The next Dalai Lama
The whole business of succession would be a lot simpler if the Dalai Lama could just regenerate, like Doctor Who. When the time comes for The Doctor to stop looking like David Tennant and start looking like Matt Smith, there's flame coming out of his head and gushing out of his sleeves, and then he explodes. When the smoke clears, there's the new Doctor.
There's no delay and no doubt. Once you accept (temporarily) the show's basic premise that Doctor Who is a benevolent immortal alien who periodically 'regenerates' from one human form to another, not even being consistent in ethnicity or gender from one body to the next, you know instantly that it's the same Doctor in there despite appearances.
With the dear old Dalai Lama, it's different. Reincarnation still happens, but the souls of the dead migrate into the bodies of a newborn and retain no memory of their previous lives. This becomes a problem when the soul of your religion's leader has to be tracked down in one of those thousands who were born around the same time the leader died.
That is exactly the problem facing the Gelug 'Yellow Hat' tradition of Tibetan Buddhism, whose leader, the Dalai Lama, turned 90 on Sunday. He will therefore soon be leaving his current incarnation, and it will be the task of his closest associates to track down the young child in whom his soul has taken up residence — who will then become the next Dalai Lama.
Then the troubles really start, because Tibet has been officially part of the People's Republic of China since the Chinese invasion of 1950 and Beijing does not like religious leaders who are beyond its control. In fact, it doesn't like religious leaders at all, especially if they also embody the national aspirations of a subject people — and least of all if they live abroad
The Dalai Lama ticks every box. He fled Tibet in the midst of a CIA-backed popular rebellion against foreign rule in 1959. He has lived in exile ever since in the northern Indian city of Dharamshala, surrounded by tens of thousands of other Tibetan exiles. And he heads what is in practice a Tibetan government-in-exile, although no other country recognizes it.
This makes the Communist authorities in Beijing nervous even though there is no real challenge to Chinese control. They therefore see the Dalai Lama's passing, whenever it happens, as a golden opportunity to 'nationalize' Tibetan Buddhism by giving the state the power to choose his successor.
We already had a preview of this 35 years ago when the Panchen Lama, second only to the Dalai Lama, died. After a lengthy but low-profile search Tibetan monks found a six-year-old boy called Gedhun Choekyi Nyima who matched the requirements, and the Dalai Lama (in exile) proclaimed him as the new Panchen Lama in 1995.
The little boy and his family were immediately arrested and 'disappeared'; none of them has ever been seen again. The Dalai Lama will not make that mistake twice: he has already said that his next reincarnation will be found in 'the free world,' which presumably means outside China.
But the vast majority of Tibetans still live in Tibet, and it is already clear that they will get a different Dalai Lama, chosen for them by the communist regime. It could end up like the Great Western Schism of 1378-1417, with two and then three popes at the same time — and that situation could easily last as long, depending on what happens to China in the long run.
All of this is ultimately about the survival of a separate Tibetan identity, which is still theoretically possible. Beijing has not yet adopted the final solution it is applying to the Uyghur minority: only Chinese may be used in the schools in both regions, but the Tibetans are not yet being drowned with Han Chinese immigrants.
The Chinese communist regime is now a little bit older than the Soviet Union was when it collapsed, but the CCP is still going strong. If it lasts another 50 years, Tibet's identity will certainly be eradicated, for there are more than 200 Chinese for every Tibetan. But if it's gone in 20 years, Tibetan culture may well survive.
Gwynne Dyer's new book is 'Intervention Earth: Life-Saving Ideas from the World's Climate Engineers'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
39 minutes ago
- Global News
Trade war with China could have devastating impact on Canadian canola farmers
'Here we go again. If it's not one thing, it's another, especially with China. They've always got something up their sleeve so they can drop our price.' That's how John Guelly, a canola producer near Westlock, Alta., reacted to Tuesday's news that China is slapping a 75.8 per cent tariff on imports of Canadian canola. Guelly, who is a former chair of Canola Alberta, an advocacy group for the province's 14,000 canola farmers, estimates the value of the Canadian canola production at $12 billion annually, or about 15 per cent of the total income Canadian farmers receive from the sale of agricultural commodities each year. View image in full screen John Guelly, who grows canola near Westlock, Alta., said trading with China is like a revolving door because they always seem to find a new reason to impose tariffs. Global News China is the world's largest importer of canola — purchasing nearly all of it from Canada, and using it primarily to make animal feed for its aquaculture sector. Story continues below advertisement In March, China also imposed a 100 per cent levy on Canadian canola oil and meal, plus peas, and a 25 per cent duty on Canadian seafood and pork. China claims these crippling new tariffs are needed to prevent 'dumping' of Canadian canola into the Chinese market, hurting domestic canola farmers. But the tariffs on raw canola are widely believed to be a China's response to Canada imposing a 100 per cent tariff on Chinese electric vehicles that was put in place in October 2024. Chinese EVs are significantly less expensive than North American-made EVs, in part because of lower labour and environmental standards and state subsidies. Then-prime minister Justin Trudeau said the tariffs, which are similar to American tariffs on Chinese EVs, were needed to protect Canada's auto industry. 