State can officially use eminent domain to site a new homeless campus. What now?
A conceptual rendering depicts what state leaders envision for a new "transformative campus" meant to house and rehabilitate people experiencing homelessness. (Courtesy of the Utah Office of Homeless Services)
Utah Gov. Spencer Cox officially signed a bill on Tuesday that not only cemented Salt Lake City's partnership with the state to improve 'public safety' within the capital city, but also one that could carry major implications for what comes next in the effort to dramatically expand the state's emergency shelter bed capacity.
The bill, HB465, started out as a punitive measure — one that would have forced Salt Lake City to formally partner with the state to police camping and drugs or else risk losing state funds. The version ultimately passed by the Utah Legislature and signed by Cox, however, no longer includes those penalties — though it still requires Salt Lake City police to enter into an agreement with the Department of Public Safety by July 1.
To Salt Lake City Mayor Erin Mendenhall, who faced demands from state leaders ahead of the 2025 legislative session to better police camping, drugs and lawlessness in her city, the final version of HB465 is much more palatable than its original.
State leaders call SLC police 'ineffective,' urge mayor to act — or state will step in
'We went into this session with a goal of preventing a state takeover of our public safety,' Mendenhall told reporters during a media roundtable on Friday. 'We succeeded in maintaining that core municipal function of Salt Lake City.'
But there's another important provision in the bill that grants the state the power to 'use eminent domain to condemn' a very specific type of parcel — 'unincorporated land' owned by Salt Lake City 'for the public use of constructing a new facility on the land for homeless services.'
That's a tool that state leaders could potentially use in their ongoing secret search for a 30-acre property meant to host what's envisioned as a 'transformative campus' to increase Utah's homeless shelter capacity by somewhere in the ballpark of 1,200 to 1,600 beds.
'We're supportive of (the eminent domain provision) because we know the legal landscape surrounding the property options that we're looking at, and this is a tool that we support in this bill,' said Mendenhall, who also serves on the Utah Homeless Services Board, the body that will make the final decision where to site the proposed homeless campus.
Finding that site has proven difficult, State Homeless Coordinator Wayne Niederhauser has said. He told Utah News Dispatch on the final night of the 2025 session that the eminent domain provision of HB465 is an optional tool to help site a 'permanent' facility — though he also said no decisions have been made.
'We're still looking at properties. This is one of the options,' Niederhauser said. 'In order for that to be an option, eminent domain is required.'
Utah lawmakers look to use eminent domain to help SLC site new homeless shelter
The mayor supported that eminent domain provision — which came about through negotiations with lawmakers — as a way to advance an effort that Mendenhall has long been urging state leaders to move on sooner rather than later: increase the number of emergency homeless shelter beds in the state's homeless system.
'Normally we would never agree to eminent domain,' Mendenhall said, but she added Salt Lake's 'highest priority in this conversation' was creating more homeless shelter space 'as soon as possible.'
That could allow the state to potentially use that city-owned property — which has not yet been publicly identified — for not just a temporary facility that Mendenhall offered in her public safety plan that she unveiled in December in response to state demands to improve 'public safety' in Salt Lake City, but it could also eventually be a permanent home for the envisioned 'homeless campus.'
When asked to clarify whether HB465 could be used to site the homeless campus, Mendenhall told reporters, 'or a transitional facility until that point.'
In order to immediately address what her plan described as a 'shortage of 1,000 to 1,600 year-round emergency shelter beds,' Mendenhall previously said in her plan that Salt Lake City would be prepared to use a 'city-owned property for a campus facility for up to 24 months if capital and operational costs can be allocated by the state and philanthropic partners' while state officials work to site a permanent property.
But as HB465 took shape, she indicated that she would be open to that property also hosting a permanent shelter.
'I've long said that the system needs more shelter. This is a humanitarian crisis that will not be resolved quickly,' Mendenhall said in a prepared statement to Utah News Dispatch last month when the new version of HB465 was first adopted. 'As much as I would prefer to have more shelter and housing in all counties across the state, I also recognize the acute needs here. Specifically, we know how difficult it is to open winter beds every year that close and leave people outside all summer. That being said, we are willing to explore permanent shelter if it is fully funded by the state and philanthropic partners.'
Details are scant on exactly where and when that city-owned property is located other than it's on 'unincorporated' land. HB465's sponsor, House Majority Assistant Whip Casey Snider, R-Paradise, also gave another hint in a Senate committee hearing that it has an 'easement against it for conservation.'
