‘Noise sensitive' woman loses battle with sisters to keep mum's £420k home for her 'emotional support' dogs
A WOMAN has lost a court fight with her sisters to keep their mum's £420,000 home for her "emotional support" dogs.
Sharon Duggan claimed the home in Crawley, West Sussex, for herself after mum Agnes passed away in 2018.
Advertisement
4
Sharon Duggan lost a battle for her mum's house
Credit: Champion News Service
4
She claimed she needed the home for her therapy dogs
Credit: Champion News Service
The "hyper-vigilant and sound sensitive" alternative therapist said she needed the house for her therapeutic rescue
dogs
.
Sharon took her sisters to court after they tried to claim their share in the home, which was left to all three daughters.
Sibling Brenda, who was supported by third sister Ann, fought the case and won after a judge threw out Sharon's claim.
Sharon had used
the 1975
Inheritance Act to argue she deserved "reasonable provision" above her one-third share of her mum's
money
.
Advertisement
Read more news
She claimed her special sensitivity and medical ailments, which include dyslexia, fibromyalgia, depression, anxiety,
insomnia
,
PTSD
, Adjustment Disorder and long Covid, meant she should get at least a life interest in the property.
But while the judge accepted that Sharon has "particular issues," he concluded a flat could not be ruled out as "suitable" accommodation for her.
Central London County Court heard most of Agnes' estate was tied up in her house, where Sharon had lived and cared for her during her final dementia-stricken years.
After Agnes died, the three sisters ended up in court when Sharon refused to move out - citing her acute physical and emotional needs and the plight of her two rescue dogs.
Advertisement
Most read in The Sun
She insisted her problems far outweighed those of her sisters and argued she had "sacrificed" her career to move in and help out her mum in 2014.
Sharon also claimed Agnes was planning to change her will to ensure the house was left to her.
She told the court she spent £30,000 of her own money on funding Agnes' hefty vet
bills
for her beloved Jack Russell/Chihuahua cross, Lady.
In her written arguments to the court, Sharon insisted that "psychologically she could not cope with living in a flat again".
Advertisement
Her barrister said: "She is anxious that
neighbours
may cause disturbances and impact upon her ability to
sleep
.
"She now has two rescue dogs, which help with her mental and emotional well-being, but which makes finding suitable alternative accommodation difficult.
"The claimant maintains that moving from the property would affect her mental
health
greatly and that having to move into rented or temporary accommodation would further affect her health negatively."
Sharon said she wanted the house transferred to her outright or the right to a life interest.
Advertisement
She also alternatively suggest an order allowing her to buy her mum's old property for a small sum, which would be raised with a mortgage.
But Brenda insisted that Sharon and her
pets
would be fine in a flat.
Judge Alan Johns said he was "satisfied" there was no promise that the house would go to Sharon alone.
He added: "Given the circumstances in which Sharon occupied the property with Agnes, there's no moral claim strong enough to deprive her sisters of their share of this modest estate."
Advertisement
The ruling means the sisters are each due a third of their mum's estate - although Sharon's share could be wiped out by the court bills for the trial.
