Addenbrooke's surgery problems 'brushed under the rug'
Ms Stohr was suspended by the hospital and has not been at work since March 2024, initially for personal reasons.In Ms Stohr's absence, her patients were seen by other doctors who discovered, a letter to the parents from the hospital said, a "higher than expected level of complications".
That led to a smaller-scale review, comparing her surgeries with the work of three other surgeons.While the others had no subpar operations, nine of hers were found to be substandard and one of those was Darcey, from the Cambridgeshire village of Somersham.Stephen, 49, said Darcey has cerebral palsy, is non-verbal and "defied the odds" by surviving a severe viral infection at birth.Ms Stohr performed surgery on Darcey in June 2022 as her hips were dislocating and her legs were becoming different lengths.As Darcey - who had a number of respiratory infections post-surgery - was being weaned out of her cast her family noticed her "foot angle would turn in" and immediately raised concerns.They said they had an "unusual" meeting with Ms Stohr, who did not take X-rays but said that she felt comfortable Darcey's hips were in joint."I did say to [Ms Stohr] 'Why is the leg so inwardly rotated?' and she said, 'Well, that might be me'," Stephen said.Charlotte said the doctor's comment left her "shocked; I didn't know how to react".
When Ms Stohr was off in 2024, a stand-in doctor told the family the surgery outcome was not as expected."You trust these people to do the job they're going to do, to do it well and if there's any problems, you will come and you will deal with it after," Charlotte, 35, said. "There was clearly a problem after but it was just brushed under the rug."There were no checks, it was just you and that surgeon and that was it. "Whilst multiple physios, [and an] occupational therapist said ' we feel there's an issue here, can you review Darcey?' the problem was it never got further than Ms Stohr."
A review found Darcey should have had pelvic osteotomies - where the pelvis is re-shaped - and that there was "poor pre-operative judgement".She now needs further surgery, which Charlotte said was "another lot of risks, another anaesthetic, another huge healing time, a lot of stress on Darcey's body".Stephen said he has been left feeling like he made a "mistake" in having the surgery under Ms Stohr, about whom concerns were raised as early as 2015."What we know now is it didn't just go wrong for Darcey, and I don't understand how it could go wrong so many times without being picked up, and also for so long," he said.
The investigation into Ms Stohr is the second one nationally to involve a paediatric orthopaedic surgeon in the past year. Some cases linked to Yaser Jabbar, a former surgeon at London's Great Ormond Street Hospital, resulted in harm, including lifelong injuries and amputation.Tom Crompton, a consultant children's orthopaedic surgeon at hospitals in the south east and London, has been asked by Addenbrooke's to look at some of the cases there.While unable to comment on the investigation, he said normal practice was for post-surgery complications to be discussed between multi-disciplinary teams.However, complications which become apparent in the longer-term "really would rely on a consultant monitoring their practice, following up the children long term... being aware of what the normal is and reporting if you think your practice was outside that normal range of discussion."
Dr Susan Broster, chief medical officer at Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, which runs Addenbrooke's, said she "fully understands that families feel let down".She said two investigations had been commissioned, including one "into what was known when about the practice of the surgeon and whether there were opportunities to have identified and addressed these issues sooner". "We apologise again to patients, and we want to do everything we can to support them at what we know is a distressing and anxious time," Dr Broster said.Ms Stohr, through her lawyers, did not respond to the BBC's questions about Darcey's case, but has previously said: "I always strive to provide the highest standards of care to all my patients. "I am cooperating fully with the trust investigation and it would not be appropriate to comment further at this time."
