&w=3840&q=100)
Southern Railway used faulty coaches in 2023 Nilgiri train: CAG flags risk
"Ministry of Railways may develop a robust mechanism for development of prototype coaches in consultation with RDSO and only after successful trial run, regular production of coaches should be started to avoid creation of ineffective and deficient coaches," the CAG said in its recommendations and observed that it didn't get any reply from the ministry on the said issue.
The full report contained 25 audit findings from various railway zones across the country and pointed out cases of undercharges or overpayments of Rs 543.17 crore.
One of the audit findings with regard to the Nilgiri Mountain Railway (NMR) under Southern Railways (SR) has not only pointed out financial deficiency worth Rs 27.91 crore but also highlighted how "Railway's improper decision which is in the nature of compromising the safety of the passengers by introducing the deficient coaches to serve as Special train without sanction of the Ministry of Railways, is also a serious lapse on the part of the Railways." The audit said that to replace the 100-year-old 28 coaches, operational between 45.88-km-long Mettupalayam and Udagamandalam stations, SR approached the Railway Ministry in May 2015 to advise Integral Coach Factory (ICF) to design and develop a prototype coach to suit NMR.
The ministry advised ICF in July 2015 to manufacture a prototype coach for NMR in consultation with Research, Design and Standards Organisation (RDSO), based on inputs given by SR.
ICF initially manufactured 15 coaches and delivered them to SR after which a trial run was conducted from Mettupalayam to Udagamandalam on April 2, 2019, with the first four coaches. The report noticed that the trial was not conducted on the section having a gradient.
"SR noticed (March 2020) that there was an increase in weight of the new coaches by around 5 tonnes each and advised ICF to reduce the weight in the remaining 13 coaches yet to be manufactured. However, no action was taken by ICF in this regard and 13 more NMR coaches were manufactured and delivered to SR in three lots," the report said.
It added that in all, 28 NMR coaches were manufactured by ICF and delivered to SR at a total cost of Rs 27.91 crore, but the freezing of the design, layouts and manufacturing of these coaches were done without any consultation with RDSO and also without ascertaining the manufacturing and successful trial of the prototype coach.
The report found that the SR modified six coaches, but even after modification, wheel slip in the locomotive was experienced during the trial run in the gradient section despite the weather being supportive with clear skies and dry weather.
"Despite deficiencies noticed in the trial run, SR introduced weekly special train services from 15/7/2023 between MTP (Mettupalayam) and UAM (Udagamandalam) with the newly manufactured NMR coaches which were put to use in the special trains. Presently (May 2024), 15 out of the total 28 new NMR coaches have been put to use for operation as weekly special trains without approval of the Railway Board," the CAG report said.
It added, "Thus, an imprudent decision was taken to manufacture 28 new NMR coaches without any consultation with RDSO and also without ascertaining the manufacturing and successful trial of the prototype coach despite clear instruction of MoR (July 2015)." The audit has stated that freezing the design and layout by SR and manufacturing the coaches by ICF without addressing the core issues of weight of the coaches and hauling capacity of the locomotive was also a premature decision, which was attributed to the manufacturing of these deficient coaches.
Hence, the coaches manufactured at a cost of 27.91 crore could not be put to effective use even after the lapse of more than three years of manufacturing, the audit report stated.
It has also expressed dissatisfaction with the response of the Southern Railways, which said that deficiencies noticed during the trial run were advised to ICF for rectification.
"As regards operation of new NMR coaches, it was stated that 18 coaches are being used in weekend/joyride special trains and further service will be improved once sanction is received from the Railway Board," the report said regarding SR responses.
"The reply of the SR Administration was not acceptable. Nothing has been stated in the reply regarding manufacturing of 28 new NMR coaches without any consultation with RDSO and also without ascertaining the manufacturing and successful trial of the prototype coach despite clear instruction of MoR," the audit said.
