
Environment Minister says ‘global action' is needed to save WA's Ningaloo Reef, rejects 2030 target
While researchers are still assessing the damage caused by a marine heatwave, the Australian Institute of Marine Science has confirmed the worst bleaching ever recorded off the WA coast.
'The length and intensity of the heat stress, and its footprint across multiple regions, is something we've never seen before on most of the reefs in WA,' the institute's senior research scientist James Gilmour said.
'Areas which had given us hope because they'd rarely or not bleached before, like the Rowley Shoals, north Kimberley and Ningaloo, have been hit hard this time.'
Sensitive to heat stress, corals expel the algae living in their tissues in warm water, causing the coral to go pale.
Environment Minister Matthew Swinbourne said the Government was monitoring the situation and was 'obviously' concerned.
'I went up to Exmouth and to the North-West Cape a couple of weeks ago, got a chance to see it for myself,' he said on Tuesday.
'It was obvious to me that this was not the normal state of the reef.
'In terms of the imperative around climate, it doesn't change that. It's been an imperative for a long time . . . we remain committed to dealing with our carbon emissions.
'We're getting out of coal in WA, we're pushing forward a renewable energy program that will hopefully see us decarbonising our economy as effectively as we can.'
Mr Swinbourne said Labor's climate legislation, that was shelved before the March election is being re-written.
He rejected the Greens' private members bill, being put to Parliament on Thursday, that would legislate a 2030 target for emissions.
'We need to be careful in terms of what we set and what we can achieve,' Mr Swinbourne said.
'What you want to do is you want to make achievable targets. It's all well and good to send a virtual signaling type of target, which is often advocated by the Greens, but actually these things don't happen in a vacuum.
'They affect other areas of our economy, other areas of our lives and so there's always a balance with these sorts of things.'
Bleaching is not always fatal but if underwater heat is prolonged and severe, corals can die.
Sea surface temperatures around Australia last summer were the warmest on record since 1900, with coral heat stress peaking in January.
Conditions varied across the tropical reefs spanning 1500km - from 'extreme', or 90 per cent bleached or dead, to 'medium', somewhere between 11 per cent and 30 per cent.
Mermaid and Clerke reefs in the Rowley Shoals, 300km west of Broome, recorded 'very high' levels of mortality, between 61 per cent and 90 per cent.
The World Heritage-listed Ningaloo Reef, known for its whale sharks, experienced 'high' bleaching and mortality between 31 per cent and 60 per cent.
Dr Gilmour said climate change was driving the increased frequency and severity of mass coral bleaching events and giving them little time to bounce back in between.
'They need 10 to 15 years to recover fully,' he said.
'The key to helping coral reefs survive under climate change is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.'
Mr Swinbourne called it a 'global level' event and said WA cannot go it alone.
'All that we could do in WA is likely to be meaningless if we don't have global action on climate change,' he said.
'The issue there is we have seen some of our big partners walk away from their commitments and that's what's most alarming because the efforts that we take here in WA will be paled into insignificance.
'It's a matter of public record that the US has walked away from many of its commitments. We have seen, of course, parts of the Liberal party here in WA throw up their climate denialism and walking away from a net zero target by 2050, which is also alarming.'
Outside Parliament on Tuesday, Liberal leader Basil Zempilas didn't want to talk about his support for the 'status quo' on net zero.
'That's not my focus today, I might add that it's not the focus of the West Australians that I've spoken to in the last 24 hours,' he said.
'Today's focus for this State Government, and for us as the Opposition, is an accountability and transparency in the health area.'
Greens MP Sophie McNeill accused both major parties of inaction and said WA's tourism industry will pay the price.
'More than 1000 West Australians work in Exmouth in tourism, they love that reef,' she said.
'And their hearts are broken. It was absolutely shocking to see what's happened to our beautiful Ningaloo on this Government's watch.
'It is the worst Government in the whole country when it comes to climate action. No 2030 target, no renewable energy target and now our stunning beautiful world heritage Ningaloo is dying on its watch.'
