Federal Election 2025: Australian Association of Practice Management deems Labor's centerpiece Medicare policy 'smoke and mirrors'
Mr Albanese has repeatedly claimed Australians would only need their Medicare cards to see a GP amid a multi-billion dollar pledge to boost bulk billing rates over the next five years.
The policy has sparked reaction from medical bodies including the Royal College of General Practitioners, which has warned expanding incentives would not necessarily result in wider access to bulk-billed consultations.
The Australian reports the Australian Association of Practice Management is the latest organisation to cast doubt on the idea patients will be able to see a doctor for free.
AAPM chief executive Miranda Grace told the masthead this would not be the reality as 'there's no such thing as free'.
'It's a nice vision and a nice political sell, but we are in the business of being practical,' she said.
'The idea that all you will need is your Medicare card to get free doctors' visits – I think that is a beautiful dream to have but I don't know how that's going to translate in reality. I think it's going to be a huge challenge."
Ms Grace said many practitioners now bulk bill based on 'particular patient needs' and the community they serve.
She said there was 'a bit of smoke and mirrors' involved in the policy, as well as 'a utopian sort of vision'.
Australian Medical Association President Dr Danielle McMullen earlier this month slammed the pledge, saying says doctors were frustrated by the 'lack of reform' and that Labor's incentives don't 'help people get that extra time with their GP'.
Mr Albanese was questioned about doubts raised over the 90 per cent bulk-billing pledge on Wednesday, declaring, 'the AMA haven't always been great fans of the whole concept of Medicare'.
'So we're not shocked that occasionally not every doctor comes on board there. But the reason why we are so confident is because this is not some academic exercise,' he said, speaking at the National Press Club in Canberra.
'The modelling that we've done shows that it will be in their interests to have fully bulk-billed services throughout the country.
'What we've got is a 2030 target of achieving (90 per cent bulk billing).'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AU Financial Review
13 minutes ago
- AU Financial Review
Children with mild autism removed from NDIS to fix the budget
The Albanese government has made its most significant gesture yet towards budget repair with a pledge to cut the growth rate of the NDIS, and a revamped proposal to remove children with mild autism and other developmental conditions from the scheme. Warning the scheme was unsustainable even at the 8 per cent growth rate target agreed to by the national cabinet two years ago, Health Minister Mark Butler said NDIS spending must be trimmed by billions more to return to its original aim of looking after the permanently and significantly disabled, and to remain financially sustainable.
West Australian
43 minutes ago
- West Australian
WA health crisis: Federal Health Minister Mark Butler claims aged care funding not to blame
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler has denied claims the Albanese Government's level of investment into aged care is adding to the bed block plaguing the WA health system. Under the heat of a series of damning reports over the state of Perth hospitals in recent days, Premier Roger Cook and several ministers have slammed the Federal Government for short changing the state in aged care and hospital funding. But Mr Butler wiped his hands of the issue when asked on Wednesday, saying the Albanese Government had taken sufficient action to fund aged care. 'We passed legislation through the Parliament at the end of the last year that, frankly, delivered once in a generation, aged care reform,' he said at the National Press Club in Canberra. 'We have done what the sector was asking us to do.' Mr Butler said consultation with the providers, financiers, and banks found the sector simply 'wasn't investable' — so government acted to change retention payments to lifting the maximum room rate. 'Right at the heart of that was making this sector — the residential aged care sector — investable again,' he said. 'Were all focused on doing what the providers told us were necessary to unleash the capital to build the beds that we need, particularly for that aging generation of baby boomers who will start to hit the residential sector on average in the next three to five years. 'So, we have done what the sector was asking us to do. 