Nearly all government ministers owe money to the State due to pension error, with funds to be ‘fully recouped'
Almost all government ministers and junior ministers owe money to the State due to errors in pension payments.
They will be informed in the coming days of the sums to be repaid, ranging from as low as €100 up to €30,000.
Although the ministers and other civil servants involved were not at fault in relation to the errors identified in the National Shared Services Office (NSSO), Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers said he will ensure 'all monies owed to the State are fully recouped'.
In some cases, ministers may be owed money due to the administrative errors.
The full scale of the issues, relating to payroll and pensions, and the number impacted is still being assessed.
The Cabinet was briefed on the administrative errors in the state HR agency yesterday.
One issue relates to a retired senior civil servant who owes €280,000 to the State because their pension was undertaxed, it has been revealed. The retiree is among up to 13,000 retired civil servants and government ministers currently being assessed.
Meanwhile, Sinn Féin's Pearse Doherty said there are 'serious questions' over the oversight of the agency 'responsible for putting taxpayers' money into the pockets of very highly paid, with golden pensions, senior civil servants – money they were never entitled to in the first place.'
It is understood the NSSO will undertake an 'engagement process' to reach an arrangement with the individual in order to recoup the payment.
There are three cohorts impacted by these errors: current and former ministers and office holders; civil service retirees with work-sharing patterns; and retired senior civil servants.
Mr Chambers said the errors span different time periods and have been detected in various ways.
ADVERTISEMENT
One issue relates to the incorrect application of pension deductions for most members of the current Government, ministers of state, some members of previous governments and recent office holders.
The amounts involved range from hundreds of euro to the low €30,000s in terms of monies to be recouped.
In addition, a number of ministers are due refunds ranging from hundreds of euro to the low €20,000s. Some are unaffected.
Another issue relates to 30 cases involving the administration of Chargeable Excess Tax, a tax on pension funds, and Withholding Tax, which is deducted from retirement lump sums, in relation to senior grade civil service pensioners.
'The liabilities for this cohort range from a few hundred euro to €280,000,' Mr Chambers said.
Another issue relates to the miscalculation and under-payment of pensions for some work-sharing civil service retirees. These individuals were in receipt of allowances before they retired in the last 20 years or so.
'The issues that have been brought to my attention by the NSSO are completely unacceptable,' Mr Chambers said.
'The NSSO has responsibility for the essential function of the provision of pay and pensions to public and civil servants and it has failed in this fundamental duty. I have instructed the CEO of the NSSO that the multiple errors must be corrected by the NSSO as a matter of urgency.'
The NSSO provides human resources, payroll, pension and finance management services to public service bodies, including government departments.
Mr Chambers said he is committed to fully and comprehensively addressing the matter to ensure all money owed to the State is fully recouped and money owed to individuals is refunded, and to restore trust in the NSSO. He said a pool of 13,000 retirees will be checked.
'To be clear, this does not imply that all 13,000 will have anomalies, but all 13,000 will be checked,' he said.
Mr Chambers said issues arose due to administrative errors in the NSSO and are not the fault of any of the individuals impacted.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Ireland's largest public GDPR fine hits State over illegal biometric data use in PSC
The Data Protection Commission has hit the State with a €550,000 fine, the largest GDPR penalty for a public body, for processing people's biometric data without a legal basis via the Public Services Card. The DPC said that the Government must now discontinue processing such data using the PSC within 9 months unless it can find a legal basis for doing so. Biometric data refers to any information that can identify a person by their physical characteristics — for example, via a fingerprint or, in the PSC case, a photograph. The State has long denied that the PSC uses biometric data, despite a person's photograph appearing on every version of the card. It has instead argued that it creates an "arithmetic template" from the photo for processing purposes — a method it claims does not constitute biometric data. Such data is classified as special category personal data under the EU's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), meaning it must be explicitly permitted in a country's laws to be processed legally. There is no single law on Ireland's statute books governing the PSC. Its various uses are allegedly permitted through dozens of amendments to the 2005 Social Welfare Consolidation Act. In addition to the €550,000 fine — five times greater than the next largest penalty for a public body — and the order to stop processing biometric data, the DPC also issued an official reprimand to the Department of Social Protection. The Commission found that the card violated GDPR by failing to identify a legal basis for processing biometric data, retaining that data without justification, and not ensuring sufficient transparency about how the data would be used during registration. Deputy Commissioner with the DPC Graham Doyle said that it is 'important to note that none of the findings of infringement identified, nor