Yorke Peninsula Council reviews $3.8m Marion Bay boat ramp over safety concerns
Edithburgh Sea Rescue Squadron commander Brian Klingberg is among waterway users who have urged Yorke Peninsula Council to improve the safety of the new boat ramp at Marion Bay.
While the council defended its consultation process, on Friday it agreed to reopen the old ramp as an temporary solution.
It came after councillors voted last Wednesday to remove the new ramp's wave attenuation wall, which was supposed to reduce water movement, a change that will result in wider entry ways.
The council will also look to raise the height of the central walkway between the two ramps which, according to a report presented at the meeting, "appears to be blocking the natural flow of sand and seaweed … leading to a build-up".
The report also said $303,000 was left in the budget, but a quote was still being sought for further works.
It remains unclear how much more money will be spent to improve the new design.
Construction on the new ramp finished in April, two years after the state government chipped in $3.04 million of the total cost.
However, Recreational Fishing SA executive officer Asher Dezsery said he was aware of at least six fishers who damaged their vessels within a fortnight of opening.
Mr Dezsery said the biggest problem was posed by the pylons on either side of the walkway, which formed part of the "wave attenuation wall", but created a collision hazard in rough weather.
The project includes two ramps either side of a walkway, one measuring four metres wide and the other six metres wide.
"You don't have any movement or forgiveness as such, because you've got those poles and the pontoon itself," he said.
"When you've got a really big boat, and some of these boats are worth $500,000 or $600,000, you've got nowhere to go.
He added that RecFish SA was not approached for its opinion about the final design.
Mr Klingberg, a Sea Rescue member of more than 20 years, described it as a "crushing hazard".
"Not being an engineer, I think what they should have done is involve the locals down there," he said.
"There are plenty of people who have used those facilities for 30, 40 years, and they're the ones who should have been consulted.
"We didn't know anything about the design until it was all there."
A Yorke Peninsula Council spokesperson said between August and September 2022, "more than 200 individuals who had previously corresponded with council about the ramp were contacted directly".
"A media release was also issued via the council's website and promoted through Facebook, reaching more than 27,000 people and resulting in over 650 visits to the project webpage," the spokesperson said.
"Council received 39 formal submissions. Of these, 56 per cent supported the concept design, 26 per cent opposed it, and 18 per cent provided neutral or mixed feedback.
According to the council's website, two years' worth of coastal modelling data was also obtained before construction commenced.
Marion Bay Rentals owner Brett Davies was pleased the old ramp had been reopened, given the algae bloom was already hurting business.
"We've had a number of guests that have been coming down for 10 years, and I've had three of them state that they won't come back because of the ramp," Mr Davies said.
"I've had quite a few phone calls where guests are asking me if the boat ramp is safe to launch and my answer is, 'If you're launching by yourself, it's going to be a challenge'.
"We're 60 per cent down [in bookings] from the same period last year, and I'm not saying that's all because of the ramp, but going forward, I think time will tell, and I think it will have a huge impact if people think they're going to damage their boats."
The ABC also contacted SA Police asking if water rescue officers had voiced safety concerns, but a spokesperson declined to comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
2 days ago
- ABC News
How distance, disadvantage and the digital divide impact country schooling
When Rob Berlin received his teaching registration, his phone began buzzing with job offers almost immediately. "Because my location … came up on a register, people were watching it and went 'I'm going to give this guy a call, see if he's interested in a job'," he says. But Rob already had a job. The former engineer, based in regional South Australia, was training to become a maths and science teacher as part of the Teach for Australia program. The program gave him work and income while he got experience in a country school and undertook an accelerated learning program to complete his master's degree in teaching. Under the program, Rob was contracted to a rural school, about 450 kilometres south of Adelaide, for a two-year placement. Two years later, he is still working there. The fact that teachers like Rob are in such hot demand in rural and remote areas of Australia tells one part of the story behind a persistent disparity in student achievement levels across the country. The latest NAPLAN results reinforced a decades-long trend in students located further from cities having poorer educational outcomes. While the NAPLAN standardised test is viewed with a degree of caution — critics say the point-in-time test is not necessarily an accurate reflection of a student's overall learning progress or potential — it does provide governments with data to assess educational outcomes across geographic areas and socio-economic backgrounds. Since its introduction in 2008, it has consistently shown if a young person attends school in a regional or remote area, they are more likely to underperform on a range of measures. "Every year when NAPLAN is released, we see the same trend, which is proving very difficult for governments to address," explained The University of Melbourne's Glenn Savage, professor of education futures. Educators, unions and experts point to a range of factors contributing to the divide, including entrenched socio-economic disadvantage, difficulties in accessing allied health specialists and support services, childcare deserts, housing shortages and digital connectivity. Then there is the critical shortage of teachers across the country, which is felt most keenly beyond the cities. In regional Western Australia, school principals say a dire lack of experienced teaching staff is the number one issue affecting their students' education. Kevin Brady has worked in country schools for decades. He is currently principal of Gingin high school, north of Perth, and president of the state's regional principals Association. Mr Brady said schools and principals were working hard and being creative in their response to the staffing crisis, including combining classes and principals and deputy principals stepping into classrooms to replace absent teachers. "We have schools that are cancelling programs or cancelling specific options for students, because they can't staff those opportunities, and we've got schools where other programs … are just simply not being provided," Mr Brady said. Before Rob Berlin started at his current school, there hadn't been a specialist maths, science teacher on staff for a couple of years. "They were utilising other teachers outside of their teaching background to take on those classes and that's happening more and more," Mr Berlin