Iraq's Jewish community saves a long-forgotten shrine
A few months ago, the tomb of Rabbi Isaac Gaon was filled with rubbish. Its door was rusted, the windows shattered and the walls stained black from decades of neglect.
Today, marble tiling covers the once-small grave, and at its centre stands a large tombstone inscribed with a verse, the rabbi's name and the year he died: 688. A silver menorah hangs on the wall behind it.
"It was a garbage dump and we were not allowed to restore it," said the head of Iraq's Jewish community, Khalida Elyahu, 62.
The Jewish community in Iraq was once one of the largest in the Middle East, but now it has dwindled to just dozens.
Baghdad today has one synagogue left, but it has no rabbis. And many houses that once belonged to Jews are abandoned and dilapidated.
The Jewish community itself is funding the shrine's restoration, at an estimated cost of $150,000.
The project will bring "a revival for our community, both within and outside Iraq", Elyahu said.
With the backing of Iraqi officials, she said she hopes to restore more neglected sites.
Who was he?
Little information is available about Rabbi Isaac. But when Iraq's National Security Adviser Qassem al-Araji visited the tomb earlier this year, he said the rabbi had been a finance official.
Rabbi Isaac Gaon was prominent during the Gaonic period, also known as the era of Babylonian academies for rabbis.
The term "Gaon" is likely to refer to his position as the head of one such academy.
His name was mentioned in the 10th century by another rabbi, who told a tale that never appeared elsewhere, according to Professor Simcha Gross from the University of Pennsylvania.
"There is only one single story," said Gross.
It goes that Rabbi Isaac led 90,000 Jews to meet Ali Ibn Abi Talib, the fourth Islamic caliph and a relation of the Prophet Mohammed, who is also revered by Shiites as the first Imam, during one of his conquests in central Iraq.
"We have no other evidence for this event, and there are reasons to be sceptical," Gross said.
Nothing else is known about Rabbi Isaac, not even his religious opinions.
But the tale has origins that are not without context, said Gross.
In the 10th century, minorities -- Christians, Jews, and Zoroastrians -- began to tell stories of how they greeted "Muslim conquerors" because "their privileges including taxes were dependent on whether or not they were believed to have welcomed the Muslims", he said.
At that same time, Jewish shrines started to appear, even though Jewish roots in Iraq date back some 2,600 years.
According to biblical tradition, Jews arrived in Iraq in 586 BC as prisoners of Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar II after he destroyed Solomon's Temple in Jerusalem.
In Iraq, they wrote the Babylonian Talmud.
Thousands of years later, in Ottoman-ruled Baghdad, Jews made up 40 percent of the population.
A turning point was the 1941 pogrom in Baghdad when more than 100 Jews were killed.
Like other Jewish communities in the Arab region, their history has changed since the Palestinian Nakba -- "catastrophe" in Arabic -- and Israel's creation in 1948. Soon afterwards, almost all of Iraq's 135,000 Jews went into exile.
Blessings
Decades of conflict and instability -- Saddam Hussein's dictatorship, the 2003 US-led invasion and the ensuing violence -- completed the community's erosion.
Some who stayed on converted to other religions, or do not reveal their faith.
Today, 50 synagogues and Jewish sites remain, Elyahu said. Most are crumbling, and some have become warehouses.
Rabbi Isaac's shrine once included a synagogue and a school, but has been reduced to the small room housing the grave, the restoration's supervisor said.
"It took us two months to clean it of garbage," said the supervisor, who asked to remain anonymous.
Now "we are receiving requests from outside Iraq to visit it".
Decades ago people would come to pray and light candles, believing in the rabbi's "healing powers".
Mussa Hayawi, 64, lives nearby. He recounted stories from his childhood in a quarter which was, until the 1940s, one of several Jewish districts in Baghdad.
He said women used to soak themselves in water from the shrine's well, hoping to conceive.
Rabbi Isaac "was a revered man". People came "to pray for their sick, to ask for a baby, or the release of a prisoner", Hayawi said.