the corrective powers exercised by the DPC, pertain to the rollout of SAFE 2 registration (the technical process by which PSC data is first collated and then stored) by the DSP as a matter of principle'. He added that the investigation focused solely on how the PSC's biometric process complies with the GDPR, noting that 'the findings announced today identify a number of deficiencies in this regard." It remains unclear what will happen next. However, if the Government accepts the report, it will finally need to introduce specific legislation through the Oireachtas to legalize the PSC. The Department of Social Protection declined to comment. In announcing its conclusions the DPC has brought to a close its lengthiest domestic data protection saga, one which had lasted close to 8 years. By announcing its conclusions, the DPC has ended its longest domestic data protection investigation—a process that lasted nearly eight years. In August 2019, the DPC ruled that the State had no lawful basis for making the PSC — originally conceived in the 2000s as a welfare benefits card by the Department of Social Protection — mandatory for all public services. That decision led to a prolonged legal battle between the State and one of its own regulators. The dispute ended in a December 2021 settlement, with the DPC's findings left unchallenged but the State continuing with the PSC project—albeit without mandatory requirements. A separate investigation into the biometric nature of the card ran concurrently with the original report. Initially, it was expected that this investigation would publish its findings by the end of 2019. While the conclusions of the biometric investigation are not surprising, today's publication comes nearly six years later than anticipated. The PSC is now used daily by millions of Irish citizens—not just for receiving welfare payments, but also for services such as renewing driving licences and accessing the National Childcare Scheme. Read More Funding available for schools to procure mobile phone storage, department says
The Irish Sun
6 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Six new social welfare changes to little-known €245 weekly payment – are you eligible?
SIX changes to a little-known social welfare payment worth €245 each week have been confirmed. The upcoming Advertisement 3 The scheme is designed to support more disabled people into employment Credit: Getty 3 Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary, Minister of State in attendance Hildegarde Naughton, Taoiseach Micheal Martin and Minister for Children, Disability and Equality Norma Foley Credit: Niall Carson/PA Wire The Wage Subsidy Scheme gives financial support to employers who employ people with disabilities. The scheme is designed to support more disabled people into employment. The changes announced are a result of the recommendations from a review of the WSS, which was carried out by the Department of Social Protection in August 2024. Advertisement Read more in Money The employer will pay the employee the going rate for the job. And the basic rate of subsidy is €6.30 per hour with the maximum annual subsidy to the employer of €12,776, based on a 39-hour week. And this equals around €245.69 each week. The employee must work at least 15 hours a week. Advertisement MOST READ IN MONEY Speaking at the event last week, the Taoiseach said: "I am delighted to launch these improvements to the Wage Subsidy Scheme. Little known social welfare benefits thousands are entitled to "Supports like this play not only a critical role in closing the employment gap for people with disabilities, reducing poverty and supporting families and communities, but also for employers in bringing new ideas, skills and knowledge to their businesses. "I am committed to advancing the rights and improving the lives of people with disabilities including through removing barriers to employment. "Supports such as this revised Wage Subsidy Scheme recognise that the perspective, talents, and contributions of people with disabilities across society add immeasurably to the quality, the richness and the diversity of all our lives." Advertisement SIX NEW CHANGES TO WSS THE reformed scheme now implements the six recommendations made in the review: Reduce the minimum required hours for the scheme. The minimum hours requirement to avail of the subsidy has been reduced from 21 hours to 15 hours to enable those with more limited work capacity to be included. Remove the term 'productivity deficit' from the scheme. The scheme no longer focuses on a productivity deficit but on the need to adapt the role to a disabled person's ability. Expand the scheme beyond recruitment to include retention of people returning to work. This is particularly important as most disabilities are acquired. People who return to work on Partial Capacity Benefit and who have acquired their disability or health condition in the previous 12 months are now eligible. Expand the scheme to the community and voluntary sector and commercial state-sponsored sector. This will increase employment opportunities for disabled people by expanding the scheme beyond private sector employers to all non-public sector employers. Review the subsidy rate on a regular basis. This will ensure that the subsidy continues to sufficiently support employers. The subsidy rate will be reviewed at least every three years. Promote and improve knowledge of the scheme. The Minister has today launched a nationwide publicity campaign for the Wage Subsidy Scheme to promote and improve knowledge of the scheme. Minister Calleary added: "I strongly encourage employers to consider how the Wage Subsidy Scheme can improve their business and offer substantial and sustainable employment to disabled people." "I believe that the changes made to the Wage Subsidy Scheme will