said. "I've heard other conversations with teachers that aren't maths trained, but they've been given a maths class and they've got to try and do the best that they can. "It's like a language, if you're not familiar with a language you are not familiar with the small connotations and other aspects of it that really give it meaning. "Teaching … another subject I wasn't familiar with, it would be quite difficult." Australian Education Union deputy federal president Meredith Peace said teacher shortages were a problem across the country, but were exacerbated in rural and remote schools. She said those schools also faced greater difficulty accessing non-teaching specialists to support students' learning. "So, whether they're looking for psychologists, speech therapists, people to support the welfare and mental health needs of students … all of those things are much more difficult for those schools to attract the staff they need," Ms Peace said. Ms Peace said it was common for teachers to be teaching out of their field, for classes to be split and for students to join other classes when a teacher was absent and unable to be replaced, leading to a disruptive experience for students and additional workload on other teachers. The union is calling for increased funding to ensure "that growing up in a rural, regional community doesn't mean that you just accept that you're in a disadvantaged cohort and your needs aren't necessarily met". "It's not good enough that we continue to see those [regional and rural] kids — as well as some of our other cohorts of kids — lagging behind when we know with the appropriate funding and support and staff, we could better meet the needs of those kids," Ms Peace said. South Australian teacher Mr Berlin said it was students who sat outside the middle range — either those with complex or high-level learning support needs, or those who were excelling and required extension or enrichment beyond the standard curriculum — who missed out the most. He said in a regional setting it was harder for both these student groups to access specialised support. For parents like Nikki Mahony, who lives near Theodore in central Queensland, it's not just about a lack of teachers, but a lack of experienced teachers in country schools. Ms Mahony represents other rural parents on the Isolated Childrens Parents Association (ICPA), a non-profit group that advocates for the educational needs of children in rural areas. She says it tends to be younger, early career teachers who head out to bush schools, often without access to appropriate levels of support. "The key is the experienced teachers who tend to have the knowledge and experience in being able to prepare lessons that can be targeted and can account for specific differences," Ms Mahony said. ICPA's Queensland state president Wendy Henning said a shortage of local housing, as well as childcare deserts in regional towns, made it hard for educators with families of their own to make the move. "If they've got young ones, if there's no child care they can't go out into the regions, because they are losing that network of support," Ms Henning said. In Theodore, for example, there's no housing available for teachers with families — Ms Henning says it's a similar story in many other small towns across regional Queensland. When the staffing shortage peaked in the wake of the COVID pandemic, around 2022, New South Wales recorded more than 2,400 teacher vacancies in public schools. The state has seen improvement in overall teacher vacancies in the past two years, but still had 962 unfilled positions at the start of the current school term. According to figures provided to the ABC by state and territory education departments, there has been a similar pattern elsewhere, with vacancies easing slightly since 2022. In recent years measures to recruit teachers to regional schools have been introduced or expanded, with governments offering a range of salary and career incentives, subsidised housing and other benefits, like additional leave entitlements. A NSW program provides inducements for teachers to work in hard-to-staff schools, the majority of which are in regional and rural areas. In some circumstances, the education department says an eligible teacher can receive incentives to the value of $75,000-$80,000 in the first year of their appointment. West Australian principal Mr Brady said incentives were creating their own problems in his state, drawing teachers to specific schools and creating shortages in other areas — even in places that were once considered desirable locations to work, like the state's south-west. Teachers in Queensland recently went on strike for the first time in 16 years, after stalled negotiations with the state government over pay and conditions. Queensland Teachers Union president Cresta Richardson said the industrial action was aimed at ensuring the best teachers possible "not just for the city, but for the country as well". Melbourne University's Glenn Savage said attracting and retaining teaching staff was only one factor in addressing the gap between educational outcomes for country and city students. He described "a tinderbox of disadvantage" that regional students face, including access to specialist support, access to technology and reliable internet, as well as socio-economic disadvantage, which he said was the number one predictor of student outcomes. "It's like a wicked policy problem," Professor Savage said. "It's really difficult to shift and unfortunately in a country as vast and geographically expansive as Australia, it will always be a challenge while we have schools in these areas. "A school teacher or a school leader can't be expected to go and fix all society's problems so they can work within the wheelhouse of their role and do the best that they can." Professor Savage said there were some good national policies aimed at improving learning, including initiatives in the National Teacher Workforce Action Plan. But he said with regional schools facing specific challenges based on their unique location, demographics, culture and histories, a one-size-fits-all approach was not ideal. He suggested policies that place the local school at the heart of the community could help achieve change. "There's a lot of research globally … suggesting that to deal with some of these wicked problems, you've got to have a more holistic approach around how education, health and other sectors can work together," Professor Savage said. "If you think of the school as like a community hub, [it] can become a central point through which these different networks can come together." Andres Molina, a senior research fellow at Victoria University's Mitchell Institute, said a model of "full service schools" had proven successful in achieving results in disadvantaged areas in the United Kingdom and the United States. Under the model, schools delivered meal programs, transport, health, wellbeing and other services to the community. "The whole idea is to provide a set of additional activities and resources and services support for children to be able to attend school," Dr Molina said. "It's a beautiful initiative … to bring the school closer to the community and … allow students who face these barriers to come to school ready to learn."
