Explained: China's recent removal of senior military officials, and what these ‘purges' indicate
Miao Hua, who is also a senior admiral in the People's Liberation Army (PLA) Navy, was first suspended pending an investigation in November 2024. At the time, the charges against him were officially termed 'serious violations of discipline', which is terminology used for corruption cases.
Another senior military official, Vice Admiral Li Hanjun, was also stripped of his legislative credentials on June 27. He was the chief of staff of the PLA Navy and its third-ranking officer.
In recent years, two Ministers of Defence, one Minister of Foreign Affairs and several other key figures in the Chinese state have been purged, with corruption often cited as the reason. What differentiates the latest removals is the seniority of the officials and the fact that they are from the all-important military establishment.
'The PLA is the Communist Party's army. It is not to the state or the People's Republic of China that the PLA owes its primary allegiance. Its main task is to help the party remain in power. The party commands the gun, and the CMC is the party's highest military leadership body,' said Jabin Jacob, Associate Professor at the Department of International Relations and Governance Studies at Shiv Nadar University, Greater Noida.
Who are the officials in question?
Miao, 69, headed the Political Work department of the CMC, tasked with political education and personnel management. 'Miao Hua is the biggest fish in the past two to three years of investigations and subsequent purges,' said Anushka Saxena, a researcher focusing on the PLA at the Bengaluru-based think tank Takshashila Institute.
On the other hand, Li, 60, was rumoured to be under investigation since March, and has not been seen publicly since then. Such 'disappearances' in China often indicate that all is not well and that an official may face an inquiry. Analysts closely monitor the visibility of leaders because, officially, little about them is ever confirmed.
The CMC decides on a range of defence matters, including weapons procurement, military priorities, and combat preparedness. The seven-member body is headed by a Chairman, two Vice-Chairmen and four members. Members represent a few of the various CMC departments, such as discipline inspection and political work (which Miao headed).
'Xi Jinping's position as CMC Chairman is his second most important position in the Chinese political system after the position of General Secretary of the Communist Party of China, and more important than his position as Chinese president,' Jacob said. The CMC also ranks higher than the Defence Ministry. 'This is why in the wake of the 2020 Galwan standoff, the then Indian ambassador to China, Vikram Misri, also met with CMC officials,' he added.
The Defence Minister is generally a part of the CMC. However, after the previous minister, Li Shangfu, was dismissed from the party in June 2024 (also for corruption charges), his successor, Dong Jun, has not been made a CMC member. This suggests a 'further decline in the status of the Ministry of Defence'.
Such is its significance to the Chinese state that when power was being transferred from party leader Deng Xiaoping, who initiated China's economic liberalisation in 1978, he initially refused to let go of the CMC leadership. 'He believed that ultimately, being President of China or the General Secretary of the Chinese Communist Party doesn't matter because by being the CMC Chairman, you have the army at your command,' Saxena said.
Even though some committees vet candidates, protegé networks or client-patron networks within the party play an important role in CMC appointments, she added.
Why is corruption often cited behind these purges?
Corruption has been a matter of concern in China over the decades. Shortly after assuming power in 2013, Xi Jinping unleashed a massive anti-corruption campaign.
Jacob said, 'In the multi-phase anti-corruption campaign, the focus has shifted from the political and legal apparatus to the military to the financial sector, but all groups continue to be targeted.'
As for the PLA, 'Corruption is certainly a serious issue, but it is entirely logical that corruption should occur since the PLA has seen a rapid growth phase for several decades now. It is modernising with the acquisition of new weapons and platforms, and the launch of new projects to achieve cutting-edge and asymmetric advantages over its adversaries. More qualified personnel are being inducted to meet its future combat requirements — both in conventional domains and new areas of warfare such as cyberspace or drone warfare.'
He added that significant sums of money and serious responsibilities are at play, with great power accorded to individuals and institutions. Thus, while tackling corruption might help Xi consolidate power in some instances, it is not the only driving motive behind the purges.
Saxena also said that if corruption were only a front, it would not be prudent for Xi to remove his loyalists, such as former Minister of Defence Li Shangfu or Foreign Affairs Minister Qin Gang. Neither was expected to rise so far up the ranks relatively quickly, but were elevated as they enjoyed Xi's support.
Further, various party factions — based on common regional backgrounds or closeness to senior leaders — compete for power. 'When this sub-leadership-level factionalism happens, each faction will try to reveal skeletons in the other person's closet. Once out in the open, Xi can sometimes have no other option but to take action. A key reason he is in power today is that he told party elders he would root out corruption from the party,' she said.
What does this mean, ultimately?
High-level purges imply an element of instability and inefficiency in the system. However, for Xi, it also shows his ability and power to remove officials as quickly as he appointed them.
