State education honchos must end New York's race-based STEM admissions — once and for all
But it needs to go further and drop the practice altogether.
Facing a federal lawsuit, SED will, for now, let schools enroll students in their STEM programs based just on economic need, rather than racial preferences.
But it's still fighting to preserve those preferences in court.
And schools will still be allowed to use them if they choose even in the meantime.
That's an enormous disappointment.
In this day and age, with much of public backing a level playing field on race (a Pew poll in December found Americans oppose affirmative action in colleges 50%-33%) — and with the unfairness of racial preferences so obvious — it's hugely disappointing that SED, Commissioner Betty Rosa and the Board of Regents seem so stuck in the past.
'It was unfair and racist for my daughter to be subjected to a low-income requirement just because she is Asian when her black and Hispanic classmates weren't,' fumes Yiatin Chu, a parent who spearheaded the lawsuit.
She's right. There's no good, moral reason why, say, a wealthy black or Hispanic student should get preference over a poor, struggling Asian or white kid with similar skills.
In 1985, the state legislature created the Science and Technology Entry Program to boost interest in STEM and health care among low-income and underrepresented minority high-school students.
C-STEP is aimed at college students from those groups.
Yet from its inception, the two programs openly discriminated against Asian and white students.
The Supreme Court's historic affirmative action ruling in 2023 couldn't be clearer: College admissions must be race-neutral.
Federal education law explicitly outlaws discrimination on the basis of race.
And, as Chief Justice John Roberts thundered in the majority opinion, 'Eliminating racial discrimination means eliminating all of it.' Hear, hear.
So when will New York state officials finally treat all students equally — and scrap race-based admission to its STEM programs, once and for all?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
an hour ago
- USA Today
Trump 'serious' about blocking Washington Commanders relocation to DC, White House says
WASHINGTON ― President Donald Trump isn't kidding around with his threat to the NFL's Washington Commanders, the White House says. 'The president was serious,' White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters July 21 when asked about Trump's new warning to block a proposed stadium deal that would return the Commanders to Washington if the team doesn't adopt its former name, Redskins. Washington retired the name Redskins in July 2020 amid nationwide protests over race, initially becoming the Washington Football Team for two seasons, and then rebranding as the Washington Commanders in 2022. Longtime owner Daniel Snyder in 2023 sold the team to a new ownership group led by billionaire investor Josh Harris, who has elected to keep Commanders as the name and has called the debate settled. Leavitt did not address how Trump has the power to restrict the team's planned relocation back to the site of Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Stadium in D.C., which served as Washington's home stadium from 1961 to 1996, before the team's move to Landover, Maryland. Trump's ability to unilaterally scrap the team's deal for a new stadium to return to the RFK site appears doubtful after Congress passed a law in December that transferred ownership of the RFK stadium site from the National Park Service to the District of Columbia. The $3.7 billion stadium deal, which includes $1.1 billion in local taxpayer funds, is in the hands of the D.C. Council, which is nearing a vote on the project. However, Trump has shown a willingness in other political battles to threaten federal funding from states, cities, colleges and universities to get his way. Another route could be to lobby Republicans in Congress to rescind the land transfer bill they passed last year. More: Trump threatens Washington Commanders' stadium plans if franchise doesn't change name White House doubles down on Trump's threat Leavitt pointed to Trump's reputation as a dealmaker. 'As part of the 'art of the deal,' part of his negotiating skills, as you know, sports is one of the many passions of this president and he wants to see this team's name changed,' she said. When asked to explain Trump's authority to block the Commanders' stadium deal, a White House official directed USA TODAY to Leavitt's remarks. More: DC locals on Trump's attempt to force Commanders' name change: Stay in your 'own lane' The Commanders, which enjoyed its most successful season in decades after making it to the NFC Championship Game last year, have not commented since Trump brought up the team's name in a Truth Social post on Sunday. In the same post, Trump called on another professional sports team that was previously named for native Americans ‒ the Cleveland Guardians, formerly the Indians ‒ to go back to its old name. "The Washington 'Whatever's' should IMMEDIATELY change their name back to the Washington Redskins Football Team. There is a big clamoring for this," Trump wrote. "Times are different now than they were three or four years ago. We are a Country of passion and common sense. OWNERS, GET IT DONE!!!" Trump had previously voiced support for the team's former name, but it marked the first time he has used his position to call for a name change. He followed it up with a subsequent post suggesting he might hold up the team's stadium plans if it doesn't ditch Commanders and go back to its former name. "I may put a restriction on them that if they don't change the name back to the original 'Washington Redskins,' and get rid of the ridiculous moniker, 'Washington Commanders,'" Trump wrote. "I won't make a deal for them to build a Stadium in Washington. The Team would be much more valuable, and the Deal would be more exciting for everyone." DC mayor focuses on council, not Trump Under the Constitution, Congress has authority over the District of Columbia. The District of Columbia Home Rule Act, signed by President Richard Nixon in 1973, gave the city local governance including an elected mayor and city council. However, Congress can still review all legislation passed by the D.C. Council and retains authority over the district's budget. No sign off from Trump is required for approval of the Commanders' stadium deal. Washington Mayor Muriel Bowser, who helped orchestrate the stadium deal, deflected when a reporter asked her Monday whether she believes Trump has the power to block the Commanders' stadium deal. "I think the thing that we should focus on in D.C. is doing our part," Bowser said, adding that the council still needs to approve the stadium deal. "We need to complete our part." Since returning to the White House in January, Trump has often talked about taking over the governance of D.C., a city he has long derided for crime and homelessness. Nevertheless, Trump hosted Bowser and the Commanders' Harris at the White House in May to announce Washington's National Mall would host the 2027 NFL Draft. 'I think you've seen the president gets involved in a lot of things that most presidents have not," Leavitt said when asked why changing the Commanders' name is a priority for Trump. "He's a nontraditional president. He likes to see results on behalf of the American people.' She added that Trump is getting behind something most Americans want. "If you actually poll this issue with sports fans across the country and even in this city, people actually do support the president's position on this and the name change," Leavitt said. Reach Joey Garrison on X @joeygarrison.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Former Rep. Marjorie Margolies on how motherhood prepared her for Congress
