‘I Know What You Did Last Summer' Review: Freddie Prinze Jr. and Jennifer Love Hewitt Return for a Legacy Sequel Not Worth Screaming About
Those throwbacks, ironically, are the most fun aspect of this new installment, which is unlikely to garner the same sort of cult following as the 1997 original. The concept remains the same, with a group of extremely good-looking young people (here in their mid-20s rather than teen years) covering up a violent death for which they were responsible. Cut to a year later, when one of them receives a note containing the ominous titular message. Not long after, a killer armed with a metal hook and clad in a fisherman's slicker and hat begins gruesomely killing them one by one.
More from The Hollywood Reporter
What Convinced Freddie Prinze Jr. to Return to 'I Know What You Did Last Summer'
Jennifer Love Hewitt Teases the Jaw-Dropping Ending of the New 'I Know What You Did Last Summer'
Sarah Michelle Gellar's Goal Is to "Bring Back Everyone Who Has Died" on 'Buffy' for Reboot
In this version, they're a fairly bland group, consisting of Danica (Madelyn Cline) and her fiancé Teddy (Tyriq Withers); Ava (The Studio's Chase Sui Wonders), their friend who's returned to celebrate their engagement; Milo (Jonah Hauer-King), with whom Ava has a romantic past; and Stevie (Sarah Pidgeon), their estranged friend from the other side of the tracks, who reunites with them for an ill-fated drive to watch fireworks from a stretch of highway accurately named Reaper's Curve.
None of them winds up being the first victim of the stalking killer. That would be Wyatt (Joshua Orpin), Danica's equally bland new fiancé, with whom she got involved after breaking it off with Teddy. He didn't have anything to do with the incident that has spurred such violent revenge, but his demise serves the purpose of setting the murderous events in motion while still leaving the central cast members in play.
Not receiving help from the local police chief or the town's chief real estate developer (Billy Campbell), who has a vested interested in covering things up, the group turns to two of the survivors of the previous rampage that took place nearly three decades earlier. They're Ray Bronson and Julie James (fan favorites Freddie Prinze Jr. and Jennifer Love Hewitt), who, needless to say, are still scarred by their experiences. Julie, at least, has made good use of her past, becoming a professor who teaches her students about the nature of trauma.
For much of its running time, I Know What You Did Last Summer tediously lurches from one violent slashing to another, which would be fine if any of the kills showcased visual originality or genuine thrills, which they don't. It's not until the final act that the film goes seriously bonkers, throwing out so many red herrings and plot twists revolving around the true identity of the murderer that Agatha Christie would throw up her hands in disgust. It doesn't help that the more entertainingly colorful supporting characters, including a creepy pastor (Austin Nichols) and a sexy podcaster (Gabbriette Bechtel, very amusing) whose show is called 'Live, Laugh, Slaughter,' are sadly underutilized.
Fortunately, Prinze Jr. and Hewitt are on hand to provide some much-needed gravitas to the proceedings (which is not a sentence I ever envisioned writing). Both are in excellent form, providing connective tissue to the original film and its sequel. And they're also good for some laughs, as when Ray, upon hearing one of the prospective victims announce that they should all simply flee the area and head to the Bahamas in a boat, sagely advises: 'For reasons I won't go into, I wouldn't do that.'
Director Jennifer Kaytin Robinson (Netflix's Do Revenge) and her co-screenwriter Sam Lansky display clear affection for the franchise, as evidenced by some fun cameos from unbilled performers whose appearances garnered delighted screams from the audience (be sure to stay for the end credits). But they haven't succeeded in breathing new life into a tired franchise that, creatively speaking, should have remained dead.
Best of The Hollywood Reporter
The 40 Best Films About the Immigrant Experience
Wes Anderson's Movies Ranked From Worst to Best
13 of Tom Cruise's Most Jaw-Dropping Stunts
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Pete Davidson says it's been his ‘dream' to be a dad
Pete Davidson is overjoyed to be entering his dad era. The actor and comedian is expecting a child, his first, with his partner Elsie Hewitt. 'I'm very lucky and very, very happy,' he told 'E! News' while attending the New York premiere of his new horror movie 'The Home' this week. Hewitt, a model and actress, made the announcement via Instagram last week sharing photos and a clip of her and the 'SNL' alum from her sonogram. Davidson said he's gotten advice from his 'SNL' buddies Adam Sandler and Colin Jost. 'Everybody's just been super excited for me, because they know it's been my dream,' Davidson said. 'They all just have been like, 'You're going to be great at this. It's the best thing you'll ever do in your life.' Sandler gave me some great advice.' It sounds like the couple have been getting quite a bit of support. 'It's been really nice that everyone's super excited,' he said. 'When you do something, when we do anything, you want everyone to be excited, especially having a child.' Hewitt and Davidson were first publicly linked in March. Davison has previously dated several famous women including Kim Kardashian and Ariana Grande. In February he talked to Page Six about why people seem so fascinated with his dating life, which has sparked memes about him being everyone's boyfriend. 'Everyone is dating everyone and it's Hollywood. But because I'm ugly, they wrote about me,' he said at the time. 'I was harassed for like five years and it made my life a living hell.' CNN's Dan Heching and Alli Rosenbloom contributed to this report.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