'In the meantime, this year, we've increased our funding to state hospital systems by 12 per cent, the biggest increase in Commonwealth funding to hospitals.' It comes after Premier Roger Cook announced he will lead a delegation to Canberra to ask for more Federal funding for aged care beds in WA and just days after he announced a new $50 million State fund to fix the ageing hospital system. Demand for aged care beds outstripping supply has been a long-running issue, with Ernst & Young modelling for the WA Department of Health, estimating there would be a gap of between 1400 and 2800 beds by 2029 in the Perth metro. It's estimated 15 to 30 new residential aged care homes could be required. WA Labor included a $100 million commitment to a concessional loan arrangement for aged care providers at the State election earlier this year, allowing them to build new, expand or refurbish existing facilities to boost supply. The election commitment was aimed to deliver up to 500 new concessional aged care beds but wasn't matched by the Federal Government. Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson will be among the MP's on Mr Cook's delegation. Ms Sanderson said there was no question more beds were needed. 'We do need more, there's no question about that. That's why all of that planning has gone into place,' the former health minister said. 'That's why we've put 900 beds on the system, it's why we've increased the staff by more than 30 per cent — the bread and butter health expansion is work that we've invested in as a government and then we have to better coordinate.' 'We're advocating strongly, I advocated strongly as Health Minister, the current Health Minister is having those discussions, and the Premier will be in Canberra next week, with the Health Ministers making the case to Canberra to increase those packages.'
The Advertiser
2 hours ago
- The Advertiser
The wrong fit: children with autism moved off NDIS
Children with autism who rely on the NDIS for support will be diverted to a new program, touted by disability groups as a "once-in-a-generation" reform. Disability Minister Mark Butler used a speech at the National Press Club on Wednesday to say the NDIS was not the right fit for the growing number of children on the autism spectrum or with development delays. A separate program called Thriving Kids will be set up to focus on those children previously covered by the NDIS. It will begin rolling out from July 2026 and be fully implemented by July 2027. Children with autism on the NDIS would not be steered from the scheme until supports were fully rolled out, the minister said. "I know this will be hard for some parents to hear and I don't say it lightly," Mr Butler said in the speech. "We need as a matter of some urgency to create a better system that will enable our children to thrive. "Diverting this group of kids over time from the NDIS is an important element of making the scheme sustainable and returning it to its original intent." Medicare items for occupational therapy, speech pathology and psychosocial therapy would be considered for the program, including a bulk-billed check-up for three-year-olds, Mr Butler said. The government would start by making a $2 billion contribution, matched by states and territories. Early intervention strategies were key for ensuring children received the right support, Autism Awareness chief executive Nicole Rogerson said. "(Thriving Kids) potentially has the opportunity to be a once-in-a-generation change in how we look at developmental pediatrics," she told AAP. She said what Mr Butler was doing was "pretty rare for a politician" because he was "owning what the problem is". Ensuring the program was in place before children were moved from the scheme was reassuring, People with Disability acting chief executive Megan Spindler-Smith told AAP. The minister said while one-in-50 people had a significant disability which would be covered by the NDIS, one-in-five young children were on the autism spectrum or had a developmental delay. Parents had little choice but to put their children with autism on a scheme designed for permanent disability, Mr Butler said. "Families who were looking for additional supports in mainstream services can't find them because they largely don't exist anymore and in that, all governments have failed them," he said. Mr Butler said the changes would help to bring down the cost of the NDIS, with taxpayers set to fork out more than $52 billion for the scheme in 2025/26. Laws passed in 2024 put in place a cap on spending growth of eight per cent per year. But the minister said the existing level of growth was unsustainable and a cap of between five and six per cent would be more effective. "After we achieve our current target, a further wave of reform will be needed to get growth down to a more sustainable position," he said. "There's no significant change in disability prevalence in the community and the scheme is now fully rolled out. So growth should really reflect unit price inflation plus growth in Australia's population." Autism peak body Aspect said families needed the right level of support. "Given the number of autistic children we support through our schools and therapy programs, families must have confidence there will be continuity of supports, real choice and control, and no gaps during the transition," chief executive Jacqui Borland said Children with autism who rely on the NDIS for support will be diverted to a new program, touted by disability groups as a "once-in-a-generation" reform. Disability Minister Mark Butler used a