Banning Palestine Action an 'abuse of power', High Court told
The ban means that membership of, or support for, the direct action group is now a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison.
On July 4, Ammori failed in a High Court bid to temporarily block the ban coming into effect, with the Court of Appeal dismissing a challenge over that decision less than two hours before the proscription came into force on July 5.
The case returned to the High Court in London on Monday, where lawyers for Ammori asked a judge to grant the green light for a full legal challenge against the decision to ban the group, saying it was an 'unlawful interference' with freedom of expression.
Raza Husain KC said: 'We say the proscription of Palestine Action is repugnant to the tradition of the common law and contrary to the [European Convention on Human Rights].'
The barrister continued: 'The decision is so extreme as to render the UK an international outlier.'
Husain added: 'The decision to proscribe Palestine Action had the hallmarks of an authoritarian and blatant abuse of power.'
'The consequences are not just limited to arrest,' Husain later said, telling the court there was 'rampant uncertainty' in the aftermath of the ban.
Blinne Ni Ghralaigh KC, also for Ammori, later said: 'The impacts [of proscription] have already been significant.'
She continued: 'Dozens and dozens of people have been arrested for protesting, seated and mostly silent protest.'
The barrister later told the court that Merseyside Police had bailed arrested protesters with a condition not to mention Palestine.
'People have been bailed to not mention Palestine?' Justice Chamberlain asked, with Ms Ni Ghralaigh replying: 'It is a condition of bail that they do not mention Palestine.'
'The Secretary of State has not distanced herself from any of these actions,' she continued, adding that Cooper had not described actions like this as an 'overreach'.
The Home Office is defending the legal challenge.
READ MORE: Three men arrested under Terrorism Act after national Palestine demo in Edinburgh
Previously, Ben Watson, for the Home Office, said Palestine Action could challenge the Home Secretary's decision at the Proscribed Organisations Appeal Commission (POAC), a specialist tribunal, rather than at the High Court.
James Eadie, representing the department on Monday, said that an 'exceptional case' would be needed for it to go to the High Court, rather than the POAC.
He said: 'Judicial review is, and has been accepted to be, a remedy of last resort and that is for very good and well-established reasons.'
However, Husain told the court on Monday morning that the POAC was not 'convenient nor effective' in this case.
He continued: 'It would be quite absurd to say that we should tolerate the consequences of the proscription […] even if it is unlawful, and just go to POAC.
'That is an absurd position.'
In written submissions, Eadie (above) said that by causing serious damage to property, Palestine Action was 'squarely' within part of the terrorism laws used in proscription.
He said: 'There is no credible basis on which it can be asserted that the purpose of this activity is not designed to influence the government, or to intimidate the public or a section of the public, and for the purpose of advancing a political, religious, racial or ideological cause.'
Cooper announced plans to proscribe Palestine Action on June 23, stating that the vandalism of the two planes, which police said caused an estimated £7 million of damage, was 'disgraceful'.
More than 100 people were arrested across the country during demonstrations this weekend protesting against the proscription, with protests held in London, Manchester, Edinburgh, Bristol and Truro on Saturday.
Saturday's arrests brought the total number of people arrested since the ban came into force to more than 200, with more than 72 arrested across the UK last weekend and 29 the week before.
