Dr Stuart Jones Mischaracterises COPD Findings, Risks Driving Smokers Back To Cigarettes
Press Release – VIANZ
A recent statement by Dr. Stuart Jones claims hard data prove that vaping alone causes COPD. A closer look at the Nicotine & Tobacco Research paper does not support Dr Joness assertions and underscores vapings potential for …
A recent statement by Dr. Stuart Jones claims 'hard data' prove that vaping alone causes COPD. A closer look at the Nicotine & Tobacco Research paper does not support Dr Jones's assertions and underscores vaping's potential for harm reduction.
Key Facts
Baseline COPD Prevalence: Only 1.3% of exclusive e-cigarette users had COPD at enrollment, versus 2.7% of never-smokers/never-vapers – a 67% lower COPD rate in the vaping group.
Incident COPD Over 3-4 Years: While vapers did develop new COPD cases at a rate 2.3-times higher than never-users (adjusted hazard ratio 2.29 [1.42–3.71]), they simply reached parity with the never-smokers/never-vapers group's higher COPD prevalence.
No Evidence Vape-Driven Epidemic: End-of-study COPD prevalence in exclusive vapers mirrored the never-user group's baseline level – hardly the 'surge' implied by Dr. Jones's sound-bite.
Short Follow-Up: COPD is a decades-long disease. A 3½-year window can only capture early or preexisting lung damage – not new COPD caused by vaping.
Harm-Reduction Evidence: Clinical research shows that smokers with COPD who fully switch to vaping experience fewer flare-ups, improved symptoms, and stabilized lung function compared to those who continue smoking. (https://respiratory-research.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12931-016-0481-x and https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33101622/)
'Cherry-picking sensational headlines over sober science does a disservice to public health,' says Jonathan Devery, Chair, Vaping Industry Association of New Zealand (VIANZ).
'Vaping is not risk-free, but for adult smokers unable to quit, it remains far less harmful than cigarettes – and misrepresenting these findings could drive people back to the most lethal form of nicotine delivery.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Aphasia advocates help share message
The difficulties experienced by people living with aphasia are being spotlighted this month, as New Zealand marks Aphasia Awareness Month. Aphasia is a disorder of communication, where speaking, reading, writing and/or understanding language is impacted. Dunedin-based Aphasia New Zealand community aphasia adviser and speech language therapist Meryl Jones said many people in the community did not know what aphasia actually was, despite 29,000 New Zealanders living with the condition. Aphasia is caused by damage to the language centre in the brain (usually in the left hemisphere), most commonly due to stroke — about one-third of people who have a stroke will experience aphasia. Brain injury, tumour and infection can also result in aphasia, which affects each person differently. Ms Jones said aphasia was a difficult concept for the general population, resulting in people with aphasia often withdrawing from social contact. The situation was summed up by the saying "until you've met it, you just don't get it", she said. "So, we are working to raise community awareness of aphasia and its impact on people's lives," she said. People with aphasia had difficulties with communicating, but this did not mean their cognitive abilities were impaired, making it extremely frustrating. "Because of the very nature of aphasia, it is difficult for people living with it to advocate for themselves," Ms Jones said. "People with aphasia say they would like people to be more patient and to give them time to get out what they want to say — rather than making assumptions or finishing their sentences for them," Ms Jones said. "Other people can help by adapting their own communication and getting to know the person with aphasia's own way of communicating." For therapists, the aim was to give people with aphasia a functional way of communicating, using their strengths, which may include non-verbal strategies, such as gestures. "We also try to educated the people around them, training up their communication partners to give them the right support. "A major goal for us is to support people with aphasia to participate in life." Ms Jones works with a group of Dunedin people who have aphasia through a Korero Club, which meets fortnightly on Tuesdays to enjoy face-to-face conversation. "We have had great friendships formed among the group, with some describing it as the highlight of their week," she said. There is also the Dunedin Aphasia Support Group, a community support group for people with aphasia and their partners, families, whanau and/or carers, which meets on Fridays in Mornington. This group can be contacted via facebook. • For more information and/or support for aphasia, email dunedin@ or phone Meryl Jones on 021 177 0587.