speech at the National Press Club on Wednesday to say the NDIS was not the right fit for the growing number of children on the autism spectrum or with development delays. A separate program called Thriving Kids will be set up to focus on those children previously covered by the NDIS. It will begin rolling out from July 2026 and be fully implemented by July 2027. Children with autism on the NDIS would not be steered from the scheme until supports were fully rolled out, the minister said. "I know this will be hard for some parents to hear and I don't say it lightly," Mr Butler said in the speech. "We need as a matter of some urgency to create a better system that will enable our children to thrive. "Diverting this group of kids over time from the NDIS is an important element of making the scheme sustainable and returning it to its original intent." Medicare items for occupational therapy, speech pathology and psychosocial therapy would be considered for the program, including a bulk-billed check-up for three-year-olds, Mr Butler said. The government would start by making a $2 billion contribution, matched by states and territories. Early intervention strategies were key for ensuring children received the right support, Autism Awareness chief executive Nicole Rogerson said. "(Thriving Kids) potentially has the opportunity to be a once-in-a-generation change in how we look at developmental pediatrics," she told AAP. She said what Mr Butler was doing was "pretty rare for a politician" because he was "owning what the problem is". Ensuring the program was in place before children were moved from the scheme was reassuring, People with Disability acting chief executive Megan Spindler-Smith told AAP. The minister said while one-in-50 people had a significant disability which would be covered by the NDIS, one-in-five young children were on the autism spectrum or had a developmental delay. Parents had little choice but to put their children with autism on a scheme designed for permanent disability, Mr Butler said. "Families who were looking for additional supports in mainstream services can't find them because they largely don't exist anymore and in that, all governments have failed them," he said. Mr Butler said the changes would help to bring down the cost of the NDIS, with taxpayers set to fork out more than $52 billion for the scheme in 2025/26. Laws passed in 2024 put in place a cap on spending growth of eight per cent per year. But the minister said the existing level of growth was unsustainable and a cap of between five and six per cent would be more effective. "After we achieve our current target, a further wave of reform will be needed to get growth down to a more sustainable position," he said. "There's no significant change in disability prevalence in the community and the scheme is now fully rolled out. So growth should really reflect unit price inflation plus growth in Australia's population." Autism peak body Aspect said families needed the right level of support. "Given the number of autistic children we support through our schools and therapy programs, families must have confidence there will be continuity of supports, real choice and control, and no gaps during the transition," chief executive Jacqui Borland said Children with autism who rely on the NDIS for support will be diverted to a new program, touted by disability groups as a "once-in-a-generation" reform. Disability Minister Mark Butler used a speech at the National Press Club on Wednesday to say the NDIS was not the right fit for the growing number of children on the autism spectrum or with development delays. A separate program called Thriving Kids will be set up to focus on those children previously covered by the NDIS. It will begin rolling out from July 2026 and be fully implemented by July 2027. Children with autism on the NDIS would not be steered from the scheme until supports were fully rolled out, the minister said. "I know this will be hard for some parents to hear and I don't say it lightly," Mr Butler said in the speech. "We need as a matter of some urgency to create a better system that will enable our children to thrive. "Diverting this group of kids over time from the NDIS is an important element of making the scheme sustainable and returning it to its original intent." Medicare items for occupational therapy, speech pathology and psychosocial therapy would be considered for the program, including a bulk-billed check-up for three-year-olds, Mr Butler said. The government would start by making a $2 billion contribution, matched by states and territories. Early intervention strategies were key for ensuring children received the right support, Autism Awareness chief executive Nicole Rogerson said. "(Thriving Kids) potentially has the opportunity to be a once-in-a-generation change in how we look at developmental pediatrics," she told AAP. She said what Mr Butler was doing was "pretty rare for a politician" because he was "owning what the problem is". Ensuring the program was in place before children were moved from the scheme was