‘It's not over until it's over': Teachers ask Cox to veto union bill in silent protest
Teachers silently protest in front of Gov. Spencer Cox's office and call on him to veto HB267 on Feb. 14, 2025. (Photo by Vanessa Hudson/Utah News Dispatch)
Educators gathered in front of the governor's office Friday morning to silently protest and ask Gov. Spencer Cox to veto HB267, the bill that would ban collective bargaining for unions in the public sector. The silent protest comes a week after almost 1,000 teachers, firefighters and other union advocates packed the Capitol to call for a veto.
It's unclear if the governor will veto the legislation; if he does, Sen. David Hinkins, R-Ferron, confirmed Thursday he's working on a compromise that would still allow public unions to collectively bargain. SB168, a backup bill for HB267, would require support from a majority of the employees in the organization the union represents, regardless of whether they're part of the union, in order to negotiate on behalf of employees.
The compromise bill also retains some restrictions on public sector unions from the original legislation, like restricting certain government resources from going toward union activity and removing access to the Utah Retirement System for employees who work for the union but not the public entity the union represents.
Is it too late for a compromise on collective bargaining bill? One senator is still trying
BreAnn Busbom is a teacher in Davis School District. She said when teachers' voices are silenced, an unhappy workforce is created, which becomes a problem for students.
'This silent protest is really symbolic of what would happen if the governor does not veto this bill,' Busbom said. 'It, in effect, silences teacher voice.'
J. Cedric Smith, a science teacher in the Weber School District, said he's hoping the governor will veto the legislation and advocate on behalf of public sector employees, students, families and teachers.
'It's not over until it's over,' Smith said.
If Cox vetoes HB267, Hinkins said his compromise bill would have an avenue forward, though Senate leadership called it a 'nonstarter' Thursday.
Busbom said she hasn't looked at what Hinkins' backup bill would do but a compromise is something she would be 'very pleased' with.
'I know others would also be pleased with having some sort of compromise at the end of the day,' she added.
A substitute to HB267 would have allowed collective bargaining if unions could get enough support from all employees, but the Legislature ultimately passed the original language, despite two weeks' worth of debate and discussions between public sector unions and lawmakers.
Smith said because HB267 was controversial and faced significant opposition, the governor now has an opportunity to exercise his judgment and veto.
'At the very least, send it back … to say, 'Hey, you know, I think you need to make a better effort at working with these folks, developing a coalition, a partnership, so that everybody's needs can be met, but their rights can't be taken from them,' Smith said.
If HB267 does end up becoming law, Busbom and Smith both said the Utah Education Association will continue to advocate for teachers and students.
'We are resilient as an association, and I know we can make it past this,' Busbom said. 'However, I will be extremely disappointed with the people that have been elected to represent the people. I'm not sure that they really are representing the people's voice in this action.'
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Majority of Utahns support spending cuts, say DOGE has been effective
WASHINGTON — A vast majority of Utah voters say they support cutting the size of the government as Congress works to approve spending cuts implemented by the Department of Government Efficiency earlier this year. Nearly 80% of Utahns say they support downsizing the government, according to a new poll conducted by HarrisX for the Deseret News. That sentiment was largely shared among those who identify themselves as Republican, with 91% saying they support compared to just 9% who said they oppose. Democratic voters were more split among themselves, as 47% said they supported cutting the size of the government compared to 53% who said the opposite, according to the poll. Since President Donald Trump was sworn into office in January, the DOGE commission has identified spending cuts officials say would save the government billions of dollars. Congress has begun the process of approving those cuts, although lawmakers — Republicans and Democrats like — are torn on whether they agree with what's on the chopping block. A majority (60%) of Utahns say DOGE has been effective at identifying spending cuts compared to just 40% who said the opposite, the poll shows. That opinion is largely split along party lines, as 80% of Republicans said DOGE was effective, with only 29% of Democrats saying the same. On the other hand, 71% of Democrats said DOGE was ineffective compared to just 20% of Republicans who agreed with that sentiment. But when it comes to DOGE cuts and slashed funding, Utah voters say they feel mostly unaffected. A majority of Utahns (67%) say they don't know anyone who has lost their job because of the DOGE cuts, according to the poll. About 12% say a close friend has lost their job, 8% say a family member and another 17% say an