
Freedom without privacy is no freedom at all
From Mahathir Rais
A culture that glorifies invading privacy is not progress. It is decay masquerading as vigilance. Social media was created to connect us, yet it has bred a culture where people's personal data, private income, private lives, and even personal choices are treated as public property.
Today, we face the real consequences of this shift. It is no longer rare to see personal information leaked, reputations destroyed overnight, and baseless allegations spread faster than truth can catch up. In the race for attention and influence, the basic human right to privacy has often become the first casualty.
Privacy is not a privilege. It is the foundation of dignity, freedom, and peace of mind. Without it, we invite fear into our daily lives, fear that anything we say, do, or even think can be weaponised against us.
Liberty is hollow without the protection of privacy. In a digital world, safeguarding privacy is not a secondary concern. It is essential for our safety, our stability, and the public's trust in the nation.
Recent incidents have shown how fragile these protections have become. Some social media figures, driven by the pursuit of followers and fame, have weaponised private information, dragging even national institutions into controversy. Content that provokes racial, religious, or royal tensions is not free speech. It is a threat to the foundations of our society.
No individual, no matter how influential, has the right to position themselves as judge and executioner in the court of public opinion. No citizen is entitled to reveal another person's private life as a tool of intimidation. The law must be the line that holds, even when social media storms rage.
The reckless exposure of private lives does more than harm individuals. It erodes social trust, damages Malaysia's reputation globally, and weakens investor and public confidence. True national stability depends as much on respecting individual rights as it does on political governance.
The Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission has made commendable efforts to act when abuses occur. But enforcement alone is not enough. Malaysia's existing Personal Data Protection Act 2010 mainly regulates how businesses handle personal information.
However, it does not fully protect individuals when private data is exposed, leaked, or abused between citizens, especially on social media. What we truly need is a full Privacy Act that criminalises the misuse of private information by any party. Privacy protection must go beyond businesses. It must defend every individual's right to live without fear of being violated or harassed in a digital world.
We urgently need a dedicated Privacy Act that makes it unmistakably clear: violations of personal privacy are serious crimes, and perpetrators will face real and serious consequences.
Those who irresponsibly incite issues involving race, religion, and royalty, or who misuse private information to harass, intimidate, or damage reputations must be held accountable. Stronger enforcement is not about restricting freedom of speech. It is about defending society against the toxic effects of slander, harassment, and misinformation.
Nations that value their people, from Europe to parts of the US, have already moved forward with strong privacy protections. They understand that safeguarding personal dignity strengthens democracy. We must not fall behind.
Communications minister Fahmi Fadzil has proven his dedication to strengthening digital responsibility. Now, that spirit must be translated into a firm legal framework that closes gaps, removes ambiguity, and protects citizens from digital harm.
Freedom without responsibility is not freedom. Openness without respect is not progress. A mature democracy is one where speech is free, but boundaries that protect dignity and truth are firmly upheld.
Protecting privacy is not about silencing voices. It is about ensuring that no one lives in fear of being dragged into public humiliation or harm. Freedom must walk hand in hand with responsibility.
Malaysia must act now. If we move decisively, we can build a safer, healthier digital culture, where dignity is preserved, trust is strengthened, and freedom remains meaningful.
Because when we protect privacy, we are not just defending individuals. We are defending the future of a society worth believing in.
Mahathir Rais is the former secretary of Bersatu and Perikatan Nasional's federal territories chapters.
