Oklahoma lawmakers on the brink of making our struggling schools even worse
In fact, just the opposite may be happening. Legislators are on the brink of making our education crisis even worse.
A bill backed by Senate Education Committee Chair Adam Pugh, R-Edmond, to give teachers another raise to help address our critical shortage is being shelved. More important to legislators, it seems, is making sure enough money is available for a small percentage cut in the state income-tax rate that won't be of much help to average Oklahomans.
Instead of better pay to fix the problem of not having enough experienced teachers to go around, the Legislature is proposing in House Bill 2125 to expand an existing program to allow untrained instructors in pre-K through third-grade classrooms. These non-certified teachers are called "adjuncts," but a better name might be "babysitters," since they are unlikely to make a dent in our dismal math and reading scores.
Superintendent Ryan Walters at the Oklahoma State Education Board meeting at the Oliver Hodge Building, Thursday, April 24, 2025.
Districts like Oklahoma City Public Schools have a "grow your own" program to get more qualified teachers in classrooms. Those programs create a pathway to eventual college certification and training. But let's be clear: Pre-K through third-grade "adjuncts" are not like the part-time college professors who may not have a post-graduate degree but bring years of experiential learning to a college classroom. Instead, they are academically untrained to meet the learning needs of students who come from a variety of backgrounds.
More: Youngest students in Oklahoma schools need qualified teachers — not beginners | Opinion
Maybe the Legislature thinks curriculum changes proposed by state schools Superintendent Ryan Walters will help. Among other things, those changes require social studies teachers to emphasize more strongly how much of an influence the Bible was on those who established our nation in the 1700s. Teachers also will be required to give special attention to claims that the 2020 election was "stolen" from President Donald Trump. Both areas are purely subjective and require no formal training for instruction ― or some might argue, indoctrination.
Senators could have had a voice in modifying Walters' plans, but chose not to vote on a proposal to reject the standards, allowing them to take effect. Oklahoma already has thousands of alternatively certified teachers in classrooms. What's needed are qualified, certified teachers well versed in how to help kids reach their full potential by third grade.
Oklahoma's kids should always be our lawmakers' priority. They deserve a world-class education with highly certified teachers, not watered down instruction from inexperienced "adjuncts." Sadly, 2025 is turning out to be a year of inaction on the part of both Walters and the Legislature toward improving our schools. Oklahoma is still in a ditch labeled "49th in education." HB 2125 has not yet been heard in the Senate. We urge the Senate to reject the "adjunct" plan and seek a permanent, sustainable path that brings training and experience into classrooms so students can boast improved education outcomes.
This editorial was written by William C. Wertz, and represents the position of The Oklahoman editorial board, which includes deputy opinion editor Wertz, opinion editor Clytie Bunyan and executive editor Ray Rivera.
This article originally appeared on Oklahoman: Oklahoma Legislature on track to make public schools worse | Editorial
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
26 minutes ago
- Axios
Newsom signs California redistricting measures in response to Texas bill
California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed two redistricting bills into law on Thursday evening after a Democratic-controlled Legislature passed them earlier in the day. Why it matters: The legislation is in direct response to Texas' Republican-controlled House passing a new congressional map at the urging of President Trump, and the consequences of both could prove pivotal in the 2026 midterms and the 2028 presidential election.
