Alabama Senate committee approves religious instruction policy mandate
An Alabama Senate committee Wednesday approved a bill that would require school boards to adopt policies on whether to allow students to leave school for religious study and give them academic credit for it.
SB 278, sponsored by Sen. Shay Shelnutt, R-Trussville, mirrors HB 342, sponsored by Rep. Susan DuBose, R-Hoover, which was rejected by the House Education Committee on April 2. The state already has a law that allows school boards to adopt such policies, known as Released Time Religious Instruction (RTRI). The bill would mandate the development of those policies.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
The committee heard from critics and supporters of the legislation last week.
'The bill is designed to provide local control and flexibility, ensuring a district can implement policies that best suit their needs, while respecting the constitutional rights of students and parents,' Shelnutt said Wednesday.
The senator said the policy could forbid RTRI.
'Yes, local boards have the ability to adopt their own policies,' he said. 'If the policy they implement is super narrow because this does not work in their district in any way, then so be it.'
Sen. Kirk Hatcher, D-Montgomery, echoed a concern raised by Dale County Superintendent Ben Baker last week that there is not enough time in the school day for students to leave campus for RTRI. He said religious instruction should happen at home.
'This is kind of boilerplate legislation, in my view. At some point we have to give parents the responsibility we say parents should have in terms of how they go about the process of sharing moral values with their kids,' Hatcher said. 'In fact, I know that it should begin at home.'
Hatcher also questioned the intent of the bill. Although the legislation says that any religious group can participate, Hatcher was concerned about what that would look like and if it would happen.
'I do know that there's a slippery slope to this kind of legislation,' he said. 'I do know that a part of the intent of legislation like this has a great deal to do with this notion of Christian nationalism.'
Sen. Roger Smitherman, D-Birmingham, raised concerns over liability. He said that students could sign up for the program, leave the school and not attend the program.
'We don't have control over them but they're still under us, but we don't have control. That's an hour that is returned outside during the hours of eight to three,' Smitherman said.
Shelnutt said the groups that host RTRI, like LifeWise Ministry, will assume all liability. According to LifeWise's sample curriculum, it teaches the Christian belief that 'God created all things good' to a list of virtues that the nonprofit describes as 'LifeWise qualities.'
At least 30 school board representatives from across the state attended Wednesday's meeting. Sally Smith, executive director of the Alabama Association of School Boards, said she is disappointed the legislation passed, but would continue to have conversations with lawmakers. Smith has consistently expressed concern and opposition to the bill.
'We think that we just have to have continued conversations with our senators due to local leaders' concerns with this bill,' Smith said in an interview. 'It is in the area of making policy that presents constitutional challenges to local boards of education. So it is not as clearly clean cut as some may think.'
The bill was approved 8-1 with Hatcher as the only member that voted against the bill. Smitherman said he only voted for it to get it out of committee, but that it still needed significant work. Shelnutt said he would work with Smitherman on his concerns.
'I'm going to vote to get the bill out of committee, but I do think that before we move that bill on the floor, that these things have got to be tightened up,' Smitherman said.
