Erin Patterson found guilty of murder in deadly mushroom case
After a nine-week trial in the Victorian Supreme Court, the 50-year-old was convicted over the deaths of Don and Gail Patterson and Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson.
They all died following a beef Wellington lunch in July 2022.
A fourth guest, Pastor Ian Wilkinson, survived after weeks in hospital and a liver transplant. Patterson was found guilty of his attempted murder.
A jury has found Victorian woman Erin Patterson guilty of murder, nearly two years after a family lunch ended in tragedy. (Source: 1News)
ADVERTISEMENT
Prosecutors told the jury this was a targeted act, alleging Patterson knowingly served death cap mushrooms, kept herself safe from harm, and fabricated a story to mislead police and health officials.
They pointed to shifting accounts, deleted phone data, a dumped food dehydrator and internet searches about poisonous fungi.
Patterson admitted lying at times, including claiming she had cancer and giving conflicting stories about the mushrooms' source. But she insisted the meal was never intended to harm, calling it a 'horrible mistake'.
Erin Patterson found guilty after weeks-long trial, TVNZ+
She testified for eight days in her own defence, denying intent and growing emotional when describing her relationship with the victims.
Her defence lawyer argued the Crown's case lacked motive and relied on circumstantial evidence. But the jury was ultimately convinced beyond reasonable doubt that Patterson intended to kill or seriously harm her guests.
She will now be sentenced, bringing to a close — pending appeal — one of the most complex cases in recent Australian history.
ADVERTISEMENT
Timeline of the case
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers, left, with an illustration of Erin Patterson. Composite image by Crystal Choi. (Source: 1News)
July 29, 2022 - Erin Patterson hosts a lunch at her Leongatha home, about 135km from Melbourne. On the menu: beef Wellington. Four guests fall violently ill.
August 4, 2022 - Don and Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson die. Pastor Ian Wilkinson survives after weeks in hospital and a liver transplant.
November 2, 2023 - Erin Patterson is charged with three counts of murder and one of attempted murder.
April 29, 2025 - The trial begins in Morwell, Victoria. Over the next nine weeks, the court hears from police, forensic experts, mushroom specialists and family.
June 2025 - Patterson testifies over eight days, denying intent but admitting to multiple lies.
Late June 2025 - Closing arguments are delivered. The jury begins deliberations.
July 7, 2025 - The jury delivers its decision: Guilty.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
6 hours ago
- 1News
WWI veteran's medals returned to grandson after theft
World War I medals stolen from the mailbox of a veteran's grandson have been anonymously returned to a war memorial museum in Wellsford, police say. The medals belonging to decorated soldier Elmer James Conlon were discovered in the returns bin at Wellsford War Memorial Museum yesterday. On Wednesday, grandson Pat Conlon made a report to police after the valuable parcel, containing the medals, was allegedly stolen from his mailbox. Pat told Breakfast earlier this week the theft was "gut-wrenching". Police then appealed to the public for information that could help locate the medals, or for any locals to report if they'd seen any suspicious activity in the area on the date of the theft. Photographs of Pat Conlon's grandfather, Elmer James Conlon. (Source: 1News) ADVERTISEMENT Yesterday, police were contacted by Wellsford War Memorial Museum staff "advising that the medals had been located in their returns bin". Senior Sergeant Damian Lawn said it appeared someone had dropped them off overnight at the museum. "We're pleased that whoever took these medals did the right thing and returned them – obviously they are hugely significant to Mr Conlon and we are glad to be able to reunite him with them," he said in a media release. Police have fingerprinted the medals and are continuing inquiries into the theft. Earlier, police had established the parcel had been delivered on July 1, but had then gone missing before the war veteran's grandson could collect it. 'Gut-wrenching' loss for veteran's grandson Speaking to Breakfast earlier this week, before the medals were found, Pat said it was "gut-wrenching" to have his grandfather's war medals stolen moments before he was due to be reunited with them after more than 40 years. ADVERTISEMENT Pat Conlon said his grandfather's medals were stolen moments before he was due to pick them up after more than 40 years. (Source: Breakfast) The medals had been lost to the family for decades but, after a long search, they were finally tracked down and sent by courier to Pat. Just metres from their destination, the priceless family heirloom was stolen from a rural mailbox near Wellsford — before Pat could reach them. 'They were the only thing I had from my grandfather,' Pat said. 'To think they were finally coming back built my hopes up — I was overjoyed about the whole thing.' Elmer James Conlon, originally from Brooklyn, New York, served in the American Navy aboard the battleship Louisiana. He "jumped ship" in Auckland, New Zealand, and eventually settled in the small Northland town of Herekino. To gain New Zealand citizenship, Elmer fought in the First World War, including at the Battle of the Somme, where he was awarded the Distinguished Conduct Medal for his service. He is buried in the Soldiers' Section at Hamilton Gardens. Additional reporting by Marlo Donoghue ADVERTISEMENT
1News
a day ago
- 1News
German backpacker flagged down motorist leading to discovery
