Karen Read juror leaned guilty through trial. Here's what changed her mind
At least one juror told interviewers afterwards that she was leaning toward guilty as she met with her fellow jurors to deliberate.
Janet Jimenez, in an interview with WCVB, told the news outlet that she had filled up a notebook and a half with notes on evidence and witness testimony.
'I was hoping that my fellow jurors could help me to go through all of this,' Jimenez said during the interview. 'So I went in with a very open mind but definitely leaning toward that she was guilty.'
Read, 45, was charged with second-degree murder, manslaughter while operating under the influence and leaving the scene of an accident causing injury or death in the 2022 death of her police officer boyfriend, John O'Keefe, who was found in the snow outside the Canton home of a fellow Boston police officer.
The jury acquitted Read of the three most serious charges — second-degree murder, manslaughter, and leaving the scene of an accident — but was convicted of operating under the influence.
That verdict ended a near three-year saga as well as two trials, the first ending in a mistrial.
Jimenez, who WCVB identified as a personal trainer, said she felt it was highly likely she would be selected to be a juror because she knew almost nothing about the case — unlike many who had followed along with the first trial.
Jimenez told WCVB that she found the defense's argument about a Google search for 'hos long to die in cold' hours before O'Keefe's body was found unconvincing, and that she found lead investigator Michael Proctor's text messages about Read 'crude' but not proof of a coverup.
What eventually swayed Jimenez was when she went looking for something among the 200 pieces of evidence, but didn't find it.
Jimenez wouldn't tell WCVB what it was she was looking for, but when it didn't turn up, that was meaningful to her.
'It was one big part that led me closer to 'there's a lot of doubt,'' she said.
Jimenez and the other jurors had a long period of deliberations. Overall it took about 22 hours for the seven women and five men to come to their decision.
The jurors sent four notes to presiding judge Beverly Cannone and had a false start on Wednesday before delivering their verdict.
Jimenez said she stands by her decision.
'I'm very comfortable with how I came to the decision,' she said. 'So I guess it will be part of my story.'
That echoes another juror who has come forward, Paula Prado, who told the Today show she was convinced Read was not guilty and that 'We did the right thing.'
MassLive reporter Charlie McKenna contributed to this article.
Poll finds widespread support for Karen Read among eligible jurors
Albert, McCabe families address Karen Read trial verdict in TV interview
'We did the right thing': Juror in Karen Read retrial confident in acquittal
Karen Read's defense changed its strategy for retrial — and won
Michael Proctor to speak in 2-hour Dateline special following Karen Read trial
Read the original article on MassLive.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
9 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Volunteers flock to immigration courts to support migrants arrested in the hallways
Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up A diverse group — faith leaders, college students, grandmothers, retired lawyers, and professors — has been showing up at immigration courts across the nation to escort immigrants at risk of being detained for deportation by masked ICE officials. They're giving families moral and logistical support and bearing witness as the people are taken away. Advertisement The Northwest Immigrant Rights Project was inundated by so many community members wanting to help that they made a volunteer training video, created 'Know Your Rights' sheets in several languages, and started a Google sheet where people sign up for shifts, said Stephanie Gai, a staff attorney with the Seattle-based legal services nonprofit. Advertisement 'We could not do it without them,' Gai said. 'Some volunteers request time off work so they can come in and help.' Robby Rohr, a retired nonprofit director, said she volunteers regularly. 'Being here makes people feel they are remembered and recognized,' she said, 'It's such a bureaucratic and confusing process. We try to help them through it.' Volunteers and legal aid groups have long provided free legal orientation in immigration court, but the arrests have posed new challenges. Since May, the government has been asking judges to dismiss deportation cases. Once the judge agrees, ICE officials arrest them in the hallways and put them in fast-track deportation proceedings, no matter which legal immigration pathway they may have been pursuing. Once in custody, it's often harder to find or afford a lawyer. Immigration judges are executive branch employees, and while some have resisted Homeland Security lawyers' dismissal orders in some cases, many are granted. Masked ICE agents grabbed the Colombian man and led him into the hallway. A volunteer took his backpack to give to his family as he was taken away. Other cases on the day's docket involved immigrants who didn't show up. Parchert granted 'removal in absentia' orders, enabling ICE to arrest them later. When asked about these arrests and the volunteers at immigration courts, a senior spokesperson with the Department of Homeland Security said ICE is once again implementing the rule of law by reversing '[President Joe] Biden's catch and release policy that allowed millions of unvetted illegal aliens to be let loose on American streets.' Some volunteers have recorded arrests in courtroom hallways, traumatic scenes that are proliferating online. How many similar scenes are happening nationwide remains unclear. The Executive Office for Immigration Review has not released numbers of cases dismissed or arrests made at or near immigration courts. Advertisement While most volunteers have done this work without incident, some have been arrested for interfering with ICE agents. New York City Comptroller and Democratic mayoral candidate Brad Lander was arrested after locking arms with a person in a failed attempt to prevent his detention. Lander's wife, attorney Meg Barnette, had just joined him in walking migrants from a courtroom to the elevator. The volunteers' act of witnessing has proven to be important as people disappear into a detention system that can seem chaotic, leaving families without any information about their whereabouts for days on end. In a waiting room serving New York City immigration courtrooms, a Spanish-speaking woman with long, dark, curly hair was sitting anxiously with her daughter after she and her husband had separate hearings. Now he was nowhere to be found. The Rev. Fabián Arias, a volunteer court observer, said the woman, whose first name is Alva, approached him asking, 'Where is my husband?' She showed him his photo. 