The updates on coral health land ahead of the expected release of the Federal Government's 2035 climate goals, due in September under the Paris Agreement rules.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Women urged to 'remain vigilant' to safeguard progress
Some young men believe women are receiving all the opportunities in a way that is impacting male rights, with Minister for Women Katy Gallagher calling it a "worrying trend". But while diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) policies are being wound back overseas, most notably by the Trump administration in the US, Australian workers are not experiencing the same pushback. "In Australia, our ethos of everyone having a fair go and treating people equally is really strong - certainly across business, community and government," Senator Gallagher told the Women in Media national conference on Friday. "There is a worrying trend emerging ... particularly with young men thinking that women are getting too much and that their rights are going backwards, and there's too much focus on women." Senator Gallagher wants to embed reforms in favour of women and diversity so they cannot be reversed by a change in government. The Australian Labor Party has the first gender-equal cabinet in the federal parliament's history, with a caucus comprising 56 per cent women. But Senator Gallagher remembered the "fierce resistance" from men within the party when affirmative action was first introduced decades ago. In 1994, the party agreed to introduce quotas for women, with a target to have women represent 35 per cent of Labor candidates preselected for winnable federal seats by 2002. "Our caucus is starting to look like the Australian people - our community that we're there to represent - but it wasn't easy and we've got to remain vigilant," Senator Gallagher said. "You can make gains but you cannot take your eye off the ball, because those gains can be taken away just as quickly as you reached them." In May, Opposition Leader Sussan Ley became the first female federal Liberal leader but the overall number of women in the party has not increased significantly in a decade. Just 33 per cent of MPs in the federal coalition are women. Hilma's Network founder Charlotte Mortlock said she had tried to talk about quotas for the Liberal Party "quietly" during the previous term of government, but nobody listened. "When you are accustomed to privilege, equality can feel like oppression," she said. "Nobody wants quotas, nobody wants DEI and we all wish that this would happen organically but when it's not, at what point do you say, 'OK, this is no longer working'?" Ms Mortlock said it was important not to demonise men in the pursuit of more opportunities and representation for women. "We have to be responsible in the language that we are using because when young men go off the rails, it impacts women," she said. "It is in (women's) interest to have really healthy, flourishing, well-rounded men."

Sky News AU
6 hours ago
- Sky News AU
‘Failure of leadership': Jacinta Allan accused of putting children ‘at risk' after latest Working With Children Check revelations
Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan has been accused of putting children at risk after the Labor leader was unable to guarantee a former childcare worker sacked for sexual misconduct would have his Working With Children's Check (WWCC) cancelled. The ABC revealed on Wednesday that a Victorian childcare worker had been blacklisted from the industry in 2020 over accusations of grooming, kissing toddlers, and attempting to organise unsanctioned catch-ups and offer babysitting services. When alerted to the incident, Premier Allan said the process to cancel the man's WWCC was underway. However on Thursday the Victorian Premier was unable to provide a timeline for how long the process would take - or provide a guarantee the man would indeed be stripped of his WWCC. 'What's occurred here is just not acceptable. It demonstrates why the system needs to be strengthened and why we have taken action to strengthen the system and more will be done when we receive the rapid review report,' Ms Allan told reporters. 'In regards to this individual, the advice I had yesterday remains the advice today; that urgent steps are being taken to go through the process of cancelling this particular individual's Working With Children's Check as soon as possible.' Pressed on the timeline for a decision, the Victorian Premier said she was 'just not in a position to comment on individual cases'. The comments prompted a heated response from the Victorian Opposition, with Shadow Attorney General Michael O'Brien and Shadow Education Minister Jess Willson accusing the Premier of placing children at 'unacceptable risk'. 'Premier Jacinta Allan's continued refusal to take decisive action to protect children in childcare and educational settings is a failure of leadership,' the two Shadow Ministers said in a joint statement. 'More than 24 hours on from revelations that an individual dismissed from a childcare centre for grooming and kissing children still has an active Working With Children Check and the Premier still cannot guarantee when this individual's WWCC will be revoked.' The opposition frontbenchers said the loopholes that enabled the situation to occur would have been addressed by a bill introduced in Parliament by the Liberals and Nationals last week. 'Instead of supporting this new legislation, Premier Jacinta Allan blocked these laws and continues to place children at unacceptable risk,' they said. 'The Premier and Victorian Government must put politics aside, work with the Parliament and pass these laws now." The Victorian government is also under pressure to release the findings of its Rapid Child Safety Review as soon as possible. The review was launched after shocking allegations against Victorian childcare Worker Joshua Brown, who worked across 23 childcare centres and has been charged with more than 70 offences, including sexual assault. Premier Allan said on Thursday the report would be released "as soon as possible" but the government needed time to consider the findings. 'There will need to be a period of time for the government to consider and provide its thoughtful, detailed response to the rapid review,'Ms Allan said. 'But I want that response to be as soon as possible – not weeks.'

