Banning Palestine Action an 'abuse of power', High Court told
The ban means that membership of, or support for, the direct action group is now a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison.
On July 4, Ammori failed in a High Court bid to temporarily block the ban coming into effect, with the Court of Appeal dismissing a challenge over that decision less than two hours before the proscription came into force on July 5.
The case returned to the High Court in London on Monday, where lawyers for Ammori asked a judge to grant the green light for a full legal challenge against the decision to ban the group, saying it was an 'unlawful interference' with freedom of expression.
Raza Husain KC said: 'We say the proscription of Palestine Action is repugnant to the tradition of the common law and contrary to the [European Convention on Human Rights].'
The barrister continued: 'The decision is so extreme as to render the UK an international outlier.'
Husain added: 'The decision to proscribe Palestine Action had the hallmarks of an authoritarian and blatant abuse of power.'
'The consequences are not just limited to arrest,' Husain later said, telling the court there was 'rampant uncertainty' in the aftermath of the ban.
Blinne Ni Ghralaigh KC, also for Ammori, later said: 'The impacts [of proscription] have already been significant.'
She continued: 'Dozens and dozens of people have been arrested for protesting, seated and mostly silent protest.'
The barrister later told the court that Merseyside Police had bailed arrested protesters with a condition not to mention Palestine.
'People have been bailed to not mention Palestine?' Justice Chamberlain asked, with Ms Ni Ghralaigh replying: 'It is a condition of bail that they do not mention Palestine.'
'The Secretary of State has not distanced herself from any of these actions,' she continued, adding that Cooper had not described actions like this as an 'overreach'.
The Home Office is defending the legal challenge.
READ MORE: Three men arrested under Terrorism Act after national Palestine demo in Edinburgh
Previously, Ben Watson, for the Home Office, said Palestine Action could challenge the Home Secretary's decision at the Proscribed Organisations Appeal Commission (POAC), a specialist tribunal, rather than at the High Court.
James Eadie, representing the department on Monday, said that an 'exceptional case' would be needed for it to go to the High Court, rather than the POAC.
He said: 'Judicial review is, and has been accepted to be, a remedy of last resort and that is for very good and well-established reasons.'
However, Husain told the court on Monday morning that the POAC was not 'convenient nor effective' in this case.
He continued: 'It would be quite absurd to say that we should tolerate the consequences of the proscription […] even if it is unlawful, and just go to POAC.
'That is an absurd position.'
In written submissions, Eadie (above) said that by causing serious damage to property, Palestine Action was 'squarely' within part of the terrorism laws used in proscription.
He said: 'There is no credible basis on which it can be asserted that the purpose of this activity is not designed to influence the government, or to intimidate the public or a section of the public, and for the purpose of advancing a political, religious, racial or ideological cause.'
Cooper announced plans to proscribe Palestine Action on June 23, stating that the vandalism of the two planes, which police said caused an estimated £7 million of damage, was 'disgraceful'.
More than 100 people were arrested across the country during demonstrations this weekend protesting against the proscription, with protests held in London, Manchester, Edinburgh, Bristol and Truro on Saturday.
Saturday's arrests brought the total number of people arrested since the ban came into force to more than 200, with more than 72 arrested across the UK last weekend and 29 the week before.