The hearing before Justice Chamberlain concluded on Monday, with the judge saying he would give his decision on July 30.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
3 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Violent Scots killer given sick nickname ‘Iron Fist' & was ‘proud' after battering mum's ex to death
His victim suffered 'catastrophic and unsurvivable' injuries - including a blood clot on the brain BRUTE CAGED Violent Scots killer given sick nickname 'Iron Fist' & was 'proud' after battering mum's ex to death Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A SCOTS killer who brutally battered his mother's ex-partner to death was callously dubbed "Iron Fist" after the attack. John Forsyth was said to have "battered the life" out of Barry Evans in November 2022. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up The 29 year-old had stormed over to his mum's home in Wishaw, Lanarkshire, having discovered Barry was there with his dog Thor. The 47 year-old suffered "catastrophic and unsurvivable" injuries - including a blood clot on the brain - following the unprovoked attack. Forsyth had claimed to be acting in self-defence. But, jurors rejected this and found him guilty of culpable homicide following a trial at the High Court in Glasgow. Forsyth had been on bail, but was remanded in custody by judge Lord Young. He repeatedly shook his head at jurors as he was led to the cells. Relatives also angrily left the courtroom. Barry had been the partner of Forsyth's mum 10 years earlier. He was latterly said to have been badly affected after losing his job. He was taking medication for anxiety and had been in hospital the day before the attack. A neighbour had last saw him that morning when he gave the woman and her children a wave. For some reason, he had ended up at the home of Forsyth's mum while she was out. Another son had came back to initially find Barry's dog there and then the victim lying on a bed. The court heard it was Forsyth who then "rushed over to deal" with Barry. Prosecutors stated the man passed away two days later in hospital having suffered repeated blunt force trauma to the head and body by means unknown. The injuries also included jaw fractures, broken teeth, black eyes and extensive bruising - some caused by Barry desperately trying to protect himself. Blood marks were consistent with him being repeatedly hit as he lay on a bed. Forsyth's brother had texted their sister stating: "Johnny's just battered the life out of him." Forsyth stated during a 999 call that "a random person" he assaulted was "dying". He claimed not to know who the man was. In his closing speech to jurors, prosecutor Vish Kathuria referred to prison phone calls after Forsyth had been held for the death. The killer was said to boasted that he had "battered" someone who had apparently "broke into" his mum's house. Mr Kathuria told jurors it appeared Forsyth and his father seemed "proud" of what he had done. The advocate depute: "That is perhaps best summed up when his dad jokingly said he was going to call him 'iron fist'. "You might think, regardless of how the situation unfolded, there is nothing funny about Barry Evans losing his life in these circumstances." Forsyth accepted assaulting Barry and had left him in "some nick" - but insisted he had been defending himself. He claimed in his evidence that he had been "petrified" at his mum's house and that there had been "a reaction" from Barry. But, Mr Kathuria said the thug had not mentioned at the time anything about an apparent "lunge" at him by the victim. The prosecutor added the self-defence claim may have been "created to try and get him off the charge". Lord Young adjourned sentencing until August 26 in Edinburgh. Detective Chief Inspector Jonathan Wright said of Police Scotland said: 'I hope this conviction brings some comfort to the family and friends of Mr Evans. 'He was subjected to a violent attack which left him with serious injuries from which he later died. 'Violence is never acceptable in our communities and we will continue to work tirelessly to bring those responsible to justice.'
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Former Latin teacher jailed for abuse of teenage girl
The now 78-year-old a was a Latin teacher at the time at a secondary in Angus as well as the leader of the school's hillwalking club. Wilson had been locked up for three years in 2021 for the serial abuse of three schoolboys. It was media reports of that case which led this latest victim to also bravely go to police and report her ordeal from 40 years ago. Wilson was today sentenced to three years and nine months at the High Court in Glasgow. Read More Man arrested and charged following 'disturbance' on flight to Glasgow He had earlier pleaded guilty to the repeated indecent assault of the then girl between 1981 and 1984. Lady Drummond said the Wilson had "manipulated" the victim in a crime involving "a high level of grooming". The youngster was said to have had a troubled home-life at the time. Prosecutor Adrian Stalker said: "Wilson took advantage of the girl's vulnerability and his position as a teacher." Wilson first struck after returning from a trip to Aviemore with the