It added, "Further it is evident from the reply of the SR administration that the deficient coaches were put to use for operation without obtaining sanction from the Railway Board.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


News18
an hour ago
- News18
Lottery Results Today Live, July 23, 2025: Punjab, Manipur, Sikkim, Goa & Arunachal Winning Numbers
Live July 23, 2025 Lottery Results: Check the full list of winning numbers for Punjab, Manipur, Goa, Sikkim, and Arunachal Pradesh state lottery here. Live July 23, 2025 Lottery Results: Lotteries in states like Punjab, Manipur, Goa and Arunachal Pradesh continue to attract participants from both urban and rural areas, all dreaming of a big win. With multiple draws scheduled at various times during the day, these states offer daily chances for players to try their luck. Here's a closer look at the key lottery draws lined up today. Punjab State Dear 10 Silver Wednesday Weekly Lottery Scheme This lottery is officially authorised for sale within Punjab and in other states where lotteries are legally permitted. Key Highlights: First Prize: Rs 1 Lakh Total Tickets: 1,00,000, distributed across ten series (from 90 to 99), with each series numbered from 0000 to 9999 Ticket Price: Rs 10 (inclusive of all taxes) Draw Schedule: Held every Saturday at 6:00 PM in Ludhiana, starting from October 7, 2023. The Director of Punjab State Lotteries reserves the right to change the draw's date, time, or venue if required. For prizes over Rs 10,000, winners must file their claims within 30 days from the date of result publication in the Punjab State Government Gazette. Claimants must fill out the official prize claim form and submit it to: Director, Punjab State Lotteries Vit te Yojna Bhawan, Plot No. 2B, Sector 33-A, Chandigarh – 160020 Modes of Submission: Claims submitted after the 30-day period will be handled according to the Punjab State Lotteries Regulation Rules, 2015, and other applicable legal guidelines. Punjab State Dear 50 Buster Wednesday Weekly Lottery This lottery is officially approved for sale in Punjab and in other states where lottery operations are legally allowed. Key Details: First Prize: Rs 25 Lakh Total Tickets: 5,00,000 tickets distributed across five series — A, B, C, D, and E — each series numbered from 00000 to 99999 (1,00,000 tickets per series). The total number of printed tickets will not exceed the limit approved under the scheme. Ticket Price: Rs 50 per ticket (inclusive of all applicable taxes) Draw Schedule: The weekly draw will be held every Wednesday at 6:00 PM, beginning July 29, 2025, at the Camp Office in Ludhiana. The Director of Punjab State Lotteries holds the authority to change the draw's date, time, or venue if required. How to Submit Claims: In person Through a nationalised bank Via registered post As an insured parcel Claims submitted after the 30-day deadline will be processed in accordance with the Punjab State Lotteries Regulation Rules, 2015, and other relevant legal provisions. Manipur State Lottery The Manipur State Lottery conducts four daily draws under its Weekly Lottery scheme, with results announced at the following times: Each draw offers a grand prize of Rs 27 lakh, along with several cash rewards for 2nd to 5th prize winners. A consolation prize of Rs 10,000 is also awarded across all series. Tickets are priced at an affordable Rs 6 and are available through authorised lottery retailers. Each ticket features a unique alphanumeric code that includes: Two digits (from 70 to 90) One letter (A to K) A five-digit number (00000 to 99999) Example Ticket Code: 83B 87219 How to Check the Manipur Lottery Results Today Visit the official website: Go to the 'Today Lottery Result' section Click on the 'Manipur Lottery Result' link Select 'View Result' Match your ticket number with the winning numbers listed. Sikkim Labh Laxmi Delight Wednesday Lottery Result The Sikkim Labh Laxmi Delight Wednesday Lottery Draw is set to take place on July 23, 2025, with the results to be declared at 4:00 PM. Conducted by the Sikkim State Lotteries and published through Lottery Sambad, this weekly draw is open to participants from across the country. Offering a first prize of Rs 10,000, and priced at just Rs 10 per ticket, the lottery provides an affordable chance to win exciting cash prizes. How to Check the Sikkim Labh Laxmi Delight Wednesday Lottery Result Visit the official Sikkim State Lotteries website Navigate to the 'Today Lottery Result' section Find the link titled 'Sikkim Labh Laxmi Delight Wednesday Lottery Result 23.7.2025" Click on 'View Result' Compare your ticket number with the list of winning numbers displayed on the screen. Goa Rajshree 30 Budh Weekly Lottery Result The Goa Rajshree 30 Budh Weekly Lottery Draw will be held on July 23, 2025, with the results scheduled to be announced at 8:30 PM. Conducted by the Goa Rajshree Lotteries and also released via Lottery Sambad, this weekly draw enjoys strong nationwide participation. With a first prize of Rs 7 lakh and a ticket price of just Rs 30, it offers an exciting and budget-friendly chance for players to win big. How to Check the Goa Rajshree 30 Budh Weekly Lottery Result Visit the official Goa Rajshree Lotteries website Go to the 'Today Lottery Result' section Find the listing for 'Goa Rajshree 30 Budh Weekly Lottery Result 23.7.2025" Click on 'View Result' Match your ticket number