However, at least one lawmaker — Senate Minority Leader Luz Escamilla, D-Salt Lake City — said she voted against HB465 out of concern that its eminent domain provision could impact west-side Salt Lake City.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
On the Senate floor, Escamilla worried it will lead state and city leaders to place 'a very large building in the west side of Salt Lake City, and (it's) very problematic because they won't have a process for the community to engage.'
When asked about Escamilla's concerns about the property being near west-side Salt Lake City, a spokesperson for Mendenhall told Utah News Dispatch to contact the Office of Homeless Services about location specifics. A spokesperson for that office declined to comment.
Previously, Mendenhall has advocated for other cities to do more to host homeless facilities since Salt Lake City already hosts many. Pressed on why she's agreed to use city-owned land for the effort, Mendenhall said she would answer that question at a later date.
'When we identify the site of the facility, we can talk about that,' she said.
Asked when that site will be announced, Mendenhall also didn't give an answer.
'If I knew I probably couldn't tell you, but I don't even know just yet,' she said.
The bill has an effective date of May 7, so state leaders could potentially exercise their new eminent domain powers at any point after that date. However, it's not clear exactly when the public will know more about that property, whether state leaders actually move to exercise their eminent domain power, or any other developments around the state's search for a homeless campus.
Utah homeless board OKs search for up to 1,200-bed 'centralized campus.' What now?
In response to questions about HB465's eminent domain provision, state officials referred to a newly created website that lists a loose timeline for the 'transformative campus.'
A 'final site announcement' isn't expected until at least 'summer 2025,' but no hard dates have been set, according to the website. After that announcement, state officials expect 'community engagement to share plans, gather input and answer questions.'
The first phase of the project isn't expected to open until at least November 2025.
But between now and then, many more details need to be hashed out. And lack of funding continues to be a major issue.
Last week, the Utah Homeless Services Board — the body that oversees and funds the state's homeless system — held its first meeting since the conclusion of the 2025 Utah Legislature.
In that meeting, Niederhauser updated board members on what lawmakers did and didn't fund.
'This is a big challenge for our office,' Niederhauser warned. 'The board needs to be aware of it.'
Cox recommended lawmakers spend at least $18.8 million on efforts to alleviate homelessness, including about $5.8 million in ongoing funds for a new family shelter that's already been approved in South Salt Lake and about $13 million in one-time funding to keep temporary emergency shelter beds open through next winter and into spring 2026.
Faith groups, advocates urge Utah Legislature to fund operations for new family shelter
However, the Legislature only funded $3.9 million for the family shelter and $5.5 million in one-time money for emergency shelter, Niederhauser said.
'That does leave us short $1.9 million ongoing' for the family shelter, he said.
The new family shelter is still expected to open within the next month, as it's currently funded to stay open at least until the end of June, Niederhauser said, but it's not yet clear what will happen to it unless state and local leaders scrape together more money for the shelter.
'We met with The Road Home and Shelter the Homeless today, brainstorming how we might get more creative to fill that gap of $1.9 million,' Niederhauser said. 'So we're all going to be participating in that, looking to potentially the private sector and maybe also some more public sector money to fill that gap.'
As for the money for winter and summer overflow beds — which helped house more than 900 people this year — Niederhauser said 'we have a serious worry' that if state leaders don't find more money to keep those beds open beyond April 30, 2026, there could be hundreds of people 'looking for a place to sleep at night in and around probably Salt Lake City, the Jordan River, creeping into other communities nearby.'
'I think we're going to be about $5 million short to get us through next fiscal year,' Niederhauser said.
He added that his office will be searching for solutions. 'But unless we get some money, other public funds maybe through some other public entities and maybe some help from the private sector, it's going to be a big challenge.'
'My guess is we'll be able to get through next winter without having to close beds,' he said. 'But on April 30 (2026), without some additional money, I think we're going to have a lot of beds close.'
Mendenhall, in her public safety plan, urged the 2025 Utah legislature to allocate a 'stable, dedicated funding source' for homeless services. That didn't happen. She told reporters Friday that was the No. 1 thing lacking from this year's legislative session.
Meanwhile, there's an even bigger hurdle that lawmakers haven't yet taken on. There's no ongoing funding yet identified to fully fund operations for the homeless campus, 'which we really, desperately need,' Niederhauser.
Last year, the Utah Legislature appropriated $25 million for a new large homeless shelter, but officials have not yet spent that cash while they continue to look for a site for the homeless campus. But ongoing funding is a much bigger problem.
