Court hears Fosterville Gold Mine noise 'torturing' Axedale neighbours
Kirsty McDonald and Karen Oliver have lodged a private nuisance claim, saying their home has become a "living hell" due to low-frequency noise from Fosterville Gold Mine's operations, 20 kilometres east of Bendigo.
The Axedale couple's claim against the mine is being heard in a judge-alone civil trial in Victoria's Supreme Court.
Fosterville Gold Mine unsuccessfully attempted to have the case dismissed late last year.
The couple's barrister, Jonathan Korman, told the court on Thursday the mine had done "not one thing" to abate the noise or ameliorate the plaintiff's "extreme state of physical and mental suffering".
Mr Korman said the couple had lived about 3km from the mine without issue for six years.
That was until mid-2020 when ventilation shafts were moved above ground, he told the court.
"It's common sense this noise is coming from the mine," Mr Korman said.
Mr Korman alleged Fosterville Gold Mine used a "repetitive gaslighting approach" to noise complaints, taking measurements that repeatedly found no breach.
"The subtle and insidious effect of this approach is to invalidate the complaint made," he said.
Giving evidence on Thursday, Ms McDonald told the court for the first eight months after the noise started, she thought the mine was working with them to fix it.
She said staff at the mine had initially agreed it was causing the noise, before retracting that view in April 2021.
"I felt betrayed and made a fool of," Ms McDonald told the court.
In the years since, she said her mental health had deteriorated, and the couple had resorted to sleeping in their car or "fleeing" to friends' homes.
Mr Korman told the court two other residents living near the mine were expected to give evidence, including one who became a "chronic insomniac" and wears earplugs or headphones day and night.
Martin Scott KC, representing Fosterville Gold Mine, told the court "exhaustive investigations were made in good faith" after complaints were received from the couple.
Mr Scott said the mine modified its ventilation fans to the satisfaction of the Environment Protection Authority.
The mine also rejects claims about how it dealt with the plaintiffs, he told the court.
Mr Scott said evidence from acoustic experts would show differences in noise measurements taken simultaneously at the mine and the plaintiffs' home.
He also said independent noise monitoring inside the Axedale home found levels were "below the threshold of audibility".
The 10-day trial continues on Friday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Harvey Brunswick Leschenault Football Club coach John Baggetta sacked over derogatory online comment about Tammy Hembrow
A football coach has been sacked over a sexist and derogatory comment he made on social media about influencer Tammy Hembrow. The Harvey Brunswick Leschenault (HBL) Football Club in WA's South West released a statement on Friday saying coach John Baggetta had been terminated as league coach over a social media post. 'We do not condone these comments, they do not reflect the values or standards of the HBL Football Club at any level,' a statement from the club read. The comment was allegedly made on a post about Hembrow going on a date with AFL star Bailey Smith. An online feminist page shared the comment in a post about 'disgusting misogynist slurs by Australian men directed at Tammy Hembrow after she went on a date.' The post highlighted the football coach was a mentor to young men who shaped their points of view. HBL said in a statement its football community and others thought the comment was inappropriate and should not be tolerated. 'We are incredibly proud to have a women's team, female representation on our board and women actively involved in our club,' the statement read. 'We have consulted with our women's side and we are committed to offering them and all the females in our club any support necessary.' 'It's not what I stand for, I have apologised and will move on to do better,' he said.