The bill moves to the full Senate.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
8 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's embrace of unchristian Christian nationalism
Pete Hegseth, widely considered the least qualified Defense secretary in American history, is hardly anyone's version of the ideal Christian husband and father. Only 45 years old, he's been married three times. His first marriage — to his high school sweetheart — lasted a mere four years, deteriorating after Hegseth admitted to multiple extramarital affairs. A couple of years later, he married his second wife, with whom he had three children. During that marriage, he fathered a child with a Fox News producer who eventually became his third wife. He paid off a woman who accused him of sexual assault (he denies the assault). He routinely passed out drunk at family gatherings and misbehaved in public when inebriated, according to numerous witnesses. His own mother once accused him of being 'an abuser of women,' though she later retracted her claims when Hegseth was facing Senate confirmation. Still, the Senate's Republican majority, cowed by President Trump, confirmed his appointment. Hegseth has two qualities that Trump prizes above all others. He is blindly loyal to the president, and he looks good on TV. After his installation, Hegseth proceeded to fire top military brass who happened to be Black or women or both. He has restored the names of Confederate generals to Army bases (Bragg and Benning). His petty 'anti-woke' crusade led him to strip the name of the assassinated gay rights leader Harvey Milk, a former Naval officer who served honorably, from a Navy ship. And he has considered doing the same to a ship named in honor of the abolitionist and Civil War hero Harriet Tubman. He has said that women do not belong in combat roles, and has kicked out transgender soldiers, cruelly stripping them of the pensions they earned for their service. In March, he shared classified information about an impending American airstrike in Yemen on an unsecured Signal group chat that included his wife, on purpose, and the editor of the Atlantic, by accident. He is, in short, the least serious man ever to lead this nation's armed forces. As if all that weren't dispiriting enough, Hegseth is now in bed (metaphorically) with a crusading Christian nationalist. Earlier this month, Hegseth made waves when he reposted on social media a CNN interview with Douglas Wilson, the pastor and theocrat who is working hard to turn the clock back on the rights of every American who is not white, Christian and male. In the interview, Wilson expounded on his patriarchal, misogynistic, authoritarian and homophobic views. Women, he said, should serve as 'chief executive of the home' and should not have the right to vote. (Their men can do that for them.) Gay marriage and gay sex should be outlawed once again. 'We know that sodomy is worse than slavery by how God responds to it,' he told CNN's Pamela Brown. (Slavery is 'unbiblical,' he avowed, though he did bizarrely defend it once, writing in 1990 a pamphlet that 'slavery produced in the South a genuine affection between the races that we believe we can say has never existed in any nation before the War or since.') When a new outpost of his church opened in Washington, D.C ., in July, Hegseth and his family were among the worshippers. CNN described Hegseth's presence as 'a major achievement' for Wilson. 'All of Christ for All of Life,' wrote Hegseth as he endorsed and reposted the interview. That is the motto of Wilson's expanding universe, which includes his Christ Church in Moscow, Idaho, the center of his Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches, a network of more than 100 churches on four continents, parochial schools, a college, a publishing house and media platforms. 'All of Christ for All of Life' is a shorthand for the belief that Christian doctrines should shape every part of life — including government, culture and education. Wilson is a prolific author of books with titles such as 'Her Hand in Marriage,' 'Federal Husband,' and 'Reforming Marriage.' His book 'Fidelity' teaches 'what it means to be a one-woman man.' Doubtful it has crossed Hegseth's desk. 'God hates divorce,' writes Wilson in one of his books. Given the way sexual pleasure is celebrated in the Old and New Testaments, Wilson has a peculiarly dim view of sex. I mean, how many weddings have been graced with recitations from the Song of Solomon, with its thinly disguised allusions to pleasurable sexual intimacy? ('Let him kiss me with the kisses of his mouth! For your love is better than wine.') Wilson's world is considerably less sensual. 'A man penetrates, conquers, colonizes, plants,' he writes in 'Fidelity.' 'A woman receives, surrenders, accepts.' Mutual sexual pleasure seems out of the question: 'The sexual act cannot be made into an egalitarian pleasuring party.' Ugh. There is nothing particularly new here; Wilson's ideology is just another version of patriarchal figures using religion to fight back against the equality movements of the late 19th and 20th centuries. They are basically the hatemongers of the Westboro Baptist Church dressed up in respectable clothing. 'Some people may conflate Christian nationalism and Christianity because they both use the symbols and language of Christianity, such as a Bible, a cross and worship songs,' says the group Christians Against Christian Nationalism on its website. 'But Christian nationalism uses the veneer of Christianity to advance its own aims — to point to a political figure, party or ideology instead of Jesus.' What you have in people like Hegseth and Wilson are authoritarian men who hide behind their religion to execute the most unchristian of agendas. God may hate divorce, but from my reading of the Bible, God hates hypocrisy even more. Bluesky: @rabcarianThreads: @rabcarian
Politico
a day ago
- Politico
Trump-inspired showmen are running this California county. Will it work on the state stage?