ABC News
06-08-2025
- ABC News
Drought-hit farmer uses own superannuation to start circular fodder fund
Unable to afford a full semi-trailer load of hay but needing more feed than charities are often able to provide, farmers such as Bridget Woods are among those falling between the gaps during South Australia's ongoing drought. The Peterborough livestock producer has resorted to dipping into her own superannuation to pay in bulk for hay for her struggling community. Over the space of four months, Ms Woods estimates she has spent "probably $80,000" of her own super on trucked-in fodder, while struggling herself to feed her nearly 200 animals, including about 80 cattle and 100 ewes. "A lot of people have only got small numbers of stock left, and even getting a semi load of hay out, the cost behind that at the moment is astronomical," Ms Woods said. "If you've only got a few sheep or cattle left you don't need a full semi load, so the idea was to source it and then people be able to share in loads." Though there was interest within the community to share a load, it had to be paid up-front. Ms Woods decided she had two options: "Ask people to believe in me enough to hand over $5,000 for a truckload of hay" or buy it all her own and hope they paid her back. "I didn't have any other options," she said. She took a leap of faith and a chunk out of her super and funded four separate deliveries. As farmers bought feed from her in smaller amounts, she was able to recuperate her costs. The circular model she set up proved to be an efficient solution, and one Ms Woods said could be adopted by other communities struggling with the drought. "The charities, they drop off four or five bales, which is absolutely wonderful and much needed, but it doesn't fix your problem," Ms Woods said. For now, Ms Woods said she could not afford any more load-sharing deliveries on her own, but alongside local Eileen Martin, she founded the Peterborough Drought Ready Group, which has been seeking funding. The group is working towards measures to improve resilience in drought management and support the community. "This is not our last drought," Ms Woods said. "This region goes in drought really commonly, but it could be [for] six months. So it's not a crisis point in six months. "It's probably been at crisis point for maybe 18 months." Ms Woods estimated she has lost about 20 sheep this season, four horses, and about 18 cows, with a majority of the losses related to the drought. "Some days you're feeling sick driving into the paddock wondering what you're going to deal with today," she said. "Who are you going to have to drag out of a water trough? Who are you going to have to shoot? "You go out, you deal with that, you come home, and then you've got to move on like nothing has happened. "It's tough. It's really tough." One person who has received feed from Ms Woods is Amee Dennis, who has about 100 animals at Quentin Park Alpacas and Studio Gallery, a working farm and agritourism experience. Her animals go through nearly three bales of hay a week, but she was allocated just one bale when the Rapid Relief Team delivered 1,200 bales to Jamestown on June 6 in a charity hay run. "In theory, it looks like there's a whole lot of support, but the reality of that is if you are slightly outside of the box, or a smaller producer rather than a large one, there isn't," Ms Dennis said. She said several drought relief supports on offer from the government had strict eligibility requirements, including a need to be on the government's Farm Household Allowance. "There are a number of us that can't receive the Farm Household Allowance or aren't eligible for it because we've had to go and do contract work, which means the majority of our income this year is not from the farm," she said. "And then you've got people like me whose income comes from the farm, but then [it] isn't [in] a standard way, so it's not the right tick box." Ms Dennis previously had an ongoing contract to receive 100 bales annually from a supplier, but he ran out 12 months ago. Since then, she has gone from travelling 20 minutes for hay, to an hour, to two, to now being unable to find any. One year ago she was spending about $350 a week on feed. That has risen to $1,200. "There has essentially been this stress every week of, 'Where are we going to get it this week?'" South Australia has finally started to receive some rain in recent weeks, with 95 millimetres falling in Peterborough in July. But by no means has the drought broken, and Ms Dennis knows from experience there is still a long way to go. In the meantime, Ms Woods said the Peterborough Drought Ready Group needs support. "We need sponsors, we need, I don't know," she said. "We need a f***ing miracle."
ABC News
02-08-2025
- ABC News
ABC News SA: DV leader speaks ahead of royal commission findings
ABC News SA ABC NEWS News Bulletin Informative Watch Article share options Share this on Facebook Twitter Send this by Email Copy link WhatsApp Messenger News from where we live. ABC News SA brings you the day's top stories, exclusive investigations and original reporting on issues that matter to you. Presented by Jessica Harmsen, plus Richard Davies, Candice Prosser, Bethanie Alderson, Isabel Dayman and the team.