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
Australia's Sam Goodman targeted by anti-doping authorities in lead up to his world-title blockbuster against defending champion Nick Ball
Sam Goodman insists he is not a drug cheat amid fears the Australian was deliberately targeted by anti-doping chiefs in a bid to destabilise him ahead of his world-title blockbuster. Goodman (20-0) faces the biggest test of his career on Sunday morning (AEST) when the Albion Park pugilist takes on Englishman Nick Ball (22-0-1) for the WBC featherweight world title in Saudi Arabia. But there are concerns from the Goodman camp that he has been a victim of sabotage after the Aussie sensation was relentlessly drug-tested by authorities in the lead-up to the Ball bout. Australian fighters are no strangers to offshore mind games and political trickery. Goodman recalls Queensland's former world champion Jeff Horn being woken up at 2am to be drug tested by anti-doping officials on the day of his title defence against Terence Crawford. It was viewed as a tactic to unsettle Horn. It worked. He was sliced-and-diced by Crawford in a ninth-round stoppage in Las Vegas. It is understood Goodman has been randomly drug-tested at least six or seven times in recent weeks, fuelling conspiracy theories promoters are trying to mess with his mind. But the classy super bantamweight, who is going up one weight division for his world-title baptism against Ball, says nothing will distract him, declaring he's as clean as his pristine win-loss record. 'For this fight, the drug testing has been going late which is a bit average,' said Goodman, who was also heavily tested before his proposed world-title bout against Naoya Inoue last year, which never eventuated after he suffered two head cuts in sparring. 'Before Inoue, I got drug tested six or seven times 10 days out from the fight and there would have been another test if I got to Japan. 'When you fight away from home, you have to expect these things. 'You hear these horror stories and that sort of s*** (boxers failing drug tests) can happen. 'There's cheaters who cheat, I get it,' Goodman added on The Punch podcast as he prepares to face Ball. 'A lot of fighters could cheat their way right up to a world-title shot. 'I'm fighting in their territory, but I'm doing everything I can control to get to the ring in the best shape possible. 'I won't let it get to me. We (the Goodman team) are in a fortress here. 'If I don't win, it's because I'm not good enough, which won't be the case.' Intriguingly, Goodman has taken inspiration from two Little Masters in another sport. Two of rugby league's greatest halfbacks, Broncos legend Allan Langer and current Brisbane skipper Adam Reynolds, are surprise motivating forces in Goodman's bid to conquer the world. The 'Wrecking' Ball is England's only current world champion and underlining his pint-sized stature, he stands a tiny 157cm — eight centimetres shorter than 'Alfie' Langer. Growing up on the NSW south coast, Goodman's first dream was to play NRL. He was a St George Illawarra fan and marvelled at vision of Langer and Reynolds, inspiring Goodman with their ability to punch above their weight as cheeky halfbacks in the NRL's land of giants. When Goodman suffered an arm injury playing league as a 10-year-old, it was the moment that convinced him to take up boxing and the 'Ghost' quickly found his niche. Now unbeaten after seven years in the professional ranks, Goodman makes his world-title debut and is being driven by two of rugby league's little champions to break down Ball in a middle-eastern mauling. Reynolds is a massive boxing fan and enjoys Goodman's high-octane style. 'The critics always underestimate us smaller guys,' said Goodman, who at 169cm has a major size advantage over Ball. 'I loved rugby league growing up and there was a time when I hoped I would be good enough to play in the NRL, but I've found success in boxing. 'Blokes like 'Alfie' Langer, Geoff Toovey (Manly great) and Adam Reynolds made a career out of proving people wrong. 'That's exactly what I will do this weekend. 'He (Ball) has a wild and frantic style. He is unique and it works for him, but there's many ways I can win this fight. 'It's a hit-and-run mission, I'll go over there, get the belt and come home.' Ball has been accused of underestimating Goodman, with the Briton admitting he hasn't watched the Australian at all. 'I don't know much about him and I don't really care,' he told this masthead. 'I won't know (about his style) until the bell goes. I just focus on me. 'My coaches do the research, I let them do it while I focus on myself and they tell me what's going to work on the night. 'I will beat him because I'm an all-round better fighter. I want it more. I'm hungrier than him. I'm more powerful. 'The best version of me beats his best and that's what I will be. 'It's going to be tough for sure, but he won't handle me.' It's understood there is a rematch clause in the deal and Goodman has no qualms about beating Ball twice in his eventual dream of fighting undisputed king 'The Monster' Inoue. 'I think there's a rematch clause so I might have to fight this guy twice,' he said. 'I'm pretty sure there is (a two-fight clause), so we'll wait and see. 'If I beat him the first time well enough, we'll see if we come to Australia. 'I've bled for this, I've sacrificed everything for this moment. 'I'm not flying halfway around the world to come home empty-handed. 'Once the bell rings there's no teammates to back me up — it's all on me. 'Come Sunday, he's going to find out exactly what I'm about ... I'm not leaving the desert without that world title.'