'Xi demands not just loyalty but also honesty to go with efficiency and progress. Such culling at the top might indicate a deep-rooted malaise within the system, but it also signals to the public that their supreme leader is serious about improving it. Simultaneously, lower-ranked officials get the message that there exists a path to promotion based on both loyalty to the party and following party discipline,' Jacob said.
In a non-democratic setup, what may be the incentive for a leader to display no tolerance for corruption? Saxena said it has to do with a sense of political insecurity as well: 'From Beijing's perspective, China is in a very precarious position right now, be it the domestic economic concerns, Taiwan, or the economic and political state of the world. At this stage, it cannot afford to have an inefficient bureaucracy or military. Say Li Shangfu's corruption-related purge was because, when he was head of the equipment development department, he rigged the bidding process and got a cut. What happens if an inferior quality system is used in battle and fails?'
Well-functioning defence, political and economic systems will also help ensure the longevity of China's unique one-party state structure. Just last Tuesday, the party marked its 104th anniversary, saying its current membership stands at more than 100 million members, making it one of the biggest political parties in the world.
Rishika Singh is a Senior sub-editor at the Explained Desk of The Indian Express. She enjoys writing on issues related to international relations, and in particular, likes to follow analyses of news from China. Additionally, she writes on developments related to politics and culture in India.
... Read More
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
10 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Eminent economist, House of Lords member Meghnad Desai passes away at 85
Eminent India-born British economist, former Labour party politician, and House of Lords member Meghnad Desai passed away on Tuesday. He was 85. A prominent and well-regarded voice in economics in the UK, India, and beyond, Desai was a widely respected academic who wrote over 200 articles published in academic journals and authored over 25 books. A Professor Emeritus of the London School of Economics (LSE), where he had a long and distinguished career, Desai also wrote scores of columns in newspapers in the UK and India, including in The Indian Express. In 2008, he was awarded India's third-highest civilian honour—the Padma Bhushan. Although a celebrated economist, Desai's writings and commentary spanned varied subjects—economics, politics, political and social economy, history, sociology, international affairs, and even cinema. In fact, Desai reportedly counted his biography of the legendary actor Dilip Kumar—Nehru's Hero: Dilip Kumar in the life of India—as his 'greatest achievement'. Desai was an avid watcher of old Hindi films, and also had a passion for cooking. After learning of Desai's passing, Prime Minister Narendra Modi took to social media platform X to express his condolences. 'Anguished by the passing away of Shri Meghnad Desai Ji, a distinguished thinker, writer and economist. He always remained connected to India and Indian culture. He also played a role in deepening India-UK ties. Will fondly recall our discussions, where he shared his valuable insights. Condolences to his family and friends. Om Shanti,' Modi posted on X. Sanjeev Sanyal, Member of Prime Minister Economic Advisory Council, wrote on X, 'Very sorry to hear that eminent economist Meghnad Desai has passed away. I had known him for over two decades. He was always cheerful and open to new ideas. I will cherish the many long discussions and debates that we had over the years. Om Shanti.' Born on July 10, 1940 in Vadodara to Jagdish Chandra, a civil servant, and Mandakini Desai a homemaker, Desai grew up with three siblings. He earned his BA in 1958 and MA in economics in 1960 from the University of Bombay, after which he bagged a scholarship to the University of Pennsylvania, where he completed his PhD in Economics in 1963. Desai, also well-known as Lord Desai due to his membership of the upper house of the British parliament, taught economics from 1965 to 2003 at the LSE. He was appointed as a lecturer at the LSE in 1965, and became a Professor of Economics there in 1983. Desai went on to head LSE's Development Studies Institute from 1990 to 1995, and established and led the LSE Centre for the Study of Global Governance. During his time at the LSE, Desai researched and lectured on a variety of subjects—Marxian analysis, applied econometrics, Indian development and reform, poverty, globalisation, and the role of private markets. In 1971, Desai joined the British Labour Party and was elevated to the House of Lords in June 1991. He was Chairman of the Gandhi Memorial Statue Trust which helped erect the statue of Mahatma Gandhi in London's Parliament Square. In 1991, he was created a life peer as Baron Desai St Clement Danes in the City of Westminster. In 2020, Desai resigned as a member of the UK's Opposition Labour Party over its failure to effectively tackle antisemitic racism within its ranks. He authored numerous books, the most recent being The Poverty of Political Economy: How Economics Abandoned the Poor (2022). His other notable books are Marx's Revenge: The Resurgence of Capitalism and the Death of Statist Socialism, Rethinking Islamism: Ideology of the New Terror, The Route to All Evil: The Political Economy of Ezra Pound, a novel Dead on Time, and The Rediscovery of India.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
12 minutes ago
- First Post
US and China in Stockholm talks agree to seek extension of 90-day tariff truce