with the winning numbers displayed on the result page. Goa Rajshree 50 Budh Weekly Lottery Result The Goa Rajshree 50 Budh Weekly Lottery Draw is set to take place on July 23, 2025, with results to be announced at 7:30 PM. Organized by Goa Rajshree Lotteries and published by Lottery Sambad, the draw enjoys widespread accessibility and attention from participants across India. With a first prize of Rs 21 lakh and tickets priced at just Rs 50, it offers players an exciting and affordable chance to win substantial cash rewards. How to Check the Goa Rajshree 50 Budh Weekly Lottery Result Visit the official Goa Rajshree Lotteries website Navigate to the 'Today Lottery Result' section Look for 'Goa Rajshree 50 Budh Weekly Lottery Result 23.7.2025" Click on 'View Result' Match your ticket number against the list of winning numbers Goa Rajshree Bumper Lottery Draws In addition to weekly draws, Goa Rajshree Lotteries hosts special bumper lotteries during major festivals, giving players a shot at even bigger prizes. These include: Goa Rajshree Lohri Bumper Goa Rajshree Diwali Bumper Goa Rajshree Baisakhi Bumper Goa Rajshree Rakhi Bumper Goa Rajshree Sawan Bumper These festive draws feature larger prize pools and are designed to bring extra excitement during celebratory times. Arunachal Dear 10 Orange Wednesday Lottery Result The Arunachal Dear 10 Orange Wednesday Lottery Draw is set to be held on July 23, 2025, with the results scheduled to be announced at 1:30 PM. Conducted by the Arunachal State Lotteries and published on Lottery Sambad, this weekly draw is known for its widespread reach and transparent operations. With a first prize of Rs 1 lakh, the draw remains a popular and budget-friendly option for lottery enthusiasts across the country. How to Check the Arunachal Dear 10 Orange Wednesday Lottery Result top videos View all Visit the official Arunachal State Lotteries website Go to the 'Today Lottery Result' section Look for 'Arunachal Dear 10 Orange Wednesday Lottery Result 23.7.2025" Click on 'View Result' Cross-check your ticket number with the list of winning numbers shown The draw's simplicity and reliability continue to attract players hoping for a lucky win. About the Author News Desk The News Desk is a team of passionate editors and writers who break and analyse the most important events unfolding in India and abroad. From live updates to exclusive reports to in-depth explainers, the Desk More Get breaking news, in-depth analysis, and expert perspectives on everything from politics to crime and society. Stay informed with the latest India news only on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated! tags : lottery view comments Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: July 23, 2025, 09:45 IST News india Lottery Results Today Live, July 23, 2025: Punjab, Manipur, Sikkim, Goa & Arunachal Winning Numbers Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


News18
an hour ago
- News18
Maharashtra Lottery Result Today Live: Winning Numbers For July 23, 2025
Last Updated: Maharashtra State Lottery Result Today Live, July 23, 2025: Here's full list of winning numbers for lottery draw. Maharashtra State Lottery Result Today Live: The Maharashtra State Lottery Department held several weekly draws on July 23, 2025, in collaboration with Lottery Sambad. These draws, conducted at various times throughout the day, offered participants multiple chances to win significant cash prizes. Here are the highlights of each draw and instructions on how to check the results. Maharashtra Akshay Weekly Lottery Draw Date: July 23, 2025 Time: 4:15 PM First Prize: Rs 8 lakh This is the golden opportunity for the participants to win an impressive amount of cash prizes. Maharashtra Sahyadri Vijayalaxmi Weekly Lottery Draw Date: July 23, 2025 Time: 4:30 PM First Prize: Rs 10,000 Held every Wednesday, this draw attracts significant participation across the state. Maharashtra Gajlaxmi BUDH Weekly Lottery This is one of the most anticipated weekly draws, with thousands of hopeful participants checking results every Wednesday. Maharashtra Ganeshlaxmi Vijayi Weekly Lottery Draw Date: July 23, 2025 Time: 5:00 PM First Prize: Rs 10,000 How To Check Maharashtra State Lottery Results To view any of the results listed above: Maharashtra State Bumper Lotteries Apart from weekly draws, the Maharashtra State Lottery Department also organises special Bumper Draws throughout the year, featuring much larger prizes. These include: These bumper draws are eagerly awaited and offer a grander scale of winnings for lottery enthusiasts. Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


New Indian Express
3 hours ago
- New Indian Express
TNIE Impact: TN allots free house to PwD whose Aadhaar suspended over biometric verification issue
TIRUNELVELI: Tirunelveli District Collector Dr R Sukumar on Tuesday sanctioned a free house to C Manikandan (31), a person with disability (PwD) born without fingers on his hands and legs. The move comes after TNIE highlighted his prolonged struggle to restore his Aadhaar card and access welfare benefits in a report published on July 8. As per the district administration, Manikandan has been allotted a house under the Urban Habitat Development Board Tenement scheme. The entire beneficiary contribution of Rs 2,96,190 will be borne by the Tamil Nadu government, making the house completely free of cost for Manikandan.