NHS Fife 'followed guidance in letting trans doctor use women's space'
Peggie was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with Dr Upton at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, [[Fife]] – where they both worked – on Christmas Eve 2023.
She was placed on special leave and then suspended after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment and cited concerns about 'patient care'.
Peggie has lodged a claim against Fife health board and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination and victimisation.
Dr Beth Upton (centre) (Image: NQ) At the tribunal on Thursday, Malone said it was her responsibility to 'speak up' on issues around female nurses sharing a changing room with a transgender doctor, and said the 'department took guidance' when refusing to meet a request made by Peggie's solicitor.
Service manager Lottie Myles sent an email to Malone on March 7, 2024 following a meeting with Peggie where she asked why Dr Upton could not be moved or asked to change elsewhere.
Despite Peggie asking through her solicitor that when she returned to work she 'could be assured of a single-sex space to change in', the board did not act, the tribunal heard.
Malone said: 'The department took guidance from the equality and human rights lead, and that wouldn't be what we would do.
'We took guidance that Beth could continue using the female changing facility.'
Cross-examining, barrister Naomi Cunningham said: 'The result of refusing to give her that guarantee of no men in female changing room would be that Sandie couldn't return to work safe in the knowledge that when she got dressed in the women's changing room, there would be no men there.'
READ MORE: NHS Fife issue statement after clearing Sandie Peggie of misconduct
Malone said: 'We took advice and the guidance at the time was that Beth could use the female changing facility.'
The tribunal heard that on March 8, Malone sent an email to HR worker Melanie Jorgensen and others that a 'further risk assessment is supported for returning SP to the workplace'.
Cunningham said: 'It had already been established at end of December that there was no shift overlap between the claimant and Dr Upton in January so there was no need to keep them apart. That had already been established by January 3 when the suspension was put in place.'
Malone said: 'I can't recall.'
Cunningham said: 'What seems to have happened is that the risk assessment has been done after a decision to continue suspension.'
She said confidentiality had been 'hopelessly lost' on December 29, 2023 when Dr Kate Searle sent an email to all consultants in the emergency department with Dr Upton's version of events, and again on January 12, 2024 when Dr Searle emailed about the incident – including Peggie, Dr Upton and potential witnesses.
Malone said: 'I don't think she [Dr Searle] should have done that.'
However on July 3, after press reports, Peggie was given a reminder about confidentiality – which Cunningham said was to 'silence her', and referred to emails exchanged on March 7 between Malone and Myles, which referred to 'misgendering' and the 'risk' of Peggie 'using he/him which may cause unrest in the wider NHS team', the tribunal heard.
Cunningham said: 'That tends to underline that the damage limitation is about preventing unrest in the workplace due to Sandie Peggie's use of correct sex pronouns for Dr Upton.'
She said 'prohibiting the subject matter' was primarily about 'preventing her ability to organise with others who shared her concerns', and to 'prevent her expressing gender-critical belief'.
READ MORE: Armed police threaten woman with terror charge for holding Palestinian flag
Malone said: 'I don't agree.'
During re-examination by counsel for NHS Fife Jane Russell KC, Malone was asked if she believed commenting on chromosomes was 'gender-critical belief'.
She said: 'No I do not. I think it's an unwanted comment.'
Russell asked if based on her knowledge of the allegations on Christmas Eve, she believed Dr Upton had sexually harassed Peggie.
The witness said: 'No I don't believe Dr Upton sexually harassed Ms Peggie. I believe it was unacceptable behaviours, unprofessional behaviours which warranted investigation.'
The tribunal continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
10 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
NHS bosses ‘still on the hook' despite nurse Sandie Peggie's ‘racist' remarks, says Anas Sarwar
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) NHS bosses are still in the firing line over their trans policy even if a nurse at the centre of a tribunal row did make 'racist' remarks, Anas Sarwar said. The Scottish Labour leader said 'horrific' remarks attributed to nurse Sandie Peggie about ethnic minorities does not detract from public bodies' duty to keep biological males out of female changing rooms. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 Nurse Sandie Peggie was accused of making highly racist remarks Credit: Getty 4 She was suspended by NHS Fife for challenging trans Dr Beth Upton (pictured) about using the women's changing room Credit: Alamy 4 Anas Sarwar said Ms Peggie's remarks should not let NHS Fife off the hook Credit: Les Gallagher Ms Peggie has denied claims from two colleagues that she joked about posting bacon through the letterbox of a local mosque, insisting the remark came from a paramedic on the ward. Ms Peggie admitted she had a fear of the mosque being built in Kirkcaldy due to her having concerns about Sharia Law being introduced in the UK. She said did not dislike all Muslims and that her beliefs did not mean she would ever treat patients differently. The nurse, who worked for 30 years with NHS Fife, also said a number of racist jokes in a WhatsApp chat regarding flooding in Pakistan that killed nearly 2,000 people in 2022 was humour, intended to try and shock people. The nurse said she had used derogatory terms to describe people from Pakistan and China because these were common terms when she was growing up. She said people of those ethnicities that she knew were not offended when the terms had been used. MSP Mr Sarwar said: 'Those comments, if they are as attributed, are completely and utterly unacceptable. 'But we have also got to be really careful that we don't distract from the big issues that matter. 'Just because we might find these comments attributed horrific doesn't mean health boards and the Scottish Government should not comply with the Equality Act and protect single sex spaces based on biological sex. 'We can do that while also building a society that is free of prejudice of any kind, including racism, homophobia, transphobia, sexism, antisemitism and Islamophobia.' NATS health secretary Neil Gray today failed to back nurse Sandie Peggie amid a row over single-sex space