'We seem to be helping out Eastern Canada and Western Canada suffers again. Unfortunately, our southern neighbour seems to be giving them a little more extra ammunition,' said Guelly. View image in full screen For canola farmers, news of the tariffs come at a particularly bad time of year because many are preparing to start this year's harvest. Global News Ryan Hofford, who farms about 480 hectares (1,200 acres) near Swan River, Man., said that almost immediately after the new tariffs were announced, the price he expects to get for his crop this fall dropped by about $30 per tonne or about $50 per acre. Story continues below advertisement 'And (it's) important to remember that that $50 per acre comes out of the profits. You know, fertilizer's been paid, seed has been paid, chemicals, everything's paid. So all we're left with now is the profits. If we didn't have any production pre-priced in my case, this hit would be about a $30,000,' said Hofford. View image in full screen Ryan Hofford, who grows canola near Swan River, Man,, said the price he can get for his canola dropped by about $50. per acre overnight — a loss of about $30,000 after expenses. Courtesy: Ryan Hofford Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe reacted to news of the tariffs, which come just as this year's harvest is about to begin, by saying they 'will have a devastating impact' on the country's agriculture industry. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'This $43 to $45 billion Canadian canola industry that we have (is) employing just over 200,000 people,' said Moe. 'To put this into context, that is significantly larger than the steel industry, the aluminum industry and the car manufacturing industry combined. It's about the same size as the Canadian forestry industry, which we saw significant supports for just this past week. Story continues below advertisement 'Each of those industries, the steel the aluminum and the EV industry, have been hit hard by U.S. tariffs, as has our forest industry.' View image in full screen Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe says the Canadian canola industry is worth $43 to 45 billion Canadian each year and employs over 200,000 people. Global News Moe said canola producers deserve the same amount of attention and support from the federal government as the other industries that have been hit hard by tariffs. 'We are asking that this be dealt with immediately and I've reached out to the prime minister this morning and I suspect I will be speaking with him at some point later today,' said Moe 3:20 Canada targets China with higher tariffs as part of steel industry measures The tariffs on canola are not the only bad news for Canadian farmers. The Chinese government also announced Tuesday that is has started an anti dumping investigation into imports of Canadian pea starch, which is used as a food ingredient and in other applications such as paper making, phamaceuticals and textiles. Story continues below advertisement While Moe said the new tariffs on canola are expected to 'stop a significant amount of trade that is flowing into China today, 'finding a replacement for the millions of tonnes of canola (that China purchases from Canada) will be very difficult unless import demand drops sharply,' said Donatas Jankauskas, an analyst with commodity data firm CM Navigator. Australia, the world's second-largest exporter of canola, has been shut out of the Chinese market since 2020 due mainly to Chinese concerns over the spread of a fungal plant disease. For Canada's canola farmers, the ultimate solution to the trade dispute would be to find other markets. 'We've been doing our own on this end, trying to get more domestic crush capacity and more use for our oil domestically so that we don't have to rely on some of these international countries that we sell to,' said Guelly. But unfortunately, in the short term, while they wait for Ottawa and Bejing to try to resolve their differences, Guelly says farmers are going to need to 'ride it out.' 'Here we are. We're not fighting the weather, we're fighting the markets.' –with files from Reuters and The Canadian Press.
Vancouver Sun
3 hours ago
- Vancouver Sun
No evidence of election law breaches in former Liberal MP Han Dong's nomination race, watchdog says
OTTAWA — Although the federal foreign interference task force said China had likely manipulated the 2019 Liberal nomination race in a Toronto-area riding, Canada's election watchdog says she found no evidence federal election laws were broken. The revelation is buried in the Commissioner of Canada Elections' latest annual report published last week. In the report, Commissioner Caroline Simard says she looked into two particular instances of alleged foreign interference that were discussed at length during the public inquiry. In both cases she found 'either no evidence or not enough evidence' to support a breach of the Canada Elections Act (CEA). The first was allegations of manipulation by the Chinese consulate in Toronto of the controversial 2019 Liberal nomination race in Don Valley North that ultimately coronated Han Dong. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. Both Foreign Interference Commissioner Marie-Josée Hogue and the task force monitoring for foreign interference in Canadian elections have reported suspicious behaviour by Chinese authorities during the 2019 Toronto-area Liberal nomination race that likely tainted the result. A report from Hogue last year said some intelligence, which was not 'firmly substantiated,' suggested Chinese students were provided with 'falsified documents' and then bused in to the Liberal Don Valley North nomination election so they could vote for Dong despite not being residents of the riding. Those documents were provided by individuals associated with a well-known Chinese proxy agent, the report read. After the vote, intelligence agencies reported that those students were in fact coerced into voting for Dong. 