The hearing before Justice Chamberlain concluded on Monday, with the judge saying he would give his decision on July 30.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Lorry driver jailed after being on video call moments before horror crash that killed woman
'COMPLETELY AVOIDABLE' Lorry driver jailed after being on video call moments before horror crash that killed woman Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A LORRY driver who caused a fatal crash while on a video call behind the wheel has been jailed. Blair Jardine, 31, caused the horrific collision that claimed the life of a pensioner on the A70 at Ochiltree in East Ayrshire on June 4 2024. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Jardine pled guilty at the High Court in Edinburgh Credit: PA:Press Association The lorry driver was speeding and not paying attention to the road when he didn't notice stationary traffic in front of him. Jardine slammed on his brakes after noticing the stopped vehicles in front of him but it was too late to avoid tragedy. Unable to avoid hitting the car in front of him, he swerved his HGV lorry into the opposite lane and collided head-on with an MG motor. Both occupants of the car, Lyndsay Thomson, 59, and her elderly aunt Sarah Wood, 88, were seriously injured. Firefighters had to cut both women out of the damaged motor and paramedics rushed them to hospital. Tragically, Sarah died from her injuries six days later on June 10 at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Glasgow. Jardine pled guilty to causing death by dangerous driving and causing serious injury by dangerous driving at the High Court in Edinburgh. Prosecutor Alex Prentice KC told the court: 'Ahead of him was a white van which had stopped and was signalling to turn right into a depot. There was a stationary car behind the van. 'Blair Jardine was on a hands-free video call with another person, and he did not pay attention to the road ahead. 'Consequently, he failed to react to the presence of the stationary vehicle, braked sharply, causing the wheels to lock and he was unable to stop in time to avoid a collision with the stationery west bound traffic so he swerved into the opposing carriageway causing a head on collision with Lyndsay Thomson's motor vehicle. Mini tourist train crashes in Brit holiday hotspot with carriage overturned injuring 20 with four in critical condition 'Lyndsay Thomson and Sarah Wood were both severely injured. Sarah later died because of the injuries she sustained.' The advocate depute that doctors treating Sarah found she had 'extensive injury' including fractures to her nose, a rib, a lumbar vertebra and both hands. The court heard that on June 5 2024, Sarah had surgery and suffered a stroke after she came out of the theatre. Mr Prentice said that on June 7 2024 she was transferred to the major trauma unit at the hospital but continued to 'deteriorate rapidly' - she later died at 7.15pm on June 10 2024. Meanwhile, Lyndsay, who was aged 59 at the time of the collision, suffered a head injury, rib, knee, leg and wrist fractures and a broken hip. Jardine was caged for four years and eight months yesterday at the High Court in Edinburgh. Police Scotland Sergeant Gordon Stewart said: 'This was a completely avoidable crash that had devastating consequences for the family and loved ones of both women. "Jardine's actions showed a clear disregard for the safety of others on the road. 'We hope this outcome brings some degree of closure to the families of those involved and serves as a stark reminder of the responsibility every road user to drive in safe manner.'
Daily Record
21 hours ago
- Daily Record
Speeding driver who killed young dad while running late for work is jailed
Euan Davis, 22, has been jailed after he knocked down Stephen McGovern in a fatal crash. A speeding driver who killed a young father has been jailed - as a judge suggested he do charity work in memory of his victim after he was freed. Evan Davis, 22, hit Stephen McGovern while running for late for a shift on July 4 2023. The 21 year-old cafe worker - who may have been crossing for a bus at the time - sadly never survived the collision in Calder Road, Edinburgh. Davis was today sentenced at the High Court in Glasgow. He had earlier admitted at a hearing in the capital to causing Mr McGovern's death by dangerous driving. Lord Arthurson sentenced Davis - who was emotional as he sat in the dock - to three years and nine months in jail. He cut the term from five years due to the guilty plea. Directly addressing Davis about this, Lord Arthurson told him: "I would suggest that you approach the sentence of imprisonment constructively as you can. "Remember at the conclusion you will one day walk out of prison and return to your family. "Remember that Mr McGovern, due to your criminal behaviour, will never do so. "Live your life well and, perhaps, undertake future voluntary work in memory of your victim. "After all that, most importantly, continue to remember Stephen McGovern, his mother, siblings and, above all, his young son." The court previously heard how a van driver had been aware of Davis approaching at speed and then undertaking him and a grey Seat car. This other motorist noticed Mr McGovern meantime jump over a fence in the central reservation. Prosecutor David Dickson then explained: "Davis continued in the nearside lane as the grey Seat began to slow down, the driver of that car being aware of Mr McGovern. "Mr McGovern was observed to run into the