© 2025 AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local France
7 days ago
- Local France
OPINION: 130 years on, the Dreyfus affair still matters to France and the world
In 1894 an obscure Jewish French army captain was falsely convicted of espionage and treason. Alfred Dreyfus spent five years alone in a cage on Devil's Island in the French Caribbean before he was pardoned and finally rehabilitated in 1906. For many decades 'the Dreyfus case' divided France. To the Catholic fundamentalist, antisemitic and ultra-patriotic Right, his guilt – no matter the lack of evidence - became an article of patriotic faith. To the Left, and not just the Left, the struggle to prove his innocence symbolised the importance and the fragility of the democratic and personal freedoms won by the French Revolution. On Monday, the National Assembly voted unanimously to promote Dreyfus to the rank of brigadier general 90 years after his death. Until relatively recently, any unanimous parliamentary decision on the Dreyfus case in France would have been unthinkable. Advertisement This week's vote managed to be both unanimous and controversial. Of the 577 deputies, only 197 voted. Thirty-eight were from the far-right Rassemblement National, direct descendants of the Vichy regime of 1940-44 which rehabilitated the senior officers who lied and cheated to frame Dreyfus. Forty-one of the pro-Dreyfus votes came from the hard-Left La France Insoumise, which has been accused in recent months of anti-semitism in its unconditional support for the Palestinian cause. The centrist Modem party, the party of the prime minister François Bayrou, refused to take part. They said that the vote, sponsored by their coalition partners, Renaissance, the party of President Emmanuel Macron, gave the far-right and the hard-left a cheap opportunity to white-wash their anti-semitism. There may be some truth in that but it misses a larger point. The Dreyfus case IS partly about anti-semitism. The persecution of Captain Alfred Dreyfus persuaded Theodor Herzl, the father of Zionism, that the future for the Jewish people was the creation of a Jewish state. But 'the case' is also about something broader - something which threatens democratic values in the 2020s as much as it did in the 1890s. The trampling of the rule of law in the name of patriotism? Politics in which facts do not shape political opinions but quasi-religious beliefs establish bogus facts? We are confronted in 2025 with the same issues which the novelist Emile Zola addressed in 1898 in his celebrated front-page article on the Dreyfus case under the banner headline: 'J'accuse'. Twenty-seven years ago, in a speech to mark the centenary of Zola's article, President Jacques Chirac said: 'The Dreyfus Affair…tore French society apart, divided families, split the country into two enemy camps, which attacked each other with exceptional violence ... It was a reminder, that the forces of darkness, intolerance and injustice can penetrate to the highest levels of the state.' The last sentence is prophetic and chilling. Chirac might have been speaking about Donald Trump. Advertisement In that centenary year of the Zola article, I interviewed Nelly Wilson, a British academic who was an expert on both Zola and Dreyfus. Ms Wilson, who died in 2017, came to Britain in 1945 at the age of 15 as one of 150 young concentration camp survivors invited to settle by the UK government. 'It is perhaps not so surprising that the (Dreyfus) affair remains so vivid in the French mind,' she told me in 1998. 'It describes a conflict at the heart of French political psychology which has not changed so very much to this day. On the one hand, a fierce nationalism and a temptation to justify almost anything for raisons d'etat ; on the other hand, a fierce attachment to justice for the individual, for the rights of the individual.' Nelly Wilson believed that the Dreyfus case changed the course of French history. It discredited the forces of extreme nationalism, anti-semitism, clericalism and nostalgic royalism which might otherwise have pushed France into a kind of proto-fascism or Francoism 30 years before Hitler, Mussolini or Franco. That conflict is still with us but is no longer at the centre of French politics alone. It can be seen in the lies and law-trampling of President Trump, in the brutal creed of Vladimir Putin and in the kleptocratic rule of Viktor Orban in Hungary. Advertisement And, yes, the 'temptation to justify almost anything for raisons d'etat ' also describes the murderous and cynical forever war for his own survival waged by Benjamin Netanyahu in Israel. The Dreyfus affair has never had quite the same resonance outside France (Jewish communities apart). In the early 20th century, British newspapers wrote puzzled or mocking articles, demanding to know what all the fuss was about. The parallels are not exact but you can see similar comments today minimising the Trump administration's wrongful arrest and imprisonment in El Salvador of Kilmar Abrego Garcia. We should no longer ask why France is obsessed with Alfred Dreyfus. History has told us, and continues to tell us, that 'the case' was about more than anti-semitism and far more than the persecution of one innocent man.
LeMonde
04-06-2025
- LeMonde
Georges Didi-Huberman: 'Neither persecuted, nor refugees, nor prisoners, we are nonetheless the psychological hostages of the intolerable situation in Gaza'
Gaza or the intolerable. For months now, each day more than the last, seemingly. The situation is two, three, a thousand times intolerable. First, on a human level, of course, for what the civilian population has endured, crushed beneath the bombs of an army that, following the American model, believes it can "eradicate" (that is, uproot entirely) by indiscriminately destroying everything on the surface (houses, hospitals, women and children, journalists, ambulance workers, humanitarian personnel…). The situation is also politically intolerable, as the countless voices raised against it have proven desperately powerless, so long as American bombs continue to be delivered and used. [Prime Minister] Benjamin Netanyahu has long since stopped listening to the world around him – a deeply cynical and tactical deafness, but also suicidal at its core, apocalyptic, eliminating any possibility of a political solution to this conflict. All of this is well known, even if it must be repeated. Yet, there is a third aspect to this intolerable situation: a psychological one, I would say, particularly affecting Jews in the diaspora. Those who have never dreamed of empire, only of a civic life in whatever country they have chosen to live in. Those who do not place their Jewish existence in the crucible of a state. They do, it is true, carry the heavy burden of history, stacked in piles or half-arranged along the winding corridors of their memory. Henry Meige, a student of Jean-Martin Charcot at the Salpêtrière, in 1893 published a medical thesis on what he called the "wandering Jew syndrome": It often concerned destitute migrants who had fled pogroms in Eastern Europe and lost their minds after enduring such immense suffering. They could be recognized in the streets of Paris by the enormous bundles they carried on their backs, filled with pitiful, disparate, useless yet sentimental objects. Four decades later, after Hitler came to power, those who had not fallen victim to Nazi persecution became migrants again who endured miserable living conditions and the loss of rights, among them many great intellectuals, such as Hannah Arendt, who analyzed this condition with rigor in a now-famous essay, We Refugees (1943).