acquaintance lost their job due to the DOGE cuts. Roughly 4% report their job was terminated because of DOGE cuts, the poll shows. The poll was conducted between May 16-21 among 805 registered voters in Utah. The margin of error is plus or minus 3.5 percentage points. Proposed spending cuts are already making their way through Congress, with the House approving a $9.4 billion rescissions package on Thursday targeting foreign aid as well as federal funding for organizations the Trump administration has accused of being anti-conservative. The package was opposed by all Democrats, and a handful of Republicans also opposed the package. However, it underscores a desire among Trump allies to codify the cuts identified by DOGE as 'waste, fraud, and abuse' as quickly as possible. The recent sentiments also come in contrast to Deseret News polling last month that showed Utah voters believe the federal government should spend more money in several different areas, with foreign funding a strong exception.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Protester shot and killed at ‘No Kings' rally in Utah, police say
A man believed to be part of a peacekeeping team for the 'No Kings' protest in Salt Lake City shot at a person who was brandishing a rifle at demonstrators, striking both the rifleman and a bystander who later died at the hospital, authorities said Sunday. Police took the alleged rifleman, Arturo Gamboa, 24, into custody Saturday evening on a murder charge, Salt Lake City Police Chief Brian Redd said at a Sunday news conference. The bystander was Arthur Folasa Ah Loo, 39. Detectives don't yet know why Gamboa pulled out a rifle or ran from the peacekeepers, but they accused him of creating the dangerous situation that led to Ah Loo's death. The Associated Press did not immediately find an attorney listed for Gamboa or contact information for his family in public records. Redd said the man who dressed in a neon green vest and was believed to be part of the peacekeeping team fired three shots from a handgun at Gamboa, inflicting a relatively minor injury but fatally shooting Ah Loo. The gunshots sent hundreds of protesters running, some hiding behind barriers and fleeing into parking garages and nearby businesses, police said in a statement. 'That's a gun. Come on, come on, get out,' someone can be heard saying in a video posted to social media that appears to show the events. 'No Kings' protests swept across the country Saturday, and organizers said millions rallied against what they described as President Donald Trump's authoritarian excesses. Confrontations were largely isolated. They included a driver of an SUV who authorities said struck a woman who was participating a 'No Kings' demonstration and sped away in Riverside, California, east of Los Angeles. The woman had 'significant injuries' but was stable police said, adding that they were still searching for the driver. Outside the Arizona statehouse, a social media video showed protesters jeering at and then skirmishing with a masked man Saturday, who eventually pulled out a handgun, causing the crowd to scatter. Another video showed Arizona Department of Public Safety officers taking the man into custody. The Utah chapter of the 50501 Movement, which helped organize the protests, said in a statement on Instagram that they condemned the rifleman in Salt Lake City, and thanked first responders and 'our safety team' for the quick response. The Utah chapter did not immediately respond to AP questions about the peacekeeping team. It was unclear who hired them, whether they were volunteers or what their training was prior to the event. Redd said that the peacekeepers' actions are also part of the investigation. The shooter and another person in a neon vest allegedly saw Gamboa separate from the crowd of marchers in downtown Salt Lake City, move behind a wall and withdraw a rifle around 8 p.m., Redd said. When the two men in vests confronted Gamboa with their handguns drawn, witnesses said Gamboa raised his rifle into a firing position and ran toward the crowd, said Redd. That's when one of the men dressed in the vests shot three rounds, hitting Gamboa and Ah Loo, said Redd. Gamboa, who police said didn't have a criminal history, was wounded and treated before being booked into jail. Police said they recovered an AR-15 style rifle, a gas mask and a backpack at the scene.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
1 man dead after being shot during ‘No Kings' protest in Salt Lake City
A 39-year-old man, identified as Utah resident Arthur Folasa Ah Loo, died Saturday after being shot during a large 'No Kings' protest in downtown Salt Lake City, Salt Lake City Police Chief Brian Redd said Sunday. Three people also believed to be part of the incident were taken into custody, one of whom, identified as 24-year-old Utah resident Arturo Roberto Gamboa, was shot as everything unfolded, according to Salt Lake police. He was transported to a hospital in serious condition. Officers responded to a report of a shooting near 151 S. State shortly before 8 p.m. It took place as an estimated 10,000 people marched downtown to protest recent federal policy decisions. At least three shots rang out, causing some people in the immediate area to flee, according to videos near the incident obtained by KSL. Several other videos were also uploaded to