4
Brenda insisted her sister would be fine in a flat
Credit: Champion News Service
4
Sister Ann supported Brenda in her fight
Credit: Champion News Service
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
5 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
The top 10 ways dads show love from doing DIY, to paying dinner bills and sending an iconic emoji
Dads prefer to show their affection by paying for meals, fixing things around the house – and the thumbs-up emoji. A poll of 2,000 adults revealed 49 per cent reckon their dad would describe himself as 'not good at emotional stuff'. 1 DIY ranks among the top ways dads show affection Credit: Alamy Instead, lending tools, helping with house moves, and checking the tyres and oil in cars were other ways dads show their affection. It also emerged 35 per cent don't think their father is good at dealing with emotions – with 14 per cent claiming they have never hugged their father. A spokesperson from Funky Pigeon, which has created a quiz where you can test how fluent you are in 'Dad Speak' and commissioned the research, said: 'Sometimes it can be hard to show real emotion. 'For many of us, our dads grew up in a world where expressing emotion wasn't always encouraged - where a pat on the back might've stood in for 'I love you', and a raised eyebrow counted as a heartfelt pep talk. 'Times are changing, and while some dads still find it hard to open up, we're seeing more and more moments where that emotional armour slips - a quiet tear at a wedding, a thumbs-up that means the world. 'These gestures might be subtle, but they speak volumes.' The study also revealed 19 per cent of those polled have never told their father they love them – and the same percentage have never had a text exchange with their old man. Nearly three in 10 (29 per cent) have also never heard their dad day 'I love you' to them, although Most read in The Sun Another 29 per cent would find it emotional if their dad said, out of the blue, he was proud of them, according to the data. But some of the most common phrases people do hear from their dad included 'You'll be alright', 'Need anything?' and 'Keep going'. It also emerged 51 per cent believe their father is not particularly affectionate physically, if at all. However, it's not a one-way street, as 25 per cent never ask their dad about his feelings, with 49 per cent rarely or never indulging in a proper heart to heart with him. Home Bargains launches Father's Day gifts in store & there's a £5.99 present shoppers are already snapping up A third went on to describe their father's texting style as 'brief', while nine per cent find them littered with emojis. Funky Pigeon's spokesperson added: 'We often joke about the 'dad grunt' — that universal sound that somehow covers everything from 'I'm proud of you' to 'don't forget your coat'. 'But behind the jokes is a real truth: dads feel just as much as anyone else, even if they don't always have the words to say it. 'There's something incredibly moving about seeing a dad trying to express what's in his heart, especially if it doesn't come naturally. 'Whether it's awkward hugs, long silences, or carefully chosen words, those small moments of effort are often the most meaningful of all.' TOP 20 WAYS DADS SHOW AFFECTION: 1. Being there when you need him, even without saying much 2. Paying for a meal 3. Teaching you how to do something practical 4. Fixing things around the house 5. Driving you places 6. Offering to lend you tools or equipment 7. Helping with your children or pets 8. Helping you move house 9. Making you a hot drink 10. Forwarding you useful links or news 11. Checking your vehicle tyres or oil 12. Giving you a thumbs up 13. Cooking a favourite meal 14. Sorting out directions or the route 15. Giving you a thumbs up emoji 16. Tidying or mowing your garden 17. Reminding you to wear a coat 18. Helping with school or university work 19. Packing snacks or food for a trip 20. Topping up your petrol
The Irish Sun
7 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Iran's unfathomably cruel execution regime is laid bare… by the man who's seen it first hand after 25 YEARS on death row
ONE of Iran's longest-serving prisoners has exposed the disturbing mechanisms the regime uses to put inmates to death. Saeed Masouri, who has spent 25 years behind bars, also revealed how the 5 Saeed Masouri been in jail in Iran for 25 years Credit: NCRI 5 Four Iranian convicts hanging after a public execution in 2007 Credit: AFP 5 Masouri is held in Ghezel Hesar prison in Iran Credit: Iran Human Rights The regime's merciless killing spree has seen at least 176 inmates sent to the gallows in the past month. Insiders told The Sun the shocking spike in executions comes amid a barbaric attempt from leaders to crush dissent and act as a warning against it. Masouri, who was arrested for his affiliation with the resistance unit People's Mojahedin Organization of Iran, has now told of the secret process behind executions. Psychological torture, threats against family and sham trials are all used as tools by the regime to condemn its