Follow Cambridgeshire news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
27 minutes ago
- The Sun
Banishing my belly with £550 fat freeze was so painful I nearly collapsed but was worth it after losing 6cm from waist
AS a roll of frozen fat the colour and shape of an extra large hot dog is forcibly massaged back into my stomach area I think, just for a second, that I may actually pass out. My legs kick in the air as aesthetician Sadaf Jaffari massages and tries to defrost the fat cells in my tummy that she has just frozen to an icy four degrees. 8 8 The aim is that those dead cells will slowly but surely over the following few weeks pass into my bloodstream and be excreted from my body through my lymphatic system. Hey presto, a flat stomach for the first time in over a decade. I was having a slimming tweakment called CoolSculpting. It was the same one that stunning, leggy supermodel Linda Evangelista had – but bits of her body actually ended up FATTER. But after a lot of research, I decided this non-surgical, non-invasive fat reduction treatment really was the one for me. I have always been an 'apple'. My legs and arms are decent, but as I've got older the weight – and fat – has piled on around my middle. Although I'm far too old for a bikini, I did fancy the idea of having a flatter and even slightly toned stomach again, so I could wear some figure-hugging outfits. I've had Botox with celebrity favourite Sadaf for many years. She's a woman I trust and is so experienced with this treatment that she has been dubbed the 'CoolSculpting Queen'. Inside the horrifying High St beauty firm butchering patients in dirty rooms with dodgy liposuction, fillers and BBLs At her clinic in London's Chelsea, she explained how the body-contouring and fat-reduction treatment has changed since supermodel Linda had it. Three years ago, one of the most photographed women in the world revealed that she had been left 'permanently deformed' and 'brutally disfigured' from the fat freezing procedure. She suffered paradoxical adipose hyperplasia (PAH), a rare side effect where fat cells expand instead of shrinking. Linda had 'full-body liposuction' procedures in 2016 and 2017 to try and remove the hardened fat. So you would think I was nuts to even attempt to have this. But Sadaf explained how there was a new newly designed machine which provides better skin contact and more effective cooling. There is still a risk of PAH, but it's minimal. My hour-long session cost £550 and kicked off with a rather embarrassing photo shoot. I had to strip to my undies and stand sideways as her assistant snapped pics of my bulging tummy. 8 8 Instinctively, I wanted to suck it all in, but that would have defeated the whole point. Sadaf then soothingly agreed that I was a great candidate. Which meant, in polite terms, I had plenty of pinchable fat. I lay back on a bed in her clinic and she drew around an area of my muffin top before spreading over a heavy gauze with a thick jelly texture. Then she grabbed the CoolSculpting 'head', which was a 30cm long and 10cm wide contraption attached to a large machine by a tube. She laid the head on top of the gauze pad. And that's when the fun really started. The machine began to make sucking and gulping noises as it suctioned my fat up and away into the gadget – and started to freeze it. I sensed an intense cooling sensation for around two minutes, which might not sound very long, but it felt strange. And for the first time I started to wonder what on earth I was actually doing there. 'Just give it a couple of minutes,' Sadaf assured me. 'And then you won't feel a thing.' She was right of course, all of a sudden everything went completely numb. If I am honest, it was all quite pleasant. I just lay there, scrolling on my phone. I FaceTimed a friend, did a bit of work and happily daydreamed of my new toned and honed physique. But the relaxed vibes were short-lived. Half an hour later, she was back to start the hideously intense massage. Sadaf is petite – tiny in fact – but she is stronger than she looks and defrosting the crystals is agony. The relaxed vibes were short-lived. Half an hour later, she was back to start the hideously intense massage 'This is the most important bit,' she said. 'This is how you get the best results.' But I was warned to be patient. I had to wait several weeks before I started to notice those eagerly anticipated results. And in the meantime I had to be brave and learn to deal with the strangest of sensations. First off, the area felt entirely numb. 8 8 Because the device freezes fat, the nerves under the skin also get a chilling blast and it takes a while for them to come back to life. It looked bloated and swollen, but if I touched it, flicked it or squeezed it as hard as I could, I felt nothing. Absolutely no sensation at all. Zilch. And I was fine with that. But then, after about ten days, the itching started to creep in. And boy did it itch. Imagine an army of angry ants crawling slowly but surely all over your torso. After speaking to Sadaf, she suggested taking antihistamines. The itching is often a result of the body's inflammatory response to the fat cell damage. As I am prone to an allergy or two, I had plenty of