San Francisco scraps ‘equity grading' program — in which homework and attendance wouldn't affect grades — one day after unveiling it amid bipartisan backlash
San Francisco school officials took a sudden U-turn Wednesday on an initiative that would have effectively let students skip homework, cut class, and re-take their exams.
Parents and politicians alike – including SF Mayor Daniel Lurie – trashed the experimental 'Grading for Equity' initiative as soon as the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD) unveiled it on Tuesday.
Things like class attendance and homework wouldn't have affected a student's final grade under the new system — instead, grades would have been left up to a final exam, which students would be allowed to redo, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.
4 The proposed 'Grading for Equity' program would have made it easier for San Francisco students to get high marks.
Pixel-Shot – stock.adobe.com
4 Education officials quickly halted plans to test the program after widespread backlash.
vchalup – stock.adobe.com
Advertisement
'Grading for Equity' would have also lowered the point threshold for letter grades.
Under a similar system at the nearby San Leandro Unified School District – which SFUSD officials have praised – students need a score of just 80% to get an A, and a score of 41% earns them a C, according to The Voice of San Francisco.
The purpose of the alternative grading approach was to minimize the impact of challenges that disproportionately affect low-income students, such as traveling to school and finding time and space to do homework.
But critics on both sides of the political spectrum said 'Grading for Equity' was not the answer.
'My immigrant dad asked me where the missing 10% went when I scored a 90. He came to America for the chance to work hard & pursue excellence,' Rep. Ro Khanna, a Democrat, posted on X. 'Giving A's for 80% & no homework is not equity—it betrays the American Dream and every parent who wants more for their kids,' he continued.
4 Under a similar program in San Leandro, students need scores of just 80% to earn an A and 49% to earn a C.
Matthew Benoit – stock.adobe.com
4 Critics included San Francisco mayor Daniel Lurie.
Koldo_Studio – stock.adobe.com
Advertisement
'We owe our young people an education that prepares them to succeed. The proposed changes to grading at SFUSD would not accomplish that,' Mayor Lurie echoed on the platform.
Seventy teachers were to test the new system in 14 district schools, but parents cried foul at a Tuesday school board meeting where board members were asked to approve $172,000 for a training program.
Superintendent Maria Su then put the plan on hold, citing widespread 'misinformation.'
Advertisement
'It's clear there are a lot of questions, concerns, and misinformation with this proposal,' Superintendent Maria Su said in a statement to the Chronicle.
'We want to make sure any changes benefit our students. I have decided not to pursue this strategy for next year to ensure we have time to meaningfully engage the community.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
EPA, Park Service take big hits in latest Trump budget plan
The Trump administration's more detailed budget request seeks to decimate science, staffing and other programs at multiple environment-related federal agencies. Entities ranging from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to the National Park Service (NPS) would see deep and specific cuts under the less 'skinny' version of the administration's budget that was released late Friday. The EPA sees a 35 percent cut to the payroll for its science staff and for staff who work on environmental programs and environmental management. NPS sees a 30 percent cut to its staff in charge of park system operations. Meanwhile, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) sees a 28 percent cut to its operations, research and facilities staff payroll. But it's not just staff that takes a hit. A number of offices related to energy and environmental research, as well as disaster response, are reduced or eliminated under the proposal. It completely zeroes out NOAA's Office of Oceanic and Atmospheric Research, for example, and also cuts federal assistance at the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) by 32 percent. Science and technology activities at the EPA would see a 33 percent cut, while environmental programs and environmental management at the agency would see an 18 percent cut. And the Energy Department would also see a 13 percent cut to its science office. The budget document also proposes to 'wind down' the department's Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations, which was established in the Biden-era Bipartisan Infrastructure Law to bolster emerging energy technologies including hydrogen power, carbon capture, advanced nuclear reactors, and batteries. 'This sick joke of a budget is a nonstarter,' said Rep. Zoe Lofgren (Calif.), the top Democrat on the House Science, Space and Technology Committee, in a written statement. 'In no way can America continue to lead if Trump continues his vendetta against the scientific enterprise. While Trump slashes budgets for American research and innovation, our adversaries, like China, are popping champagne. I will do everything I can to stand in the way of this ridiculous plan.' In previous years, a White House budget request has been taken as more of a signal of an administration's priorities than a roadmap that's likely to be realized since it's Congress, not the administration, that has the power of the purse. The Trump administration, however, has signaled that it is willing to go further to challenge that authority, already instituting massive layoffs at many agencies and gearing up for more. And White House Office of Management and Budget Director Russell Vought said over the weekend that the administration would consider 'impoundment' to get its agenda across the finish line. It's not entirely clear how the budget would play out politically, as cuts to programs such as NPS have been historically unpopular. The administration's calls for cuts to FEMA have also been met with mixed reviews even within the GOP, although the budget proposal stops short of the administration's broader calls to eliminate FEMA entirely. The document released late Friday gives additional color to a less detailed 'skinny budget' previously released by the administration. The skinny budget also proposed big cuts at similar agencies. The White House has described the cuts as an effort to take on the 'Green New Scam,' saying in a fact sheet that 'President Trump is committed to eliminating funding for the globalist climate agenda while unleashing American energy production.' The previously announced document called for a 55 percent cut to the EPA's overall budget and a 31 percent cut to the Interior Department, which houses the Park Service. It also called for transferring certain national park 'properties' to the states. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Battleground senators condemn antisemitism at Hatch Foundation event after terror attack