71-Year-Old Jockey Perry Ouzts Approaching New Record
71-Year-Old Jockey Perry Ouzts Approaching New Record originally appeared on Paulick Report. "Ironman" jockey Perry Ouzts, 71, will start a new record for starts in a Thoroughbred horse race in this Saturday's fifth race at Belterra Park in Cincinnati, Ohio. The veteran jockey will enter the starting gate for a 53,579th time, eclipsing the previous record set by retired California-based rider Russell Baze. At this writing, Ouzts sports a record of 53,570 starts– 7,514 wins – 7,013 seconds – 6,694 thirds, for earnings of $53,055,913. The next active rider is Hall of Famer John Velazquez with 37,363 mounts and 6,703 is also the record holder as the oldest jockey to win a race in North America — a feat he accomplished last summer. Ouzts has spent most of his career riding in Northern Kentucky and Ohio. Though he has never won a graded stakes race, he was the subject of an award-winning 2015 documentary "Ironman Perry Ouzts," produced by the Hennegan ranks fifth all-time in wins, trailing only Russell Baze (12,842 wins), Laffit Pincay Jr. (9,530), William Shoemaker (8,833), and Pat Day (8,803).Ouzts told John Engelhardt that loyalty has been a key factor in his success. He credits the support of trainers W.J. Danner, Larry Holt, Joe Woodard, Bill Connelly, Matt Kordenbrock, Barb Riley and Larry Smith for the many winners they have put him up on. He has also had the same agent, Jamie Fowler, for 38 years. Fowler contracted throat cancer in February of 2023 and has undergone 50 radiation treatments, several surgeries, and 10 months of physical therapy. This week, Fowler was declared cancer-free. According to Ouzts: 'I asked if he could still do the job from home when it was discovered, and with texting, video replays and other on-line features, he hasn't missed a beat.' He has won 35 meet titles at River Downs/Belterra Park, 13 titles at the now defunct, Beulah Park and 2 titles at Turfway Park. He won the last race at River Downs and the first race there under its new name Belterra Park. He was the first jockey to win a stakes race at 70 years old. His richest races won were the $200,000 Cradle Stakes (2007), the $100,000 Queen City Oaks (1988) and the $100,000 Green Carpet Stakes (this season). He won four races on a horse named Oats N' Ouzts. He and his wife, Toni have two sons – Kyle (35) and Tyler (32). This story was originally reported by Paulick Report on Jul 24, 2025, where it first appeared.
Eater
6 hours ago
- Eater
It's All About Realistic Corn Gummies in Cocktails at This D.C. Bar
As Halloween-meets-summer continues to trend, one uppity D.C. bar is taking the concept of candy corn to new heights. The lounge at Bourbon Steak, celebrity chef Michael Mina's sleek, people-watching magnet tucked inside Georgetown's Four Seasons hotel, has come up with a cocktail garnish that (we can attest) literally looks and tastes like the freshly shucked summer vegetable. But this yellow corn-ament of sorts, found in the new It's A-Maiz-Ing cocktail, is of the gummy and small variety. 'Engi' Alebachew, Bourbon Steak's head bartender, tells Eater that he has long wanted to invent such a believable, realistic cocktail accoutrement. And the sweet and savory grain ingredient is definitely having a moment at D.C. bars as of late. Since the drink debuted two weeks ago, Alebachew says the team's sold around 100 little corn garnishes. 'Some people ask for it without the drink — 'can I have one more of those?' I can't say no, even though it takes forever to make,' he says. So, how does he make it? 'We buy fresh corn and slowly cook it. Then we throw away the cob and blend the juice [extract] with sugar and salt,' Alebachew says. The syrup then joins pectin (as a gelling agent) and combines with agave nectar and fruit juice to produce a 'gummy candy' of sorts. The complex compilation goes into a cute corn-shaped mold before it's finally 'thrown in the freezer' for a couple of hours, he explains. Bourbon Steak's collection of new summer cocktails. Bourbon Steak Bourbon Steak's Engi Alebachew preparing the Beekeeper (Bar Hill Gin, yellow Chartreuse, lemongrass, honey, lemon). Bourbon Steak Due to limited kitchen prep space, sheer time constraints, and popularity, however, he's now looking to potentially outsource the edible party favor. 'I found a good garnish company online making the same kind of them,' he says, reporting that their recently sent sample hit his high standards. And there's not just corn on the cocktail menu. A new vodka-and-sherry coupe called Rice and Shine also comes topped with a tasty conversation starter: a big piece of rice paper that's fried in hot oil and sprinkled with green matcha. 'There are so many kinds of fun and edible things I want to work on,' he says. A riff on a gin Bee's Knees loops in lemongrass and is garnished with real honeycomb. And a big cluster of grapes dangles off the Singani 63-infused Grape Expectations. All of the new summer cocktails are $26 each (2800 Pennsylvania Avenue NW). Executive chef Quentin Welch is also having fun in the kitchen during her second summer in the head role. She recently perfected a delightfully fluffy, caviar-topped 'twinkie' made with cornbread cake and yuzu creme fraiche. Meanwhile, Mina is gearing up to expand in D.C. with the opening of Acqua Bistecca, his newly named coastal Italian restaurant coming to City Ridge. Stay tuned for more. Eater DC All your essential food and restaurant intel delivered to you Email (required) Sign Up By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