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
Trial for Outback Wrangler Matt Wright hears explosive claims
A Netflix reality star 'idolised' by his staff was an 'anti-vaxxer' who broke Covid-19 laws and was allegedly secretly recorded talking about tinkering with flight records while visiting a chopper crash survivor left paraplegic in hospital, a jury has heard. The extraordinary claims about Outback Wrangler Matt Wright were made this week during his trial in the Northern Territory Supreme Court, where he is charged with three counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice. The 45-year-old celebrity is accused of failing to accurately record flight times in the Robinson-R-44 that crashed in February 2022, killing his co-star Chris 'Willow' Wilson. It is not alleged Mr Wright is responsible for the crash. Mr Wilson, 34, was dangling from a sling attached to the helicopter during a dangerous crocodile egg collecting mission when the chopper crashed in Arnhem Land. CHOPPER RECORDS ALLEGEDLY FUDGED Pilot Seb Robinson, who survived the crash but is now a paraplegic, testified his former boss was an 'anti-vaxxer' despite Mr Wright going to two Covid restricted areas – the remote helicopter crash site and the injured pilot's Brisbane hospital room. He told the jury the main reason Mr Wright was not on the egg mission was 'because he was an anti-vaxxer'. At the time, there were strict Covid rules for anyone entering remote areas in the Territory, where they needed to provide proof of vaccination and take a rapid antigen test. The jury previously heard Mr Wright flew to the crash site with Wild Harvest NT director Mick Burns and off-duty senior NT Police officer Neil Mellon. Following the crash, Mr Robinson spent one month in hospital, where Covid restrictions meant two people could visit and everyone needed to provide a valid vaccination certificate. Mr Robinson said he had just come out of a coma, was heavily sedated and 'hallucinating' but 'vaguely' remembered a visit from Mr Wright and his wife Kaia on March 11. 'I have a vivid memory of him having some sort of paperwork in his hands,' Mr Robinson said. He alleged his boss wanted to move 'a few' hours from the crashed helicopter – with the call sign IDW – to Mr Robinson's personal chopper,with the call sign ZXZ. Mr Robinson, 28, also alleged Mr Wright 'asked to go through my phone and delete a few things'. 'I remember looking over and seeing him holding my phone and flicking through it and deleting things,' Mr Robinson said. The jury heard the former pilot also deleted 'some stuff', including phone notes for start and stop times for IDW during egg collection trips. 'It was a very hard time for me. I didn't know who to trust and I panicked and went along with it,' he said. Mr Robinson alleged on Mr Wright's second hospital visit he brought Jai Thomlinson to again discuss the transfer of hours from IDW to ZXZ. 'I just remember having concerns about what was happening,' Mr Robinson said. 'I said I didn't feel comfortable doing it,' he said. 'I don't think (Mr Wright) was upset … he sort of said: 'That's OK.'' A secret mobile audio recording of this hospital visit allegedly captured Mr Wright talking about IDW flight times over the phone. Mr Robinson admitted he initially repeatedly lied to investigators because he 'panicked' and was worried about losing his pilot's licence. PILOT'S COCAINE PARTYING Mr Robinson admitted he used cocaine 'a couple times a year' – up to 10 times over 12 months – but he denied he was a 'raging cocaine junkie'. The former pilot said he had never flown a helicopter while intoxicated, either by drugs or alcohol. He admitted he sometimes supplied cocaine for his mates and footy players, as well as flying small amounts of booze into Aboriginal communities. But Mr Robinson denied being a 'drug dealer' while being questioned about a series of texts about his wild partying. Mr Wright's defence counsel David Edwardson accused Mr Robinson of 'sourcing and supplying' cocaine from 2018 to the time of the crash. Mr Edwardson read messages from the pilot's friends asking 'are you getting more coke?', 'Seb any chance you know where to get the good stuff?' and 'anyone got bags?'. In one message exchange, Mr Robinson told a friend he was 'crook as a dog', with his mate replying 'snorting too much coke out of Matty's arse?'. Mr Robinson said the friend knew Mr Wright. But the lawyer has said the reality star had a 'zero tolerance' approach to drugs. Under cross-examination, Mr Robinson was also grilled about a message sent to a mate in November 2019, saying there were 'footy players in town wanting bags' and other texts referring to 'zingers' and 'pills'. 