logo
Newborn baby ‘stable' the day before dying following an infection, probe hears

Newborn baby ‘stable' the day before dying following an infection, probe hears

Yahoo18-02-2025

A newborn baby who died in a Glasgow hospital after developing an infection was 'stable' the day before she passed away, an inquiry has heard.
Sophia Smith was just 11 days old when she died at the Royal Hospital for Children (RHC) at Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (QEUH) campus in Glasgow on April 11 2017.
The newborn became ill with an infection similar to MRSA, which developed into sepsis.
In 2020, Sophia's case was handed over to the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) which, earlier this year, announced a Fatal Accident Inquiry (FAI) into her death.
Sophia was born at the Royal Alexandra Hospital in Paisley, Renfrewshire, on March 31 2017.
The inquiry at Glasgow Sheriff Court heard that following her birth Sophia had difficulty breathing and a possible heart issue, so she was transferred to the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) at the RHC.
There she was placed in an incubator with one-on-one nursing care and a 'raft of machinery' next to her cot.
She was also given antibiotics via lines into her body, initially in her abdomen and then in her left foot.
The child 'rallied' over the following days, with parents Theresa and Matthew Smith being led to believe she would be home in 'a matter of weeks'.
However on April 10 Sophia's health suddenly deteriorated and despite efforts to save her Sophia she died at 5.48pm on April 11.
Samples taken from her body on April 10 and 11 subsequently tested positive for a bacteria called staphylococcus aureus (SA), which the inquiry heard can 'cause harm' if it gets into the body.
On Tuesday the inquiry heard evidence from Lorna McSeveney, a senior charge nurse who had been on duty at NICU on April 10 and 11.
The inquiry heard she carried out a routine 'package of measures' at the start of her shift at 7.30am on April 10 to check on Sophia's condition, and that these did not give her 'cause for concern'.
'She was a sick baby, but she was stable,' she told the inquiry.
She took the inquiry through Sophia's medical charts for April 10 and into April 11.
These showed, she said, that the initial signs Sophia was 'not quite right' came at about 3pm.
This included changes in a number of vital signs, including her temperature, heart rate and oxygen levels, which were being constantly monitored.
Small amounts of blood were also found in her airway.
These signs continued to worsen over the ensuing hours, and she was found to be suffering from a pulmonary haemorrhage (bleeding on the lung).
When asked whether these could have been signs Sophia had sepsis, Ms McSeveney said not necessarily, since they could have been caused by other things.
She added that it was 'very difficult' even for experienced staff to detect sepsis in newborn children, and that the signs of the condition could be 'very subtle'.
She was also asked if there was anything she would have done anything differently in the knowledge Sophia had an infection.
She replied: 'I have gone over it in my head I don't know how many times.
'I don't think there was.'
She said Sophia was being constantly monitored, and that from a nursing perspective she had done everything she could.
She was also asked how handwashing protocols were 'policed' in NICU, with Sophia's parents saying on Monday it was 'frustrating' to see they were not always being followed by visitors and staff.
She replied that staff had a 'duty' to ensure infection control measures were being followed, and that she would always challenge people if there were not complying with them.
In the afternoon, the inquiry heard evidence from Pamela Joannidis, interim associate director of infection prevention and control at the NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde health board from 2019 to 2022.
She told the inquiry that any break in Sophia's skin – such as from a tube – could have been a 'doorway' for the SA bacteria to enter her body.
However, she said establishing the exact source of the infection was 'particularly difficult'.
On Monday, the inquiry heard that no other cases of the same PVL-MSSA bacteria were found in the NICU in the six months before or after Sophia was nursed there.
Ms Joannidis was pressed by Iain Mitchell KC, representing Sophia's parents, on whether the infection could be due to a 'failure' in the ward's hygiene protocols around the insertion of 'lines', or tubes, into patients.
'How likely is it that there can have been the infection being introduced otherwise than by a failure in the protocol of asepsis, or a failure in the protocol of prevention of a line becoming infected?' he asked.
Ms Joannidis replied that it was not possible to say for sure the infection was linked to a 'device', but said 'you could not rule it out as a hypothesis'.
On Monday, Sophia's mother Theresa Smith told the inquiry she just wanted to know what happened to her baby.
'I want to know why she is not here, playing with her brothers and sisters,' she said.
She added: 'She's dead. I live every day of my life knowing she's dead, knowing that absolutely putrid hospital caused an infection in my child and killed her,' she said.
'And when it killed her it killed me too. I want to know what happened.'
The inquiry continues.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Graphs that paint the picture of HIV in SA
Graphs that paint the picture of HIV in SA