enemies to death on trumped-up charges. More on Iran Masouri's emotional letter was smuggled out of the notorious Ghezel Hesar prison in Iran and shared with The Sun from Iran Human Rights Monitor. "It is often said that every criminal act is preceded by criminal preparations, hidden beneath the surface," the 60-year-old wrote in a letter to the UN. "For instance, when an execution is carried out, the inhumane and rights-violating acts that preceded it remain hidden from view. "Formal steps like prosecution, indictment, and trial are mere facades. Every detail, from A to Z, is orchestrated by these security agencies." Most read in The Sun Masouri told how those accused are hauled into court with a "fabricated case file" to give a smoke screen of a fair and legal procedure. "These so-called 'judges don't even read the actual files," he said. Dad set to be executed in Iran shares powerful audio message blasting regime from behind bars "This is why there is no logical argumentation or credible evidence in the case files, no opportunity for defence (as trials rarely last more than 10 minutes), and no access for lawyers to review the case materials. "Verdicts are predetermined and simply announced. "Empty phrases about 'resolving disputes', 'equality before the law', 'prohibition of injustice', or 'delivering rights to rightful owners' are just lip service. "In reality, defendants are denied the right to a fair defense, and the courts are devoid of justice and even basic adherence to their own laws. "Meanwhile, the stripping of civil rights is carried out to the fullest extent possible." Defendants - and their lawyers - are often even denied access to their own files, making it near impossible to be cleared. Masouri said this is true in the cases of Mehdi Hassani and Behrouz Ehsani, who both face imminent execution. "When the so-called evidence in a case has no real basis or credibility, the only way to keep it hidden is to declare the entire file confidential," he wrote. Haunting message of dad behind bars Exclusive by Katie Davis, Chief Foreign Reporter (Digital) A DAD set to be executed in Iran blasted its brutal regime in a powerful voice message recorded behind bars. He now faces But defiant Hassani has unleashed a blistering put down of Iran's 'cruelty and oppression' in a voice message to his daughter Maryam that has been shared with The Sun. The dad-of-three said: 'This regime has for the past 46 years spent the country's wealth on warmongering and suppressing the people of Iran. 'If I'm in prison today and have been sentenced to execution, it is only because I could not tolerate seeing such cruelty and oppression against this nation and against the children of my land and I stood up against oppression. 'They have no evidence against me and they didn't even allow my lawyer to access and study my file so that he could expose the contradictions that exist.' Hassani - who was arrested in September - vowed the regime is 'doomed to perish'. "[This allows] the system to coerce forced confessions, such as televised admissions or baseless claims presented as 'documentaries'. "In return, the accused is promised clemency or a reduction in punishment. In this way, the defendant is forced to choose: either confess to lies or face execution. "Lawyers - stripped of any ability to defend their clients - are left to weigh between refusing to participate in injustice and doing something, anything, to save their client's life. "Often, the only path left is for the accused themselves to express remorse, seek forgiveness, or act in whatever way they think may help." But Masouri warned even if inmates decide to "confess" to fabricated charges, it does not put them in the clear. "The accused's family is summoned and threatened: if your loved one does not repent, if they do not write a confession, if they do not seek a pardon - then execution is inevitable, and nothing can stop it," he said. "If the execution happens, the blame lies with them—and with you. "Thus, when families and lawyers are left with no means of defense, they may blame themselves, one another, or even the defendant. 5 Pictures show a man named Balal who was led to the gallows by his victim's family 5 "The government and judiciary, meanwhile, are absolved of any responsibility. It comes amid a staggering rise in executions - which sources told The Sun More than 1,100 state executions have taken place Supreme Leader According to figures from the National Council of Resistance of Iran (NCRI), that marks more than a 20 per cent increase compared to 2023, when the regime executed 853 Iranians. Hossein Abedini, deputy director of the NCRI offices in the UK, said paranoid rules were hellbent on stamping out repression. He told The Sun: "Executions under the clerical regime contravene all internationally recognised standards and norms of due process and are fundamentally used as a political instrument of repression. "Faced with deep-rooted crises stemming from illegitimacy, corruption, and incompetence, and driven by fear of popular uprisings and nationwide protests, this regime has