France's highest court upholds some of Bashar Assad's legal protections
The Cour de Cassation upheld Assad's head-of-state immunity, but added that since he is no longer in office, 'new arrest warrants may have been or may be issued against him for acts that may constitute war crimes or crimes against humanity'.
Advertisement
The decision is a blow to activists who had hoped the court would set aside the immunity, a decision that could have had far-reaching consequences for other leaders accused of atrocities.
'From our side as a victim, this is a huge mistake. This will support another dictatorship to keep doing this kind of crime, they know they will enjoy immunity,' said Mazen Darwish, president of the Syrian Centre for Media, which collected evidence of war crimes.
'It is a sad day for us,' Mr Darwish said.
⚖️[Press release] Scope of immunity of foreign officials and Heads of State
👓Press release and rulings >
https://t.co/geYuof4ner
pic.twitter.com/jKLGvWKOtJ
— Cour de cassation (@Courdecassation)
July 25, 2025
The president of the Cour de Cassation, Christophe Soulard, said in the ruling that 19 judges had declined to lift Assad's immunity, which could have paved the way for his trial in absentia in France over the use of chemical weapons in Ghouta in 2013.
Advertisement
Human rights lawyers had said that it was high time to enable prosecution of leaders linked to atrocities while they are in power, not just when they leave.
But international law forbids it.
'Under current international law, crimes against humanity and war crimes are not exceptions to the principle of jurisdictional immunity for sitting foreign heads of state,' Mr Soulard said.
Assad, the former leader of Syria now in exile in Russia, retained no lawyers for these charges and has denied that he was behind the chemical attacks.
Advertisement
'The court's ruling is a missed opportunity for justice,' said Mariana Pena, a lawyer with the Open Society Justice Initiative, which helped bring the case to the court.
But she said that the ruling 'leaves the door open to the prosecution of Assad'.
The court also ruled on a case against a former Syrian government finance minister in Assad's government, allowing that he could be prosecuted.
Adib Mayaleh's lawyers have argued that he had immunity under international law.
Advertisement
For more than 50 years, Syria was ruled by Hafez Assad and then his son Bashar.
During the Arab Spring, rebellion broke out against their tyrannical rule in 2011 across the country of 23 million people, igniting a brutal 13-year civil war that killed more than 500,000 people, according to the Syrian Observatory of Human Rights.
Millions more fled to Lebanon, Jordan, Turkey and Europe.
The Assad dynasty manipulated sectarian tensions to stay in power, a legacy driving renewed violence in Syria against minority groups, despite promises that the country's new leaders will carve out a political future for Syria that includes and represents all of its communities.
Advertisement
The International Criminal Court is not bound by head of state immunity and has issued arrests warrants for leaders accused of atrocities – like Russian President Vladimir Putin in Ukraine, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in Gaza, and Rodrigo Duterte in the Philippines.
The Syrian government denied in 2013 that it was behind the Ghouta attack, an accusation that the opposition rejected, because Assad's forces were the only side in the brutal civil war to possess sarin.
The United States subsequently threatened military retaliation, but Washington settled for a deal with Moscow for Assad to give up his chemical weapons' stockpile.
Assad survived in power more than a decade longer, aided militarily by Russia and Iranian-backed proxies.
Activists and human rights group accuse him of using barrel bombs, torture and massacres to crush opponents.
But then in late 2024, a surprise assault by rebels swept into Aleppo and then Damascus, driving Assad to flee to safety to Russia on December 8, 2024.
New warrants after Friday's ruling in France could lay the groundwork for the former leader's trial in absentia or potential arrest, if he travels outside Russia.
Any trial of Assad, whether in absentia or if he leaves Russia, would mean this evidence could then 'be brought to light', Ms Pena said, including an enormous trove of classified and secret evidence amassed by the judges during their investigations.
Syrians often took great personal risk to gather evidence of war crimes.
Mr Darwish said that in the aftermath of a chlorine gas attack in Douma, for example, teams collected witness testimonies, images of devastation and soil samples.
Others then tracked down and interviewed defectors to build a 'chain of command' for the Syrian government's chemical weapons production and use.
'We link it directly to the president himself, Bashar al-Assad,' he said.
