SC won't stay Kerala HC order to publish revised KEAM rank list
Adopting a cautionary note, the top court said it did not want to create a sense of uncertainty among students.
A Bench headed by Justice P.S. Narasimha, instead, issued notice to the State and the Commissioner for Entrance Examinations on a petition challenging the High Court decision.
The High Court had directed Kerala to revert to the standardisation formula followed in the original prospectus of KEAM 2025.
The apex court listed the next hearing after four weeks. The court did not budge even though petitioners requested an earlier date of hearing for the reason that admission procedures would be over by August 14 as per the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) deadline.
Kerala won't file appeal
Meanwhile, the State of Kerala informed it was not filing an appeal against the High Court order. The top court had, on July 15, asked Kerala to revert on whether it planned to file an appeal.
Appearing for Kerala, senior advocate Jaideep Gupta said the State proposed to implement the necessary reforms in KEAM's standardisation formula the next year in order to level any bumps in the playing field between CBSE and State syllabus candidates.
'We propose to make the change next year,' Mr. Gupta said.
Appearing for a group of CBSE students who had filed a caveat in the case, senior advocate Raju Ramachandran and advocate Aljo Joseph said the State must also reflect on why State syllabus students were lagging behind their CBSE counterparts year after year.
'Perhaps they need to have a relook of the curriculum. There has to be an introspection by Kerala and other States,' Mr. Ramachandran said.
Advocates Prashant Bhushan and Zulfiker Ali P.S., representing the State syllabus students who appealed against the High Court order, countered that the State's decision to amend the standardisation formula was a result of such an 'introspection'. The amended formula had been devised to end the disparity between CBSE and State syllabus candidates for KEAM.
Unfair advantage
The State had constituted the Standardisation Review Committee in April after exam authorities had flagged that the 1:1:1 ratio for marks obtained in 10+2 for Maths, Physics and Chemistry gave CBSE students an unfair advantage over the State Board students.
'This had meant the State students would see their marks drop while the CBSE students would have their marks soar,' Mr. Bhushan said.
On July 1, the State, taking into consideration the committee report and the suggestions given by the Commissioner of Entrance Examinations, had decided to amend the ratio for subject marks in KEAM 2025 to 5:3:2 instead of the earlier 1:1:1. It had gone on to publish the KEAM rank list the very same day.
On July 10, the High Court had directed the reversion to 1:1:1 as provided in the original prospectus.
'The State government was entirely within its right to make the amendment. It was done on the basis of a report by an expert committee. The High Court had intervened despite a consistent stand by this court to not intervene in policy matters unless they were found to be arbitrary or discriminatory to students,' Mr. Bhushan argued.
Mr. Gupta said the State was entirely with Mr. Bhushan on merits, and assured reforms for next academic year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
27 minutes ago
- News18
EC Likely To Take Action Against 2 West Bengal Officers Over Inclusion Of Fictitious Voters
Sources in the EC told News18 that both officers, serving as Electoral Registration Officers (EROs) in Baruipur and Moyna, had allegedly shared login credentials The Election Commission of India (EC) is likely to initiate strict action against two West Bengal Civil Service (WBCS) officers after they were found guilty of facilitating the inclusion of fictitious voters in the electoral rolls. Sources in the EC told News18 that both officers, serving as Electoral Registration Officers (EROs) in Baruipur and Moyna, had allegedly shared login credentials through which fake voter names were added to the rolls. They were summoned on Monday for a hearing, and a preliminary inquiry held them responsible for the anomalies. 'The competent authority has been asked to take necessary disciplinary action against both officials," a senior official told News18. The irregularities were uncovered during a random sampling audit conducted by the Commission, prompting it to issue a fresh directive to all District Electoral Officers. The EC has ordered a comprehensive review of all voter inclusions made in the past one year, citing evidence of fake entries. In a move to tighten administrative oversight, the Election Commission has further instructed that no contractual data entry operators will be allowed to participate in any election-related tasks going forward. This comes after reports surfaced indicating misuse and procedural lapses involving temporary staff. 'Only permanent government staff will be assigned to handle sensitive election duties, particularly related to voter roll management," a source said. Amid these developments, preparations are underway for the rollout of SIR (State-wide Integrated Revision) in West Bengal. Sources confirm that all necessary arrangements are in place for its imminent implementation. The issue of fake voters has sparked a fresh political slugfest in the state. Leader of the Opposition Suvendu Adhikari on Monday alleged that his team had uncovered fake voters in two Assembly constituencies. 'They've created bogus voters. Their names must be deleted. In Baruipur alone, we have identified 118 fake names," Adhikari claimed. 'This will not be tolerated." On the other hand, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee reiterated her concern that there may be wrongful deletion; she stated that under no circumstances should genuine voters be struck off the list under the guise of revision. As the state gears up for electoral roll cleansing, the controversy underscores the high-stakes battle between integrity and political maneuvering in Bengal's voter database. view comments First Published: July 29, 2025, 19:45 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Why is there fertiliser shortage despite excess supply, questions BJP
Telangana State BJP president N. Ramchander Rao has once again charged the Congress government of spreading misinformation about the fertiliser availability in the State for the farmers and reiterated that sufficient supply has been made available. Hence, the onus was on the government to control the distribution and supply preventing black marketing, he said. Attacking Agriculture Minister Tummala Nageswar Rao for questioning his 'understanding' on the issue, the BJP leader challenged the former for a debate on his home turf of Khammam district during his ongoing tour there on Tuesday. The government is misleading both the BCs and farmers to derive political gain in the coming local body elections as neem-coated urea is being supplied to every village to prevent shortages. The Central government has supplied 12.2 lakh metric tons of urea when requirement is 9.80 lakh metric tons, claimed the BJP chief and wondered why a shortage still exists despite 'excess supply'. The people have rejected the BRS government and are now ready to reject the Congress for their 'anti-people' policies and waiting to bless the 'committed' BJP which always stood with the farmers and their fight for justice, claimed Mr. Rao. The party is rapidly gaining ground in the district which was traditionally considered a Communist stronghold and hoped that Khammam will become a 'BJP fortress' in coming days. Even Communist party cadres are welcome to join the BJP. Earlier district president N. Koteshwar Rao and other leaders spoke. In a separate statement, party chief spokesperson N.V. Subash, has accused the ruling party of misusing the office of the President to divert attention from its own legislative failures on quota for BCs. 'If the Congress is truly committed, it can introduce the reservation right at the gram panchayat level without resorting to such political theatrics which is a smokescreen designed to confuse the people. The Constitution is clear — no religion-based reservations are permitted — and yet the Congress is hell-bent on violating that in the name of BC upliftment,' said Mr. Subash.
The Hindu
4 hours ago
- The Hindu
Maharashtra government issues guidelines for government servants
No self-praise, no sharing of govt documents without prior approval, limited use of WhatsApp, Telegram, among some of the rules. The Maharashtra government has issued guidelines for government servants regarding the use of social media, asking them not to criticise any current or recent policy of either the State government or the Union government. In a list of dos and don'ts, the government has also warned of strict disciplinary action if the social media guidelines are not adhered to. From keeping personal and professional social media accounts separate, to discretion in sharing information, to avoiding the use of designations, uniforms, logos and other information on personal accounts, the detailed social media guidelines have spelt out the rules for all government servants. The order will be applicable to all the government officers, employees including those on deputation and on contract basis, working in local self-government bodies, boards, corporations and public undertakings. Those flouting the rules will face disciplinary action as per the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1979 and other relevant rules, the order stated. Here are the main points from the government order:
