, they've lost all of their leverage and will likely hit the escape button to a peace deal,' Cox said. Economists warn that a dramatic rise in oil prices could damage a global economy already strained by Trump's tariffs. Still, any pullback in equities might be fleeting, history suggests. During past prominent instances of Middle East tensions coming to a boil, including the 2003 Iraq invasion and the 2019 attacks on Saudi oil facilities, stocks initially languished but soon recovered to trade higher in the months ahead. On average, the S&P 500 slipped 0.3% in the three weeks following the start of conflict, but was 2.3% higher on average two months following the conflict, according to data from Wedbush Securities and CapIQ Pro. Dollar woes An escalation in the conflict could have mixed implications for the U.S. dollar, which has tumbled this year amid worries over diminished U.S. exceptionalism. In the event of U.S. direct engagement in the Iran-Israel war, the dollar could initially benefit from a safety bid, analysts said. 'Do we see a flight to safety? That would signal yields going lower and the dollar getting stronger,' said Steve Sosnick, chief market strategist at IBKR in Greenwich, Connecticut. 'It's hard to imagine stocks not reacting negatively and the question is how much. It will depend on Iranian reaction and whether oil prices spike.'
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
US B-2 bombers, bunker-busters and alternatives: How US strikes Iran's nuclear sites
The US B-2 costs about US$2.1 billion (S$2.7 billion) each, making it the most expensive military aircraft ever built. PHOTO: REUTERS US B-2 bombers, bunker-busters and alternatives: How US strikes Iran's nuclear sites WASHINGTON - The US Air Force's B-2 Spirit stealth bombers were involved in strikes on Iran's nuclear sites on June 21 . Three Iranian nuclear sites were struck in a 'very successful attack', President Donald Trump said on June 21 , adding that the crown jewel of Tehran's nuclear programme, Fordow, is gone. The B-2 is one of America's most advanced strategic weapons platforms, capable of entering sophisticated air defences and delivering precision strikes against hardened targets such as Iran's buried network of nuclear research facilities. B-2 spirit specifications: The US B-2 costs about US$2.1 billion (S$2.7 billion ) each, making it the most expensive military aircraft ever built. Made by Northrop Grumman, the bomber, with its cutting-edge stealth technology, began its production run in the late 1980s but was curbed by the fall of the Soviet Union. Only 21 were made after the Pentagon's planned acquisition programme was truncated. The bomber's range of over 11,112km without refueling enables global strike capabilities from continental US bases. With aerial refuelling, the B-2 can reach virtually any target worldwide, as demonstrated in missions from Missouri to Afghanistan and Libya and now Iran. Its payload capacity of more than 18,144 kg allows the aircraft to carry a diverse array of conventional and nuclear weapons. The bomber's internal weapons bays are specifically designed to maintain stealth characteristics while accommodating large ordnance loads which could include two GBU-57A/B MOP (Massive Ordnance Penetrator), a 13,607kg precision-guided 'bunker buster' bomb. Reports said six bunker buster bombs were used on Iran's Fordow research site. The B-2's two-pilot crew configuration reduces personnel requirements while maintaining operational effectiveness through advanced automation systems. The B-2's stealth technology incorporates radar-absorbing materials and angular design features that minimise detection by enemy air defence systems. Its radar cross-section is reportedly comparable to that of a small bird, making it nearly invisible to conventional radar. Massive ordnance penetrator (MOP): The 13,607kg MOP represents the largest conventional bomb in the US arsenal, specifically engineered to defeat hardened underground bunkers. Its massive size requires the B-2 to carry only one or two MOPs per mission, but provides unmatched bunker-penetration capability. The weapon's 6.25m length and GPS-guided precision targeting system enable accurate strikes against specific underground facilities. Its penetration capability of over 61m through hardened concrete makes it effective against the world's most protected underground installations. Conventional payloads: Joint Direct Attack Munitions provide the B-2 with precision conventional strike capability against fixed targets. These GPS-guided weapons can be deployed in large numbers, with the bomber capable of simultaneously engaging multiple targets with high accuracy. Joint Standoff Weapons extend the aircraft's engagement range while maintaining stealth characteristics during approach. These glide bombs allow the B-2 to strike targets from outside heavily defended airspace perimeters. Joint Air-to-Surface Standoff Missiles offer long-range precision strike capability with their own stealth features. The extended-range JASSM-ER variant provides strike options against targets over 805km away. Nuclear payload capabilities: The B-2 Spirit serves as a key component of America's nuclear triad, capable of delivering strategic nuclear weapons with stealth and precision. The aircraft can carry up to 16 B83 nuclear bombs. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
