Hipkins Undermines Finance Spokesperson As Labour Struggles With Economic Policy
'Chris Hipkins has once again publicly undermined his Finance spokesperson, telling a blogger last night not to 'read too much into' the fact she committed Labour to continuing the 50 per cent debt cap, originally signed up to by Grant Robertson,' says National's Finance spokesperson Nicola Willis.
'He also unbelievably claimed she was talking about Labour's policy at the 2023 election, despite Barbara Edmonds specifically saying the 50 per cent cap will continue to be Labour's policy and her rejection of the OBEGALx fiscal measure adopted in 2024.
'At the same time, she also committed to an operating surplus in the year ending June 2029, a year not mentioned in Labour's 2023 fiscal plan, making it difficult to see how she could have been talking about their 2023 policy.
'Earlier this year, her position on public-private partnerships was promptly undermined by Chris Hipkins before she excruciatingly had to walk it back in the media.
'If New Zealanders are being told not to read into what Barbara Edmonds says is Labour's position on debt or PPPs, how can they take seriously anything Labour says on the economy and the Budget?
'Chris Hipkins needs to start being upfront on Labour's fiscal plan. They have opposed every savings measure and committed to spending more on virtually everything, including locally made school lunches, and half-price public transport, while also reversing changes to pay equity laws, and continuing all of this Government's infrastructure projects.
'They will need to find the money through higher taxes, higher debt or both. A recipe that has already proven to be a disaster for Kiwis.
'If Chris Hipkins can be clear enough to undermine Barbara Edmonds' positions on almost everything, he can be upfront on what Labour's actual position on debt is.'
Notes:
Transcript of Chris Hipkins' comments:
Martyn Bradbury: So why has Labour locked itself into the exact same neoliberal economic debt straitjacket that National have us chained to? Economist Bernard Hickey was heavily critical of your decision to strangle us with the exact same neoliberal limitations of net debt capped at 50 per cent of GDP.
Chris Hipkins: Well, I mean, I don't think we should read too much into the fact that Barbara was – Barbara, our Finance spokesperson – Barbara Edmonds, was talking about the policy we went into the last election with. We haven't determined the policy that we're going to go into the next election with.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
8 hours ago
- 1News
Ruth Richardson calls for super age hike, warns of fiscal 'crisis'
Former finance minister Ruth Richardson has called for an increase in the retirement age, warning New Zealand faces a balance sheet crisis without urgent action. The newly appointed chairperson of the Taxpayers' Union, a right-wing political lobby group, told Q+A that government debt needed addressing. "We need to control our spending appetite, we need to bring debt under control, and we need to restore New Zealand's books to a state of fiscal responsibility," Richardson said. "From a central government perspective, it's clear that we have a crisis, and the crisis is looming — as it is in many other countries in the West, we're not alone." The architect of the 1991 "Mother Of All Budgets" said the Government should follow her previous reforms that raised the superannuation eligibility age from 60 to 65. ADVERTISEMENT "On my watch, we increased the age of eligibility from 60 to 65, with near a mutter. It was done as part of a broader package of reforms to put New Zealand on a sounder footing, and we need to do the same again," she said. "We should have a superannuation age of eligibility, just like the electoral boundaries. You just adjust it for — in this case — the data that tells you about the age of longevity." Richardson, who became aligned with ACT after retiring from politics, criticised the coalition government for ultimately committing billions more in spending at Budget 2025. She said: "We're starting to swamp education spending, we're starting to swamp defence spending — that is not defensible. We need a credible deficit track. "At the moment, we've got fiction. What we want is fact, and fact is going to require some pretty hard decisions taken about the issues... starting with superannuation." Ruth Richardson (Source: Supplied) She also rejected the characterisation that the country had a lack of funding for infrastructure, saying instead that too much money was being spent on "vanity projects" at the local government level. ADVERTISEMENT Finance Minister Nicola Willis has previously rejected suggestions she had broken an election promise to return to surplus by 2027. It was despite Treasury forecasts now showing a return to surplus wouldn't occur until 2029 under the Government's preferred accounting measure known as OBEGALx. By the traditional measure, known as OBEGAL, New Zealand wasn't expected to return to surplus until the 2030s at the earliest. OBEGALx excluded the costs of ACC. Richardson also advocated for asset sales, suggesting the Government should sell state-owned enterprises, including power companies, Landcorp and commercial broadcaster TVNZ — which she said was "probably worth a dollar". Richardson steadfast on views nearly 35 years on Speaking on Q+A, Richardson, who was recently made a companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit in the King's Birthday Honours, defended her 1990s reforms after being presented with poverty statistics showing persistent increases following her Budget cuts. When presented with data showing child poverty rates grown significantly after her reforms and never ultimately corrected, Richardson defended herself, saying doing nothing in her time would have been "the most immoral option". ADVERTISEMENT "We took our courage in our hands and did the right thing, and the economy prospered. You're not putting up the stats that showed the rise in growth, the rise in employment, the halving of the debt and putting the books back into balance," she said. "If you were balanced, you'd be showing those statistics." She added: "The real poverty was New Zealand's if we had done nothing. If we had done nothing, then New Zealand would have most certainly faced the crisis that the Labour government did in the mid-'80s. And in a crisis, the people who are hurt most are the poorest people, the people on the bottom of the rung." For the full interview, watch the video above Q+A with Jack Tame is made with the support of New Zealand On Air
Scoop
17 hours ago
- Scoop
TOP Will Convene Citizens' Assemblies To End Political Gridlock