an hour ago
'It's alarming': Education Department revokes guidance on English learning services
The U.S. Education Department has rescinded critical guidance to schools regarding how they provide English language learning services for roughly 5 million students in U.S. schools. The Education Department on Tuesday rescinded a 2015 Dear Colleague letter on its website, which served as a guide for school districts that are serving English learners to ensure they're providing adequate resources to their students under Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. In a statement to ABC News, the Education Department said the document was "overly prescriptive" and that it micro-managed states. "States have vastly different needs for this important population of students and are best equipped to determine how best to educate these students while following all applicable federal laws," the department said in the statement. The document is still available online for "historical purposes only," according to a notice. The Washington Post was the first to report the guidance had been rescinded. Advocates worry the decision removes federal oversight and accountability, which could lead to school districts opting to discriminate against English learners. Despite those concerns, removing the guidance does not strip resources from schools nor does it alter state curriculums, which are handled by state and local agencies. Roxanne Garza, director of higher education policy at the Education Trust, suggested the move could further the fears of immigrant students wary of returning to school amid the Trump administration's measures to curb illegal migration. "I think it could add to the overall feeling of fear -- like making these people, these families, feel like they don't belong in their communities." Montserrat Garibay, former assistant deputy secretary and director of the Office of English Language Acquisition (OELA) during the Biden administration, equated the now-rescinded English-learners document to the Bible for English language instructors. During her tenure, she said the letter was instrumental to her office in providing resources to the students who needed it most. Garibay, who said nearly three quarters of students in English Language Acquisition programming are U.S. citizens, argued the move could have a lasting impact if it results in scaled-back resources. "These are children who eventually are going to be paying our Medicare and Medicaid, right? Our Social Security, because they are U.S. citizens. And it's outrageous that we are not providing them with the resources that they need to be successful in the 21st century." Garibay also said lifting the long-standing guidance appears to fly in the face of an executive order Trump signed earlier this year designating English as the official language of the United States. Education advocates decried the agency's decision. ImmSchools Co-Founder Viridiana Carrizales told ABC News "It's alarming because, you know, it feels like this administration is stripping away every right, every protection, funding, access to resources etc. that are so critical for those 5 million students in the country who are learning English." Carrizales, whose organization partners with school districts to create more welcoming and safe schools for K-12 immigrant students, said the recent move is a significant shift for classroom educators because immigrant protections, overall, are "diminishing." "We're hearing a lot more concerns from educators themselves, who're trying to figure out how they can meet and support this population when their resources and protections are being taken away," she said. Anne Kelsey, senior policy analyst for disability rights at the Young Center for Immigrant Children's Rights, argued the decision will harm immigrant children and families. "Language access is a fundamental right that builds safer, smarter, and more connected communities, and ensures children can receive a full and fair education while keeping their parents actively involved," Kelsey wrote in a statement to ABC News, adding "These programs welcome parents and families fully into the school community and we know it leads to stronger educational outcomes for students." The effort to return education responsibilities and decisions to the states is arguably President Donald Trump's top K-12 education priority. Secretary of Education Linda McMahon kicked off her 50-state "Returning Education to the States" tour last week.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
As Michigan schools lay off staff due to ongoing budget standoff, Hall tells them to hold the line
Michigan House Speaker Matt Hall (R-Richland Township) speaks to members of the news media to discuss the ongoing battle over the state's budget and new notices from schools that they are laying off staff due to funding uncertainty. Aug. 21, 2025 | Photo by Ben Solis/Michigan Advance Michigan schools facing uncertainty over the state budget are beginning to issue layoff notices to staff, adding another layer of disarray over the Legislature's strained and stagnant funding plans for the coming fiscal year. On Thursday, Michigan House Speaker Matt Hall (R-Richland Township) eschewed schools' claims that new layoffs were related to the current budget fight. Hall also doubled down on his assertion that his chamber's budget would provide them with more money than in years past. In a regularly hosted news conference, the speaker told schools to hold the line and wait it out, promising that the House's full budget would be presented soon, and that negotiations on a consensus plan with the Senate would emerge swiftly. Those who represent and advocate for Michigan's K-12 schools, however, said Thursday that districts can't wait for the Legislature's fight to continue, and the longer they do, tough decisions would need to be made. SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX At present, the Legislature is now many weeks past its statutory July 1 deadline to complete and present to the governor an appropriations bill to fund state departments, public schools and higher education. Although the deadline has been missed before, this year's budget fight is novel in the fact that partisan gridlock has stalled movement on negotiations. A full budget has been passed by the Michigan Senate, but the chamber lacks a clear roads funding plan, which the Republican-controlled House has blamed for the current impasse. The House has yet to present its full budget funding state operations, but it has crafted a roads plan and passed K-12 and higher education budgets. The Democrats who control the Senate say it's the House that's holding up the process. Either way, the two competing school funding plans are diametrically different in their approaches to funding. That's given K-12 districts no insight into how to best plan for the year to come. To give themselves some cushion, some districts are already either talking about laying off staff or have already done so. In his press conference to address the ongoing stalemate held Thursday, Hall was asked if he had comment on those schools who are directly tying the budget crisis to their decisions on layoffs. The question from a reporter focused mainly on school safety and mental health staff that were allegedly getting the ax. To that, Hall said that the previous Democratic trifecta, which held power for the last two years, slashed funding for mental health and school safety, and that his chamber's schools budget this year was a restoration of those areas. Some have criticized the House budget because it rolled up all the categorical spending line items for funding areas into the total per-pupil allowance, which gave schools no clear direction on how to spend that money. Critics have also said that schools would remove free meals and other key programs if the House budget was adopted into law because the Legislature no longer mandated that they fund them. Hall said boilerplate language in the House education budget mandates money to be used for mental health and schools. 