US officials said it was up to President Donald Trump to decide whether to extend a trade truce that expires on August 12 or potentially let tariffs shoot back up to triple-digit figures read more Advertisement Representational image. AP US and Chinese officials agreed to seek an extension of their 90-day tariff truce on Tuesday, following two days of talks in Stockholm aimed at defusing an escalating trade war between the world's two biggest economies that threatens global growth. No major breakthroughs were announced, and US officials said it was up to President Donald Trump to decide whether to extend a trade truce that expires on August 12 or potentially let tariffs shoot back up to triple-digit figures. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD After months of threatening high tariffs on trading partners, Trump has secured trade deals with the European Union, Japan, and others, but China's powerhouse economy and grip on global rare earth flows make these talks particularly complex. Both sides in May walked back from imposing triple-digit tariffs on each other in what would have amounted to a bilateral trade embargo. But global supply chains and financial markets could face renewed turmoil without an agreement. Trump will have the final say on whether to prolong a truce, U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told reporters. Another 90-day extension is one option, US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer added. 'We'll report back to him the process we had here. We had constructive meetings for sure, to go back with the positive report. But the extension of the pause, he'll decide,' Greer said after talks at Rosenbad, the Swedish prime minister's office in central Stockholm. Bessent said there would likely be another meeting between US and Chinese officials in about 90 days, and the agreements on the flow of Chinese rare earths were becoming more refined after previous talks in Geneva and London. 'There was good personal interaction being built up, good, mutual respect. I think we understand their agenda much better,' he said. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Underlining the stakes, the International Monetary Fund on Tuesday raised its global growth forecast but flagged a potential rebound in tariff rates as a major risk. China's top trade negotiator Li Chenggang said both sides fully recognized the importance of maintaining a stable and sound economic and trade relationship. 'The Chinese and U.S. economic and trade teams will maintain active communication, exchange views on economic and trade issues in a timely manner, and continue to promote the stable and healthy development of bilateral economic and trade relations,' said Li. The talks could pave the way for a meeting between Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping later in the year, though Trump denied going out of his way to seek one and U.S. officials said the topic was not discussed. The Stockholm meetings also included a lengthy discussion on the U.S. and Chinese economies, with Greer and Bessent emphasizing the need for China to shift away from a state-led, export-driven manufacturing economy to one powered by increased consumer demand, which would help U.S. exports. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD China vs. EU talks The Stockholm talks follow Trump's biggest trade deal yet with the European Union on Sunday for a 15% tariff on most EU goods exports to the United States, and a deal with Japan. That agreement has brought a measure of relief to the EU but also frustration and anger, with France denouncing the deal as a 'submission' and Germany, Europe's largest economy, warning of 'significant' damage. China can exercise a degree of leverage with its grip on the global market for rare earths and magnets, used in everything from military hardware to car windshield wiper motors, analysts say. Unlike the EU, it does not rely on the United States for security ties and can let trade talks play out for several more months, Cyrus de la Rubia, chief economist at Hamburg Commercial Bank, told Reuters. 'China is well aware of its strong negotiating position, as could clearly be seen in the temporary escalation observed in April,' he said. 'But over Europe always hangs the Damocles sword of the U.S. withdrawing its security guarantee, and that is why the EU did not escalate the situation like China did.' Previous U.S.-China trade talks in Geneva and London in May and June focused on bringing U.S. and Chinese retaliatory tariffs down from triple-digit levels and restoring the flow of rare earth minerals halted by China and Nvidia's H20 AI chips, and other goods halted by the United States. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Among broader economic issues, Washington complains that China's state-led, export-driven model is flooding world markets with cheap goods, while Beijing says U.S. national security export controls on tech goods seek to stunt Chinese growth. Separately, China's industry minister on Tuesday met with a delegation of U.S. businesses, including Apple, in Beijing, and pledged to uphold fair and open market competition and provide support and services for foreign enterprises.
Time of India
12 minutes ago
- Time of India
From Busting Trump's Ceasefire Claim To Bursting Cong's Pak 'Sympathy'- PM Modi's Full Speech in LS
In a thunderous rebuttal in Parliament, PM Modi finally broke his silence on Donald Trump's ceasefire claims during Operation Sindoor. Modi made it clear that no world leader, not even the US President, told India to stop. He revealed that when the US Vice President tried to warn him about a Pakistani retaliation, he didn't even take the call immediately, because he was in a war room with Indian military commanders. Modi also hit back at the Congress party, accusing them of importing Pakistan's narratives, questioning the armed forces, and undermining India's victory. He called Operation Sindoor India's boldest strike, crippling terror HQs deep inside Pakistan, proving that nuclear threats and blackmail no longer work against India. From airbases in ICU to terror masterminds losing sleep, Modi said Pakistan begged for mercy. Watch the full breakdown of the biggest military and political expose from PM Modi.