social media. On scene, officers found Folasa Ah Loo and attempted life-saving efforts. Redd said preliminary investigations show that Folasa Ah Loo was not the intended target but an 'innocent bystander participating in the demonstration.' With witnesses-provided information, officers pursued Gamboa to the area of 200 East 100 South, where he was apprehended, taken to the hospital and later booked into the Salt Lake County Metro Jail for investigation of murder, police said. Gamboa had a minor gunshot wound and was 'hiding in a group of people,' Redd said. Officers also recovered a backpack Redd said was removed from Gamboa by bystanders that contained an 'AR-15 style rifle,' black clothing and gas mask. Two other armed individuals wearing high-visibility vests who were 'possibly part of the event's peacekeeping team' were also detained initially, Redd said. 'Based on early witness statements, these men saw Gamboa separate from the crowd during the march and move behind a wall, where they noticed him pull out a rifle and begin manipulating it. Gamboa was then confronted by these two men. Witnesses say Gamboa raised the weapon in a firing position and began running toward the crowd. One of the individuals fired three rounds, striking Gamboa and tragically striking the man who later died,' Redd said, adding that Gamboa never fired a shot. According to a police booking affidavit, the peacekeepers called out to Gamboa to drop his weapon after drawing their own. 'Arturo Gamboa was acting under circumstances evidencing a depraved indifference to human life and knowingly engages in conduct that creates a grave risk of death to another individual and thereby causes the death of the other individual,' according to the affidavit. Redd added that the two peacekeepers are not in custody and the one who fired the rounds is cooperating with police. 'We did not take any actions last night on those two individuals,' Redd said. The investigation is still ongoing. Leah Pittman was marching in the protest with her dad. It was his first time participating in a protest, Pittman said. Before the shooting, she described the march as 'very peaceful' and 'very unified.' 'It also felt ... almost like, fun at times. There was music that was playing. There was a band that was marching with us,' Pittman said. 'I just felt very grateful to be with a group of people that were there for the same reasons that I was. It was just a group of people from different backgrounds. We all felt very unified.' Of course, that all changed in an instant. Pittman said she and her dad were about 15 feet away from Folasa Ah Loo when he was shot. At first, she and her dad thought the three loud bangs were fireworks — then the magnitude and stakes of the situation became apparent. 'Then we just saw people running. So we started running, and I ran past the victim lying on the ground, and I saw him bleeding from his head. That's kind of when I realized what was happening and how much danger we were all in,' Pittman. She and her dad hid underneath cars at a nearby apartment complex until the complex was opened to allow people access to shelter. 'The immediate moments after, I just would say there was complete chaos. People running everywhere, a lot of screaming, a lot of crying, a lot of people calling out to each other, trying to find people that they were with,' Pittman said. For Pittman, Saturday's active shooter situation wasn't even her first. That came when she was in middle school. 'I remember the fear being similar,' Pittman said. 'No matter your political opinion, something like this happening is not OK. And there's nothing that could be done to justify it. You know, like, just the kind of violence that happens in America today is unacceptable, and I hate that it's become so normalized and that it's something that I've experienced several times in my life. That should never be the case.' Specifically, Pittman said she was sheltering in the apartment complex alongside children — four that were younger than 10 years old. 'One of the girls was just telling me that this was her first ever shooting and that she was very scared. I just hate that that's something that happens often nowadays. We just need to actively be fighting against that kind of hate and that kind of violence that leads to situations like this,' she said. Gov. Spencer Cox posted on social media that he had spoken with Salt Lake City Mayor Erin Mendenhall about the incident. Mendenhall said she called to governor to update him on the situation, and he relayed his support for the city's first responders. 'The shooting at tonight's protest in Salt Lake City is a deeply troubling act of violence and has no place in our public square,' Cox wrote. 'This is an active situation, and we're working closely with law enforcement to ensure accountability.' Mendenhall on Saturday night said the shooting 'does not define our city.' 'The purpose of today's demonstration was a powerful and peaceful expression until this event, and that cannot be overshadowed or silenced by a single act meant to harm,' Mendenhall said. 'I want to urge everyone in the public to be calm, to give one another grace and to look out for one another tonight in the coming days.' Utah State Rep. Tyler Clancy, R-Pleasant Grove, on Sunday posted a message of condolences and support to the Folasa Ah Loo family.