tablets at my disposal. After taking them for a couple of days, the itching subsided. On the upside, at least I knew that the weirdness meant it was working. Unlike the surgical procedure liposuction, that removes fat through a suction technique, the results aren't immediate or dramatic. CoolSculpting is a non-surgical, non-invasive treatment and it can take months for results to show. SMOOTHER STOMACH But now, ten weeks later, I can definitely see some. The whole area around my stomach is smoother and less flabby. You can visibly see that there is less fat there. I recently went on holiday and could wear a tight dress without having a bulging gut. I even asked The Geordie – my husband, who is a man of few compliments – if it looked any flatter and he agreed it did. Result! And the tape measure even shows results too. At a recent health check up I discovered that I've lost 6cm off my waist in the past year. And I know there's zero chance of that being down to sit ups or knocking Sauvignon Blanc on the head! I am planning to have another round of CoolSculpting – when I have saved up for it, because it does cost £550 a go – as there is no limit to the number of treatments you can have. You just need to wait for a couple of months in between them. Obviously the quicker route to achieve fat melting is the surgical one, but the risks and costs are so much higher and CoolSculpting really is something you can have during your lunchtime. So – unless you want to tell the world about it, as I have just done – it can be your own little secret.
Daily Mail
36 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Startling discovery about The Pill and cancer that's rising in young people
Thousands of women who take the Pill are not at higher risk of potentially deadly liver cancer, research today suggested. Studies have long suggested there may be a link between the combined oral contraceptive pill and the risk of developing tumours in the liver. This is because the birth control pill contains the hormone oestrogen, which scientists believe can stimulate some cancer cells to grow. But now, in one of the largest studies to date involving more than 1.5million British women, researchers discovered there was 'little to no association' between taking the Pill and liver cancer. Experts, who said the study was the 'most comprehensive to date', concluded there was 'no overall link'. Liver cancer now kills 5,800 people in the UK each year compared with 2,200 in the late 1990s, making it the UKs fastest rising killer and responsible for double the deaths of skin cancer. It's currently the eighth most common cause of cancer death in the UK, but by 2040, the charity warns that it could rank sixth. Cancer Research UK figures also suggest rates of the disease have increased by 86 per cent among 25-to-49-year-olds since the 1990s. In the study, researchers analysed data from 23 previous studies as well as the UK biobank health study involving over a million women. They compared women who had ever used a birth control pill with those who never used them and found there were 5,400 liver cancer cases logged across all studies. Writing in the journal The Lancet Oncology, the researchers said there was 'no association with liver cancer risk'. However, they added, there was 'weak evidence that women who used the birth control pill for longer periods had a very slight increased risk of liver cancer (6 per cent) per 5 years of use.' This they said, was likely to due to unmeasured factors such as patients who had Hepatitis B or C infection—a major risk factor for liver cancer. Around one in four liver cancer cases in the UK are also caused by obesity, while a fifth are related to smoking, and one in 14 are due to excessive alcohol, research shows. Latest NHS figures for suggest there were almost 3million prescriptions for the combined pill and more than 4million for the mini pill, which just contains progestogen. Around a quarter of all women aged 15 to 49 are on either the combined or progesterone only pill. The proportion of women taking oral contraceptives has fallen by more than two-thirds, from 420,600 in 2012/13 to 126,400 in 2022/23, according to the NHS data. Around 555,400 women turned to the health service's sexual and reproductive health services in 2022/23 — equivalent to four per cent of 13 to 54-year-olds Taken every day, it works by stopping the ovaries releasing an egg each month. It also thickens the cervical mucus and thinning the womb lining to stop sperm reaching an egg, and attaching itself in the womb. It is over 99 per cent effective with perfect use but if used incorrectly—such as missing a pill or experiencing nausea and diarrhoea while on it—around one in ten women (9 per cent) may get pregnant. Known side effects of the Pill include nausea, breast tenderness, mood swings and headaches. Others claim they pile on pounds while taking the because of increased fluid retention and appetite, yet the NHS says there is no evidence it leads to weight gain. Decades of research has failed to provide any conclusive evidence that this supposed side effect is real. However, rarer side effects include blood clots and a slightly heightened risk of breast and cervical cancer.