Telegraph
12 hours ago
- Telegraph
Gender-critical campaigners criticise NHS trans row tribunal
Gender-critical campaigners have accused the NHS health board at the centre of a transgender row of undermining the Supreme Court. Sandie Peggie is suing NHS Fife for unlawful discrimination after the nurse had to share a changing room with Dr Beth Upton, a trans medic, at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023. At last week's hearing in Dundee, Jane Russell KC, the barrister representing NHS Fife and Dr Upton, repeatedly questioned the Supreme Court's ruling that a trans woman is a man. In April, the court ruled that the words 'sex', 'man' and 'woman' mean biological sex, biological man and biological woman regarding the Equality Act. But when Ms Russell was challenged by Naomi Cunningham, Ms Peggie's barrister, that the court had in fact determined that a 'trans woman is a man' for the purposes of the Equality Act, Ms Russell said she disagreed with the lawyer's 'summary' of the case's judgment. Judge Sandy Kemp went on to describe the case's meaning as a 'contentious matter', adding that its meaning was 'in dispute'. For Women Scotland has now weighed into the Dundee tribunal, saying it is 'concerned' about Ms Russell's comments in a letter to the hearing. Ther campaign group said: 'If the tribunal does not make it clear to the parties (and the viewing public) that 'what exactly For Women Scotland says' is in fact clear and settled law and not 'contentious', 'a hypothesis' or 'in dispute' then it may render the judgment open to appeal on any point where Dr Upton's sex is relevant.' It also listed three exchanges between the barristers, one in which Ms Russell argued that the Supreme Court judgment was an abstract case regarding representation on public boards in Scotland and did not concern lavatories. In a second exchange, on July 23, Mr Russell told the court: 'Dr Upton is not a man, she is a trans woman.' In response, Ms Cunningham said: 'Dr Upton is a trans woman and trans women are men, certainly for the purposes of the Equality Act as we know from For Women Scotland.' Finally, on July 24, Ms Russell said: 'Dr Upton is not a man. For Women Scotland [the case] doesn't say so.' The gender-critical group's letter to the tribunal judge said the first exchange was not 'factually correct', adding: 'We are surprised there was no correction by the tribunal. 'In the second and third exchanges, Ms Cunningham was factually correct in her statement that Dr Upton is a man under the Equality Act, in accordance with the For Women Scotland ruling by the Supreme Court. This should not be a point in dispute by the court, nor regarded as contentious or a hypothesis to be tested.' Ms Peggie is seeking financial compensation for 'harassment' and 'hurt feelings' from both Dr Upton and NHS Fife. The veteran nurse was placed on special leave in January last year after Dr Upton made allegations of bullying and harassment, and cited concerns about 'patient care'. Evidence hearings have now concluded and oral submissions will be heard in September.
The National
14 hours ago
- The National
Anas Sarwar: Don't conflate Sandie Peggie 'racist' comments with point of tribunal
We previously told how Peggie, a nurse, allegedly told colleagues that she 'wanted to post bacon through the letterbox of a mosque' during the ongoing tribunal against NHS Fife. The Scottish Labour leader, who has publicly supported Peggie, told the Daily Record on Thursday that the comments were 'horrific'. Asked by The National if he regretted publicly supporting Peggie now the remarks had come to light, Sarwar insisted that he supported the 'primacy of the Equality Act'. READ MORE: Revealed: The full text of SNP's independence strategy Peggie was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, [[Fife]], on Christmas Eve 2023. Allegations were made during the tribunal regarding Peggie's comments relating to mosques, as well as "racist" jokes she had shared in a work group chat about flooding that killed thousands in Pakistan. Peggie denied the remarks in relation to mosques, but said the joke about the floods were sent in 'dark humour' to friends. Asked if he regretted supporting Peggie (below) following the revelations, Sarwar told The National: 'I think there should not be a conflation on saying that we support the protection of the Equality Act, the primacy of the Equality Act, and the protection of single sex spaces based on biological sex. (Image: Andrew Milligan/PA Wire) 'That is our position and remains our position. At the same time, we have to call out racism or any other form of prejudice, and that's exactly what we have done. 'We think the Scottish Government and NHS boards should be complying with the Equality Act. Should be urgently complying with the Equality Act whilst, and this is not inconsistent, whilst also calling out prejudice.' Pushed on if that meant he didn't regret publicly supporting Peggie, he said: 'I have zero regret in saying that we have to support the Equality Act, the primacy of the Equality Act and protecting single sex spaces based on biological sex. 'And I also continue to call out any form of racism or prejudice, as was demonstrated in those comments that have been attributed.' READ MORE: 43 SNP branches back challenge to John Swinney's independence strategy After Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment, citing concerns about 'patient care', Peggie was placed on special leave. She then lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment, harassment related to a protected belief, indirect discrimination, and victimisation. The tribunal has become a flash point for gender-critical campaigners and anti-trans groups, particularly following the Supreme Court ruling on the definition of a woman earlier this year. And now, For Women Scotland, which brought the case against the Scottish Government in relation to the definition of the Equality Act to the Supreme Court, has been granted permission to lodge a written intervention.