Sunday 15 June 2025. To break the cycle of political indecision and costly policy reversals, The Opportunities Party is launching The Citizens' Voice. The party's first 2026 Election policy calls for the use of Citizens' Assemblies on pressing issues successive Governments are failing on. "Politics as usual isn't working. We're stuck in a wasteful cycle of pendulum politics where every left-right lurch after an election costs us," says TOP spokesperson David Webb. 'Every time Government changes, we endure economic uncertainty on par with 9/11. We just can't afford that anymore'. Recent examples of political waste include $229 million on the abandoned Auckland light rail project, $300 million (and counting) for cancelled inter-island ferries and $297 million lost in (another) overhaul of New Zealand's polytechnics. 'The consistent decline in right track / wrong track polling shows us that people are losing trust in our political system. The Citizens' Voice is about turning that trend around by doing democracy differently – with everyday people leading on the hard issues, and politicians following' says Webb. The Citizens' Voice policy has two components: Citizens' Assemblies. Like jury duty but for policy, Assemblies bring together a random, representative, paid group of New Zealanders to learn about a complex issue, deliberate on solutions and make recommendations that Government must respond to. The process is designed to progress politically gridlocked, long-term issues like superannuation, housing, healthcare and infrastructure. Parliamentary Commissioner for Citizens' Voice. An independent, non-partisan office gives the policy institutional backbone. The Commissioner will convene Assemblies, ensure they are fair and robust, use new digital democracy tools to amplify Citizens' voices and ensure Government engages seriously with Citizens' recommendations. 'Citizens' Assemblies are about trusting that everyday New Zealanders, when given information and time, can find common ground and set sensible, long-term policy directions on the issues politicians have failed on' says Webb. Citizens' Assemblies have helped navigate tense, complicated issues internationally and in New Zealand. In Ireland, Assemblies broke decades of deadlock on marriage equality and abortion. In Auckland, an Assembly's recommendations on water infrastructure were adopted by the Watercare Board. Two issues that could benefit from a Citizens' Assembly approach are New Zealand's Constitutional system and Superannuation. 'The Treaty Principles controversy highlighted the partisan, performative nature of Parliament. The Bill itself was short-sighted and divisive, but there is a real need for a national conversation on our Constitutional framework and the role of Te Tiriti. How we make that decision is as important as the decision itself - maybe more so' says Webb. 'Superannuation is on track to send New Zealand over the fiscal cliff – but it's a politically untouchable issue because it's a vote loser for politicians. A Citizens' Assembly would give Parliament the social license to finally act on Superannuation.' 'The problem with kicking the can down the road, is that eventually, you run out of road' says Webb. 'With challenges like AI and climate change coming at us, New Zealanders deserve a political system built around courage, co-operation and long-term thinking. We're launching the Citizens' Voice policy to do just that.' A full overview of The Citizens' Voice policy - including FAQs, briefing papers and international examples - is available at
1News
a day ago
- 1News
Moving south: Why North Islanders are upping sticks in droves
The South Island is attracting a growing number of internal migrants, with new figures revealing more than 85,000 Kiwis have relocated there from the North Island in five years. Between 2018 and 2023, 85,575 people made the move south, 30,000 more than those heading north, according to Stats New Zealand. Auckland alone saw a net migration loss of 50,000 people over five years. Canterbury and Otago had the highest number of people living in the region that had moved between the two islands since the 2018 Census. Stats NZ 2023 Census spokesperson Rosemary Goodyear said housing affordability and study opportunities were likely to be "strong factors" for drawing people south. ADVERTISEMENT "House prices are typically lower in Canterbury than in much of the North Island. "Students may be moving to study at universities – 15 to 29-year-olds made up one-third of people that moved to Canterbury from the North Island between 2018 and 2023, and half of those who moved to Otago from the North Island." Minister for the South Island James Meager. (Source: Getty) Christchurch has the lowest average rents and house prices among New Zealand's three major cities. South Island Minister James Meager said there was "massive growth" in housing developments across Te Waipounamu, including in Lincoln, Rolleston, and in central Otago. "I spent the last two days in Queenstown, and that is going absolutely bananas." He said so many people wanted to move down for the environment, the scenery, and work opportunities. ADVERTISEMENT "If you want to come from the North Island and bring your direct foreign investment south, we are welcoming you with open arms." Youth migration is being driven by Christchurch's revitalisation following the earthquakes with a record-high enrolment at the University of Canterbury of 25,000 students. The city's population of those aged 15-24 has increased by 6%, bucking the national trend. The revitalisation of Christchurch after the earthquakes has been a major reason for increased internal migration. (Source: 1News) "Christchurch has essentially been rebuilt after the earthquake, so you've got new, attractive housing and buildings," said Canterbury University Student Association president Luc MacKay. "People consistently tell me they really enjoy coming here because it's fresh." The West Coast mining sector has added 1200 jobs, while manufacturing and future-focused sectors were expanding too in Canterbury ADVERTISEMENT ChristchurchNZ chief executive Ali Adams said incredible jobs were being created and advertised in the Garden City daily. "This is particularly in some of our future focus sectors like aerospace and clean tech and also in the health tech industries." The island's famed beauty, from snow-capped mountains to glacial lakes, was also a big drawcard for North Island expats. Milford Sound. (Source: Claire Turnbull, who moved from Auckland to Queenstown, said the shift was about improving family life. "We just wanted to simplify life. So, we downsized and made the move," she said. "It comes down to quality of life. If you can make it work living in a smaller place, and your pace of life is a bit slower, that can feel a lot better."