make it more accessible and flexible for both employers and disabled people. "People with disabilities have the talents and skills that employers need. "Improving employment prospects for disabled people is an absolute priority for me, the Taoiseach and this government." Advertisement There are around 1,500 employers who are already taking part in the Wage Subsidy Scheme across the country. WHO IS ELIGIBLE FOR WSS? You must be at least 18 years of age to participate in the WSS and you cannot take part if you are eligible to apply for the State Pension. The scheme is not available to self-employed people, people on the Community Employment scheme, Tús, or the Rural Social Scheme, or those who are on the Work Placement Experience Programme. You can qualify for the WSS without a medical assessment if you are getting one of the following disability payments: Advertisement Disability Allowance Blind Pension Disablement Pension - at 20 per cent or more for life Illness Benefit Invalidity Pension If you are not getting a disability payment, you can still apply for the WSS. To apply, you need a recent specialist's report or doctor's letter confirming your disability. Your doctor must also fill out a confidential medical report form confirming that you have a disability which will reduce your ability to work. Minister for Advertisement "There is so much potential and talent that can be tapped into. "I hope these improvements to the scheme will encourage more employers to become involved and provide real opportunities for people with disabilities to showcase their talents and abilities.' 3 Taoiseach Micheal Martin and the Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary last week announced the expansion of the scheme Credit:
Irish Times
21 hours ago
- Irish Times
Q&A: What is the pension payment error all about and can the money be recouped?
Unions and representatives of retired civil servants say they are awaiting detail of the errors made in relation to the pensions of their current or former members . However, there is concern that some of the issues could require legislation and that senior politicians could be impacted by any changes to the law. What has happened? On Tuesday the Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers said 'serious and systemic operational issues' had been identified at the National Shared Services Office (NSSO), which employs about 850 people and handles payroll administration for all government departments. The belief is these errors have resulted in some retired civil servants being underpaid in their pensions; incorrect pension contributions having been deducted from current and previous ministers; and the wrong amount of tax being deducted from the lump sums paid to about 30 senior civil servants upon retirement. With a review of 13,000 retirees' positions under way, however, and an external audit of the NSSO to be undertaken, it is uncertain how the situation will develop. READ MORE What will happen in respect of people who owe or are owed money? Mr Chambers said he was committed to ensuring 'all monies owed to the State are fully recouped and monies owed to individuals are refunded'. The former is likely to create issues, however, especially in relation to the larger amounts, with one retiree said to owe €280,000. With Mr Chambers suggesting some ministers may be asked to repay more than €30,000, the tax issue could be considerable. Details of the time frame have not been clarified, but Ciaran Rohan of the Association of Higher Civil and Public Servants says recouping overpayments stretching back more than four years could leave retirees, or potentially some politicians, substantially out of pocket. This is because current legislation would only allow the reclaiming of the extra tax paid as a result of receiving the extra money for the past four years, even if the overpayments stretched further back. Could that be changed? Only by legislation, says employment lawyer Barry Kenny, who says the issue means 'the original error has financial implications beyond a simple repayment issue'. It also has the potential to make it a political one. How could the money be recouped? A government circular in 2018 sets out the various ways in which overpayments can be reclaimed but there is no provision for anything like a liability of €280,000. The intention should be to recoup all the money and ideally within a year, it suggests, usually by deductions from pay or pensions of up to 8 per cent of the gross amount the person is receiving. But these people can afford to repay, no? The largest figures relate to people who had pension funds on retirement worth more than €2 million. That would certainly suggest they are well off but coming up with the funds to repay a six-figure sum is likely to be regarded as an issue. Cloda Ryan of the Retired Civil and Public Servants Association (RCPSA), which has some 7,000 members, says the vast majority of amounts involved are likely to be far smaller but still have the potential to cause problems for the pensioners concerned. 'Contrary to public perception, the majority of Civil Service pensioners have moderate pensions, in many cases lower than they would receive under the social welfare State pension for which, in general, civil servants recruited before April 6th, 1995 do not qualify.' The organisation is seeking assurances 'that no recovery of pension overpayments would take place without consultation and agreement with each pensioner affected'. And if an agreement can't be reached? 'Any civil servant faced with a request to refund money, large or small, should take legal advice to clarify the legal basis for the demand to repay and whether the figures are accurate,' says Mr Kenny. He says where the validity is established, 'reasonable' deductions or instalments would need to be agreed.