BBC News
39 minutes ago
- BBC News
Starmer outlines six-day a week neighbourhood health hub plan after backing Reeves
Update: Date: 07:19 BST Title: Reeves doing excellent job, PM tells BBC after Commons tears Content: The prime minister has backed Rachel Reeves to stay on as chancellor for "many years to come" after she was seen crying during PMQs. In the Commons, Starmer didn't say whether Reeves would still be in her job at the next election. But later, speaking to BBC Radio 4's Political Thinking with Nick Robinson, Starmer said he worked "in lockstep" with Reeves and that she was "doing an excellent job as chancellor". He also insisted her tearful appearance had "nothing to do with politics". You can watch a clip of the conversation below. This video can not be played Reeves will be chancellor 'for a very long time to come', says Starmer Update: Date: 07:06 BST Title: 'Deeply upsetting' to see chancellor in tears - shadow minister Content: The NHS reform plan set to be announced today comes after yesterday's PMQs, where Chancellor Rachel Reeves was seen in tears. Shadow chancellor Mel Stride tells BBC Breakfast he sent Reeves a message yesterday 'just to say I hope that she was all right'. 'I felt for her,' he says. He adds it was 'deeply upsetting to see', especially as it was 'such a public moment'. 'We are all human beings at the end of the day - politicians are human beings - they do have feelings,' he says. But on the business side, he says the welfare U-turn shows the government 'is not gripping things', and adds the bond markets 'are quite twitchy'. Update: Date: 06:53 BST Title: 'It's reform or die' for the NHS, says Starmer Content: Keir Starmer during a visit to the Elective Orthopaedic Centre at Epsom Hospital in January In comments released overnight, Keir Starmer says the health system the government has inherited is "in crisis". "That ends now," he says. "Because it's reform or die. "Our 10 Year Health Plan will fundamentally rewire and future-proof our NHS so that it puts care on people's doorsteps, harnesses game-changing tech and prevents illness in the first place." This means, Starmer says, giving everyone access to GPs, nurses and wider support all under one roof in their neighbourhood, and "rebalancing our health system so that it fits around patients' lives, not the other way round". He says it's not an overnight fix, but the government is already "turning the tide on years of decline", with four million extra NHS appointments, 1,900 more GPs and waiting lists at their lowest level for two years. "But there's more to come. This government is giving patients easier, quicker and more convenient care, wherever they live." Update: Date: 06:45 BST Title: What will the 'Neighbourhood Health Service' look like? Content: Keir Starmer says today's plan will "fundamentally rewire" the NHS in England, with a focus on three areas: moving from treatment to prevention, analogue to digital, and hospital to more community care. What does that mean in practice? Update: Date: 06:43 BST Title: Starmer sets out 10-year NHS plan amid 'tough' few days for Labour Content: This video can not be played Watch: Starmer says past few days have 'been tough' Prime Minister Keir Starmer is today setting out a 10-year plan for the NHS in England, aiming to move the health service towards prevention and community care, as well as digitalising it. The prime minister says his NHS plan will "fundamentally rewire" the service, with the aim that by 2035 most outpatient care - including eye care, cardiology and mental health - will happen outside hospitals. But while the government is selling the "Neighbourhood Health Service" as a major overhaul, others are asking how soon people will see a difference - and exactly how, and if, it will work. Today's announcement follows Starmer giving his "full backing" to Chancellor Rachel Reeves after her tearful appearance in the Commons yesterday. The last few days have been "tough" for Starmer's government, the PM said, after a major climbdown over welfare changes left a hole in Labour's spending plans. Speaking to Nick Robinson, Starmer admitted he "did not engage" properly with Labour MPs on the issue, and praised Reeves for "doing an excellent job as chancellor". We'll bring you all the latest updates, analysis and reaction to all of the above throughout the day. This video can not be played Reeves appears tearful during PMQs