A German backpacker was "extremely lucky" to flag down a motorist which led to her discovery after spending nearly two weeks in the rugged Australian outback. Carolina Wilga, 26, was last seen at a general store in the Western Australian wheatbelt town of Beacon on June 29, some 300km northeast of Perth. Her disappearance triggered a massive search after a desperate plea for help from her mother amid concerns for her daughter's safety. Late on Friday afternoon, she managed to flag down a passing motorist who alerted the police that Wilga was alive. "Extremely lucky and we're extremely grateful to that member of the community who helped us," WA Police Acting Inspector Jessica Securo told Nine's Today Show on Saturday. ADVERTISEMENT She was distressed, exhausted, dehydrated and needed some food when she was found. "Overall, [she was] just relieved that she had come across someone and was able to get that help," Insp Securo said. The WA outback area has "challenging" terrains and Securo said Wilga likely thought she was never going to come across someone for help, but luckily she did. Wilga was flown to a hospital in Perth for medical treatment after being ravaged by mosquitoes while spending days lost in tough terrain, where temperatures dropped to zero at night. "She's receiving some medical attention and just some emotional support," Securo said. "She was out in the wilderness for about 11 days so she's going to need some support wrapped around her." New images of Carolina Wilga's bogged van on Friday showed just how badly bogged and remote it was when the backpacker decided to abandon it. (Source: Nine) ADVERTISEMENT WA Police had earlier said Wilga "covered a lot of ground" during her "amazing journey" and it was a testimony to her bravery. "I think once we do hear her story, it will be a remarkable story," Inspector Martin Glynn told reporters on Friday. "She's obviously coped in some amazing conditions. As to whether Wilga will continue her great Australian adventure after the ordeal, WA Police said she will likely take some time to recover. "Her priority is just getting that medical care," Securo said. "She is in touch with her family. "... we'll let things settle for a little while and then she'll reassess from there." ADVERTISEMENT Wilga's Mitsubishi van was found in dense bushland on Thursday in the Karroun Hill Nature Reserve, about 35km from the main track. It was bogged in mud following rain and she had tried to free it but had apparently failed. Wilga left the car in an attempt to seek help elsewhere. Authorities combed the surrounding area on foot and by air but were unable to find her. Wilga's mother previously pleaded for anyone with information about her daughter to contact authorities. WA Premier Roger Cook said the news of Wilga's survival "is nothing short of remarkable" and thanks emergency services and those who searched. ADVERTISEMENT "We're yet to have the full picture of what happened, but tonight, we can all breathe a little easier knowing Carolina is safe and well," he posted on social media.
1News
a day ago
- 1News
German backpacker found alive after two weeks lost in Australian bush
A "brave" German backpacker is recovering in hospital after being found alive following almost two weeks missing in the Australian outback. Carolina Wilga, 26, was last seen at a general store in the Western Australian wheatbelt town of Beacon on June 29, some 300km northeast of Perth. Her disappearance triggered a massive search after a desperate plea for help from her mother amid concerns for her daughter's safety. Late on Friday afternoon, she was found walking on a bush track by a member of the public. German backpacker Carolina Wilga. (Source: WA Police) ADVERTISEMENT "She's obviously been through a great deal," WA Police Inspector Martin Glynn told reporters. "She does have some injuries. She's been ravaged by mosquitoes." Wilga was flown to a hospital in Perth for medical treatment after spending days lost in tough terrain, where temperatures dropped to zero at night. "I think once we do hear her story, it will be a remarkable story," Inspector Glynn said, adding that it was a "great result" for the backpacker's family and those involved in the search. "She's obviously coped in some amazing conditions. "There's a very hostile environment out there, both from flora and fauna. It's a really, really challenging environment." Glynn said Wilga had "covered a lot of ground" during her "amazing journey" and it was a testimony to her bravery. ADVERTISEMENT Wilga did not appear to have any serious injuries, but she had a lot of minor ones, he said. "She's endured a lot... [and is] in quite a fragile condition," he said. New images of Carolina Wilga's bogged van on Friday showed just how badly bogged and remote it was when the backpacker decided to abandon it. (Source: Nine) Wilga's Mitsubishi van was found in dense bushland on Thursday in the Karroun Hill Nature Reserve, about 35km from the main track. "It's a miracle they've actually spotted the car, to be honest," IGlynn said earlier. It was bogged in mud following rain and she had tried to free it but had apparently failed. Authorities combed the surrounding area on foot and by air but were unable to find Ms Wilga. ADVERTISEMENT Wilga's mother previously pleaded for anyone with information about her daughter to contact authorities. WA Premier Roger Cook said the news of Wilga's survival "is nothing short of remarkable" and thanks emergency services and those who searched. "To our emergency services and everyone who searched, shared information, and supported the family through this ordeal — thank you." he posted on social media. "We're yet to have the full picture of what happened, but tonight, we can all breathe a little easier knowing Carolina is safe and well."