resorted to increasing executions. "It employs inhumane pressures on political prisoners, torturing and harassing them and their families. "As a result, the rate of executions in Iran is rising at an unprecedented level in recent decades, with death sentences issued even for political prisoners arrested during the September 2022 uprising." Iran ramps up executions by Katie Davis, Chief Foreign Reporter (Digital) PARANOID Iranian leaders are hellbent on ramping up repression on home turf in a dramatic bid to stamp out rebellion, insiders say. It comes as Iran's regime has been left red-faced by the downfall of Syria's dictatorship as well as Executions are said to be taking place every couple of hours as Iran has one of the most horrific human rights records in the world, and according to campaigners also holds the harrowing title for the highest execution rate. The Sun previously revealed how dozens of Harrowing records leaked from Iran's torturous prisons also showed how In 2024, the Iranian regime ramped up the executions of its own people - including women, children and political prisoners. Official records show that the number of executions last year reached 1,000 - the highest number in 30 years and 16 percent higher than the previous. Of those on record, 34 were women and seven were under 18 at the time of their so-called crimes. The Most of the surging executions are by hanging, but there is also evidence of other
The Irish Sun
21 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Russia's ambassador to the UK ‘blames Britain' for Ukraine's daring drone attack & warns of ‘WWIII risk'
RUSSIA'S ambassador to the UK has blamed Britain for Ukraine's "historic" drone attack - and chillingly warned of World War Three. Moscow diplomat Andrei Kelin said that Ukrainian attacks "are bringing the conflict to a different level of escalation". Advertisement 7 The Russian ambassador to the UK Andrei Kelin who has been in post since November 2019 Credit: The Times 7 Ukraine hit bombers at the Russian Belaya Air Base in Irkutsk 7 Multiple aircraft were set ablaze at Belaya Air Base 7 Over the weekend, Volodymyr Zelensky hailed Ukraine's daring drone blitz on Russian airbases as one for the "history books". It marked Kyiv's longest range operation of the conflict so far with at least 40 aircraft being attacked as part of the expert operation codenamed "Spiderweb". In an embarrassing result for a raging Vladimir Putin 34 per cent of his cruise missile carriers at the targeted airfields were blasted, Zelensky said. A £260million AWACS aircraft and bombers capable of dropping nuclear weapons were also struck. Advertisement read more news Ukraine said the sneak attack was worth $7bn (£5.2bn) in damage to Russia. But Russian ambassador to the UK Kelin warned that Kyiv shouldn't "try to engulf World War Three" in an interview with He also seemingly blamed the UK for potentially providing Ukraine with weaponry that could have been used during the weekend attacks. He said: "[This] kind of attack involves, of course, provision of very high technology, so-called geospaced data, which only can be done by those who have it in possession. Advertisement Most read in The Sun "And this is London and Washington. "I don't believe that America [is involved], that has been denied by President Trump, definitely, but it has not been denied by London. Baby among 5 dead as Putin unleashes strikes on Ukraine hours after revenge vow "We perfectly know how much London is involved, how deeply British forces are involved in working together with Ukraine." US President Donald Trump has spent the past few months since he returned to office trying to balance his relationship with both Moscow and Kyiv. Advertisement In his latest attempt to draw both sides closer to a ceasefire he spoke with Putin over the phone in a 75 minute call . Trump revealed that the despot made it clear he feels he 'will have to respond' to the audacious drone assault. It comes as The Sun laid out the six possible methods Putin may use to respond to the enemy. The tyrant could retaliate with one of his terrifying tactical nukes, launch a deadly 7,600mph missile or even order a renewed 50,000 troop assault to overpower his enemies. Advertisement The Kremlin gave a chilling response earlier today regarding how they may respond. A spokesperson said: "Russian Federation will respond to the attack on airfields when and in the way that the military deems appropriate." And overnight, Vlad already launched his first retaliatory strikes on several residential regions. The worst saw a baby, their mum and grandma all killed due to a Shahed kamikaze drone blast which caused their home to collapse. Advertisement Two others were also found dead in Chernihiv with another 17 seriously wounded in Kharkiv. 7 Ukraine hit bombers at the Russian Belaya Air Base in Irkutsk 7 A satellite picture of the Belaya Airbase shows how a Russian bomber was left smashed to pieces after Ukraine's strikes Credit: AFP 7 Ukraine released photos of the drones in the crates taken from inside Russia Credit: Unpixs Advertisement