'ICE detained him,' Arias told her, and tried to comfort her as she trembled, later welling up with tears. A judge had not dismissed the husband's case, giving him until October to find a lawyer. But that didn't stop ICE agents from handcuffing him and taking him away as soon as he stepped out of court. The news sparked an outcry by immigration advocates, city officials, and a congressman. At a news conference, she gave only her first name and asked that her daughter's be withheld. Brianna Garcia, a college student in El Paso, Texas, said she's been attending immigration court hearings for weeks where she informs people of their rights and then records ICE agents taking people into custody. Advertisement 'We escort people so they're not harassed and help people memorize important phone numbers, since their belongings are confiscated by ICE,' she said. Paris Thomas began volunteering at the Denver immigration court after hearing about the effort through a network of churches. Wearing a straw hat, he recently waited in the midday heat for people to arrive for afternoon hearings. Thomas handed people a small paper flyer listing their rights in Spanish on one side and English on the other. One man walking with a woman told him, 'Thank you. Thank you.' Another man gave him a hug. Denver volunteer Don Marsh said they offer to walk people to their cars after court appearances, so they can contact attorneys and family if ICE arrests them. Marsh said he's never done anything like this before but wants to do something to preserve the nation's 'rule of law' now that unidentifiable government agents are 'snatching' people off the streets. 'If we're not all safe, no one's safe,' he said.
Hamilton Spectator
9 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
‘Dangerous' 14-year-old boy suspected in stabbing death of 71-year-old woman at North York plaza
Police temporarily identified a 14-year-old boy as the suspect in the unprovoked stabbing death of a woman as she loaded groceries into her car on Thursday morning . At a news conference Friday evening, Toronto police said they believe the suspect intended to rob 71-year-old Shahnaz Pestonji who died from stab wounds she suffered at a North York plaza in the Parkway Forest Drive and Sheppard Avenue East area. Pestonji's devastated family on Friday described her as an 'angel on this Earth .' 'We now believe this was a robbery that escalated to a deadly attack,' said Det. Matthew Pinfold. The federal Youth Criminal Justice Act prohibits identifying suspects under the age of 18. Toronto police said they obtained judicial authorization to temporarily release the male's name and photo. Police say Thursday's stabbing was unprovoked, and that the suspect — who is wanted for second-degree murder — is still at large. 'I want to be very clear, do not approach this individual. He is considered dangerous,' Pinfold said. 'If you see someone matching his description, or if you have any information about his whereabouts, please call 911 immediately.' Pinfold said the youth was last seen Thursday around noon at the TTC's Kennedy Station, and is possibly still in the transit system. He also said police were able to track his movements from Don Mills Station, and to and from the crime scene, through video surveillance. 'I can't nail it down to an exact area of the city, but he is, as far as we know, very knowledgeable of the city, and especially riding the transit system,' he said. Pinfold spoke directly to the suspect: ' I am directing you to turn yourself in immediately. We are actively looking for you, and we will find you.' A number of videos claiming to show the suspect are circulating on social media. Toronto police did not confirm if the videos are legitimate. 'We are aware of the videos circulating online. This remains an active investigation, and we are urging anyone who has any information to contact the police,' a police spokesperson told the Star in an email. The suspect is described as five-foot-seven, 135 pounds with a skinny build. He was wearing black pants and a black hooded sweatshirt with the writing 'New York — 555' on the front in white, police said in a news release Friday . He was last seen wearing a balaclava-style face covering with his hood up and carrying a black satchel. With files from Elissa Mendes Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Hamilton Spectator
10 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Vehicle found in river north of Montreal could be linked to missing person case
MONTREAL - Police north of Montreal say a vehicle found in the Mille-Îles river on Sunday could be linked to the case of a Laval man who went missing in 1988. Deux-Montagnes police say they are looking into the discovery, reported to police by a diving group known as Exploring With a Mission. The group searches waterways for missing people and says they located a vehicle on the bottom of the river with bones inside. Group member William McIntosh says he believes the vehicle is the tan Jeep Cherokee Chief belonging to Robert St-Louis, a 42-year-old father of five last seen in June 1988. Police say they requested the assistance of Quebec provincial police divers because the vehicle might be linked to a missing person case. Laval police says its crimes against persons division will try to confirm whether any human remains recovered from the site can be identified. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 20, 2025. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