'Are you implying I'm a drug dealer? … No,' Mr Robinson said. While Mr Robinson did not believe he was a trafficker, Justice Alan Blow explained: 'It is trafficking, even if you're not making any money for yourself.' Trace amounts of cocaine were detected in Mr Robinson's blood, which prosecutor Jason Gullaci said experts were likely to say was from use days before the crash. Mr Robinson admitted to flying in booze to remote communities, but said he did not sell the alcohol. He said 'on occasion' he would take a small amount of alcohol under the seat of his chopper for people in Arnhem Land. PILOT'S INJURIES Mr Robinson said his last memory from that fateful day was 'having a laugh' with his mate in the chopper. The jury was shown a photo of Mr Wilson piloting the Robinson R-44, with the image appearing to capture the fuel gauge between three-quarters and completely full mark. Mr Robinson said at that level, the helicopter should have been able to travel from Noonamah to King River and back. He became emotional as he shared his next memory – waking up in hospital, then being told his friend was dead and he would likely never walk again. Mr Robinson's spinal cord was completely severed, he had 12 broken ribs and puncturing in his lungs. His neck, elbow and both ankles were also fractured. He said he struggled with his memory due to a traumatic brain injury. NETFLIX STAR AN 'IDOL' Fellow helicopter pilot Jock Purcell told the jury he took official aviation records from Mr Robinson's home two days after the crash but could not recall who asked him to do it. He said he did not show the logbook to anyone or take photos of the official records, but was later asked by Mr Robinson to return the records. 'I took it home, and then Seb's brothers come and got it from my house,' Mr Purcell said. However, in a tapped telephone conversation between Mr Purcell and Mr Wright five months after the crash, the pair allegedly discussed Mr Robinson talking to investigators, the crashed chopper's maintenance release and Hobbs Meter, which records flight hours. 'Something had gone on with the Hobbs there, I dunno, they've moved it forward or some f***ing thing as well,' Mr Wright said. 'I'm just trying to think how much Sebby's, or what Sebby's tried to say to them, if anything even.' The pair then said some of that information could have been gathered from the maintenance release, which pilots fill out to record flight hours and service histories of helicopters. Three years after the bugged call, Mr Purcell told the court he was unsure if it was related to the crash investigation. Mr Purcell, who arrived at the crash scene, initially said he did not remember anyone approaching but then said the only thing removed were a few headsets. However, under cross examination, Mr Purcell said: 'I know someone lifted the dash of the helicopter.' Mr Purcell said he checked to see why the chopper might have gone down, and happened to notice the Hobbs Meter was connected. But Mr Gullaci alleged the sole purpose for Mr Purcell to look under the dash was to inspect this device 'because you knew there was a practice among Matt Wright's helicopters of the Hobbs Meter being disconnected'. 'And you wanted to see whether it was connected or not, for when investigators turned up to look at the crashed helicopter?' Mr Gullaci asked. Mr Purcell said he did not believe that was the case. When asked what else he could have been inspecting, the experienced pilot said: 'I'm not an investigator so I don't know.' However, Mr Purcell had already conceded there was a pattern of not recording flight hours, and had previously seen both Mr Wright and Mr Robinson disconnect the Hobbs Meter. He said there were times when the flight hour recorder was disconnected because 'it was getting close to service'. Mr Robinson also made full admissions to the jury of his own dodgy record keeping practices, which he said were common across the Territory helicopter industry. After almost a decade in the industry, Mr Robinson alleged he had worked for two other businesses which had similarly failed to properly record flight hours. Mr Robinson agreed he continued to 'break the rules' while working at Mr Wright's company. '(Mr Wright) would say 'pop the clock for this trip',' Mr Robinson alleged. He also said Mr Wright 'controlled all aspects of his aircraft regarding maintenance scheduling'. Mr Robinson said employees 'absolutely' followed Mr Wright's directions. 'We were young men, we looked up to him,' he said. 'Everyone looked at Matt as an idol. He'd say 'jump' and they'd say 'how high?' 'He had an aura about him. 'Everyone wanted to be around him, work for him, everyone bent over backwards to try and be a part of what he was doing.' The trial continues.