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Focus Malaysia
11 hours ago
- Focus Malaysia
Govt under fire from opposition, allies over telco data handover demand
THE Malaysian government is facing mounting criticism over an alleged directive requiring all telecommunications companies (telcos) to hand over comprehensive mobile user data, including call records, internet usage, and GPS location history. MCA President Datuk Seri Dr Wee Ka Siong has voiced serious concern over the move, warning that it poses a significant threat to citizens' privacy and could lead to the misuse of personal information. He rejected the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission's (MCMC) claim that the data had been 'de-identified,' arguing that metadata, such as GPS coordinates, call logs, and IP addresses, could still be easily traced back to individuals, especially when cross-referenced with other digital sources. He believed MCMC is trying to downplay the issue by saying, :Don't worry, the data has been de-identified and contains no personal details that can identify individuals.' 'But I want to ask, de-identified, really? Don't try to fool us. If you're collecting data on who we call, when we call, how long we talk, our IP address, and our GPS coordinates, the exact latitude and longitude, time and day, anyone with access to this data can easily match it back to our identities. Especially now, with e-wallets, CCTV, Touch 'n Go, and banking records, it's incredibly easy to pinpoint someone's identity,' he said in a video posted to Facebook on Saturday. From the opposition, Pejuang raised similar concerns. Pejuang information chief, Muhammad Rafique Rashid Ali, criticised the move as unjustified and questioned the true motive behind collecting such intrusive data. 'What exactly does MCMC intend to do with this data? Their excuse is to promote local tourism? But what is the real motive?' he said. 'Not only is this a privacy issue, but there is also the risk of this data being misused or leaked to other parties,' Rafique added. 'MCMC should stop trying to cover up a huge scandal with a tiny sieve,' he said via Facebook on Sunday. Both Pejuang and MCA, despite being on opposing sides of the political spectrum, are united in calling for greater transparency and accountability from the government on this issue. Their joint concern marks a rare moment of bipartisan unity in defending Malaysians' right to privacy and democratic safeguards. —June 8, 2025 Main image: Securiti


The Sun
15 hours ago
- The Sun
MCMC Clarifies Mobile Call Data Request for Policymaking Use
KUALA LUMPUR: The Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission's (MCMC) request for mobile phone call data from telecommunications companies is aimed at supporting evidence-based policymaking, including enhancing network infrastructure, Communications Minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil said. He said the requested data does not include identities or any information that could be used to identify individuals. 'The purpose is to collect data for the official statistics of the Department of Statistics Malaysia (DOSM). It does not contain any personal information but focuses on trends to enable us to gather more detailed information about quality, engagement levels and the number of users in specific mukims (sub-districts) or districts. 'Currently, much of the information about the telecommunications sector remains too general,' he told reporters at the Lembah Pantai UMNO's Perpaduan sacrificial ritual ceremony here today in conjunction with the Aidiladha celebration. He said this new, more detailed approach will enable the government to assess the actual needs of the public and bridge the digital divide more effectively. 'We have also begun shifting from providing general information to focusing on Coverage of Populated Areas (COPA). 'This ensures that the data collected under DOSM will enable more planning and policies based on evidence-based policymaking, bringing greater benefits to the public,' he said. Fahmi said the decision was reached through mutual agreement between telecommunications companies and MCMC, involving agencies such as DOSM in a series of workshops held since 2023. 'Discussions have been ongoing for some time, and there are no issues. In fact, I understand that telecommunications companies will not provide any information containing personal data. 'Only anonymised data, processed as thoroughly as possible by the telecommunications companies themselves, will be provided,' he said. The South China Morning Post reported recently that MCMC had issued a directive requiring telecommunications companies to submit data on all mobile phone calls made from January to March. However, last Friday, MCMC clarified in a statement that the requested data does not include identities or any information that could be used to identify individuals.


The Sun
15 hours ago
- The Sun
Telco call data request aims to improve network, not invade privacy
KUALA LUMPUR: The Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission's (MCMC) request for mobile phone call data from telecommunications companies is aimed at supporting evidence-based policymaking, including enhancing network infrastructure, Communications Minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil said. He said the requested data does not include identities or any information that could be used to identify individuals. 'The purpose is to collect data for the official statistics of the Department of Statistics Malaysia (DOSM). It does not contain any personal information but focuses on trends to enable us to gather more detailed information about quality, engagement levels and the number of users in specific mukims (sub-districts) or districts. 'Currently, much of the information about the telecommunications sector remains too general,' he told reporters at the Lembah Pantai UMNO's Perpaduan sacrificial ritual ceremony here today in conjunction with the Aidiladha celebration. He said this new, more detailed approach will enable the government to assess the actual needs of the public and bridge the digital divide more effectively. 'We have also begun shifting from providing general information to focusing on Coverage of Populated Areas (COPA). 'This ensures that the data collected under DOSM will enable more planning and policies based on evidence-based policymaking, bringing greater benefits to the public,' he said. Fahmi said the decision was reached through mutual agreement between telecommunications companies and MCMC, involving agencies such as DOSM in a series of workshops held since 2023. 'Discussions have been ongoing for some time, and there are no issues. In fact, I understand that telecommunications companies will not provide any information containing personal data. 'Only anonymised data, processed as thoroughly as possible by the telecommunications companies themselves, will be provided,' he said. The South China Morning Post reported recently that MCMC had issued a directive requiring telecommunications companies to submit data on all mobile phone calls made from January to March. However, last Friday, MCMC clarified in a statement that the requested data does not include identities or any information that could be used to identify individuals.