Scoop
12-05-2025
- Scoop
Signs Of Progress In Tobacco Control Sector: New Bill And Council Action Offer Hope
Amid recent setbacks in New Zealand's Smokefree efforts, two new developments bring fresh momentum to tobacco harm reduction that have renewed hope in our goals for a healthier Aotearoa. Health spokesperson Hon Dr Ayesha Verrall has launched the Tobacco Transparency Bill, aimed at stopping tobacco industry lobbying in health policy. "Around the world, tobacco companies have a long history of influencing and weakening health policies to better suit their bottom line. This Bill will address those influences and help us protect people's health…," said Dr Verrall.[1] This Bill follows growing calls for stronger lobbying regulations in New Zealand politics. There is a pressing need for greater transparency and accountability, especially among those whose decisions directly impact public health outcomes. If passed, the Tobacco Transparency Bill would help the government understand its duties under international law and could lead to stronger rules around emerging nicotine products. Similarly, Far North District Council votes to develop a Smokefree/Vapefree policy for public spaces. The council's decision follows a new study linking vaping to chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), adding urgency to calls for regulation.[2] These developments offer timely encouragement for Smokefree and Vapefree advocates across Aotearoa as we mark World Smokefree May. Jasmine Graham, National Tobacco Control Manager at Hāpai te Hauora says, "While major challenges remain, these steps offer hope that momentum toward a healthier, smokefree Aotearoa is not lost." Notes: [2] "Far North Council Moves to Adopt Smokefree and Vape-free Policy," NZ Herald, last modified May 8, 2025,
NZ Herald
08-05-2025
- NZ Herald
Far North Council approves smokefree policy amid vaping health concerns
More than 50 other local councils last year had policies that designated council areas as smoke and vape-free. Far North Mayor Moko Tepania said he gave up vaping after seeing the item on the agenda, joking: 'that is why I am a bit grumpy sometimes.' He said he is fully behind the motion and encouraged other council members to lead by example. 'We are late to the party, our cousin councils already put stuff like this on the line and it only makes sense to have a policy like this.' Tepania wanted the council to lead by example. 'Like I would like our staff to stop smoking and vaping in front of our offices and use the smoke shed in the back,' he said. 'It's important if we are going to be regulators of a smokefree/vapefree policy.' The Far North District Council's policy would allow it to designate council-owned or administered public spaces as smokefree and to ensure signage identified the areas, as well as commit to partnering with relevant stakeholders to promote the areas. Council's group manager for planning and policy Roger Ackers said council is considering at today's meeting the staff recommendation to create a standalone smokefree/vape-free policy for the Far North. He said if the recommendation goes ahead, then council staff would engage with Health NZ Te Whatu Ora, other organisations, and the wider community to design the policy and look into costs and logistics. A draft policy and an implementation plan would then be presented to the council for consultation and adoption. A research report which investigates developing a smokefree/vape-free policy for the Far North stated the socio-demographic make-up of the district presented unique challenges for the population in relation to smoking and vaping. 'Smoking rates are higher in the Far North than nationally,' the report said. 'In the 2023 Census, 13% of those aged 15 or more from the Far North said they smoked tobacco regularly compared with 8% nationally.' The report said a smokefree/vape-free policy may potentially impact all community members as well as visitors who may be exposed to second-hand tobacco and vape smoke in public places owned or administered by the council. 'A standalone non-regulatory policy will align with the approach of other Northland local councils and with other councils across New Zealand. 'It will provide clear guidance regarding council-owned and administered areas where smoking is discouraged,' the report said. The council's decision to consider a vaping/smoking policy comes as a recent study published in the Nicotine and Tobacco Research Journal has for the first time linked vaping to a life-limiting and irreversible lung disease. The study found e-cigarette use is strongly associated with increased new diagnoses of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). COPD is the fourth leading cause of death in New Zealand. Asthma and Respiratory Foundation NZ chief executive Letitia Harding said the study confirmed what was long suspected, that vaping was not just risky, it was dangerous to people's health. 'For years, we've been gaslighted into believing vaping is harmless – or at least 'less harmful' than cigarettes – meanwhile, we've watched teen vaping rates skyrocket," Harding said. 'Vaping is not harmless – it never has been – and this study shows it causes long-term irreversible lung damage.' Harding said the study, which tracked 250,000 people over about three-and-a-half years, should be a significant wake-up call to the Government to tighten regulations even further. 'Let's stop pretending we're balancing harm reduction with consumer freedom - vaping isn't harm reduction, it's harm transfer.' Director of health promotion at Te Whatu Ora, Kathrine Clarke said they remain committed to addressing vaping, particularly youth vaping nationally. '[We] are running a number of campaigns and initiatives to support youth to remain smokefree and vapefree.'