Sky News AU
9 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Parents hit back at Premier Jacinta Allan after extraordinary attack on concerns about a ‘school to gender clinic pipeline'
A group of parents with kids suffering from gender dysphoria have hit back at Premier Jacinta Allan after the Labor leader launched an extraordinary attack on parents concerned about the teaching of radical gender theory in Victorian schools. The Australian revealed on Thursday that the Victorian Department of Education had quietly updated its Respectful Relationships program to include content that teaches kids as young as five their biological sex may not align with their gender identity. The report included concerns from a spokeswoman from Parents of Adolescents with Gender Distress there was a 'school to gender clinic pipeline' which was pushing kids towards irreversible medical interventions. Premier Allan blasted the reporting during a press conference on Thursday, claiming the Respectful Relationships program was 'all about protecting kids, strengthening resilience of kids and supporting kids to be who they are across our schools'. The Premier then took aim at the parents' concerns, branding them 'disgraceful, nonsense' and claiming 'transgender kids are 15 times more likely to kill themselves'. In a letter responding to the Premier, the Parents of Adolescents with Gender Distress accused Ms Allan of making 'alarmist and irresponsible claims' in relations to suicide which were not supported by data. 'You made the alarming suggestion of a 15 times higher rate of suicide amongst transgender children. We believe this figure comes from survey data and concerned thoughts of suicide rather than completed suicide,' the parents wrote. 'Data shows suicide rates for transgender youth, while elevated, remain extremely low, and as many also suffer from co-occurring conditions (ASD (autism spectrum disorder), eating disorders, anxiety) which have similar levels of risk, a direct correlation can't be made,' the parents wrote. 'Neither affirmation nor medicalisation impacts this suicide risk or suicidal ideation and there is no evidence that programs introducing unevidenced concepts of 'gender identity' are beneficial to the mental health of children or adolescents. The parent group's concerns are supported by findings from a comprehensive independent review into gender dysphoria treatment in the UK found that 'the evidence does not adequately support the claim that gender affirming treatment reduces suicide risk'. The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare's website also states there is 'no reliable national data on rates of suicide and self-harm among LGBTIQ+ communities in Australia'. In their letter to Ms Allan, Parents of Adolescents with Gender Distress requested the Premier meet with them to hear about their experiences – noting Education Minister Ben Carroll and his departmental secretary had 'refused to engage' with their attempts to organise a meeting for the past year. In its report on Thursday, the Australian revealed new content had been added to the Respectful Relationships program. The content, aimed at kids in their first year of primary school, includes a case study involving a transgender girl named "Stacey" who wants to play on the boys sport team. The curriculum also seeks to educate the five and six-year-old students about the notion of being transgender, by telling them that 'some people feel they did not get a good match for their body parts, and they do not want to be called a boy or a girl, but rather something that is right for them'. Parents of Adolescents with Gender Distress's letter states the group 'believe these programs which invite children to question their sex, and therefore their comfort in their own bodies, based on stereotypes, create unnecessary anxiety and confusion, particularly for gender-nonconforming or neurodiverse children. 'We hope that in the spirit of inclusivity you could meet with us to hear our personal stories.' Speaking to Sky News Australian on Thursday evening, Queensland Psychiatrist Andrew Amos agreed the content in the curriculum could be 'extremely harmful to kids'. Dr Amos said kids start to develop an understanding of sex characteristics at a reasonably young age, but this is mostly at the level of play. 'The way that kids learn is that they play with ideas, they play with clothes, they play with toys. What's happening, though, is in the school and in the clinic, people with a very strong political idea about what should happen with kids are then pushing them into a pipeline that really will follow them for the rest of their lives and do a lot of harm to them,' he said. 'We haven't got any good evidence that it helps kids and we know that it does significant and irreversible harm to them. 'So yeah, I think it's extremely inappropriate to be teaching five-year-olds, this sort of sexualized idea that you can be born into the wrong body.'