hillwalking club. The girl had also been a member. He dropped off other pupils first and then asked her into his home claiming he was tired. Wilson made her dinner and gave her three glasses of wine. He went on to initially massage the girl, who described how she "froze". Wilson kissed the pupil and molested her. It was only later that she realised she was probably drunk at the time. The next day at school, Wilson spoke to the girl. He asked her to come back to his home that evening. Mr Stalker: "He said what happened was wrong due to her age and him being a teacher. "He was upset during this discussion and the girl felt sorry for him. "But, he said it was her fault for inviting herself into his house." He carried out another sex attack and then again implied she was to "blame" for what happened. The abuse continued until the girl was aged around 18. He had given her a key to his home, but she could only visit when it was dark and no one was outside. She could also not wear perfume. The court heard the girl "would often cry" when being preyed upon. Other attacks occurred during trips with the hillwalking club including to Ben Nevis. The victim did not tell anyone until many years later when she was married. It was a newspaper article in 2021 about Wilson's abuse of the three boys over a near 20-year period which saw her go to police. Wilson had been struck off as a teacher in 2011 following a probe into his behaviour, but it was a decade later before he was convicted in a criminal court. Lady Drummond cut the jail-term from five years due to the guilty plea. Wilson was also put on the sex offenders' list indefinitely. The judge stated: "I have read the victim impact statement and she describes how your behaviour has affected almost every aspect of her life. "She has been profoundly impacted emotionally and psychologically. "There was a high-level of grooming. "You controlled and manipulated her. At times, you blamed her for what had happened."
STV News
4 hours ago
- STV News
Former Latin teacher jailed for abusing pupil he 'manipulated and groomed'
A former teacher who admitted to the repeated abuse of a then-pupil has been jailed for almost four years. Andrew Wilson preyed on the teenage girl in the early 1980s, which often had her in tears. The now 78-year-old was a Latin teacher at a secondary school in Angus at the time and the leader of the school's hillwalking club. Wilson had previously been jailed for three years in 2021 for the serial abuse of three schoolboys. It was media reports of that case which led this latest victim to also go to the police and report her ordeal from 40 years ago. On Tuesday, Wilson was sentenced to three years and nine months at the High Court in Glasgow. He had earlier pleaded guilty to the repeated indecent assault of the then-girl between 1981 and 1984. Lady Drummond said the Wilson had 'manipulated' his victim in a crime involving 'a high level of grooming'. The youngster was said to have had a troubled home life at the time. Prosecutor Adrian Stalker said: 'Wilson took advantage of the girl's vulnerability and his position as a teacher.' Wilson first struck after returning from a trip to Aviemore with the hillwalking club where the girl had also been a member. He dropped off other pupils first and then asked her into his home, claiming he was tired. Wilson made her dinner and gave her three glasses of wine. He went on to initially massage the girl, causing her to 'freeze'. Wilson kissed the pupil and molested her. It was only later that she realised she was probably drunk at the time. The next day at school, Wilson spoke to the girl. He asked her to come back to his home that evening. Mr Stalker said: 'He said what happened was wrong due to her age and him being a teacher. 'He was upset during this discussion, and the girl felt sorry for him. 'But, he said it was her fault for inviting herself into his house.' He carried out another sex attack and then again implied she was to 'blame' for what happened. The abuse continued until the girl was around 18. He had given her a key to his home, but she could only visit when it was dark and no one was outside. She could also not wear perfume. The court heard the girl 'would often cry' when being preyed upon. Other attacks occurred during trips with the hillwalking club, including to Ben Nevis. The victim did not tell anyone until many years later, when she was married. It was a newspaper article in 2021 about Wilson's abuse of the three boys over a nearly 20-year period, which saw her go to the police. Wilson had been struck off as a teacher in 2011 following a probe into his behaviour, but it was a decade later before he was convicted in a criminal court. Lady Drummond cut the jail term from five years due to the guilty plea. Wilson was also put on the sex offenders' list indefinitely. The judge stated: 'I have read the victim impact statement, and she describes how your behaviour has affected almost every aspect of her life. 'She has been profoundly impacted emotionally and psychologically. 'There was a high level of grooming. 'You controlled and manipulated her. At times, you blamed her for what had happened.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