Power suits for working mom Marjorie Margolies. Emmy winner now out of Congress but she had been elected with Bill Clinton's first term and rep'd an area outside Philadelphia. Democrat. So, with stuff oozing out about unemployed Kamala, ventriloquist Jill Biden, whoever's trying to unseat Hochul, is it tougher for a woman in politics than a man? 'Yes. First off I have trouble with TV's female anchors. Like all blond. Dead of winter, wearing sleeveless dresses. And they apologize more than men. Instead, they just need to marginalize their next comment. Not repeat what's just been said. When I was born, broadcasting was not simply repeating what's just been said. There's not that kind of interest now. In my beginnings we'd spend the whole day getting both sides.' OK, so what's your background? 'I grew up as an athlete. Tried for the Olympics but that didn't work. I was basically a student. Went to Penn. Studied journalism. Worked at NPR. Then NBC. Next I got married. He had four girls already. Then we ended up with two boys. One you hear about periodically because he married Chelsea Clinton. I'd adopted two Asian girls. Next I was asked to take in a refugee boy, age 4, who's now an anesthesiologist. 'All together we had 11 kids. Things got a little complicated so I'm no longer married.' In the '90s, 'a group suggested I run for Congress.' Yeah, OK, but washing didees and shoving pablum down a kid's throat does not exactly usually ready a person for Congress. 'But I was. Immediately I noticed women added something and we should have been represented — but weren't. Women were not included on everything. We weren't on different committees we should've been on. 'To put it simply, I think guys were just not yet used to female operators.' Bucks stop here So, about today's upgrade in what's with downgrade merch in whatever grade the Hamptons is in during fund-raising time. Get opinions and commentary from our columnists Subscribe to our daily Post Opinion newsletter! Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters Sagaponack Store has: Hats, $35. Kids sweatshirt, $45. Crewnecks, $60. Hoodies, $159. Another 30 cents and you could own the place. Kids aprons, $75. T-shirts, $40. Baby bundle, $180. Blue tote, $80. Some linen something, $65. Blue Sagaponack tote, $142. Have any money left you could always hop a bus back to Madison Avenue. It's tiring being animated John Goodman, once Papa Conner with Roseanne Barr, is now Papa Smurf. He says: 'It's draining. I put my whole body into the sound to make it more authentic. I'm now tired.' The thing co-stars Rihanna, James Corden, Sandra Oh, Hannah Waddingham. Wake your own papa and take him. Senior-type husband: 'I really prefer a music concert. But I've begun to notice that if I don't get to a concert for six months, I don't notice it.' Possibly only in New York, kids, only in New York.
UPI
an hour ago
- UPI
Trump administration releases thousands of files on MLK Jr. assassination
The Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. is pictured in a photo from 1966. On Monday, the Trump administration released 230,000 files on the 1968 assassination of the civil rights leader. UPI File Photo | License Photo July 21 (UPI) -- The Trump administration on Monday released 230,000 files on the 1968 assassination of civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr. Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard announced the files' release and provided a link to the thousands of FBI records. "Today, after nearly 60 years of questions surrounding the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., we are releasing 230,000 MLK assassination files, available now at Gabbard wrote Monday in a post on X. "The documents include details about the FBI's investigation into the assassination of MLK, discussion of potential leads, internal FBI memos detailing the progress of the case, information about James Earl Ray's former cellmate who stated he discussed with Ray an alleged assassination plot, and more," Gabbard added. The release comes after Trump signed an executive order in January that also declassified records on the assassinations of former President John F. Kennedy and Sen. Robert F. Kennedy. The documents, which were stored in federal facilities for decades and released Monday -- in partnership with the Justice Department, Central Intelligence Agency, National Archives and Federal Bureau of Investigation -- have been digitized and are available for all to see. "I am grateful to President Trump and DNI Gabbard for delivering on their pledge of transparency in the release of these documents on the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr.," said his niece, Dr. Alveda King. "My uncle lived boldly in pursuit of truth and justice, and his enduring legacy of faith continues to inspire Americans to this day," she added. "While we continue to mourn his death, the declassification and release of these documents are a historic step towards the truth that the American people deserve." Besides advocating for civil rights, Martin Luther King Jr., was a Baptist minister. He was shot and killed on April 4, 1968, at Lorraine Motel in Memphis, Tenn., at the age of 39. Convicted robber and prison escapee James Earl Ray was identified as King's killer after his fingerprint was found on a rifle near the murder scene. The documents also reveal Ray's conversation with a former cellmate about the alleged assassination plot. Ray pleaded guilty to King's murder to avoid the death penalty. He was sentenced to 99 years in prison and died in custody in 1998. "Under President Trump's leadership, we are ensuring that no stone is left unturned in our mission to deliver complete transparency on this pivotal and tragic event in our nation's history," Gabbard said. "I extend my deepest appreciation to the King family for their support."