News24

timea day ago

  • News24

Graphs that paint the picture of HIV in SA

Eight million people are living with HIV with more than six million being on treatment. Behind these big numbers lurk a universe of fascinating epidemiological dynamics. In this special briefing, Spotlight editor Marcus Low unpacks what we know about the state of HIV in South Africa. This is part 1 of 3. Four decades ago, hardly anyone in South Africa had HIV. Today, roughly one in eight people here are living with the virus. HIV has quite simply become a routine part of life in South Africa. But thanks to the fact that antiretroviral treatment is keeping several million people alive, HIV is no longer the crisis it was at the turn of the century. For many, the virus is still an all-too-real part of their lives. It still ranks among the country's top killers. As we will see in this Spotlight special briefing, there is good and bad news. We have made massive progress in our collective fight against HIV, especially since around 2008. But, as positive as the big picture may be, there are also reasons to be worried. In the 10 sections of this special briefing, we have used lots of graphs and an interactive table to liven things up. We have drawn almost entirely on estimates from Thembisa, the leading mathematical model of HIV in South Africa and also the basis for UNAIDS' country numbers. The big picture Total PLHIV in SA Graphic: Spotlight South Africa has the world's biggest HIV epidemic. Eight million people, or 12.8% of the population, lived with the virus in 2024. Despite the massive progress we've made in the last 20 years, this absolute number has kept increasing, and, at least by this measure, the epidemic has kept getting bigger. But while more people are living with HIV, dramatically fewer people are dying of HIV-related causes than two decades ago - we've gone from 281 000 HIV-related deaths in 2005/06 to 53 000 in 2023/24. This is mainly because antiretroviral medicines have kept several million people alive who would otherwise now be dead. The rate of new infections has also declined a lot, as shown in the above graph. South Africa's HIV epidemic is closely entwined with our tuberculosis (TB) epidemic. This is because untreated HIV breaks down the immune system, which then makes people vulnerable to falling ill with TB. Accordingly, TB is the top cause of HIV-related deaths in South Africa. Recovering life expectancy Just what a big deal HIV has been in South Africa is clear from estimates of life expectancy in the country. As HIV killed more and more people through the nineties and early 2000s, life expectancy dropped precipitously from 63.2 in 1990 to 53.2 in 2004. But then, as antiretroviral treatment started keeping more and more people alive, it increased again. It stood at 66.1 in 2024. Graphic: Spotlight There is much history that is not captured in this graph. Perhaps most notably, the introduction of antiretroviral treatment in South Africa's public sector was intentionally delayed by the state's policy of Aids denialism under then-president Thabo Mbeki. While the dramatic improvement from 2005 onward is impressive, life expectancy didn't have to drop as low as it did in the first place. The blip you can see on the right of the graph is a result of the Covid-19 pandemic. While significant, the broader trend is driven by HIV and the recovery from HIV. A massive treatment programme Of the eight million people living with HIV in South Africa, about 6.2 million or roughly four in five, were on treatment in 2024. This means South Africa has the world's most extensive HIV treatment programme by some distance. We take it somewhat for granted these days, but to treat so many people is a tremendous success story for which many healthcare workers, activists, government officials, donors, and others deserve great credit. That said, it is concerning that about one in five people with the virus are not on treatment. Treatment is recommended for everyone living with the virus. Though we focus on treatment coverage here, these numbers are often split further into the UNAIDS 95-95-95 targets. READ | Trump's HIV funding cuts will hit diabetes and cervical cancer treatment hard. Here's why In 2024, 95% of people living with HIV had been diagnosed, 81.5% of those diagnosed were on treatment, and 92% of those on treatment were virally suppressed - meaning the amount of virus in their blood was below a low threshold. The key takeaway from these numbers is that the most significant gap in South Africa's HIV response is in helping people who have already been diagnosed to start and stay on treatment. *Check back tomorrow for part 2 of this series. You can also find the complete version of this #InTheSpotlight special briefing as a single page on the Spotlight website. Note: All of the above graphs are based on outputs from version 4.8 of the Thembisa model published in March 2025. We thank the Thembisa team for sharing their outputs so freely. Graphs were produced by Spotlight using the R package ggplot2. You are free to reuse and republish the graphs. For ease of use, you can download them as a Microsoft PowerPoint slide deck. Technical note: The Thembisa model outputs include both stock and flow variables. This is why we have at some places written 2024 (for stock variables) and 2023/2024 (for flow variables). 2024 should be read as mid-2024. 2023/2024 should be read as the period from mid-2023 to mid-2024.