Pennsylvania Sens. John Fetterman and David McCormick joined together to condemn antisemitism at a bipartisan event just a day after police say a terror attack in Colorado was the latest in a series of increasing acts of antisemitism in the U.S. Fetterman, a Democrat and staunch ally of Israel, and McCormick, a Republican in his first term, joined the Orrin G. Hatch Foundation for its Senate Project Series on Monday. They admitted that while they disagree on many things, they both stand against the 'horrific rise of antisemitism across our country and the world.' That includes in their home state, where a man broke into Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro's mansion in April and threw in two Molotov cocktails, starting a fire. No injuries were reported, but Shapiro had celebrated Passover with his family just hours before the attack. Police later said the suspect cited the war in Gaza as a reason for the attack. The Hatch Foundation series is intended to bridge the gap between parties, create dialogue between lawmakers on opposite sides of the aisle in the Senate and build on the relationship between former Utah Sen. Orrin Hatch, a Republican, and former Sen. Ted Kennedy, a Massachusetts Democrat. Fetterman and McCormick's conversation, moderated by Fox News' Shannon Bream, came just a day after a terror attack in Boulder, Colorado, where police arrested a suspect after he used a 'makeshift flame thrower and threw an incendiary device' into a crowd of people participating in a walk for the hostages held by Hamas. Witnesses said the man yelled 'Free Palestine' as he carried out the attacks. Fetterman, who has been one of the most outspoken Democrats backing Israel in the ongoing conflict, highlighted the attack in Boulder while speaking to the crowd at the event Monday. 'What happened yesterday in Boulder, it's astonishing, you know, the kinds of, the rank antisemitism … out of control,' Fetterman said. The attack comes as a rise of antisemitism occurs across the country in response to the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza that began when Hamas attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023. According to the Anti-Defamation League's Audit of Antisemitic Incidents, assault and vandalism increased significantly in 2024 and overall antisemitic incidents increased 5% from the year before. The FBI has reported that hate crimes for all races, religions, sexual orientation and gender were on the rise in 2023. The senators noted how there's been a rise in their state of Pennsylvania, too, evident in the attack on Shapiro. McCormick said he visited the University of Pennsylvania campus, where pro-Palestinian protests occurred, including a 16-day encampment in 2024 as part of a larger wave of demonstrations at universities across the country. 'You started to see these huge … rallies and this antisemitist … hate,' McCormick said Monday. 'Hatred really spewed at places like University of Pennsylvania and others. I actually went to University of Pennsylvania, saw these demonstrations. This wasn't free speech. This was intimidation, and in some cases physical violence.' 'We see this deeply seeded in our society and it's something that we have to stand up against with complete moral clarity,' he later said. The state also grieved after a gunman killed 11 people during Shabbat morning services in the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh in 2018. The shooting anniversary was where Fetterman said he and McCormick met for the first time. 'From the Tree of Life massacre down the road from where we live, to Boulder yesterday, D.C. the week before, and so many more horrific accounts,' Fetterman said in a post online. 'We both see the way antisemitism has impacted communities across Pennsylvania, the country and the world—and we must call it out.' While the two senators agree that antisemitism is wrong and should be stopped, they didn't point to concrete ways to reduce it across the country, Bream told her fellow Fox News hosts after the panel. However, they did share support for Israel in its offensive against Hamas, and for securing the country's southern border, among other issues. Matt Sandgren, the executive director of the Orrin G. Hatch Foundation, said the Senate Project works to prove Hatch's belief that the Senate works best when lawmakers can disagree respectfully. 'The Senate Project continues to prove that principle can thrive even in these divided times,' Sandgren said in a statement, noting the foundation was thankful to the senators for 'showing that serious, respectful debate still has a place in American politics.'
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Delgado will challenge Hochul for New York Governor in 2026
The Brief New York Lieutenant Governor Antonio Delgado has announced his run for New York Governor. He will challenge New York Governor Kathy Hochul for the Democratic nomination for New York Governor in 2026. NEW YORK - New York Lieutenant Governor Antonio Delgado has announced his run for New York Governor. What we know Delgado will challenge New York Governor Kathy Hochul for her seat in next year's Democratic primary in 2026. He is the only other Democrat who has declared a run in the 2026 New York gubernatorial election. A recent Siena College Poll showed that only 12 percent of registered Democratic voters in New York would support Delgado in the upcoming gubernatorial primary – 46 percent said they would support Hochul. What they're saying U.S. Representative Tom Suozzi posted this in response to Delgado's announcement: The Source This article includes reporting from posts made by New York Lieutenant Governor Antonio Delgado and U.S. Representative Tom Suozzi.