France 24
28-05-2025
- France 24
Iraq's Jewish community saves a long-forgotten shrine
A few months ago, the tomb of Rabbi Isaac Gaon was filled with rubbish. Its door was rusted, the windows shattered and the walls stained black from decades of neglect. Today, marble tiling covers the once-small grave, and at its centre stands a large tombstone inscribed with a verse, the rabbi's name and the year he died: 688. A silver menorah hangs on the wall behind it. "It was a garbage dump and we were not allowed to restore it," said the head of Iraq's Jewish community, Khalida Elyahu, 62. The Jewish community in Iraq was once one of the largest in the Middle East, but now it has dwindled to just dozens. Baghdad today has one synagogue left, but it has no rabbis. And many houses that once belonged to Jews are abandoned and dilapidated. The Jewish community itself is funding the shrine's restoration, at an estimated cost of $150,000. The project will bring "a revival for our community, both within and outside Iraq", Elyahu said. With the backing of Iraqi officials, she said she hopes to restore more neglected sites. Who was he? Little information is available about Rabbi Isaac. But when Iraq's National Security Adviser Qassem al-Araji visited the tomb earlier this year, he said the rabbi had been a finance official. Rabbi Isaac Gaon was prominent during the Gaonic period, also known as the era of Babylonian academies for rabbis. The term "Gaon" is likely to refer to his position as the head of one such academy. His name was mentioned in the 10th century by another rabbi, who told a tale that never appeared elsewhere, according to Professor Simcha Gross from the University of Pennsylvania. "There is only one single story," said Gross. It goes that Rabbi Isaac led 90,000 Jews to meet Ali Ibn Abi Talib, the fourth Islamic caliph and a relation of the Prophet Mohammed, who is also revered by Shiites as the first Imam, during one of his conquests in central Iraq. "We have no other evidence for this event, and there are reasons to be sceptical," Gross said. Nothing else is known about Rabbi Isaac, not even his religious opinions. But the tale has origins that are not without context, said Gross. In the 10th century, minorities -- Christians, Jews, and Zoroastrians -- began to tell stories of how they greeted "Muslim conquerors" because "their privileges including taxes were dependent on whether or not they were believed to have welcomed the Muslims", he said. At that same time, Jewish shrines started to appear, even though Jewish roots in Iraq date back some 2,600 years. According to biblical tradition, Jews arrived in Iraq in 586 BC as prisoners of Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar II after he destroyed Solomon's Temple in Jerusalem. In Iraq, they wrote the Babylonian Talmud. Thousands of years later, in Ottoman-ruled Baghdad, Jews made up 40 percent of the population. A turning point was the 1941 pogrom in Baghdad when more than 100 Jews were killed. Like other Jewish communities in the Arab region, their history has changed since the Palestinian Nakba -- "catastrophe" in Arabic -- and Israel's creation in 1948. Soon afterwards, almost all of Iraq's 135,000 Jews went into exile. Blessings Decades of conflict and instability -- Saddam Hussein's dictatorship, the 2003 US-led invasion and the ensuing violence -- completed the community's erosion. Some who stayed on converted to other religions, or do not reveal their faith. Today, 50 synagogues and Jewish sites remain, Elyahu said. Most are crumbling, and some have become warehouses. Rabbi Isaac's shrine once included a synagogue and a school, but has been reduced to the small room housing the grave, the restoration's supervisor said. "It took us two months to clean it of garbage," said the supervisor, who asked to remain anonymous. Now "we are receiving requests from outside Iraq to visit it". Decades ago people would come to pray and light candles, believing in the rabbi's "healing powers". Mussa Hayawi, 64, lives nearby. He recounted stories from his childhood in a quarter which was, until the 1940s, one of several Jewish districts in Baghdad. He said women used to soak themselves in water from the shrine's well, hoping to conceive. Rabbi Isaac "was a revered man". People came "to pray for their sick, to ask for a baby, or the release of a prisoner", Hayawi said. © 2025 AFP