Lawmakers fund $25 million toward new 600-800 bed homeless shelter
'That's going to have to be a big discussion that we have this summer and into next legislative session,' Niederhauser said.
He noted Haven For Hope in San Antonio — which Utah leaders visited last year as they shaped their vision for Utah's homeless campus — costs an estimated $30 million a year to operate.
'So that's a big nut to crack,' he said. 'That's going to be a big nut for the Legislature to consider. So we are going to have to come together and figure this out as a whole community. That's the state, county, cities, and the private sector, to figure out how that's going to work.'
Despite the challenges, Niederhauser said he's 'bullish' that leaders will find a way to make the campus a reality.
But in the meantime, if homeless service providers have to cut back on case management in order to fill the funding gaps the 2025 Legislature left, that could create more issues that run contrary to the Homeless Service Board's goal to not just warehouse people, but help them get back on their feet.
Jim Behunin, a former legislative auditor who now serves on the Homeless Services Board, said 'we cannot be asking our providers to come up with any more efficiencies.'
'I've seen how short they are in their funding already,' he said. 'We are already underfunding for supportive services.'
However, Behunin also said as he's spoken with legislators, 'there is a lack of confidence' in the state's homeless system to support added investment, especially 'new funds' through a tax that would likely be needed to support operations of the new campus.
'They're not ready to bite on that offer,' he said. 'There's still a lot of concern about whether the funds would be spent effectively. And how we bridge that gap is something that we all need to be grappling with somehow.'
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Axios
an hour ago
- Axios
Houston readies for protests as Abbott deploys National Guard
City leaders say they're equipped to handle planned protests this weekend in Houston, while Gov. Greg Abbott says he will deploy the Texas National Guard "to ensure peace & order." Why it matters: Abbott's decision comes amid a national debate about the militarization of law enforcement and the rights of protestors as thousands are expected to protest during "No Kings Day" on Saturday. Driving the news: The National Guard will be deployed across the state, Abbott posted on X late Tuesday night, saying he's instructed them to "use every tool & strategy to help law enforcement maintain order." "Peaceful protest is legal. Harming a person or property is illegal & will lead to arrest." Abbott didn't specify where troops will be deployed. Catch up quick: Protesters will march on Houston City Hall at 10am Saturday, part of the nationwide demonstration to counter President Trump's multimillion-dollar military parade in Washington, D.C. Texas state troopers are monitoring planned events and " stand ready," the Department of Public Safety said Tuesday. The White House has already deployed the National Guard and Marines in response to protests in Los Angeles against Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids. Zoom in: Mayor John Whitmire and Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo say law enforcement is ready to respond to potential unrest. "I've monitored this very carefully. It's my highest responsibility," Whitmire told Houston City Council members Wednesday. "We will not tolerate civil disobedience." The intrigue: U.S. Rep. Wesley Hunt (R-Houston) sent a letter to Whitmire and county leadership this week offering federal assistance in quelling what he called "riots" on the horizon. "Public servants, like us, must promote law and order and protect our city … from descending into violence and chaos like Los Angeles," Hunt wrote. Yes, but: Whitmire declined to respond to Hunt's letter, telling council members Wednesday that Hunt's letter was "speaking about something that does not exist in Houston."