Chantel Moore's mother talks about change in policing, 5 years after of her daughter's shooting death
Chantel Moore's mother talks about change in policing, 5 years after of her daughter's shooting death

Hamilton Spectator

time5 days ago

  • Hamilton Spectator

Chantel Moore's mother talks about change in policing, 5 years after of her daughter's shooting death

By Nora O'Malley Local Journalism Initiative Reporter Tofino, B.C. – Chantel Moore's daughter Gracie is 11 this year. 'She's growing. She often talks about her mom and how she misses her,' said Gracie's grandmother Martha Martin on June 4, 2025, the fifth anniversary of her daughter's fatal shooting by Edmundson City Police Force Officer Jeremy Son during a wellness check. 'She was six when her mom passed,' said Martin. 'She struggled with it for a really long time. She would always ask, 'When are the angels going to be done with my mom? Can they just send her back now?'' 'There are times when she gets really quiet and it's in those moments I know that she is missing her mom, and rightfully so,' she adds. 'It's really tough. I'm never going to be able to take her mother's place.' Moore was 26 when she was shot and killed at her New Brunswick home. To honour the memory of her daughter, Martin is walking with family and supporters 33-kilometres from the Tofino-Ucluelet Junction to Tofino's First Street Dock. Last year when she did the walk, the pain from a leg injury and her personal struggle with mental health had her in tears by the end. But this year, Martin says she's in better health – physically and mentally. 'Hopefully it won't be as hard and as long. I've been doing training for the last month. This year I'm more prepared,' Martin told the Ha-Shilth-Sa before setting off north to Tofino. There are also positive developments within policing services that Martin shared. 'Victoria's Police Chief Del Manak started a co-response team in honour of my daughter. A couple of weeks ago I was there, and I was able to do a presentation. I put the yellow pin dress on their co-response team,' said Martin. She offered a 'huge applause' to Chief Del Manak for being willing to make change. Front line RCMP officers are now being equipped with body-worn cameras as part of a national rollout to across Canada's rural, urban and remote locations. The deployment of body-cameras is something the Nuu-chah-nulth Tribal Council has been calling for since Moore's shooting death in 2020. 'My daughter had a huge part of this,' said Martin. There is no actual real-time surveillance, police vehicle dash cam or body-worn video camera evidence depicting the actual events of what took place the day Moore was shot four times by Officer Son. Officer Son was not criminally charged for the shooting death of Moore, and within a few weeks of the tragedy he was back on duty. Martin has a civil lawsuit against the City of Edmundston and Son, with a meeting set for March 2026. Moore's auntie Corinne Martin says she misses her niece's bubbly personality. 'She was so full of life, just her energy. She was just like her mom when she walked into the room, she could get everybody's attention,' said Corinne, who joined Martin for the journey from the junction to Tofino. Moore's family members Hjalmer Wenstob and Timothy Masso performed the Healing Song for Martin before she began to walk on the overcast Wednesday morning. Five months after Moore's tragic shooting death, Martin's son Mike Martin died in police custody. 'I'm keeping her name alive. I will never let the government forget her or my son,' she said. She went on to note that Hotel Zed Tofino currently has a display up in the lobby that tells Chantel Moore's story. 'I look at my granddaughter and I see my nieces and nephews and I want to ensure that their future safety - should anyone be pulled over and should anyone need a mental health check - that they will not be shot multiple times. That's unacceptable,' said Martin. -30- Captions The family of Chantel Moore gather on June 4 at the Tofino-Ucluelet Junction before walking to remember the loss of a young Tla-o-qui-aht woman. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .

5 comforting homemade breads to dip, dunk and devour this winter
5 comforting homemade breads to dip, dunk and devour this winter

News24

time5 days ago

  • News24

5 comforting homemade breads to dip, dunk and devour this winter

There is surely nothing better than a slice of warm, freshly baked bread slathered with butter on a chilly day - especially when there's a warm bowl of soup nearby. From crusty classics to soft, pillowy loaves, these five easy homemade breads are made for dipping, dunking and devouring all winter long. Need some soup inspiration? Here are six comforting bowls you can make from scratch Cheesy mielie bread with tomato and chilli butter Warm, savoury loaf that brings a comforting South African twist to classic cornbread. Delicious pan bread These soft rolls are pan-fried in olive oil rather than baked, and are worth the wait of the long resting time. Home crafted beer usually has a really good flavour and is perfect for cooking. Try baking this bread using different types of beer to taste the difference in flavours. ER Lombard Home-baked bread rolls Baking your own bread is fun, especially when you're not in a hurry and can enjoy the process. Easy onion and bacon beer bread Home crafted beer usually has a really good flavour and is perfect for cooking. Try baking this bread using different types of beer to taste the difference in flavours. Donna Lewis Shortcut cheesy mushroom bread So long as the taste isn't compromised, there's no reason why you can't take shortcuts in the kitchen. One shortcut I'm quite fond of is using store-bought dough from my nearest supermarket. Donna Lewis

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store