road, hesitate and was then struck by the front offside wing of Davis's car." "Mr McGovern was thrown into the air and, on colliding with the road, would have died." The young dad, of Edinburgh, sustained head, chest and neck injuries. Mr Dickson: "While it is not known, it may be Mr McGovern observed a line of traffic, ran out in front of it thinking there were no cars in the nearside lane and that he would be able to cross the road." The advocate depute said calculations showed that Davis would have to have been driving at no more than 36 mph to avoid a collision with Mr McGovern if he saw him when he first stepped onto the road. He had increased the speed of his Toyota Auris from 53 mph to more than 62 mph in the four seconds before hitting Mr McGovern. A visibly distressed Davis, of Bonnyrigg, Midlothian, got out his motor after the incident and called the emergency services. John Scullion KC, defending, today said the incident remains "the first thing he thinks about in the morning" and continues in his thoughts the rest of a day. The advocate: "He is troubled by nightmares and flashbacks. He has considerable empathy for the ongoing pain and suffering (of Mr McGovern's family)." Davis was also banned from the road for five years after his release. Sentencing, Lord Arthurson further told him: "You were driving to Aberdeen in connection with your work and were behind schedule. "You failed to observe your victim, who was a pedestrian. "You were in a hurry, you were running late. Your time was more important to you than the welfare of fellow road users. "As a result, you killed Mr McGovern. You now have to live with that." After his death, Mr McGovern was described online by those who knew him as "a lovely soul" who "lit up the room every time he walked into one". Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
STV News
21 hours ago
- STV News
Speeding driver who killed young father while running late for work jailed
A speeding driver who killed a young father has been jailed for almost four years. Evan Davis, 22, hit Stephen McGovern while running for late for a shift on July 4, 2023. The 21-year-old cafe worker – who may have been crossing for a bus at the time – did not survive the collision on Calder Road, Edinburgh. Davis was sentenced at the High Court in Glasgow on Friday. He had earlier admitted at a hearing to causing Mr McGovern's death by dangerous driving. Lord Arthurson sentenced Davis – who was emotional as he sat in the dock – to three years and nine months in jail. He cut the term from five years due to the guilty plea. The judge referred to Davis's comment he made to police after the collision: 'How am I going to live with this?' Directly addressing him about the comment, Lord Arthurson told Davis: 'I would suggest that you approach the sentence of imprisonment constructively as you can. 'Remember at the conclusion you will one day walk out of prison and return to your family. 'Remember that Mr McGovern, due to your criminal behaviour, will never do so. 'Live your life well and, perhaps, undertake future voluntary work in memory of your victim. 'After all that, most importantly, continue to remember Stephen McGovern, his mother, siblings and, above all, his young son.' The court previously heard how a van driver had been aware of Davis approaching at speed and then undertaking him and a grey Seat car. The other motorist also noticed Mr McGovern jump over a fence in the central reservation. Prosecutor David Dickson then explained: 'Davis continued in the nearside lane as the grey Seat began to slow down, the driver of that car being aware of Mr McGovern. 'Mr McGovern was observed to run into the road, hesitate and was then struck by the front offside wing of Davis's car.' 'Mr McGovern was thrown into the air and, on colliding with the road, would have died.' The young dad, of Edinburgh, sustained head, chest and neck injuries. Mr Dickson said: 'While it is not known, it may be Mr McGovern observed a line of traffic, ran out in front of it thinking there were no cars in the nearside lane and that he would be able to cross the road.' The advocate depute said calculations showed that Davis would have to have been driving at no more than 36 mph to avoid a collision with Mr McGovern if he saw him when he first stepped onto the road. He had increased the speed of his Toyota Auris from 53 mph to more than 62 mph in the four seconds before hitting Mr McGovern. A visibly distressed Davis, of Bonnyrigg, Midlothian, got out his vehicle after the incident and called the emergency services. John Scullion KC, defending, said the incident remains 'the first thing he thinks about in the morning' and continues in his thoughts the rest of a day. The advocate said: 'He is troubled by nightmares and flashbacks. He has considerable empathy for the ongoing pain and suffering (of Mr McGovern's family).' Davis was also banned from the road for five years after his release. Sentencing, Lord Arthurson further told him: 'You were driving to Aberdeen in connection with your work and were behind schedule. 'You failed to observe your victim, who was a pedestrian. 'You were in a hurry, you were running late. Your time was more important to you than the welfare of fellow road users. 'As a result, you killed Mr McGovern. You now have to live with that.' After his death, Mr McGovern was described online by those who knew him as 'a lovely soul' who 'lit up the room every time he walked into one'. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