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Salt Lake City leaders, Black community mark Juneteenth, raise controversial new city flag
Juneteenth is next week, and leaders in the Black community and their advocates gathered to preemptively mark the holiday, stressing the importance of resilience. The theme of Tuesday's gathering at the Salt Lake City-County Building was 'And Still We Rise,' which Betty Sawyer, one of the speakers, said is pertinent today. Sawyer serves as head of the Ogden branch of the NAACP and was instrumental in the passage of legislation by Utah lawmakers in 2022, making Juneteenth, June 19, a state holiday. The theme was selected to underscore the importance of 'not getting overwhelmed by circumstances, good, bad or indifferent, but to recognize and embrace the resilience that we have, the tenacity that we have and, most importantly, the love that we have for one another,' she said. Together, 'when we decide to do something, there's no stopping us.' Salt Lake City Mayor Erin Mendenhall also addressed the gathering, which drew around 100 people, noting the controversial new city flag that city officials approved last month, which incorporates the blue and red Juneteenth flag. HB77, approved by state lawmakers earlier this year, in effect prohibits the display of flags perceived as political at schools and local government offices. City officials added a sego lily flower to the Juneteenth flag and adopted it as an official city flag on May 6 to circumvent the law. 'This is what determination, partnership, creativity looks like,' Mendenhall said, referencing the new flag. 'Our values aren't changing. Diversity, equity, inclusion are our values. They're American values. That will never change.' Mendenhall's remarks drew applause from those on hand, but Gov. Spencer Cox blasted the flag when asked about it separately at his regularly monthly press conference later on Tuesday. In approving the Juneteenth-inspired flags last month, the City Council also adopted gay pride and transgender flags with sego lilies on them as official city flags, to get around HB77. 'They're dumb flags, and it was a dumb bill,' Cox said, noting that other racial and ethnic groups are left out. 'It's ridiculous. I feel bad for the Japanese Americans. I feel bad for the Polynesian Americans. I mean, who are we leaving out here? I'm sure they feel great that they got around this dumb law, and they did it with dumb flags. The whole thing is dumb.' The tone at Tuesday's ceremony, however, remained upbeat with a measure of defiance. She doesn't know if the Juneteenth flag will require a sego lily on it in years to come so that it can be flown outside the Salt Lake City-County Building, 'but this city's committed forever,' Mendenhall said. The Juneteenth flag, she went on, 'celebrates freedom, a new horizon, and it honors the bloodshed by the enslaved people who were oppressed for hundreds of years.' Though meant to celebrate the end of slavery, Juneteenth more specifically marks June 19, 1865. That's the day when Union troops reached Galveston, Texas — months after the end of the U.S. Civil War — to let some 250,000 African Americans know they were free. Some leaders in the Black community refer to Juneteenth, a federal and state holiday, as their second Independence Day, after July 4. 'The legacy of Juneteenth reminds us to never give up hope in uncertain times, to remember the resilience of generations that came before us and to keep these important stories and lived experiences alive, both today and for our shared future,' said Utah Rep. Sandra Collins, D-Salt Lake City. She sponsored the 2022 legislation making Juneteenth a state holiday in Utah. Numerous activities are scheduled around Utah in the days to come to mark Juneteenth. Ogden will host a Juneteenth Freedom Festival at the Ogden Amphitheater from Friday, June 13, to Sunday, June 15, featuring musical performances, a car show and much more. It's organized by Project Success, led by Sawyer. The city of Millcreek is hosting a Juneteenth celebration on June 18 from 6-10 p.m. at Millcreek Common. Salt Lake Juneteenth will be held June 19 at The Gateway in Salt Lake City from noon to 10 p.m. The Juneteenth Healing and Reconciliation Vigil will be held June 28 at the International Peace Gardens at Jordan Park in Salt Lake City from 4-6 p.m.


Axios
7 hours ago
- Axios
Abbott orders National Guard deployment to protests
Gov. Greg Abbott says he will deploy the Texas National Guard across the state ahead of protests planned this weekend against the Trump administration. Why it matters: Thousands are expected to protest during "No Kings Day" on Saturday across the state and nation. Abbott's decision comes amid a national debate about the militarization of law enforcement and the rights of protestors. What they're saying: The national guard "will be deployed to locations across the state to ensure peace & order," Abbott posted on X late Tuesday night. "Peaceful protest is legal. Harming a person or property is illegal & will lead to arrest." He instructed the Texas National Guard to "use every tool & strategy to help law enforcement maintain order." Catch up quick: The protests on Saturday are part of a nationwide demonstration to counter President Trump's multimillion-dollar military parade in Washington, D.C. "We stand united in solidarity with those peacefully protesting ICE and federal aggression while condemning all violence," per a statement signed by a handful of Austin city council members this week. "As the Trump administration continues its assault on free speech and dissent, it's critical to act with intention, stay informed, and look out for one another." Meanwhile, Texas state troopers are monitoring planned events and " stand ready," the Department of Public Safety said Tuesday. The White House has already deployed the National Guard and Marines in response to protests in Los Angeles against Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids. The big picture:"No Kings" events planned for Saturday are expected to be the largest single-day anti-Trump rally since the start of the administration. The movement echoes earlier Hands Off, May Day and 50501 protests. The organizers say the intent of the rallies is to "reject authoritarianism." Zoom in: People gathered this week in Austin and other cities across Texas to protest the administration's mass deportation plans. One person was arrested in Dallas and several were arrested in Austin. "Peaceful protesting is legal," Abbott wrote on X on Tuesday. "But once you cross the line, you will be arrested." He posted about the Department of Public Safety's planned response to future protests, saying, "Don't mess with Texas law enforcement." The other side:"Donald Trump wants tanks in the street and a made-for-TV display of dominance for his birthday," the No Kings website said.