'Some intelligence reported after the election indicated that veiled threats were issued by the PRC Consulate to the Chinese international students, implying their student visas would be in jeopardy and that there could be consequences for their families back in the PRC if they did not support Han Dong,' read the report. The Security and Intelligence Threats to Elections Task Force also stated in its report on the 2019 federal election that 'PRC officials likely manipulated one of the nomination contests in the Toronto riding of Don Valley North,' but said that some of the allegations remained 'unconfirmed.' In a statement, commissioner spokesperson Pierre Verriere said the office conducted 'extensive research, interviews, and analysis' of the Don Valley North Liberal nomination race before deciding in February to close the review without imposing any sanctions. In a document submitted to the foreign interference inquiry last year, the commissioner's office said it was investigating five potential contraventions including voter intimidation, inducing others to vote outside of their electoral district and illegal electoral donations by an ineligible donor. Verriere said the office looked into multiple potential CEA breaches but found that the evidence to support them was either non-existent or insufficient. 'To take formal compliance or enforcement action, the Commissioner must have tangible evidence to substantiate allegations of wrongdoing,' commissioner spokesperson Pierre Verriere said in a statement. 'Following our assessment of the allegations against potential CEA contraventions, we found either no evidence to support formal enforcement action or insufficient evidence, depending on the provision in question,' he added. But as it was highlighted repeatedly throughout the Foreign Interference Inquiry last year, the commissioner's oversight power during party nomination races is very limited. She told inquiry staff that her mandate during internal party elections is limited to political financing and that it would be a major resource challenge for her to have to oversee every nomination race for all 343 federal ridings. She also noted that she does not have the mandate nor the ability to verify intelligence, which was the basis for most of the allegations in Don Valley North. Dong, who stepped away from Liberal caucus after a string of media stories regarding these allegations in 2023 and did not run in the 2025 election, has always denied any wrongdoing. In June, he settled a two-year defamation lawsuit with Global News. He told National Post on Tuesday that he was not aware that the commissioner's investigation was closed until National Post reached out to him for comment. 'I have always said that I have always followed the election rules. Unfortunately, my family, my team and I have suffered irreversible harm,' Dong said in a text message. 'I remain hopeful that this conclusion of Commissioner Simard's investigation will bring DVN electors, especially Liberals, full closure and restore public confidence in our democratic process and institutions.' The other review into foreign interference Simard discussed during the public inquiry was into allegations of Chinese interference against Conservative candidate Kenny Chiu during the 2021 federal election in the B.C. riding of Steveston–Richmond East. During her testimony in front of the Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference (PIFI) last year, Simard said her office had already concluded there was insufficient evidence to support charges of 'undue foreign influence' or any other breaches of the CRA. National Post cnardi@ Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our politics newsletter, First Reading, here .
Edmonton Journal
3 hours ago
- Edmonton Journal
No evidence of election law breaches in former Liberal MP Han Dong's nomination race, watchdog says
In a document submitted to the foreign interference inquiry last year, the commissioner's office said it was investigating five potential contraventions including voter intimidation, inducing others to vote outside of their electoral district and illegal electoral donations by an ineligible donor. Verriere said the office looked into multiple potential CEA breaches but found that the evidence to support them was either non-existent or insufficient. 'To take formal compliance or enforcement action, the Commissioner must have tangible evidence to substantiate allegations of wrongdoing,' commissioner spokesperson Pierre Verriere said in a statement. 'Following our assessment of the allegations against potential CEA contraventions, we found either no evidence to support formal enforcement action or insufficient evidence, depending on the provision in question,' he added. But as it was highlighted repeatedly throughout the Foreign Interference Inquiry last year, the commissioner's oversight power during party nomination races is very limited. She told inquiry staff that her mandate during internal party elections is limited to political financing and that it would be a major resource challenge for her to have to oversee every nomination race for all 343 federal ridings. She also noted that she does not have the mandate nor the ability to verify intelligence, which was the basis for most of the allegations in Don Valley North. Dong, who stepped away from Liberal caucus after a string of media stories regarding these allegations in 2023 and did not run in the 2025 election, has always denied any wrongdoing. In June, he settled a two-year defamation lawsuit with Global News. He told National Post on Tuesday that he was not aware that the commissioner's investigation was closed until National Post reached out to him for comment. 'I have always said that I have always followed the election rules. Unfortunately, my family, my team and I have suffered irreversible harm,' Dong said in a text message. 'I remain hopeful that this conclusion of Commissioner Simard's investigation will bring DVN electors, especially Liberals, full closure and restore public confidence in our democratic process and institutions.' The other review into foreign interference Simard discussed during the public inquiry was into allegations of Chinese interference against Conservative candidate Kenny Chiu during the 2021 federal election in the B.C. riding of Steveston–Richmond East. During her testimony in front of the Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference (PIFI) last year, Simard said her office had already concluded there was insufficient evidence to support charges of 'undue foreign influence' or any other breaches of the CRA. Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our politics newsletter, First Reading, here.