Syrian authorities are now investigating nearly 300 people for crimes during several days of fighting on the coast earlier this year. T
The interim authorities in Damascus have pledged to work with the United Nations on investigating further war crimes of the Assad government and the civil war.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
9 minutes ago
- The Sun
Benjamin Netanyahu defies ex-army chiefs as he hints at new Gaza offensive despite calls to end war with Hamas
ISRAELI Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hinted at wider military action in Gaza despite former army and intelligence chiefs calling for the war to end. A security cabinet meeting was postponed last night amid mounting tensions about possible plans for a 'full occupation' of the battered Middle Eastern strip. 2 Mr Netanyahu was said to be considering taking total control of the Palestinian-occupied territory to end the 22-month fight against Hamas. Senior Israeli military officials warned it could endanger the lives of captured hostages and further isolate the nation on the world stage. But local media reported Mr Netanyahu had already made up his mind, quoting an unnamed senior official saying: 'The die has been cast. 'We're going for the full conquest of the Gaza Strip – and defeating Hamas.' Previously, In a fiery address Sunday night, the Mr Netanyahu declared that Israel would press forward with a "decisive military victory" to free the remaining hostages. Netanyahu again vowed to crush Hamas, which he said was deliberately starving captives in scenes chillingly reminiscent of the Nazi death camps. , he said: "You see them languishing in a dungeon, but the Hamas monsters surrounding them have thick, fleshy arms. "They have everything they need to eat. They are starving them, just as the Nazis starved the Jews." The footage — released by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad last week and approved for publication by the families — shows the hostages visibly emaciated, trembling, and close to collapse. Starmer vows UK will recognise Palestine in weeks unless Israel ends crisis – but critics blast 'reward' for Hamas 2
The Sun
39 minutes ago
- The Sun
Keir Starmer made a colossal error scrapping the Rwanda scheme — his one in, one out gimmick will deter no one
Boat missed ANOTHER day, another shambolic attempt to fix Britain's broken borders. The latest big idea is a so-called 'one in, one out' deal with France. But Home Secretary Yvette Cooper refuses to put a number on how many bogus asylum-seekers will actually be sent back. At the very most it is likely to be no more than 50 a week — while 800 are arriving every seven days The scheme does nothing to end the migrants' incentives to come to the UK — such as bountiful benefits and the booming black market. Crucially, it doesn't act as any meaningful deterrent either. We DID once have a genuine plan: sending them to Rwanda. Yet Keir Starmer made a colossal error by scrapping the scheme on his first day in power. Branding it a gimmick, he insisted it had no chance of working. But the evidence showed that it WAS. In fear of its planned introduction last summer, hundreds had already started heading to Ireland instead. That's why, in a major embarrassment to the PM, Donald Trump has nicked the idea. 25K migrants have arrived across the Channel so far this year despite Labour's promise to crackdown The President — who has already slashed illegal migration in the US by 94 per cent — is now paying Rwanda to take their migrants. How many boats would have been stopped had Labour done the same? 1 Crippled tipple WHAT a devastating blow it is to see more than 1,100 pubs and restaurants close since Labour's jobs tax Budget. And what more terrible proof of its disastrous impact than the loss of two beloved boozers and eateries a day? Punters are clearly now holding on to what little spare cash they have. Being forced to stay at home is having devastating consequences on the hospitality industry. Landlords can't cope with soaring energy costs, crippling business rates and the deeply damaging National Insurance rise. And that's before hole in her next Budget. It's a tragic mix costing our vital communities dear. Bob villains TO the Left, race-hate rapper Bob Vylan is a martyr to the Palestinian cause. Yet a surge in antisemitic attacks followed his vile rants at Glastonbury. Racism watchdog CST says six incidents of hatred were committed against a Jewish person every day in the first half of this year. Such a shameful toll shows the obvious dangers to British Jews of Government appeasement of the pro-Palestinian mob.
Reuters
39 minutes ago
- Reuters
Zelenskiy says he had 'productive' call with Trump ahead of ceasefire deadline
KYIV, Aug 5 (Reuters) - Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy said on Tuesday that he had had a "productive" conversation with his U.S. counterpart Donald Trump on ending the war, sanctions on Russia and the finalisation of a U.S.-Ukraine drone deal. "President Trump is fully informed about Russian strikes on Kyiv and other cities and communities," Zelenskiy wrote on X, referring to intensifying drone and missile attacks. Trump, who has signalled frustration with Vladimir Putin in recent weeks, has given the Russian president until August 8 to make peace in Ukraine or face tougher sanctions. A source in Washington said U.S. envoy Steve Witkoff would be meeting the Russian leadership in Moscow on Wednesday. Speaking in his nightly video address, Zelenskiy said Trump "knows the situation along the front line," which extends for 1,000 km (620 miles) through eastern and southern Ukraine. Ukraine, he said, had long supported U.S. proposals for an immediate ceasefire and had proposed a number of formats to implement a halt to the fighting. "We have spoken with and proposed to Russia quiet in the skies, no missile and drone attacks and specifically no attacks on civilian infrastructure or on the energy sector," he said. "All of this has been violated by the Russians and in a very cynical fashion." Trump has threatened to hit Russia with new sanctions and impose 100% tariffs on countries that buy its oil, although sources close to the Kremlin have told Reuters that Putin is unlikely to bow to the ultimatum. Zelenskiy said Ukraine was also ready to conclude a deal with the U.S. on the purchase of Ukrainian drones that would amount to "one of the strongest agreements". He had earlier said the deal was worth around $30 billion. Ukraine is increasingly seeking financing and investment from its foreign partners to bolster its burgeoning domestic arms industry. Zelenskiy said Kyiv's European partners had so far pledged to buy more than $1 billion in U.S. weapons for Ukraine as part of a new scheme.