reassuring, People with Disability acting chief executive Megan Spindler-Smith told AAP. The minister said while one-in-50 people had a significant disability which would be covered by the NDIS, one-in-five young children were on the autism spectrum or had a developmental delay. Parents had little choice but to put their children with autism on a scheme designed for permanent disability, Mr Butler said. "Families who were looking for additional supports in mainstream services can't find them because they largely don't exist anymore and in that, all governments have failed them," he said. Mr Butler said the changes would help to bring down the cost of the NDIS, with taxpayers set to fork out more than $52 billion for the scheme in 2025/26. Laws passed in 2024 put in place a cap on spending growth of eight per cent per year. But the minister said the existing level of growth was unsustainable and a cap of between five and six per cent would be more effective. "After we achieve our current target, a further wave of reform will be needed to get growth down to a more sustainable position," he said. "There's no significant change in disability prevalence in the community and the scheme is now fully rolled out. So growth should really reflect unit price inflation plus growth in Australia's population." Autism peak body Aspect said families needed the right level of support. "Given the number of autistic children we support through our schools and therapy programs, families must have confidence there will be continuity of supports, real choice and control, and no gaps during the transition," chief executive Jacqui Borland said Children with autism who rely on the NDIS for support will be diverted to a new program, touted by disability groups as a "once-in-a-generation" reform. Disability Minister Mark Butler used a speech at the National Press Club on Wednesday to say the NDIS was not the right fit for the growing number of children on the autism spectrum or with development delays. A separate program called Thriving Kids will be set up to focus on those children previously covered by the NDIS. It will begin rolling out from July 2026 and be fully implemented by July 2027. Children with autism on the NDIS would not be steered from the scheme until supports were fully rolled out, the minister said. "I know this will be hard for some parents to hear and I don't say it lightly," Mr Butler said in the speech. "We need as a matter of some urgency to create a better system that will enable our children to thrive. "Diverting this group of kids over time from the NDIS is an important element of making the scheme sustainable and returning it to its original intent." Medicare items for occupational therapy, speech pathology and psychosocial therapy would be considered for the program, including a bulk-billed check-up for three-year-olds, Mr Butler said. The government would start by making a $2 billion contribution, matched by states and territories. Early intervention strategies were key for ensuring children received the right support, Autism Awareness chief executive Nicole Rogerson said. "(Thriving Kids) potentially has the opportunity to be a once-in-a-generation change in how we look at developmental pediatrics," she told AAP. She said what Mr Butler was doing was "pretty rare for a politician" because he was "owning what the problem is". Ensuring the program was in place before children were moved from the scheme was reassuring, People with Disability acting chief executive Megan Spindler-Smith told AAP. The minister said while one-in-50 people had a significant disability which would be covered by the NDIS, one-in-five young children were on the autism spectrum or had a developmental delay. Parents had little choice but to put their children with autism on a scheme designed for permanent disability, Mr Butler said. "Families who were looking for additional supports in mainstream services can't find them because they largely don't exist anymore and in that, all governments have failed them," he said. Mr Butler said the changes would help to bring down the cost of the NDIS, with taxpayers set to fork out more than $52 billion for the scheme in 2025/26. Laws passed in 2024 put in place a cap on spending growth of eight per cent per year. But the minister said the existing level of growth was unsustainable and a cap of between five and six per cent would be more effective. "After we achieve our current target, a further wave of reform will be needed to get growth down to a more sustainable position," he said. "There's no significant change in disability prevalence in the community and the scheme is now fully rolled out. So growth should really reflect unit price inflation plus growth in Australia's population." Autism peak body Aspect said families needed the right level of support. "Given the number of autistic children we support through our schools and therapy programs, families must have confidence there will be continuity of supports, real choice and control, and no gaps during the transition," chief executive Jacqui Borland said