Bianco is a vocal supporter of Trump who regularly mirrors the president's rhetoric as he lays into Democrats on crime, immigration, high taxes and affordability. In the past, he said he would not enforce state vaccine mandates, promised to end sanctuary laws, and was once a dues paying member of the Oath Keepers, an extremist militia. When he endorsed Trump in 2024, he released a tongue-in-cheek video proclaiming 'It's time we put a felon in the White House. Trump 2024, baby.' Shaw, meanwhile, led a successful effort in 2023 to bar teachers from displaying the Pride flag at Chino Valley Unified schools. That same year, she promoted a local policy requiring schools to inform parents if their child might be transgender, prompting the state to quickly sue the school district (last year, a court permanently blocked the policy). A Los Angeles Times profile of Shaw observed that depending on who you ask, she is a 'righteous mother' or 'a small-town bigot, basking in the celebrity she's attained as a mouthpiece for Christian evangelicals.' 'I think they're coming out fighting and swinging because people want to see results,' Ingram said. 'I don't know there is a center anymore when it comes to politics.' For Democrats, that's a major problem. The party had expanded its ranks in the county by promoting a more moderate brand of center-left politics. But cost of living and other economic concerns are especially pronounced here. Longer commutes and lower wages mean economic issues resonate. Many residents who drive to Los Angeles for work spend hours each day on the highway to avoid paying for the toll road. Traffic grows worse by the year. And while the county's ever-more diverse suburbs had propelled Democrats to past victories, Bianco, Essayli, and Shaw's wins in the half-decade leading up to 2024 were precursors to an election in which Republicans were able to capitalize on lower turnout and peel off voters who trusted the GOP more on core issues like public safety and the economy, said Democratic political consultant Derek Humphrey. That migration, in swing states, was vital in delivering Trump the presidency and could reshape politics around the country — if it persists. 'There's certainly concern,' Humphrey said. 'The big question is: Was this a temporary shift? Or was it part of a long-term trend?' In Norco, the traditional values of the Old West are (literally) embedded into the structure of the 25,000-person town. Gravel horse trails, groomed near-daily by city maintenance workers, lead to the piled haystacks at Tony's Hay and Grain beside Norco's Christian Community Church. On Corona Street, a series of corrals line the block, the mares inside watched over by an ironwork silhouette of two riders heading for a desert cross. New construction, by law, is required to look 'Western' — a regulation taken so literally that the City Council once rejected the domed architecture of a planned Hindu temple for not fitting a 'western aesthetic.'
San Francisco Chronicle
2 days ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Federal judge orders Oakland public schools to allow religious after-school clubs
A U.S. District Court judge has ordered the Oakland Unified School District to allow a Christian ministry to use public school buildings for after-school meetings. The temporary order comes after the Child Evangelism Fellowship sued the Oakland school district in December, alleging schools opened campuses for secular organizations such as the Girl Scouts but in 2023 denied spaces to Good News Clubs, which had held weekly club meetings at a number of Oakland schools for a decade before pandemic shutdowns. Lawyers from the conservative nonprofit Liberty Counsel representing the fellowship argued in their December lawsuit that the Oakland district, which has 45,000 students, is 'showing hostility towards the religious identity, speech, and viewpoint' of the organization and the district was violating a variety of its liberties including its free speech and equal protection rights. 'It is not clear how much of a dispute actually exists here,' U.S. District Judge Haywood S. Gilliam said. 'The Court finds that the law and facts clearly favor Plaintiff's position that OUSD violated CEF's free speech rights.' The district 'appears' to argue its schools had no space to offer the fellowship, according to the court order. The district then appears to pivot its argument, suggesting that providing the fellowship with campus space would violate the Establishment Clause because the ministry's programming is from a Christian viewpoint. Gilliam relied on Supreme Court precedent that rejected a similar argument. Liberty Counsel is now seeking a permanent ruling, cementing their access to Oakland school campuses for its after school clubs, which it says provide students with religious and other teaching to encourage moral and character development, learning and spiritual growth. 'This is a great victory for Child Evangelism Fellowship, parents, and the students in Oakland public schools,' said Mat Staver, Liberty Counsel founder and chairman. 'The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that public schools cannot discriminate against Christian viewpoints regarding use of school facilities. Child Evangelism Fellowship gives children a biblically based education that includes moral and character development. Good News Clubs should be in every public elementary school.'