'Right before the [2024] election, they tried to fix that and put a little bit in, but it's still way down,' Hall said. 'One of the main things we're trying to achieve in our budget, we … put a rule in place that you must fund school safety and mental health with this money.' In response to the talk of layoffs in the face of potentially more school funding from the House this year, Hall said he believed those layoffs were more performance based than anything else. Another reporter noted that despite whatever the House put in its version of the education budget, the lower chamber and its big brother in the Senate still needed to work out a consensus conference budget. Gov. Gretchen Whitmer would also have considerable influence in those negotiations. That could take time even after the House presents its full plan and the Senate finally moves forward on road funding. Schools would be left in the lurch despite promises of increased funding because they don't have that money now. Again, Hall asked schools to hold the line and not make any rash personnel decisions because the money was coming. 'If I was a school superintendent, and I was watching this and I saw that all parties want to increase my funding, I wouldn't be making all of these crazy decisions, because I see that all parties are trying to fund me more,' Hall said. 'I would assume they'll work it out. … All three budgets [the House, the Senate and the governor's recommendations] increase funding for schools, it's just the House Republicans who are increasing it the most.' Hall chalked up the disconnect to the new House budgeting process, adding that the chamber was doing it 'in a way that is a little different than the establishment is used to.' Robert McCann, executive director of the K-12 Alliance of Michigan, said schools have a reason to be worried as the budget battle rages on. 'The reason for these layoffs is directly tied to the fact that they haven't passed a budget,' McCann told Michigan Advance. 'The budget is more than the per pupil [amount]. The budget is more than the total amount you're getting. It's pieces that create an entire budget for a school year, and those individual pieces fund specific programs and specific personnel.' McCann said schools typically build their budgets in June, even though, as in years past, a final consensus budget might not be completed. 'But we were pretty far along in the process [in previous years] where they can take some reasonable guesses as to where their final budget is and what it's going to look like,' McCann said. 'They might have had to come back and tweak it a little bit at the end of the summer, but it's close, and they could make enough informed decisions to keep personnel or to bring on new ones.' In the current saga, McCann said schools have nothing to go on. 'With all due respect to the speaker, I couldn't disagree more. Yes, they had two budgets that have been passed, but they were radically different from one another,' he added. 'That's where I say, it's not just the fact that there were two budgets passed that would give them some amount of money, it's that there were two budgets that contained very different funding and ways of distributing that funding.' Aside from the dilemma facing schools, the roads issue continues to take precedence in the budget talks for Hall, as does the new Republican ethos to target funding areas that they consider 'waste, fraud and abuse.' The speaker has said that the full budget hasn't come out yet, despite an optimistic view from his appropriations chair, state Rep. Ann Bollin (R-Brighton) that it could be delivered as soon as next week, because his team keeps finding wasteful spending areas that it says it can cut safely and responsibly. Although that concept has been a national GOP talking point, Hall has only given a few examples of where waste was located in previous spending plans and where cuts might come from. On Thursday, he shared more, targeting the Department of Attorney General, the Department of Technology, Management and Budget, the Department of Labor and Economic Opportunity, the Department of Civil Rights and the Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy. Hall showed slides comparing the budgets of former Republican Gov. Rick Snyder to the last two budget cycles when Democrats held all levers of power in state government. By his caucus' math, the attorney general's office budget grew by 22%; management and budget by 36%; civil rights by 80%; labor by 92%; and EGLE by 107%. For Hall, that was evidence enough for Republicans to take the ax to those ballooning departments and label that all as waste. The numerous press conferences and tough talk in Lansing, on both sides of the aisle, have brought the budget no closer to completion. Hall previously said it was his estimation that the full budget proposal would land by Sept. 30, the constitutional drop deadline for the fiscal year before the government lands in a shutdown. The last government shutdown in Michigan lasted only a few hours, with a consensus reached soon afterward. The Advance asked Hall what that might look like if both budgets are delivered and passed by each chamber on Sept. 30 or Oct. 1, and how swiftly he believed the two sides could come to agreement to stave off a potential shut down. Hall has said his team was putting together 'the perfect budget,' and therefore, any shut down might only last a few hours in this round, if it happens at all. 'In that scenario, we would only need a couple of hours at that point,' Hall said. 'But I think we'll try to give them a little more time, a few more days than that, to work through this.' In the face of sneering political mistrust between Democrats and Republicans, Hall's assumption appears highly optimistic. The speaker, however, blamed any infighting on two opposing factions within the Democratic Party, and not on House Republicans. 'If the Democrats can unify and empower their leader, Governor Whitmer, we'll get a deal done in about two weeks, probably less,' Hall said. 'I think when I show this to her, she will see a lot of this waste, fraud and abuse, and will help us eliminate it. And then I think we share a common goal of getting the roads fixed.' Play Farm Merge Valley
